Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / CrimsonPeak

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** There are also obvious parallels between this movie and "Literature/TheFallOfTheHouseOfUsher", what with a brother and sister living together in a cumbling old mansion, with an added dash of incest (implied in the Poe story, explicit in the movie) for good measure.

to:

** There are also obvious parallels between this movie and "Literature/TheFallOfTheHouseOfUsher", what with a brother and sister living together in a cumbling crumbling old mansion, with an added dash of incest (implied in the Poe story, explicit in the movie) for good measure.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** There are also obvious parallels between this movie and "Literature/TheFallOfTheHouseOfUsher", what with a brother and sister living together in a cumbling old mansion, with an added dash of incest (implied in the Poe story, explicit in the movie) for good measure.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BittersweetEnding: [[spoiler: Edith and Alan survive their experiences at Allerdale Hall and manage to get away, the village now has the Clay Extractor for the brickworks to hopefully bring them prosperity, and Thomas has apparently redeemed himself and can move on to whatever comes after death. But -- if we're going with the standard del Toro view on the afterlife in his films -- Lucille and her victims are probably trapped as ghosts forever, just as miserable and despairing in death as they were in life. Though Edith's narration at the end implies that with the violent murders that tied the ghosts to the mansion now being discovered and the murderers killed, it's possible the other ghosts were able to move on, while Lucille will be trapped there forever.]]

to:

* BittersweetEnding: [[spoiler: Edith and Alan survive their experiences at Allerdale Hall and manage to get away, the village now has the Clay Extractor for the brickworks to hopefully bring them prosperity, and Thomas has apparently redeemed himself and can move on to whatever comes after death. But -- if we're going with the standard del Toro view on the afterlife in his films -- Lucille and her victims are probably trapped as ghosts forever, just as miserable and despairing in death as they were in life. Though Still, Edith's narration at the end implies that with the violent murders that tied the ghosts to the mansion now being discovered and the murderers killed, it's possible the other ghosts were able to move on, while Lucille will be trapped there forever.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** One of this movie's trailers features a cover of Creator/NickCave's song "Red Right Hand". Another cover was featured in Del Toro's earlier ''Film/{{Hellboy|2004}}''.

to:

** One of this movie's trailers features a cover of Creator/NickCave's Music/NickCave's song "Red Right Hand". Another cover was featured in Del Toro's earlier ''Film/{{Hellboy|2004}}''.



** [[spoiler:Thomas']] ghost shares the same appearance as [[Film/TheDevilsBackbone Santi's]] : skin that looks like cracked porcelain, yellow eyes, blood pouring out like smoke from the wound that killed them...

to:

** [[spoiler:Thomas']] ghost shares the same appearance as [[Film/TheDevilsBackbone Santi's]] : Santi's]]: skin that looks like cracked porcelain, yellow eyes, blood pouring out like smoke from the wound that killed them...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding pothole


* BrotherSisterIncest: Edith notices how unusually close her new husband is with his sister. Lucille is a spinster and lives with him in the house and the two always travel together. Edith starts to suspect they're actually husband and wife pretending to be siblings. [[spoiler: They're actually incestuous siblings, and they murdered their mother after they were discovered]].

to:

* BrotherSisterIncest: Edith notices how unusually close her new husband is with his sister. Lucille is a spinster {{spinster}} and lives with him in the house and the two always travel together. Edith starts to suspect they're actually husband and wife pretending to be siblings. [[spoiler: They're actually incestuous siblings, and they murdered their mother after they were discovered]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Yandere}}: [[spoiler:Lucille. When she realises Thomas actually loves Edith, she resorts to killing him too.]]

to:

* {{Yandere}}: [[spoiler:Lucille. When she realises Thomas actually loves Edith, she resorts to killing kills him too.in a fit of jealous/possessive rage.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SexEqualsLove: [[spoiler:After having sex with Edith, Thomas seems to accept that he loves her and turns on Lucille to try and save her life. Invoked by Lucille, who has an OhCrap moment when she realizes that Thomas consummated his relationship with Edith, clearly believing this trope to be in effect. Also justified by the fact that both Thomas and Lucille seem to believe that sex ''is'' the main way of showing love.]]

Added: 102

Changed: 66

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FanDisservice: [[spoiler: Thomas and Lucille caught in a romantic embrace inside their childhood bedroom. With Lucille singing rather eerily than romantically into Thomas'ear as she runs her hand down onto his crotch. Considering that they're really siblings.]]

to:

* FanDisservice: [[spoiler: Thomas and Lucille caught in a romantic embrace inside their childhood bedroom. With Lucille singing rather eerily than romantically into Thomas'ear as she runs her hand down onto his crotch. Considering that they're not actually husband and wife pretending to be siblings but really are siblings.]]



* InterruptedIntimacy: [[spoiler: Thomas and Lucille were about to have sex when Edith catches them]].



--> '''Lucille:''' [[spoiler: How sweet... ''(rips the ring off of Edith's wedding finger)'' I am.]]

to:

--> '''Lucille:''' [[spoiler: How sweet...sweet. ''(rips the ring off of Edith's wedding finger)'' I am.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FanDisservice: [[spoiler: Thomas and Lucille caught in a romantic embrace inside their childhood bedroom. With Lucille singing rather eerily than romantically into Thomas'ear as she runs her hand down onto his crotch. Considering that they're really siblings.]]
* {{Fanservice}}: [[spoiler: Thomas and Edith's first big kiss and their first love scene inside the winter cabin. Complete with a shot of Thomas' backside and then Edith being on top.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WhamLine: [[spoiler: As Edith and Lucille fight after Edith caught her and Thomas about to have sex, she says she should've known that Lucille isn't Thomas' sister but really his lover. Lucille delivers this line, revealing to a shocked Edith that she's actually both.]]
--> '''Edith:''' [[spoiler: I knew it! You're not his sister!]]
--> '''Lucille:''' [[spoiler: How sweet... ''(rips the ring off of Edith's wedding finger)'' I am.]]
* WhamShot: Edith following the sound of the lullaby singing and [[spoiler: catching Thomas and Lucille in a romantic embrace]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WritersCannotDoMath: There are various dates given for events in the Sharpe siblings' lives, some of which would set their ages at 30 and 32, others which would mean they're 34 and 36.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
cross wicking

Added DiffLines:

* MoreExperiencedChasesTheInnocent: The [[TheIngenue youthful, innocent, and sheltered]] Edith Cushing is pursued by the dashing and worldly Sir Thomas Sharpe, who acts the perfect gentleman, seemingly averting the trope. In reality, [[spoiler: Thomas is TheBluebeard, having married several women and allowed his sister Lucille to murder them so they can inherit their assets, and is also in a [[BrotherSisterIncest sexual relationship with Lucille]]. In fact, he and Lucille specifically chose Edith to be their next victim ''because'' of her naivete and inherited wealth]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The plot about Edith stealing the cellar's key in a ''Literature/{{Bluebeard}}'' fashion, and the cellar containing the proof of illicit activities. Also [[spoiler: her drink is ritually poisoned by an evil in-law and then she's saved in extremis by a former suitor]]. All of this comes straight from Creator/AlfredHitchcock 's ''Film/{{Notorious}}''.

to:

** The plot about Edith stealing the cellar's key in a ''Literature/{{Bluebeard}}'' fashion, and the cellar containing the proof of illicit activities. Also [[spoiler: her drink is ritually poisoned by an evil in-law and then she's saved in extremis by a former suitor]]. All of this comes straight from Creator/AlfredHitchcock 's ''Film/{{Notorious}}''.''Film/{{Notorious|1946}}''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LodgedBladeRemoval: Both Thomas Sharpe and Alan [=McMichael=] remove knives from their bodies after being stabbed, resulting in Thomas dying and Alan narrowly surviving (albeit with considerable blood loss). While the first case is forgivable as Thomas was stabbed in the face and would have died anyway, Alan is a doctor and really should know better.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AllThereInTheManual: The artbook in particular includes truncated versions of character backstories that Guillermo del Toro wrote out and gave to the actors. The originals were apparently much much longer.

to:

* AllThereInTheManual: The artbook in particular includes truncated versions of character backstories that Guillermo del Toro wrote out and gave to the actors. The originals were apparently much much longer.originals, eventually posted on his Twitter account, get deep into the three main characters' histories and motivations- down to details as small as their favorite foods and astrological signs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Dewicked trope


* KnifeNut: [[spoiler: Lucille]] uses a knife to threaten Edith and [[spoiler:murder her brother]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
cut trope


* LettingHerHairDown: Lucille in the film's last act, when she shows her true nature; her hair goes from a severe bun to a braid that falls [[RapunzelHair to her knees.]]

to:

* LettingHerHairDown: Lucille in the film's last act, when she shows her true nature; her hair goes from a severe bun to a braid that falls [[RapunzelHair to her knees.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* StupidEvil: Rather than [[spoiler: destroy the incriminating evidence, the Sharpes lock everything in a safe. Lucille is a serial killer and did collect other mementoes from her victims such as cuttings of their hair, but she probably shouldn't have left Enola's suitcase in the basement given that workers visit it regularly.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheirFirstTime: Happens between Edith and Thomas when they're stuck in town during a snowstorm; without Lucille there to interfere, Thomas's attraction and affection for Edith combines with her inquisitiveness and frustration (since by this point they've been married several months and she's still a virgin) and they make love (her first time, his first time with any woman besides his sister).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AllThereInTheManual: The artbook in particular includes truncated versions of character backstories that Guillermo del Torro wrote out and gave to the actors. The originals were apparently much much longer.

to:

* AllThereInTheManual: The artbook in particular includes truncated versions of character backstories that Guillermo del Torro Toro wrote out and gave to the actors. The originals were apparently much much longer.



* OtherworldlyCommunicationFailure: [[spoiler:The ghosts haunting Allerdale Hall? They aren't trying to hurt Edith but war her and protect her from Lucille and Thomas, the latter marries wealthy young woman and the former kills them so they can inherit the wealth.]]

to:

* OtherworldlyCommunicationFailure: [[spoiler:The ghosts haunting Allerdale Hall? They aren't trying to hurt Edith but war warn her and protect her from Lucille and Thomas, the latter marries wealthy young woman and the former kills them so they can inherit the wealth.]]



* RomanticRunnerUp: Alan is Edith's childhood friend and clearly has romantic feelings for her, but she chooses to marry the mysterious Sir Thomas. [[WordOfGod]] states that, while he's in love with her, she has only ever seen him as a dear friend.

to:

* RomanticRunnerUp: Alan is Edith's childhood friend and clearly has romantic feelings for her, but she chooses to marry the mysterious Sir Thomas. [[WordOfGod]] WordOfGod states that, while he's in love with her, she has only ever seen him as a dear friend.

Added: 153

Changed: 329

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OurSpiritsAreDifferent: While Edith may be spooked by the various ghosts throughout the film, none of them bear any ill intent towards her.

to:

* OtherworldlyCommunicationFailure: [[spoiler:The ghosts haunting Allerdale Hall? They aren't trying to hurt Edith but war her and protect her from Lucille and Thomas, the latter marries wealthy young woman and the former kills them so they can inherit the wealth.]]
* OurSpiritsAreDifferent: While Edith may be spooked by the various ghosts throughout the film, none [[spoiler:none of them bear any ill intent towards her.her]].

Changed: 150

Removed: 344

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* QuestionableConsent: [[spoiler: Lucille's]] affair with [[spoiler: Thomas]] began before [[spoiler: Thomas]] was twelve years old, and he is shown with his eyes closed when the two are in bed together, something that had previously been described as a defence mechanism during uncomfortable situations in order to make them pass more quickly.



* RomanticRunnerUp: Alan is Edith's childhood friend and clearly has romantic feelings for her, but she chooses to marry the mysterious Sir Thomas. [[spoiler:However, the film's ending implies that [[FirstGuyWins Edith and Alan will get together after all]]]].

to:

* RomanticRunnerUp: Alan is Edith's childhood friend and clearly has romantic feelings for her, but she chooses to marry the mysterious Sir Thomas. [[spoiler:However, the film's ending implies that [[FirstGuyWins Edith and Alan will get together after all]]]].[[WordOfGod]] states that, while he's in love with her, she has only ever seen him as a dear friend.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AntiVillain: [[spoiler:Thomas is complicit in multiple murders, but is ultimately revealed to be a deeply tragic character shaped by his traumatic experiences at the hands of his AbusiveParents and an incestuous relationship with his equally abusive sister]].

to:

* AntiVillain: [[spoiler:Thomas is complicit in multiple murders, but is ultimately revealed to be a deeply tragic character shaped by his traumatic experiences at the hands of his AbusiveParents and an incestuous relationship with his equally abusive sister]].(also rather abusive) sister. Lucille also qualifies, to an extent, having suffered horribly just like her brother. But she never even approaches redemption, as Thomas eventually does]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Crimson Peak'' is another approach of Creator/GuillermoDelToro to {{ghost stor|y}}ies, released in October 2015. It is - in his own words - a classic [[GothicHorror gothic horror romance]] with a modern take. The film stars Creator/MiaWasikowska, Creator/TomHiddleston, Creator/JessicaChastain and Creator/CharlieHunnam.

to:

''Crimson Peak'' is another approach of Creator/GuillermoDelToro to {{ghost stor|y}}ies, released in October 2015. It is - -- in his own words - -- a classic [[GothicHorror gothic horror romance]] with a modern take. The film stars Creator/MiaWasikowska, Creator/TomHiddleston, Creator/JessicaChastain and Creator/CharlieHunnam.



* BittersweetEnding: [[spoiler: Edith and Alan survive their experiences at Allerdale Hall and manage to get away, the village now has the Clay Extractor for the brickworks to hopefully bring them prosperity, and Thomas has apparently redeemed himself and can move on to whatever comes after death. But - if we're going with the standard del Toro view on the afterlife in his films - Lucille and her victims are probably trapped as ghosts forever, just as miserable and despairing in death as they were in life. Though Edith's narration at the end implies that with the violent murders that tied the ghosts to the mansion now being discovered and the murderers killed, it's possible the other ghosts were able to move on, while Lucille will be trapped there forever.]]

to:

* BittersweetEnding: [[spoiler: Edith and Alan survive their experiences at Allerdale Hall and manage to get away, the village now has the Clay Extractor for the brickworks to hopefully bring them prosperity, and Thomas has apparently redeemed himself and can move on to whatever comes after death. But - -- if we're going with the standard del Toro view on the afterlife in his films - -- Lucille and her victims are probably trapped as ghosts forever, just as miserable and despairing in death as they were in life. Though Edith's narration at the end implies that with the violent murders that tied the ghosts to the mansion now being discovered and the murderers killed, it's possible the other ghosts were able to move on, while Lucille will be trapped there forever.]]



** When the McMichaels brag about Thomas' aristocratic status as a baronet, Edith refers to him as a "parasite". The Sharpes are able to survive in the early 20th century by [[spoiler: taking advantage of young women who fall in love with Thomas]].

to:

** When the McMichaels [=McMichaels=] brag about Thomas' aristocratic status as a baronet, Edith refers to him as a "parasite". The Sharpes are able to survive in the early 20th century by [[spoiler: taking advantage of young women who fall in love with Thomas]].



* OnlyAFleshWound: [[spoiler: Justified: Thomas points out that since Alan's a doctor, he'll be able to tell him a place on his body to stab that will look convincing but do no real damage. Later, Lucille stabs Thomas in that same spot - only then to stab him again ''in the face.'' ]]

to:

* OnlyAFleshWound: [[spoiler: Justified: Thomas points out that since Alan's a doctor, he'll be able to tell him a place on his body to stab that will look convincing but do no real damage. Later, Lucille stabs Thomas in that same spot - -- only then to stab him again ''in the face.'' ]]



* SexlessMarriage: Thomas and Edith have one because Thomas is respecting her decision to [[spoiler: mourn her father]]. [[spoiler: They later consummate the union at a local inn after being snowed in, although it turns out that Edith's mourning wasn't the only reason he was initially holding off being intimate with her - he didn't want to [[ClingyJealousGirl make his sister angry]]]].

to:

* SexlessMarriage: Thomas and Edith have one because Thomas is respecting her decision to [[spoiler: mourn her father]]. [[spoiler: They later consummate the union at a local inn after being snowed in, although it turns out that Edith's mourning wasn't the only reason he was initially holding off being intimate with her - -- he didn't want to [[ClingyJealousGirl make his sister angry]]]].



* SpannerInTheWorks: [[spoiler: Obviously the Sharpes couldn't account for the fact that Edith can see ghosts, meaning she finds out what they're planning thanks to evidence that the spirits help her discover. However, even more crucially, Thomas wasn't supposed to fall in love with Edith - "But it happened."]]

to:

* SpannerInTheWorks: [[spoiler: Obviously the Sharpes couldn't account for the fact that Edith can see ghosts, meaning she finds out what they're planning thanks to evidence that the spirits help her discover. However, even more crucially, Thomas wasn't supposed to fall in love with Edith - -- "But it happened."]]



* TravellingAtTheSpeedOfPlot: Once Alan begins to suspect something's fishy, he sets off for England from Boston - and somehow manages to get there in about a ''day,'' judging by the amount of time that's passed at Allerdale Hall.

to:

* TravellingAtTheSpeedOfPlot: Once Alan begins to suspect something's fishy, he sets off for England from Boston - -- and somehow manages to get there in about a ''day,'' judging by the amount of time that's passed at Allerdale Hall.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:333:''"Beware of Crimson Peak...!"'']]

to:

[[caption-width-right:333:''"Beware of Crimson Peak...!"'']]\n
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

[[caption-width-right:333:''"Beware of Crimson Peak...!"'']]

Top