Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / AStarIsBorn2018

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EvilBrit: Rez is presented as more or less the villain of the film (or unlikable at best), being [[FalseFriend toxic toward Ally]] at worst for most of the film, creating Ally's image as a manufactured pop star, and then [[spoiler: he more or less nudges Jackson towards suicide. Even worse]].

to:

* EvilBrit: Rez is presented as more or less the villain of the film (or unlikable at best), being [[FalseFriend toxic toward Ally]] at worst for most of the film, creating Ally's image as a manufactured pop star, and then [[spoiler: he more or less nudges Jackson towards suicide. Even worse]].suicide, which is the worst thing that anyone could ever do]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Cutting out link to disambiguation page
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''A Star is Born'' is a 2018 [[{{Romance}} romantic]] {{musical}} {{drama}} directed by Creator/BradleyCooper (in his directorial debut), starring himself and Music/LadyGaga. It's also the fourth version of ''A Star is Born'' to be made, following the original film in [[Film/AStarIsBorn1937 1937]] and the remakes in [[Film/AStarIsBorn1954 1954]] and [[Film/AStarIsBorn1976 1976]]. Like the 1976 version, it is set within the music industry.

to:

''A Star is Born'' is a 2018 [[{{Romance}} romantic]] {{musical}} {{drama}} drama directed by Creator/BradleyCooper (in his directorial debut), starring himself and Music/LadyGaga. It's also the fourth version of ''A Star is Born'' to be made, following the original film in [[Film/AStarIsBorn1937 1937]] and the remakes in [[Film/AStarIsBorn1954 1954]] and [[Film/AStarIsBorn1976 1976]]. Like the 1976 version, it is set within the music industry.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Creator/SamElliott, Creator/GregGrunberg, Creator/{{Shangela}}, Creator/WillamBelli, Creator/DaveChappelle, Creator/AndrewDiceClay, and Lukas Nelson (son of Music/WillieNelson) also appear, while Music/{{Halsey}} and Creator/AlecBaldwin {{cameo}} as themselves. All the musical numbers in the film were performed live on set, and feature compositions by Gaga, Nelson, Cooper, Music/JasonIsbell, and Mark Ronson.

to:

Creator/SamElliott, Creator/GregGrunberg, Creator/{{Shangela}}, Creator/WillamBelli, Creator/DaveChappelle, Creator/AndrewDiceClay, and Lukas Nelson (son of Music/WillieNelson) also appear, while Music/{{Halsey}} and Creator/AlecBaldwin {{cameo}} [[TheCameo cameo]] as themselves. All the musical numbers in the film were performed live on set, and feature compositions by Gaga, Nelson, Cooper, Music/JasonIsbell, and Mark Ronson.



** “I’ll Never Love Again” [[spoiler: Used as the finale of the film to great effect and clearly part of Lady Gaga’s “For Your Consideration” package]].

to:

** “I’ll "I’ll Never Love Again” Again" [[spoiler: Used as the finale of the film to great effect and clearly part of Lady Gaga’s “For Gaga's "For Your Consideration” Consideration" package]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Renamed trope per Wick Cleaning Projects


* BadassBaritone: Bobby has one, purely due to being played by Sam Elliott. Jack has one as well, [[spoiler: though it quickly becomes apparent that he's mimicking Bobby's voice, and his actual speaking voice is significantly softer.]]

to:

* BadassBaritone: BaritoneOfStrength: Bobby has one, purely due to being played by Sam Elliott. Jack has one as well, [[spoiler: though it quickly becomes apparent that he's mimicking Bobby's voice, and his actual speaking voice is significantly softer.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BareYourMidriff: Ally does this a few times on stage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Creator/SamElliott, Creator/GregGrunberg, [[Series/RuPaulsDragRace Shangela Laquifa Wadley]], Creator/WillamBelli, Creator/DaveChappelle, Creator/AndrewDiceClay, and Lukas Nelson (son of Music/WillieNelson) also appear, while Music/{{Halsey}} and Creator/AlecBaldwin {{cameo}} as themselves. All the musical numbers in the film were performed live on set, and feature compositions by Gaga, Nelson, Cooper, Music/JasonIsbell, and Mark Ronson.

to:

Creator/SamElliott, Creator/GregGrunberg, [[Series/RuPaulsDragRace Shangela Laquifa Wadley]], Creator/{{Shangela}}, Creator/WillamBelli, Creator/DaveChappelle, Creator/AndrewDiceClay, and Lukas Nelson (son of Music/WillieNelson) also appear, while Music/{{Halsey}} and Creator/AlecBaldwin {{cameo}} as themselves. All the musical numbers in the film were performed live on set, and feature compositions by Gaga, Nelson, Cooper, Music/JasonIsbell, and Mark Ronson.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Also, "can be considered this" is Word Cruft of the "bogus qualifer" variety. Either this is an example or it isn't.


* ICouldaBeenAContender: Ally's father can be considered this. Though he's had success at running a coach company, he still clings to his failed attempt at stardom himself, remembering when a famous singer said that he had more raw singing talent than Music/FrankSinatra. Ironically, this leads to him discouraging and inadvertently insulting his own daughter.

to:

* ICouldaBeenAContender: Ally's father can be considered this. Though he's has had success at running a coach company, but he still clings to his failed attempt at stardom himself, remembering when a famous singer said that he had more raw singing talent than Music/FrankSinatra. Ironically, this leads to him discouraging and inadvertently insulting his own daughter.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
"Could care less" is incorrect. That implies that it's possible to care less.


* DeathByChildbirth: Starting off the tragedy that was Jackson's life was the fact that his mother died giving birth to him, leaving him without a mother and a father who could have cared less about him.

to:

* DeathByChildbirth: Starting off the tragedy that was Jackson's life was the fact that his mother died giving birth to him, leaving him without a mother and a father who could couldn't have cared less about him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** "Shallow" seems to be getting the most focus in its advertising campaign, and it's a major plot point in the film itself, as it's Ally's introduction to the music world.

to:

** "Shallow" seems to be getting the most focus in its advertising campaign, and it's a major plot point in the film itself, as it's Ally's introduction to the music world. Unsurprisingly, it swept the award circuits.



* InvulnerableKnuckles: Averted. On the night they meet, Ally hurts her hand by punching a {{Jerkass}} bar patron who was harassing Jackson. The rest of their night together is spent with Jackson nursing her hand with frozen veggies and gauze.

to:

* InvulnerableKnuckles: Averted. On the night they meet, Ally hurts her hand by punching a {{Jerkass}} bar patron who was harassing Jackson. The rest of their night together is spent with Jackson nursing her hand with [[BeefBandage frozen veggies veggies]] and gauze.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DiegeticMusical: The film has a original soundtrack, and all the songs are performances in front of live crowds or for television.

to:

* DiegeticMusical: The film has a an original soundtrack, and all the songs are performances in front of live crowds or for television.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AwardShow: Ally wins a Grammy. Jackson makes a drunken spectacle of himself at the ceremony.


Added DiffLines:

* MusicIsPolitics: Ally changes her music and image in order to be a successful solo act.

Added: 240

Changed: 406

Removed: 186

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Fanservice}}: Both leads.

to:

* {{Fanservice}}: Both leads.{{Fauxshadowing}}: [[spoiler:Jackson was originally going to commit suicide by drowning, as in the [[Film/AStarIsBorn1937 1937]] and [[Film/AStarIsBorn1954 1954]] versions. This is foreshadowed by his interest in swimming while in rehab and the lyrics of "Shallow". Creator/BradleyCooper claimed that he even scouted the beach where the scene would be filmed]].



* FunctionalAddict: Jackson is often too drunk or high to even stand up straight, but is a ConsummateProfessional whenever he goes on stage. At the Grammys some people notice something is off as he plays back-up guitar for a musical number, but after a shaky start he kicks in and does as well as he usually does. [[spoiler: Things don't fully fall apart until Ally accepts the award for best breakout artist, as he wanders on stage in a daze and even soils himself]]. This actually reflects comments made by a number of actors and musicians, especially in live performances, as they could be drunk, high or sick but when they have their craft to perform they suddenly have all the strength and clarity they need.

to:

* FunctionalAddict: Jackson is often too drunk or high to even stand up straight, but is a ConsummateProfessional whenever he goes on stage. At the Grammys Grammys, some people notice something is off as he plays back-up guitar for a musical number, but after a shaky start he kicks in and does as well as he usually does. [[spoiler: Things don't fully fall apart until Ally accepts the award for best breakout artist, as he wanders on stage in a daze and even soils himself]]. This actually reflects comments made by a number of actors and musicians, especially in live performances, as they could be drunk, high or sick but when they have their craft to perform they suddenly have all the strength and clarity they need.



* IWantMyBelovedToBeHappy: Jackson's biggest drive to clean up his act is for Ally's sake, not his own. In the end, he realizes he wants her to be happy even if he's not in the picture.



* IWantMyBelovedToBeHappy: Jackson's biggest drive to clean up his act is for Ally's sake, not his own. In the end, he realizes he wants her to be happy even if he's not in the picture.



* MissingMom: Ally's mother was a drunk who abandoned the family.

to:

* MissingMom: MissingMom:
**
Ally's mother was a drunk who abandoned the family.



* PromotedToParent: ...Jackson's dad died when he was 13, and his older brother, Bobby, apparently took care of him after that. As adults, Bobby works as Jackson's manager and still takes a paternal attitude toward him, and is still the one to manage his behavior (up until their falling out).

to:

* PromotedToParent: ...PromotionToParent: ...Jackson's dad died when he was 13, and his older brother, Bobby, apparently took care of him after that. As adults, Bobby works as Jackson's manager and still takes a paternal attitude toward him, and is still the one to manage his behavior (up until their falling out).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PracticallyDifferentGenerations: Though it's left ambiguous as to the actual age gap between the brothers is in the film, in real life Bradley Cooper and Sam Elliott have a thirty years age gap, so at the very least Bobby is old enough to have been closer to being an age more appropriate to being his brother's father instead of older sibling when he was born. Related to that...

to:

* PracticallyDifferentGenerations: Though it's left ambiguous as to If the actual thirty-one year age gap between the brothers is in the film, in real life Sam Elliott and Bradley Cooper and Sam Elliott have a thirty years age gap, so at the very least is any indication, Bobby is old enough to have been closer to being an age more appropriate to being be Jackson's dad, rather than his brother's older brother. This is [[LampshadedTrope lampshaded]] since Bobby mentions that the two were often mistaken for father instead of older sibling when he was born.and son in Jackson's younger years. Related to that...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Just making this phrased more clearly.


''A Star is Born'' is a 2018 [[{{Romance}} romantic]] {{musical}} {{drama}} directed by Creator/BradleyCooper (in his directorial debut), starring himself and Music/LadyGaga. It's also the third remake (and fourth version overall) of the 1937 film [[Film/AStarIsBorn1937 of the same name]], the second having been made [[Film/AStarIsBorn1954 in 1954]] and the third [[Film/AStarIsBorn1976 in 1976]]. This version most closely resembles the 1976 version, starring Music/BarbraStreisand and Kris Kristofferson, which was also a music story.

to:

''A Star is Born'' is a 2018 [[{{Romance}} romantic]] {{musical}} {{drama}} directed by Creator/BradleyCooper (in his directorial debut), starring himself and Music/LadyGaga. It's also the third remake (and fourth version overall) of ''A Star is Born'' to be made, following the 1937 original film in [[Film/AStarIsBorn1937 of 1937]] and the same name]], the second having been made remakes in [[Film/AStarIsBorn1954 in 1954]] and the third [[Film/AStarIsBorn1976 in 1976]]. This version most closely resembles Like the 1976 version, starring Music/BarbraStreisand and Kris Kristofferson, which was also a it is set within the music story.
industry.



This [[SimilarlyNamedWorks is not related to]] the 1948 film ''Film/ASongIsBorn''

to:

This [[SimilarlyNamedWorks is not related to]] the 1948 film ''Film/ASongIsBorn''
''Film/ASongIsBorn''.

Added: 719

Changed: 577

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeathByChildbirth: Starting off the tragedy that was Jackson's life was the fact that his mother died giving birth to him, leaving him without a mother and a father who could have cared less about him.



* DisappearedDad: Jackson's father died when he was thirteen, likely of old age since he would have been 76 at the time, leaving him to be raised by his older brother Bobby.



** Jackson's mom also died in giving birth to him.



* PromotedToParent: Jackson's dad died when he was 13, and his older brother, Bobby, apparently took care of him after that. As adults, Bobby works as Jackson's manager and still takes a paternal attitude toward him, and is still the one to manage his behavior (up until their falling out).

to:

* PromotedToParent: PracticallyDifferentGenerations: Though it's left ambiguous as to the actual age gap between the brothers is in the film, in real life Bradley Cooper and Sam Elliott have a thirty years age gap, so at the very least Bobby is old enough to have been closer to being an age more appropriate to being his brother's father instead of older sibling when he was born. Related to that...
* PromotedToParent: ...
Jackson's dad died when he was 13, and his older brother, Bobby, apparently took care of him after that. As adults, Bobby works as Jackson's manager and still takes a paternal attitude toward him, and is still the one to manage his behavior (up until their falling out).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KarmaHoudini: [[spoiler:The film doesn't depict Rez facing any consequences for more or less driving Jackson to suicide, though as the film ends shortly after that point, it is fairly likely Ally dumped him as her manager, ''or'' Rez may have felt personal guilt in the aftermath.]]

to:

* KarmaHoudini: [[spoiler:The film doesn't depict Rez facing any consequences for more or less driving Jackson to suicide, though as the film ends shortly after that point, it is fairly likely Ally dumped him as her manager, manager; ''or'' Rez may have felt personal guilt in the aftermath.aftermath (very unlikely).]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Black Best Friend has been renamed, and this may or may not fit the trope, no context to tell


* BlackBestFriend: Noodles is this to Jack.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HateSink: Rez Gavron is Ally Campano's manager who arranges for her to take on a more flashy image and more poppy songs. He demands that her husband Jackson "Jack" Maine not accompany her on her tour later after Jack gets out of rehab, which results in Ally wanting to cancel the tour. Rez berates Jack, who thought Rez was corrupting Ally's image, to his face for threatening to tank her career just with his presence and this results in Jack being DrivenToSuicide. On top of that, Rez is [[KarmaHoudini not shown after]] to feel guilt for what has happened or face any consequences either.

to:

* HateSink: Rez Gavron is Ally Campano's manager who arranges for her to take on a more flashy image and more poppy songs. He demands that her husband Jackson "Jack" Maine not accompany her on her tour later after Jack gets out of rehab, which results in Ally wanting to cancel the tour. Rez berates Jack, who thought Rez was corrupting Ally's image, to his face for threatening to tank her career just with his presence and this results in Jack [[spoiler:Jack being DrivenToSuicide.DrivenToSuicide]]. On top of that, Rez is [[KarmaHoudini not shown after]] to feel guilt for what has happened or face any consequences either.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Creator/SamElliott, Creator/GregGrunberg, [[Series/RuPaulsDragRace Shangela Laquifa Wadley]], Creator/WillamBelli, Creator/DaveChappelle, Creator/AndrewDiceClay, and Lukas Nelson (son of Music/WillieNelson) also appear, while Music/{{Halsey}} and Creator/AlecBaldwin {{cameo}} as themselves. All the musical numbers in the film were performed live on set, and feature compositions by Gaga, Nelson, Cooper, [[Music/Jason Isbell]], and Mark Ronson.

to:

Creator/SamElliott, Creator/GregGrunberg, [[Series/RuPaulsDragRace Shangela Laquifa Wadley]], Creator/WillamBelli, Creator/DaveChappelle, Creator/AndrewDiceClay, and Lukas Nelson (son of Music/WillieNelson) also appear, while Music/{{Halsey}} and Creator/AlecBaldwin {{cameo}} as themselves. All the musical numbers in the film were performed live on set, and feature compositions by Gaga, Nelson, Cooper, [[Music/Jason Isbell]], Music/JasonIsbell, and Mark Ronson.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Creator/SamElliott, Creator/GregGrunberg, [[Series/RuPaulsDragRace Shangela Laquifa Wadley]], Creator/WillamBelli, Creator/DaveChappelle, Creator/AndrewDiceClay, and Lukas Nelson (son of Music/WillieNelson) also appear, while Music/{{Halsey}} and Creator/AlecBaldwin {{cameo}} as themselves. All the musical numbers in the film were performed live on set, and feature compositions by Gaga, Nelson, Cooper, [[Music/DriveByTruckers Jason Isbell]], and Mark Ronson.

to:

Creator/SamElliott, Creator/GregGrunberg, [[Series/RuPaulsDragRace Shangela Laquifa Wadley]], Creator/WillamBelli, Creator/DaveChappelle, Creator/AndrewDiceClay, and Lukas Nelson (son of Music/WillieNelson) also appear, while Music/{{Halsey}} and Creator/AlecBaldwin {{cameo}} as themselves. All the musical numbers in the film were performed live on set, and feature compositions by Gaga, Nelson, Cooper, [[Music/DriveByTruckers Jason [[Music/Jason Isbell]], and Mark Ronson.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DiegeticMusical: The film has a original soundtrack, and all the songs are performances in front of live crowds or for television.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Mentor Ship is now YMMV; objective examples go under Teacher Student Romance


Jackson Maine (Cooper) is a veteran musician who discovers [[StarvingArtist struggling singer]] Ally (Gaga) in a night club, and quickly takes her under his wing. Their mentor-protege relationship [[MentorShip soon turns romantic]], but as Ally's career takes off under Jackson's guidance, his begins winding down, which leads to strife between them.

to:

Jackson Maine (Cooper) is a veteran musician who discovers [[StarvingArtist struggling singer]] Ally (Gaga) in a night club, and quickly takes her under his wing. Their mentor-protege relationship [[MentorShip [[TeacherStudentRomance soon turns romantic]], but as Ally's career takes off under Jackson's guidance, his begins winding down, which leads to strife between them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EvilBrit: Rez is presented as unlikable at best and [[FalseFriend toxic toward Ally]] at worst for most of the film, creating Ally's image as a manufactured pop star, and then [[spoiler: he more or less nudges Jackson towards suicide. Even worse]].

to:

* EvilBrit: Rez is presented as more or less the villain of the film (or unlikable at best and best), being [[FalseFriend toxic toward Ally]] at worst for most of the film, creating Ally's image as a manufactured pop star, and then [[spoiler: he more or less nudges Jackson towards suicide. Even worse]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/a_star_is_born_0.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:350:''We’re far from the shallow now.'']]

-->''"I'll always remember us this way."''

to:

[[quoteright:350:https://static.[[quoteright:300:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/a_star_is_born_0.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:350:''We’re [[caption-width-right:300:''"We're far from the shallow now.'']]

-->''"I'll
"'']]

->''"I'll
always remember us this way."''



** Cooper's Jackson Maine was originally known as Norman Maine (1937 & 1954) and then John Norman Howard (1976).
** Gaga's Ally is named Esther in every past adaptation (last name Blodgett in 1937 & 1954, Hoffman in 1976). In the first two films Esther adopts the {{stage name}} Vicki Lester.

to:

** Cooper's Jackson Maine was originally known as Norman Maine (1937 & and 1954) and then John Norman Howard (1976).
** Gaga's Ally is named Esther in every past adaptation (last name Blodgett in 1937 & and 1954, Hoffman in 1976). In the first two films Esther adopts the {{stage name}} Vicki Lester.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HateSink: Rez, full stop. Not only is he devoid of any redeeming qualities but [[spoiler:it's heavily implied that his abusive speech directed at Jackson is what causes the latter to commit suicide. The fact that the movie [[KarmaHoudini doesn't show Rez getting any comeuppance]]]] only increases the hate for him.

to:

* HateSink: Rez, full stop. Not only Rez Gavron is he devoid of any redeeming qualities but [[spoiler:it's heavily implied Ally Campano's manager who arranges for her to take on a more flashy image and more poppy songs. He demands that his abusive speech directed at her husband Jackson is what causes "Jack" Maine not accompany her on her tour later after Jack gets out of rehab, which results in Ally wanting to cancel the latter tour. Rez berates Jack, who thought Rez was corrupting Ally's image, to commit suicide. The fact that the movie his face for threatening to tank her career just with his presence and this results in Jack being DrivenToSuicide. On top of that, Rez is [[KarmaHoudini doesn't show Rez getting not shown after]] to feel guilt for what has happened or face any comeuppance]]]] only increases the hate for him.consequences either.

Top