History DethroningMoment / ICarly

* [=FromtheWordsofBR=]: "iSpace Out". I actually find this show to be a guilty pleasure, but this episode was just horrible. In this episode, the ''[=iCarly=]'' team gets invited to a competition against another webshow, ''Exercise Rox''. The winner of the competition gets to do a webshow [[RecycledInSpace IN SPACE!]] But, before they can do that, they have to do tests to see if they withstand the basics of space travel. All goes well...until they have to do the space pod test. That's when Carly, Sam and Freddie start getting SpaceMadness, but Carly manages to make Sam and Freddie look tame. At this point, she develops claustrophobia and can't take it anymore, and [[spoiler:breaks the window of the pod to escape from it, thus disqualifying the ''[=iCarly=]'' team in the competition.]] [[spoiler:This ending]] is especially horrible because the hype for this episode was built around ''[=iCarly=]'' doing a webshow in space! Talk about about a [[spoiler:ShaggyDogStory]]!

* Tropers/{{TheFarmboy}}: "iSell Penny Tees." Sam is running an underground sweatshop with ten-year-olds to make the shirts, and Carly and Freddy don't do anything to stop her; they only take half the kids and put them to work their own way. Now if this was Neville or some other antagonist, this would be [[MoralEventHorizon crossing the line,]] but when [[DesignatedHero Sam]] does it, [[DudeNotFunny it's supposed to be funny?]] At least she gets a form of [[LaserGuidedKarma Laser-Guided Karma]] at the end of the episode where the kids steal the Penny Tees business idea. The gang does apologize for their actions, but still...

* Tropers/{{LLSmoothJ}}: ''iOMG'': I only watch this series occasionally and Carly's actions towards Freddie in ''iParty with Victorious'' was eye roll-worthy. But let's rewind back to ''iOMG''. I think we all know exactly what this is about. The fact that promos for the follow up episode implies that they start dating motivated me enough to add this entry. So you mean to tell me that after all the hell she put Freddie through, Sam Puckett, possibly the worst love interest and biggest JerkSue since [[LoveHina Naru freaking Narusegawa]], all of a sudden is in love with Freddie and now they're going to start dating? EsotericHappyEnding doesn't even begin to describe this, [[DomesticAbuse knowing where this is likely heading]], as I believe Freddie can do and deserves a lot better than Sam or her glorified enabler Carly.

** Tropers/{{CantNotLookAtThisSite}}: What always got me about this episode is the fact that in RealLife, Fred is pretty much the JustinBieber of the web comedy circuit: you either [[{{Fandom}} love him]], or you [[{{Hatedom}} spout vile insults about him at every opportunity]]. Why Fred (and Lucas Cruikshank) is depicted as an all-loved, wonderful, Chairman Mao-like cult of personality is beyond me. I mean, at least Freddie didn't say Fred should consider killing himself or other unpleasant things -- as many, many, many people on YouTube say every day. This episode is just vile. Of course, the pathetically unfunny video montage at the end doesn't help. Paddling pools, screaming, cabbages. It's something that would captivate the sense of humour of a six-year-old child (admittedly that's probably the target demographic for this show, but my point still stands). If anything, the montage at the end proves Freddie right, and that's pretty much the icing on this cake of total crap.

''{{iCarly}}'' makes its name in ComedicSociopathy, characters being [[{{JerkAss}} Jerkasses]], multiple moments of KickTheDog and GettingCrapPastTheRadar. However, it can only go so far before it begins annoying or offending people for [[DarthWiki/WallBanger the]] [[DudeNotFunny wrong]] [[DarthWiki/DethroningMomentOfSuck reason]].

* ''iSavedYourLife'' is probably one of the lowest points in the series. Just when Freddie and Carly are starting to grow close, Sam has to go and fill Freddie's head with doubt on Carly's feelings and ruin everything. Definitely the nastiest thing Sam's ever done.

** DarkLadyCelebrian: ''iLook Alike'' is my DMOS as well. Carly acts like a complete entitled brat in this episode, and the worst part is it's portrayed as perfectly acceptable and Carly and her friends [[{{Karma Houdini}} get away with it scot-free]]. The MMA fighter beating up Spencer was horrible to watch, and even more horrible is that he's portrayed to be in the right! The episode seems to be saying that Spencer deserved to get beat up for daring to say no to [[{{Mary Sue}} Carly]] for what's probably the first time in the entire series. This episode is basically what did it for the entire show, in my opinion.
* ''iGoNuclear'' is a piece of work too. Freddie worked hard on a compost heap for his nature class, but the teacher gives him a failing grade because of the resources that were wasted to make it. Even worse, when Carly suffers a similar grade, the teacher gives her another chance, but not Freddie? Isn't that a bit unfair?

* [=FromtheWordsofBR=]: "iSpace Out". I actually find this show to be a guilty pleasure, but this episode was just horrible. In this episode, the ''[=iCarly=]'' team gets invited to a competition against another webshow, ''Exercise Rox''. The winner of the competition gets to do a webshow [[RecycledInSpace IN SPACE!]] But, before they can do that, they have to do tests to see if they withstand the basics of space travel. All goes well...until they have to do the space pod test. That's when Carly, Sam and Freddie start getting SpaceMadness, but Carly manages to make Sam and Freddie look tame. At this point, she develops claustrophobia and she can't take it anymore, and she [[spoiler:breaks the window of the pod to escape from it, thus disqualifying the ''[=iCarly=]'' team in the competition.]] [[spoiler:This ending]] is especially horrible because the hype for this episode was built around ''[=iCarly=]'' doing a webshow in space! Pardon the {{understatement}}, but....wow....just.....talk about a [[spoiler:ShaggyDogStory]]!

** Tropers/{{Eddy1215: You forgot about the part where Freddie's mom admitted she had a tracking chip planted in his brain when he was born! Seriously, how unethical can you}} get?!

** starkitty93: I liked the episode up until the last few minutes or so where Carly and her date are mocking the date's sister for being 18 and having no license, I was 18 and licenseless when I saw this episode and tgat just fueled some hatred in me, the ''Series/Victorious'' episode "Driving Tori Crazy" did something similar with Andre and Beck making fun of Tori for being 16 and licenseless.

** Tropers/{{IAmNotAFunguy}}: To me it seems this whole episode runs on the same ideology as most hard liberals seem to go by in real life. The basic idea is that "There is nothing wrong with your opinion as long as I agree with it, and if I don't then you're absolutely wrong."
** FairyDreamer: I don't know what liberals have to do with it, but I agree. That was the worst thing about the episode for me. It basically treats popular opinions as fact and if you dare to challenge them, you deserve to be harassed and beaten.

** Tropers/Eddy1215: You forgot about the part where Freddie's mom admitted she had a tracking chip planted in his brain when he was born! Seriously, how unethical can you get?!

** FariyDreamer: I don't know what liberals have to do with it, but I agree. That was the worst thing about the episode for me. It basically treats popular opinions as fact and if you dare to challenge them, you deserve to be harassed and beaten.

* Chimanruler15: I've decided to change my entry to "iThink They Kissed" because I want everyone to know just how much of a [[JerkAss huge bitch]] Carly Shay is. Firstly, when Spencer was telling Carly about his day, Carly outright ignored him, and when he told her to calm down, she hit him a few times without even apologizing. Secondly, she attempted to get Freddie to reveal his secret by using physical force on him. Thirdly, she told Sam that she found out about the kiss, despite agreeing not to mention it for Freddie's sake, and when Sam attacked Freddie, she did nothing about it. Fourthly, when the gang was tied up, she blamed Freddie for it even though she caused it by telling the escaped convicts where the duct tape was. Fifthly, she cannot learn to mind her own business. Carly, your friends don't need to tell you everything about their lives. Yes, you all promised not to keep secrets from each other, but promised =/= entitled. If they want to keep something to themselves, they have every right to do so, but considering that this is ''Carly Shay'' we are talking about, a girl who is manipulative, spoiled, whiny, entitled, rude, enabling of abuse, and dismissive of laws, privacy, and authority, it's really no surprise that she would behave in such a disgusting manner. [[CrowningMomentofAwesome The only good thing about this episode was when Freddie managed to pin down Carly.]] I honestly don't see what Freddie ever saw in this girl.

* Chimanruler15: I've decided to change my entry to "iThink They Kissed" because I want everyone to know just how much of a [[JerkAss huge bitch]] Carly Shay is. Firstly, when Spencer was telling Carly about his day, Carly outright ''ignored'' him, and when he told her to calm down, she hit him a few times without even apologizing. Secondly, she attempted to get Freddie to reveal his secret by using physical force on him. Thirdly, she told Sam that she found out about the kiss, despite agreeing not to mention it for Freddie's sake, and when Sam attacked Freddie, she did ''nothing'' about it. Fourthly, when the gang was tied up, she blamed Freddie for it even though she caused it! Fifthly, she cannot learn ''to mind her own business''. Carly, your friends don't need to tell you ''everything'' about their lives. If they want to keep something to themselves, they have every right to do so, but considering that this is ''Carly Shay'' we are talking about, a girl who is manipulative, spoiled, whiny, rude, enabling of abuse, and dismissive of laws, privacy, and authority, it's really no surprise that she would behave in such a disgusting manner. [[CrowningMomentofAwesome The only good thing about this episode was when Freddie managed to pin down Carly.]] I honestly don't see what Freddie ever saw in this girl.

* Tropers/{{TheFarmboy}}: "iSell Penny Tees." Sam is running an underground sweatshop with ten-year-olds to make the shirts, and Carly and Freddy don't do anything to stop her; they only take half the kids and put them to work their own way. Now if this was Neville or some other antagonist, this would be [[MoralEventHorizon crossing the line,]] but when [[DesignatedHero Sam]] does it, it's supposed to be funny? At least she gets a form of [[LaserGuidedKarma Laser-Guided Karma]] at the end of the episode where the kids steal the Penny Tees business idea. The gang does apologize for their actions, but still...

* Tropers/{{TheFarmboy}}: "iSell Penny Tees." Sam is running an underground sweatshop with ten-year-olds to make the shirts, and Carly and Freddy don't do anything to stop her; they only take half the kids and put them to work their own way. Now if this was Neville or some other antagonist, this would be [[MoralEventHorizon crossing the line,]] but when [[DesignatedHero Sam]] does it, [[KarmaHoudini she receives no comeuppance?]] At least she gets a form of [[LaserGuidedKarma Laser-Guided Karma]] at the end of the episode where the kids steal the Penny Tees business idea. The gang does apologize for their actions, but still...

* Chimanruler15: I've decided to change my entry to "iThink They Kissed" because I want everyone to know just how much of a [[JerkAss huge bitch]] Carly Shay is. Firstly, when Spencer was telling Carly about his day, Carly outright ''ignored'' him, and when he told her to calm down, she hit him a few times without even apologizing. Secondly, she attempted to get Freddie to reveal his secret by using physical force on him. Thirdly, she told Sam that she found out about the kiss, despite agreeing not to mention it for Freddie's sake, and when Sam attacked Freddie, she did ''nothing'' about it. Fourthly, when the gang was tied up, she blamed Freddie for it even though she caused it! Fifthly, she cannot learn ''to mind her own business''. Carly, your friends don't need to tell you ''everything'' about their lives. If they want to keep something to themselves, they have every right to do so, but considering that this is ''Carly Shay'' we are talking about, a girl who is manipulative, spoiled, whiny, rude, enabling of abuse, and dismissive of laws, privacy, and authority, it's really no surprise that she would behave in such a disgusting manner. The old Carly would never have done such a thing [[CrowningMomentofAwesome The only good thing about this episode was when Freddie managed to pin down Carly.]] I honestly don't see what Freddie ever saw in this girl.

* Chimanruler15: I've decided to change my entry to "iThinkTheyKissed" because I want everyone to know just how much of a [[JerkAss huge bitch]] Carly Shay is. Firstly, when Spencer was telling Carly about his day, Carly outright ''ignored'' him, and when he told her to calm down, she hit him a few times without even apologizing. Secondly, she attempted to get Freddie to reveal his secret by using physical force on him. Thirdly, she told Sam that she found out about the kiss, despite agreeing not to mention it for Freddie's sake, and when Sam attacked Freddie, she did ''nothing'' about it. Fourthly, when the gang was tied up, she blamed Freddie for it even though she caused it! Fifthly, she cannot learn ''to mind her own business''. Carly, your friends don't need to tell you ''everything'' about their lives. If they want to keep something to themselves, they have every right to do so, but considering that this is ''Carly Shay'' we are talking about, a girl who is manipulative, spoiled, whiny, rude, enabling of abuse, and dismissive of laws, privacy, and authority, it's really no surprise that she would behave in such a disgusting manner. The old Carly would never have done such a thing [[CrowningMomentofAwesome The only good thing about this episode was when Freddie managed to pin down Carly.]] I honestly don't see what Freddie ever saw in this girl.

* Tropers/{{TheFarmboy}}: "iSell Penny Tees." Sam is running an underground sweatshop with ten year olds to make the shirts! Now if this was Neville or some other antagonist, this would be [[MoralEventHorizon crossing the line.]] Yet when [[DesignatedHero Sam]] does it, [[KarmaHoudini she receives no comeuppance?]] At least she gets a form of [[LaserGuidedKarma Laser-Guided Karma]] at the end of the episode where the kids steal the Penny Tees business idea.
** Chimanruler15: ...not to mention that Carly and Freddy don't do anything to stop her. They only take half of the kids with them to put them to work their way. They all apologize for their actions, but still...

* Tropers/{{TheFarmboy}}: "iSell Penny Tees." Sam is running an underground sweatshop with ten year olds to make the shirts! Now if this was Neville or some other antagonist, this would be [[MoralEventHorizon crossing the line.]] Yet when [[DesignatedHero Sam]] does it, [[KarmaHoudini she receives no comeuppance?]] At least they get their comeuppance at the end of the episode where the kids steal their business idea.
** Chimanruler15: ...not to mention that Carly and Freddy don't do anything to stop her. They only take half of the kids with them to put them to work their way.

* Tropers/{{TheFarmboy}}: "iSell Penny Tees." Sam is running an underground sweatshop with ten year olds to make the shirts! Now if this was Neville or some other antagonist, this would be [[MoralEventHorizon crossing the line.]] Yet when [[DesignatedHero Sam]] does it, [[KarmaHoudini she receives no comeuppance?]]
** Chimanruler15: ...not to mention that Carly and Freddy don't do anything to stop her. They only take half of the kids with them to put them to work their way. At least they get their comeuppance at the end of the episode where the kids steal their business idea.

* Chimanruler15: My entry is "iSell Penny Tees." [[KarmaHoudini The kids got away with stealing iCarly's Penny Tee business idea.]] [[PlotHole I find it odd that the iCarly gang didn't sue the kids.]] Daka didn't hesitate to threaten to sue the iCarly gang before despite the fact that they were kids, [[PlotInducedStupidity so why did the iCarly gang buy the idea that suing ten-year-olds wouldn't work?]] I honestly hope that Socko's sister shut down the company because that ending was very unsatisfying.
** Tropers/{{TheFarmboy}}: This episode is rather awful for a different reason. Maybe it could be the... oh, I don't know... that Sam is running an ''underground sweatshop with ten year olds to make the shirts?!'' Now if this was Neville or some other antagonist, this would be [[MoralEventHorizon crossing the line.]] Yet when [[DesignatedHero Sam]] does it, [[KarmaHoudini she recieve no comeuppance?]] The fact that the kids hijacked the idea would really be a [[CrowningMomentofAwesome CMoA]] instead of a Dethroning Moment.

* Tropers/{{Supernintendo128}}: For me, it was "iFind Spencer Friends". Spencer's Birthday is coming up and his only adult friend, Socko, is out of town. So Carly, Sam, Freddie, and Gibby find friends for him. After Spencer meets his new "friends", they all eat at the local restaurant. However, they turnout to be boring and [[JerkAss unlikable.]] What bothers me is that they never told Spencer about this until after they found the guys. I know they were trying to help but still. Another thing that bothers me is the subplot. Gibby is hanging out at the diner's bathroom when someone mistakes him for the bathroom attendant. He decides to work as the the bathroom attendant [[GetRichQuickScheme so he can make money]]. Does the manager even know that he's the bathroom attendant? And that Emma Stone cameo was unfunny, felt forced, and [[BigLippedAlligatorMoment it came out of nowhere]]. [[AdvertisedExtra And that's what the hype for this episode was built around, a 30-second Emma Stone cameo that comes out of nowhere!]] During the climax, a waiter tries to blow snot on Freddie's Nachos to get revenge on him for making fun of the way he talks. Um, is he aware that [[DidntThinkThisThrough he could get fired for doing that!?]] Luckily, it ends up at Spencer's table and it made his so-called "friends" sick. The episode ends with Spencer, Carly, and her friends celebrating Spencer's birthday. That's it? [[WhatHappenedToTheMouse What about finding spencer friends?]]

* Supernintendo128: For me, it was "iFind Spencer Friends". Spencer's Birthday is coming up and his only adult friend, Socko, is out of town. So Carly, Sam, Freddie, and Gibby find friends for him. After Spencer meets his new "friends", they all eat at the local restaurant. However, they turnout to be boring and [[JerkAss unlikable.]] What bothers me is that they never told Spencer about this until after they found the guys. I know they were trying to help but still. Another thing that bothers me is the subplot. Gibby is hanging out at the diner's bathroom when someone mistakes him for the bathroom attendant. He decides to work as the the bathroom attendant [[GetRichQuickScheme so he can make money]]. Does the manager even know that he's the bathroom attendant? And that Emma Stone cameo was unfunny, felt forced, and [[BigLippedAlligatorMoment it came out of nowhere]]. [[AdvertisedExtra And that's what the hype for this episode was built around, a 30-second Emma Stone cameo that comes out of nowhere!]] During the climax, a waiter tries to blow snot on Freddie's Nachos to get revenge on him for making fun of the way he talks. Um, is he aware that [[DidntThinkThisThrough he could get fired for doing that!?]] Luckily, it ends up at Spencer's table and it made his so-called "friends" sick. The episode ends with Spencer, Carly, and her friends celebrating Spencer's birthday. That's it? [[WhatHappenedToTheMouse What about finding spencer friends?]]