Follow TV Tropes

Following

History BittersweetEnding / Literature

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/AScannerDarkly'': Bob/Fred's Substance D addiction has caused him such catastrophic brain damage that he completely loses his sanity and sense of self, and he's shipped off to the only rehab center for Substance D in existence. Only it turns out that the people running the rehab center are the ones growing the flowers that Substance D is distilled from, and that Donna was really an undercover cop who purposely pushed Bob/Fred into his breakdown so she'd have a mole in their organization. The only thing keeping the book from looking too down is that Bob/Fred retains enough presence of mind to bring the evidence back home to his superiors...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moved from the Anime and Manga subpage

Added DiffLines:

* While it can be considered a DownerEnding by some readers/viewers, ''Literature/AiNoKusabi'' ends with both protagonists finally getting together only to die in each others' arms moments later.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:




* ''Literature/DustDevils'': Cody ends up losing his father and stepfather to the vampires and is forced to destroy his friend Willet, who has been turned into a vampire. That said, Cody does end up destroying the entire vampire gang and avenging their many victims, and he settles down with Marguerite and states they'll name their possible future son Jack in honour of Cody's father.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the ''Literature/TheBlackMagicianTrilogy'', they defeat the Ichani but [[HeroicSacrifice Akkarin, Sonea's love interest, dies giving Sonea all his power]].

to:

* In the ''Literature/TheBlackMagicianTrilogy'', they defeat the Ichani but [[HeroicSacrifice Akkarin, Sonea's love interest, dies giving Sonea all his power]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


* ''Literature/NoGodsForDrowning'': The city of Valentine falls, a lot of people die and Lilac never ends up returning her mother, the goddess Logoi to save it. Arcadia Myrn, though, gains godhood and uses it to create a truce between humanity and the Glories, with the land divided between them and humanity beginning to recover. Arcadia also reveals to Lilac that she will one day have a new child as well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/ABadPlaceToBeAHero'' ends with Lokenn dead, while Corlis and Thessa manage to earn their freedom from the paladins but otherwise gain nothing out of the ordeal. Corlis also lost his aunt Ulmira in the process, and even though it was her wish to die, it still clearly takes an emotional toll on him. Still, after all is said and done, the two survivors agree to turn over a new leaf and [[FireForgedFriends start over as friends]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/OldMortality'': Lord Evandale dies, but Basil's death means Lady Margaret regains her lands while Henry and Edith are finally able to marry.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/CagingSkies'': Elsa escapes Jojo, but she's in a whole new world with no money or resources, and Jojo grieves her loss alone.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/WhatShouldDannyDo'': One of the nine possible endings in the first book has Danny enjoying a bath, but still disappointed that he was denied a trip to the park as punishment for arguing with his brother Charlie and made to clean his room.

Added: 206

Changed: 260

Removed: 238

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Literature/HisDarkMaterials'' is a children's series, but ends with The Authority destroyed and his Regent, Metatron, eliminated... but in the process, Lord Asriel and Mrs. Coulter are trapped in the space between worlds for eternity, and Will and Lyra are separated into their own worlds because moving between worlds results in the end of Dust. They would've been able to stay together, but people who stay in a non-native world lead shorter lives than they would in their native world, typically dying only a few short years due to disease. Truly unfair.
** At least Will and Lyra have the consolation that they will [[TogetherInDeath meet again one day and then never part again]]. That's what they promised themselves, and that makes it easier for them to endure being unable to be together.

to:

* ''Literature/HisDarkMaterials'' is a children's series, but ends with The Authority destroyed and his Regent, Metatron, eliminated... but in the process, Lord Asriel and Mrs. Coulter are trapped in the space between worlds for eternity, and Will and Lyra are separated into their own worlds because moving between worlds results in the end of Dust. They would've been able to stay together, but people who stay in a non-native world lead shorter lives than they would in their native world, typically dying only a few short years due to disease. Truly unfair.
** At
unfair, but at least Will and Lyra they have the consolation that they will [[TogetherInDeath meet again one day and then never part again]]. That's what they promised themselves, and that makes it easier for them to endure being unable to be together.



* ''Literature/InheritanceCycle'' In the end, Eragon defeats Galbatorix and all ends well in Alagaesia, but he has to leave the place. Even after Arya and Eragon all but say they loved each other they separate because of their duties. Poor Nasuada was left alone by Murtagh, when he leaves for his soul-healling trip.

to:

* ''Literature/InheritanceCycle'' In the end, Eragon defeats Galbatorix and all ends well in Alagaesia, but he has to leave the place. Even after Arya and Eragon all but say they loved each other they separate because of their duties. Poor Nasuada was left alone by Murtagh, when he leaves for his soul-healling soul-healing trip.


Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/JessicasGhost'': Jessica [[AscendToAHigherPlaneOfExistence ascends to the afterlife]], but she changed Francis, Andi, and Roland's lives for the better, and the three are still close friends.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Cormac [=McCarthy=]'s ''The Road''. The father dies, completely uncertain and afraid of his son's future in the post-apocalyptic wasteland. It's believed to have been a worthwhile sacrifice, however, as his son was finally able to find some place safe to be raised by decent people. The ending is then given even more bittersweetness as the epilogue implies that humanity will never be able to recover from the catastrophe that befell the earth, and will eventually die out completely. Still, given [=McCarthy=]'s usual KillEmAll tactic, this is practically a parade with balloons and circus animals.

to:

* Cormac [=McCarthy=]'s ''The Road''. The father dies, completely uncertain and afraid of his son's future in the post-apocalyptic wasteland. It's believed to have been a worthwhile sacrifice, however, as his son was finally able to find some place safe to be raised by decent people. The ending is then given even more bittersweetness as the epilogue implies that humanity will never be able to recover from the catastrophe that befell the earth, and will eventually die out completely. Still, given [=McCarthy=]'s usual KillEmAll EverybodyDiesEnding tactic, this is practically a parade with balloons and circus animals.



* One of the {{Trope Codifier}}s: Creator/CharlesDickens' ''Literature/ATaleOfTwoCities''.

to:

* One of the {{Trope Codifier}}s: Creator/CharlesDickens' ''Literature/ATaleOfTwoCities''. Sydney takes Darnay's place at the guillotine, sacrificing himself so that Darnay can live peacefully in England.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/LastNightAtTheTelegraphClub'': Lily reunites with Kath and it's indicated the two may rekindle their relationship. However, what will happen to both with their disapproving families isn't clear. We also never learn what happened with Joyce and Tommy, who faced charges over letting teenage lesbians into the club, nor if it will be closed for good.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Crosswicking Secret Vampire

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/SecretVampire'': Poppy beat cancer by becoming a vampire, she's accepted by the Night World because she's discovered to have been a lost witch, and she and Janes finally get together. However, in the process Poppy has lost her human life, which includes never being able to see her mother and stepfather again (who believe she died), and having limited contact with her brother. The book ends with Poppy telepathically talking to her mother while she sleeps and giving her a happy dream, telling her "I'm okay now, Mom. You don't have to worry about me anymore." before driving off into the night with her soulmate, James.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/ASickDayForAmosMcGee'': Amos still hasn't fully recovered by the end of the story, but he's improving.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/TheHoundOfTheBaskervilles'': Holmes manages to save Henry Baskerville's life, but he is left a nervous wreck and heartbroken by the fact that Beryl was (probably) playing with his heart, albeit to save his life. Beryl is free after years of abuse and neglect, but it is uncertain what type of future she can have, either with Sir Henry or on her own.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Creator/HansChristianAndersen
** ''Literature/TheLittleMatchGirl'': The titular little girl [[DyingAlone freezes to death all alone in an alley]], but from her perspective, it's a happy ending; [[TogetherInDeath she's guided to Heaven by the spirit of her grandmother]], the only person who ever treated her with any love and kindness, and is finally free of her miserable life with her abusive father. [[TooGoodForThisSinfulEarth The people who find her the next morning realize how pointlessly tragic her death was]], [[GoOutWithASmile but note that she passed away with a smile on her face]].
** ''Literature/TheLittleMermaid'': The prince falls for the woman he ''thought'' rescued him. The poor transformed, mute mermaid sadly carries her train at the wedding. When offered a chance to become a mermaid again instead of dying by killing the man she loved, she decides not to take it. She does die physically, but God transforms her into an air spirit. This is because mermaids don't have immortal souls, and in fact the mermaid hoped to gain one by marrying the prince. As an air spirit, she will have the chance to shape a soul for herself, though it is clearly stated it will take centuries. Not surprisingly, many prefer the Franchise/DisneyAnimatedCanon take on this story.

to:

* Creator/HansChristianAndersen
By all accounts, Creator/HansChristianAndersen [[CreatorBreakdown was a very depressed man]]. Out of all his fairy tales, there are only a few with unambiguously happy endings.
** ''Literature/TheLittleMatchGirl'': The titular little girl [[DyingAlone freezes to death all alone in an alley]], but from her perspective, it's a happy ending; [[TogetherInDeath she's guided to Heaven by the spirit of her grandmother]], the only person who ever treated her with any love and kindness, and is finally free of her miserable life with her abusive father. [[TooGoodForThisSinfulEarth The people who find her the next morning realize how pointlessly tragic her death was]], [[GoOutWithASmile but note that she passed away with a smile on her face]].
face]]. As such, some remakes from our more cynical times either rewrite it to give her a more materialistic HappyEnding ([[DeusExMachina somehow]]) or portray it as a truly tear-jerking DownerEnding with no belief in a good afterlife. [[Literature/{{Hogfather}} Even Death can't stand it.]]
** ''Literature/TheLittleMermaid'': The prince falls for the woman he ''thought'' rescued him. The poor transformed, mute mermaid sadly carries her train at the wedding. When offered a chance to become a mermaid again instead of dying by killing the man she loved, she decides not to take it. She does die physically, but God transforms her into an air spirit.spirit, a "daughter of air" with the prospect of eventually entering Heaven, very probably a result of revision by Andersen. This is because mermaids don't have immortal souls, and in fact the mermaid hoped to gain one by marrying the prince. As an air spirit, she will have the chance to shape a soul for herself, though it is clearly stated it will take centuries. Not surprisingly, many prefer the Franchise/DisneyAnimatedCanon take on this story. Initially this was the selected ending, even put in the working title, but there was a reworked version in which the mermaid apparently just dissolved into foam in the end. Even the happier version has the FridgeHorror of knowing that the [[DeaderThanDead dissolving into foam]] fate is eventually going to befall the Little Mermaid's sisters and family if they don't act as she did.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/TheYearling'': Jody returns home, but Flag is dead and the novel implies that Ezra might not recover from his illness.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/{{Metaltown}}'' ends with Jed Schultz killed, Minnick ousted, Colin's family with enough to live on, and working conditions improve across the board with hope to eventually transition away from weapon making, but Ty is also dead, Lena's father remains untouchable, and the war is still ongoing by the time the book ends.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Literature/{{Evernight}}'': Almost ever book ends with one:

to:

* ''Literature/{{Evernight}}'': Almost ever every book ends with one:



** The fifth book's ending. The main bitterness comes from the fact Skye and Balthazar will have to face the constant threat of vampires coming after Skye for her blood, and her parents are still in denial about their son's death and will now lose their daughter too. However Redgrave has finally gotten his comeuppance for all his atrocities, there's a possibility Charity and Balthazar could repair their relationship, Skye comes to terms with Dakota's death and her powers, and she and Balthazar are happy together.

to:

** The fifth book's ending. ''Balthazar'': The main bitterness comes from the fact Skye and Balthazar will have to face the constant threat of vampires coming after Skye for her blood, and her parents are still in denial about their son's death and will now lose their daughter too. However Redgrave has finally gotten his comeuppance for all his atrocities, there's a possibility Charity and Balthazar could repair their relationship, Skye comes to terms with Dakota's death and her powers, and she and Balthazar are happy together.

Changed: 1794

Removed: 330

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Literature/{{Evernight}}'': Every single book has one:
** The first book: Bianca and Lucas are forced to part, but vow to always love one another and find a way to be together.
** The second book: [[spoiler: Bianca and Lucas get to be together, but she has to leave her family and friends behind, if Black Cross figures out she's a vampire she's screwed and ghosts are coming after her]].
** The third book: The only thing that stops from slipping into DownerEnding territory is the fact that [[spoiler: Lucas and Bianca will still get to be together (even if they're both dead)]].
** The fourth book: [[spoiler: Bianca and Lucas can finally be together, Mrs Bethany has been defeated and the vampires and humans of Evernight are saved. But, Lucas will inevitably die someday, though he says that living on in Bianca is fine by him, Balthazar is still all alone (though this is resolved in the SpinOff when he falls in love with Skye), Lucas will probably never see his mother again and Black Cross will be hunting them.]]
** The fifth book, though it has a much happier ending compared to the others. The main bitterness comes from the fact [[spoiler: Skye and Balthazar will have to face the constant threat of vampires coming after her for her blood, and her parents are still in denial about their son's death and will now lose their daughter too]].

to:

* ''Literature/{{Evernight}}'': Every single Almost ever book has ends with one:
** The first book: ''Evernight'' ends with Bianca and Lucas are being forced to part, part ways for their own safety, but they vow to always love one another and find a way to be together.
together. They both hold onto the hope that they will see each other again.
** The second book: [[spoiler: At the end of ''Stargazer'' Bianca and Lucas get runs away from Evernight to be together, with Lucas; they're happy to be together but she it's tainted by the fact Bianca has to leave her family and friends behind, if behind (and didn't have a chance to reconcile with her parents beforehand), she and Lucas are currently stuck with a Black Cross figures cell who will likely kill her if they figure out she's a vampire she's screwed and vampire, plus ghosts are still coming after her]].
her.
** The third book: The only thing that stops from slipping into DownerEnding territory ''Afterlife'': Lucas' humanity is the fact that [[spoiler: Lucas and Bianca will still get to be together (even if they're both dead)]].
** The fourth book: [[spoiler:
restored, Bianca and Lucas can finally be together, together openly and with her parents' acceptance, Mrs Bethany has been defeated defeated, and the vampires vampires, wraiths and humans of Evernight are saved. But, It's not a straight HappilyEverAfter though, due to a few factors: Lucas will inevitably die someday, someday though he says that living on in Bianca is fine by him, Balthazar is still all alone (though this is resolved in the SpinOff when he falls in love with Skye), Lucas will probably never see his mother again and Black Cross will be hunting them.]]
them.
** The fifth book, though it has a much happier ending compared to the others. book's ending. The main bitterness comes from the fact [[spoiler: Skye and Balthazar will have to face the constant threat of vampires coming after her Skye for her blood, and her parents are still in denial about their son's death and will now lose their daughter too]].too. However Redgrave has finally gotten his comeuppance for all his atrocities, there's a possibility Charity and Balthazar could repair their relationship, Skye comes to terms with Dakota's death and her powers, and she and Balthazar are happy together.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/RoysBedoys'':
** At the end of “You’re Grounded, Roys Bedoys!”, Roys apologises to his mother and Loys, but he’s still grounded and can’t go to Maker’s party. However, Maker brings the Bedoys brothers a donut each.
** “Roys Bedoys Goes to the Hospital” ends with Roys watching a movie with his friends and brother, but still bedridden in the hospital.
** At the end of “Get Well Soon, Roys Bedoys!”, Roys is starting to recover from his respiratory virus, but hasn’t yet.
** “Easter is Cancelled, Roys Bedoys!” ends on the Bedoys brothers getting candy and money, but their parents not getting any prizes and Mr. Bedoys being made to sniff Roys’s dirty sock.
** At the end of “Just Tell the Truth, Roys Bedoys!”, Roys gets punished for throwing his console, while Loys gets punished for blackmailing his brother, but Roys is still happy that he isn’t a “slave” anymore.
** At the end of “Where Are You, Roys Bedoys?”, Roys is grounded for not asking permission to go to Maker’s house, but the family is happy to have him back.
** In “Don’t Be Late, Roys Bedoys!”, Roys never gets the gingerbread house kit he wanted, but he can help Loys build one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''Literature/TheLittleMatchGirl'': The titular little girl freezes to death, but from her perspective, it's a happy ending; [[TogetherInDeath she's guided to Heaven by the spirit of her grandmother]], the only person who ever treated her with any love and kindness, and is finally free of her miserable life with her abusive father. [[TooGoodForThisSinfulEarth The people who find her the next morning realize how tragic and unnecessary her death was, but note that she died with a smile on her face]].

to:

** ''Literature/TheLittleMatchGirl'': The titular little girl [[DyingAlone freezes to death, death all alone in an alley]], but from her perspective, it's a happy ending; [[TogetherInDeath she's guided to Heaven by the spirit of her grandmother]], the only person who ever treated her with any love and kindness, and is finally free of her miserable life with her abusive father. [[TooGoodForThisSinfulEarth The people who find her the next morning realize how pointlessly tragic and unnecessary her death was, was]], [[GoOutWithASmile but note that she died passed away with a smile on her face]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''Literature/TheLittleMatchGirl: The titular little girl freezes to death, but from her perspective, it's a happy ending; [[TogetherInDeath she's guided to Heaven by the spirit of her grandmother]], the only person who ever treated her with any love and kindness, and is finally free of her miserable life with her abusive father. [[TooGoodForThisSinfulEarth The people who find her the next morning realize how tragic and unnecessary her death was, but note that she died with a smile on her face]].

to:

** ''Literature/TheLittleMatchGirl: ''Literature/TheLittleMatchGirl'': The titular little girl freezes to death, but from her perspective, it's a happy ending; [[TogetherInDeath she's guided to Heaven by the spirit of her grandmother]], the only person who ever treated her with any love and kindness, and is finally free of her miserable life with her abusive father. [[TooGoodForThisSinfulEarth The people who find her the next morning realize how tragic and unnecessary her death was, but note that she died with a smile on her face]].

Added: 1189

Changed: 685

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Creator/HansChristianAndersen's ''Literature/TheLittleMermaid'': The prince falls for the woman he ''thought'' rescued him. The poor transformed, mute mermaid sadly carries her train at the wedding. When offered a chance to become a mermaid again instead of dying by killing the man she loved, she decides not to take it. She does die physically, but God transforms her into an air spirit. This is because mermaids don't have immortal souls, and in fact the mermaid hoped to gain one by marrying the prince. As an air spirit, she will have the chance to shape a soul for herself, though it is clearly stated it will take centuries. Not surprisingly, many prefer the Franchise/DisneyAnimatedCanon take on this story.

to:

* Creator/HansChristianAndersen's Creator/HansChristianAndersen
** ''Literature/TheLittleMatchGirl: The titular little girl freezes to death, but from her perspective, it's a happy ending; [[TogetherInDeath she's guided to Heaven by the spirit of her grandmother]], the only person who ever treated her with any love and kindness, and is finally free of her miserable life with her abusive father. [[TooGoodForThisSinfulEarth The people who find her the next morning realize how tragic and unnecessary her death was, but note that she died with a smile on her face]].
**
''Literature/TheLittleMermaid'': The prince falls for the woman he ''thought'' rescued him. The poor transformed, mute mermaid sadly carries her train at the wedding. When offered a chance to become a mermaid again instead of dying by killing the man she loved, she decides not to take it. She does die physically, but God transforms her into an air spirit. This is because mermaids don't have immortal souls, and in fact the mermaid hoped to gain one by marrying the prince. As an air spirit, she will have the chance to shape a soul for herself, though it is clearly stated it will take centuries. Not surprisingly, many prefer the Franchise/DisneyAnimatedCanon take on this story.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Literature/UnderHeaven'': The Ninth Dynasty survives, and the Ang Li Rebellion is suppressed, but several named characters die, and the Emperor steps aside in favor of his DesignatedHeir.

to:

* ''Literature/UnderHeaven'': The Ninth Dynasty survives, and the Ang Li Rebellion is suppressed, but several named characters die, and the Emperor steps aside in favor of his DesignatedHeir.[[HeirClubForMen Designated Heir]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Ill Boy has been changed to Delicate And Sickly. Example does not fit criteria for trope.


* ''Literature/ForestOfTheNight'': The main character fulfills her childhood dream in the end. But by then, her mentor is dead, as is the [[IllBoy disabled native child]] whom she'd befriended. She's had to dump her boyfriend, because it's clear he'll never fully understand her. And she's become [[KnightInSourArmor generally disillusioned]].

to:

* ''Literature/ForestOfTheNight'': The main character fulfills her childhood dream in the end. But by then, her mentor is dead, as is the [[IllBoy disabled native child]] child whom she'd befriended. She's had to dump her boyfriend, because it's clear he'll never fully understand her. And she's become [[KnightInSourArmor generally disillusioned]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/APoisonDarkAndDrowning'': London has fallen to [[EldritchAbomination the Ancients]], Rook has been turned into the new Korozoth, the sorcerers of England have been reduced to a few hundred, and [[TheProtagonist Henrietta]] has been made into an Unclean. However, she and George Blackwood have gathered all the remaining sorcerers of England and brought them to his estate in Sorrow-Fell, where they plan to make their final assault against the Ancients.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** ''Literature/TheSleeperAndTheSpindle'': The curse is broken, the witch defeated and deceased, everyone who was enchanted has woken up and the queen decides to choose her own path in life with her friends, rather than resign herself to a role she doesn't want -- but the princess remains an old woman whose life was stolen from her, and she might never wake again.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/TheTaleOfJemimaPuddleDuck'' ends with Jemima saved from the [[FoulFox Sandy-Whiskered Gentleman]], but the dogs also eat her eggs. She later lays more eggs, but it's implied that some of the unhatched chicks died, since the narration notes that "only" four of the eggs hatched, implying there were more.

Top