TV Tropes Org
site search
X 1999 back to reviews
Comments
Violent Seinen seen by Women
X/1999 is a big Take That to the beliefs that Shojo Tastes Like Diabetes and that women can't write anything worthy of consideration.

CLAMP is the Moustache De Plume of a group of female writers. Yes, all women. And they rock.

X/1999 is basically a complete subversion of the Shojo tropes. Even though we still see the usual romance and Ship Tease that are the defining trait of the genre, the high degree of violence, the focus on morality rather than feelings and the intricate symbolism are completely alien to a classical female-oriented and female-written media. Actually this mix of genres has appealed to a larger demographics than expected.

The story itself uses a lot of Seinen elements and all characters are developed sufficiently, given their own motivations and moral conflicts, all struggling with a supposedly inevitable fate and driving the plot relentlessly towards its climatic conclusion. The pace is steady and , despite being stalled in the manga, and walks the line of the Sliding Scale Of Idealism Versus Cynicism, using a lot of references of various religions, tarot, Japanese culture and even Freemasonry.

The series is declined through 3 media: the manga that remains unfinished but that is still enjoyable albeit frustrating since it leaves many questions unanswered; the film that is based on the manga and follows it loosely and gives a massive Downer Ending; and the TV animé series, that is more faithful to the manga and offers a more uplifting yet Bittersweet Ending.

All declinations are worthy by themselves but This Troper has a preference for the Animé that offers more interesting and in-depth perspectives than the film and that, unlike the manga, doesn't frustrate viewers with unfinished business. On the other hand, the film had to condensate which is a little difficult given the plot's intricacy.

Bottomline, it's a very creative and original series that refreshes Seinen standards with the sensitivity of women, yet is still very violent, cynical and dark, hence by no means intended to young children or squeamish viewers.
Personally, neither I nor the people I willingly associate with would ever claim that women can't write anything worthy of consideration. But I've never even remotely enjoyed anything by CLAMP, and all my female friends hold them in disdain.

Far from refreshing Seinen standards, when I told one of the aforementioned friends that I was mostly reading seinen rather than shonen at that point, on the basis that I found it better thought out with more compelling narrative, she offered CLAMP's body of work as a counterexample.

Speaking as a guy who not only counts quite a few female authors among my favorites, but occasionally enjoys works deliberately targeted at women, CLAMP is, well, not the last creative force that comes to mind as a positive example of a feminine touch in writing (that would probably be Stephanie Meyer,) but it's still nowhere on my list of recommendations.
comment #332 Desertopa 31st May 09 (edited by: Desertopa)
Clamp rock. There's no need to say more.
comment #2052 186.140.199.2 13th Mar 10
I agree. One of the greatest comic/manga of all times.
comment #2053 186.140.199.2 13th Mar 10
Would I like this if I like Berserk? Probably would if I liked Devilman, I'm sure.
comment #7420 Schitzo 25th Apr 11
I like the tv series for being able to sucess at expanding the series... but the ending... dammit that ending. I cannot help but hate it, maybe because it feels rushed nad maybe because they are good at expanding and not as writting from scratch, I do not know. Also how many things got cut :(
comment #9488 Romanticide 27th Aug 11
I like the tv series for being able to sucess at expanding the series... but the ending... dammit that ending. I cannot help but hate it, maybe because it feels rushed nad maybe because they are good at expanding and not as writting from scratch, I do not know. Also how many things got cut :(
comment #9489 Romanticide 27th Aug 11
In order to post comments, you need to Get Known
TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy