Changed w/o discussion: Sinister Schnoz

The image on Sinister Schnoz was recently changed from this◊ (from String Theory) to a big collage. I actually think the new pic's an improvement on the page, but it's too crowded and too focused on Disney villains, plus I don't think Bela Lugosi's distinctive enough to really count. My suggestion would be to cut the rightmost column off since those characters' noses aren't as prominent as the others, and reformat the rest of the pics so they're not squashed horizontally, although if there's other examples that could be thrown into the mix, we can certainly discuss them.

I'd suggest a less Disney-centric collage. Maybe one that excludes the Despicable Me character (he's hardly an actual villain) and includes the previous image's character?

Heiss? Was going to suggest Ganon, but that game is featured enough as it is.

Gru from Despicable Me is totally a villain, but that's Anton Ego from Ratatouille.

The original looks more sinister I'd say, though I think most of the images in the second row could be better; 1 for not looking evil enough, 2 for not being evil enough, and 3 for drawing more attention to his crooked teeth than his nose.

Order UP!

The original images are artifacty-fied so its gonna have to be redone with higher quality components.

edited 20th Jul '15 6:08:03 PM by Paktra

Can we replace the Wicked Witch of the West with something else though? Like the removed entries, her nose is not prominent at all.

Agreed, unless there's a profile pic of her or the illustrations of her from the book show her nose better.

EDIT: Found one◊

edited 20th Jul '15 9:16:16 PM by Willbyr

That might just be better standalone

I like the solo shot.

That also works.

I'm good with just that by itself.

for 9.

I feel having a standalone image is better for this trope. I don't see any benefit of making it collage. Especially since it makes the noses smaller; obscuring the very thing the trope image is trying to display.

edited 23rd Jul '15 6:54:50 AM by peasant

Adding my for 9.

Yeah, 9 works well enough on its for the reasons above.

I agree with 13.

9 is good.

If we're doing 9 as a picture, then how about "I smell you, my pretty — and your little dog too!" as a caption?

^ Works well enough.

*pfffft* I like that.

EDIT: We've got enough consensus for the Wicked Witch pic, so it's up and tagged. Old pic:

edited 25th Jul '15 8:53:08 AM by Willbyr

Caption's up.

Anyone else good with that caption?

It's not bad.

I can live with that

Works for me.

Any pothole suggestions?