The Place for Purging Porn and Pedo-Pandering (AKA P5 flag evaluations)

After careful deliberation, I am going to devilhead Gore Screaming Show after all. While it apparently has enough plot to not count as porn, Yuka (the purple haired one) looks too much like a kid to keep the page.

Edit: Also angelheaded Silver Chaos 2 since upthread discussion suggested it's not very porny and there aren't any characters who look young enough to count as pedopandering.

edited 7th Aug '12 6:53:44 AM by tdgoodrich1

Since the name was mentioned once again recently: today, it's two months since Catalogue was last seen here. What to do? Whatever has happened to him (we hope he's fine and the absence is only due to serious real life issues), the P5 are still short of one member, and I'm baffled at how often the issue has been danced around, with replies like "Well, Catalogue has already taken prolonged absences in the past". For how long can we still go on with that? At worst, his absence has been a big problem in the weeks between Martello quitting and tgoodrich's induction in the P5; at best, it's irrelevant because a lot of issues are being resolved and the few 2 angels / 2 devils ties could be resolved without his input.Unless the current four are considered enough, it's time to find a replacement P5. If and when Catalogue hopefully returns, I'm sure he won't be offended.

And I swear this is the last time I raise the issue, hoping it doesn't fall on deaf ears once again.

New information about Family Project: Apparently it has a clean PSP port. Since this cuts out the problematic underaged content and the story is otherwise perfectly fine it should get an angel instead of more devilheads. I was originally going to write this post saying it needs to be cut but then I went and looked that up.

Most likely the issue will be put on hold until we get a bunch of deadlocked votes.

@Arha: A clean PSP port, eh? Well, since I'm the only one who voted on it, I'll just zap it, reflag it, and give it an angelhead. Thanks for letting us know about the clean version, good sir.

Thanks for catching that. Angelheaded.

Gave VisualNovel.Family Project the third angel, and a "Bleached Underpants only" disposition.

As for Webcomic.The Key To Her Heart, after reading it, I have to give it a devil-head. Every single chapter has a sex scene which the plot revolves around. Not really seeing any way to call it anything else.

edited 7th Aug '12 1:17:26 PM by Discar

Gave it third devil, doomed it.

Shintaro Kago: Seems to be a guro creator (and why doesn't that have its own page?) and a lot of works to check. It seems that at least one (Multiplication) is not about sex, so keepworthy.

CaptainGerBear: Will depend upon Grant's fate.

Grant: Not sure where on the linked page to search.

Bartleby Tales seems to be here (No evidence of NSFW content so far on the linked page)

Death Note Smut Fic clearly violates the "No directory of porn or explicit content" rule. Kill it.

Suika (apart from a misuse of lolicon) has a Wikipedia page. I'll see on Sankaku Complex too - they seem to collect all the most questionable images from eroges after all.

Suika is safe either way since it has multiple Bleached Underpants versions.

vndb page on Suika http://vndb.org/v99.

edit: It has 9 non 18+ versions.

edited 7th Aug '12 3:20:53 PM by shadis

I'm conflicted on Webcomic.Druids. While it has some explicit sex scenes, I can't say that it has a higher ratio of explicit to non-explicit strips than Oglaf or The Blonde Marvel, both of which we kept.

I'm leaning towards giving it an angel for now, with the plan to revisit it once there's more material available.

eta: Pulling the trigger on cutting Miss World 96 Nude, however.

edited 7th Aug '12 3:22:41 PM by Meeble

^Yeah, that game is practically porn. I once saw some TGWTG guys play that and they had to bust out the censor bars.

edited 7th Aug '12 3:38:56 PM by RocketDude

Put request for cleanup of Family Project in the Special Efforts Thread. Also cleared out the "Resolved, but not done" list as best I could. Still no progress on Kanojo no Kagi Wo Akeru Houhou, Ironwood, or Omamori Himari AFAICT.

UPDATE: Family Project declared clean. Also, Koihime Musou resolved to keep, clean mentions of 18+ versions.

edited 7th Aug '12 7:39:47 PM by tdgoodrich1

I have a long work-day tomorrow, but if there needs to be some fanfiction read on Thursday or Friday to help out, I can give judgments there, if there's still a few that need parsing.

Update on The List:

• First page:
  • Druids, 2 devils and 2 angels.
  • Daiteikoku, 2 devils and 0 angels.
• Second page:
  • Shortbus, 0 devils and 2 angels.

About Hentai Kamen:

First of all, I haven't read it and because I'm at a work computer right now (though not on the clock yet, so I can do personal stuff) I don't want to go looking for scanlations.

However, before anyone votes against it just because of the name, I want to point a few things out.

For starters, "Hentai" is not the Japanese word for porn or even cartoon porn. Only non-Japanese folk use it that way. "Hentai" in Japan simply means "pervert" or "perverted" and does not necessarily imply pornography.

The Other Wiki classifies it as a comedy, martial arts and superhero strip, but says nothing about it being pornographic, or even ecchi.

According to The Other Wiki, it is a shounen demographic series carried in Weekly Shonen Jump. This is an extremely mainstream magazine that also carries series like Bleach, One Piece, Hunter X Hunter, Nurarihyon No Mago, and Yu Gi Oh.

The Anime News Network classifies it as action and comedy, and does not tag it as being ecchi, porn, lolicon, shotacon or anything of the sort.

It does list "objectionable content" as "significant", however that can be misleading. "Significant" is actualy one of their lowest categories. If the manga was pornographic, the article would say "pornographic" instead. Also, for their purposes, swearing, violence, and minor nudity even of fully grown adults all counts as "significant objectionable content".

MyAnimeList categorizes it as Comedy, Ecchi, Martial Arts, and Shounen.

In summary, it would appear that this is at most ecchi shounen, not porn in any way.

edited 8th Aug '12 6:21:37 AM by Catbert

IIRC Hentai Kamen is not porn at all. Just perverted. Protagonist undresses to his undies, slaps another pair on his face and beats shit up, but not actually has any sex.

edited 8th Aug '12 4:55:42 AM by Adannor

@Largo: Can you start with Deserving?

I had a look at Hentai Kamen earlier, and really it's not even ecchi, the only thing notably perverse is the panties-as-a-mask thing.

But yeah, if the Japanese title has "hentai" in it, that bears no relation to whether it is erotic material. Though this may be the only time it comes up.

Fair enough. Angelhead.

Ditto.

... Panties as a mask... x3

I suppose it's like the Japanese version of Captain Underpants.

Well, maybe... if Captain Underpants wore them on his face instead of where they're supposed to belong.