Oh, I'd be all for calling the article something other than Cookie Cutter Cuties.
Well what about combining mine and Madraguda's suggestions for a new article, as the trope 'All Actresses Are Beautiful' is the reason we have things like Cookie Cutter Cuties and how things Hollywood Homely, Hollywood Pudgy and Hollywood Thin occur.
If it's not going to have the name Cookie Cutter Cuties and it's not going to have the content currently on that page... then aren't we essentially talking about cutting the page?
To me, that's what all the reasonable options boil down to. If someone wants to take an in-universe All Actresses Are Beautiful to YTTW, great. If someone thinks individual types might be tropable and wants to YTTW Marilyn Clone, etc., fantastic. If someone wants to create a Useful Notes on Beauty Trends, sure why not. But I still don't see how Cookie Cutter Cuties, either in name or in content, contributes anything to the site.
It keeps getting cutlisted and then spared. Not enough consensus?
Actually a girl.wait till a mod calls the crowner.
Speaking words of fandom: let it squee, let it squee.Yeah. I haven't cutlisted it myself, I've just seen it on there thrice now. I'm sure my newbness shows as I wasn't really sure when it's done.
Actually a girl.The one who's doing the cutlisting is me. I see no reason whatsoever to keep this around for any longer. No matter how long we let the crowner run we're not gonna see any drastic changes in consensus.
How long has the crowner been running?
I didn't write any of that.Three days.
Reality is that, which when you stop believing in it, doesn't go away. -Philip K. DickBit under three days, apparently.
edited 9th Sep '11 10:41:29 PM by Arha
2 days, 6 hours. It was hooked on the 7th at about 4:30 in the afternoon.
...if you don’t love you’re dead, and if you do, they’ll kill you for it.Oh, the date is listed right on the crowner. Derp.
I didn't write any of that.So... is there a minimum time or something? Because it just got declined AGAIN.
Cut it already. Don't dick around. The consensus couldn't be any clearer.
Shrug. There's no harm in waiting for the whole three days.
Especially when it's right on the edge of the required 2:1 supermajority. This is not guaranteed at all yet, so chill.
Speaking words of fandom: let it squee, let it squee.It finally got cut.
edited 10th Sep '11 3:11:42 PM by Insignificant
Crown Description:
What would be the best way to fix the page?
That doesn't change the fact that it has nothing to do with the current article and would be better off going by a different name anyhow. (i.e. Useful Notes: Beauty Trends)
edited 8th Sep '11 4:50:58 PM by Insignificant