troperville

tools

toys


main index

Narrative

Genre

Media

Topical Tropes

Other Categories

TV Tropes Org
random
YMMV: Twenty Thousand Leagues Under the Sea
  • Acceptable Targets: The British, the author being a Frenchman.
    • Somewhat ironic because Verne was far more pro-British than most of his countrymen (through that might not have been saying much, with the Napoleonic Wars in living memory at the time). And before them, it was the Russians.
      • Verne wanted it to be the Russians, but his publisher balked at the idea, since France was on good terms with them, at the time. Not only that, but the sales as well. Russia always was a huge market for Verne's books, at one point being the largest of them all, and Hetzel didn't want to lose all that money by offending and alienating the readers. He managed to persuade Verne to change Nemo's nation, and he, ever the pragmaticnote , agreed.
  • Ass Pull: Whilst in the Maelstrom, the protagonist writes about how no ship has ever escaped the vortex. He is knocked unconscious, and when he comes to, he and his friends are safe, and offers no explanation as to how that was achieved.
    • "What happened that night, how the skiff escaped from the Maelstrom’s fearsome eddies, how Ned Land, Conseil, and I got out of that whirlpool, I’m unable to say. But when I regained consciousness, I was lying in a fisherman’s hut on one of the Lofoten Islands. My two companions, safe and sound, were at my bedside clasping my hands."

  • Common Knowledge: A few instances of this, considering how many more people know about the story than have actually read it:
    • As mentioned above, the title refers to the distance that the Nautilus travels while under the sea, not the depth that it dives to (20,000 leagues is actually about twice the circumference of the Earth).
    • Captain Nemo is the antagonist of the novel, not the protagonist. Though he's certainly the most famous character in the novel, he's an Antihero at best, and a full-on villain at worst. This misperception is probably because Aronnax is the Unreliable Narrator.
    • The Nautilus crew didn't have an epic showdown with a giant squid, they had a prolonged battle with an entire school of giant squid. The Disney film contributes a lot to this misconception, since (presumably) the studio only had enough money in the budget for one giant animatronic squid.
    • Related to the above: it's somewhat debatable whether Verne actually meant his famous monsters to be squid; in the original French text, he referred to them as "poulpes" ("octopuses") rather than "calmars" ("squids"), and many early English translations likewise called them "poulps" (an archaic English term for octopi). This may have been in the interest of greater scientific accuracy: in the years since the book was published, zoologists have become mostly certain that Real Life octopi don't actually grow to the gigantic proportions seen in the book, though Real Life squid do.
  • Crowning Moment of Funny: Conseil hopes Ned Land will get some red meat soon, "lest sir wake up one morning and find only chunks of me to serve him".
  • Crowning Moment Of Heart Warming: After Ned Land and Conseil tried to give The Professor Aronax some precious oxygen, they converse More Expendable Than You:
    "No, Ned," I replied, "it isn't worth more. Nobody could be better than a kind and generous man like yourself!"
    "All right, all right!" the Canadian repeated in embarrassment.
  • Draco in Leather Pants: The Captain Nemo is a truly, Wicked Cultured, Affably Evil Nice Guy who constantly crosses the Moral Event Horizon and hardly even notices when he Kick the Dog. An Aesop of the novel is to show that no matter how good or charismatic are you, Technology Is Evil and to have a Weapon of Mass Destruction means that With Great Power Comes Great Insanity as Nemo’s Villainous Breakdown takes him and his entire crew to the Maelstrom. However, Misaimed Fandom always forget the Aesop because Nemo is the poster boy (Out and In-Universe) for Affably Evil, Cry for the Devil, Dark and Troubled Past, Troubled, but Cute, Well-Intentioned Extremist and even Woobie, Destroyer of Worlds.
    • Don't forget that he has something of a Misaimed Fandom purely because of his wonderful toys— you read ocean explorers like Robert Ballard and Jacques Cousteau saying that as children, they read the book over and over and "wanted to be Captain Nemo", meaning they wanted his awesome submarine and diving gear, not that they wanted to be supervillains, and two later real-life submarines were named "Nautilus" in homage.
  • Harsher in Hindsight / Not So Crazy Anymore: Since the beginning of his career as a writer, Verne was being accused by critics of being ''only'' a HardScifi writer that paid little heed to the social ramifications of technology. But with Twenty Thousand Leagues Under The Sea Verne wrote in 1869 about Captain Nemo, a man from an oppressed country who had training in the west, and has enough money to pay a country’s national debt, whom decides to create an organization strong enough to fight an entire Western country through terrible acts of violence, and therefore is chased as a menace by all established countries in the West. After Osama bin Laden, 9/11 and The War on Terror, we must admit that Verne really knew much more than anyone ever suspected about how the world will turn in the next 130 years!
    • This is aknowledged in the finale volume of The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen, where a descendant of Nemo is a transparent Expy of Bin Laden.
    • A lot of the descriptions of whaling and fishing and the beauty of the sea becomes this due to modern pollution problems, rampant overfishing, and climate change. Worst of all, some species described in the book (the greater Auk, for example) are outright extinct.
  • It Was His Sled: There's no sea monster. It's a submarine.
  • Values Dissonance: The crew spend an entire chapter killing sperm whales for no particular reason, except that Nemo doesn't like them.
    • He appears to be killing them to protect a pod of baleen whales, much as a farmer of the time would hunt wolves. Still counts though.
    • There's also all the times they find endangered species, such as a sea otter and a dugong, and kill them. Even when they point out how bad things are going to be if humans don't stop killing and eating endangered animals, they still proceed to do that exact thing with little remorse. And the hunting of a supposed undiscovered species of "giant narwhal" that starts the plot of the book in the first place, as well.
    • The crew also treat Papuan natives who attack the Nautilus like savages instead of people; they don't even stop one from wandering onto the (electrified) staircase of the ship.
      • However, also Ned Land, Counseil and Aronnax treat them as savages. Maybe could be said that it was Fair for Its Day? Captain Nemo lampshades that "savages" can be found at any part of the world, and even when the papuans wandered on the electrified staircase, it's stated it was only capable of repelling them and not killing them. Nemo said:
    "Well, sir, let them come. I see no reason for hindering them. After all, these Papuans are poor creatures, and I am unwilling that my visit to the island should cost the life of a single one of these wretches."

The 1954 film adaptation contains examples of:

random
TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy
23536
26