Sliding Scale Of Idealism Versus Cynicism / Theatre
In the old days, musicals tended to be highly idealistic comedies. This tendency has been largely lost in contemporary musical theatre: though idealistic shows (e.g. La Cage aux folles, The Producers) still are produced, about as common are cynical shows including snide Take Thats against idealism (e.g. Chess, Urinetown).
Then again, the greatest shows of the early Broadway era weren't as lightweight as people remember. Show Boat dealt fairly realistically with race relations, and not all of the good guys got happy endings. Rodgers and Hammerstein? Hooboy. Oklahoma! has a song wherein the hero tries to convince his rival to commit suicide, and he later kills his rival and is universally praised for doing so. The King and I has two self-righteous egos butting heads, and one dies at the end. The Sound of Music- yeah, real happy ending: they have to flee their home, leaving behind anything they can't easily carry, in order to escape the Nazis.
Whether William Shakespeare's plays are idealistic or cynical, and how much, is highly debated. The same plays can seem very different depending which critics you read.
Shakespeare'sRomeo and Juliet is utterly cynical toward romance as a whole, portraying the two Star-Crossed Lovers as blind to the reality of their family feud. Even though the two feuding families finally make peace with each other after the lovers are Driven to Suicide by their madness, it is still a highly cynical subversion of traditional love stories. You'd never know it, though, from listening to some of its very idealistic fans.
...Except that it's not, and you could make a strong case that the play is meant to illustrate the power of love (dumb and teenage though it may be) as a force for political unity. It's possible to walk away from the play with the message that even naive adolescent love can be an antidote to the impersonal hatred of political conflict. It's important to note that the opening sonnet says that Romeo & Juliet "doth with their death, buried their parents' strife"- implying that their deaths are directly, causally connected to peace, and that the resulting peace is as important to note as their deaths.
Urinetown, mentioned above, is a bit more complicated. It starts out as a pretty straightforward clash between the idealist and cynic, but when the cynic kills the idealist, the forces of idealism find a new leader who is both more idealist and more detached from reality, who blindly propels the story into a Nice Job Breaking It, Hero!.
Cirque du Soleil shows are Earn Your Happy Ending at worst (see trope entry for examples), and shimmeringly idealistic at best. Saltimbanco was intentionally created to counter cynicism and despair, particularly regarding urbanization, in society. And Corteo takes the concept of the death-dream of a clown and turns it into a loving celebration of life.
Also, the characters themselves fall on different parts of the scale. Which happens to be heavily tilted towards cynicism. At the start, they range from midway through the cynical (Sweeney) to evil-but-not-either (Turpin) to falling off the idealist end (Anthony). By the end of Act 1, Anthony is about at the midway point, Sweeney's fallen off the cynical end, and Mrs. Lovett has actually risen into idealism. Once you hit the endgame, Antony is still at the midpoint, Johanna is obviously at the cynical end, Toby's, well, crazy, and Sweeney is a dot at the end of the cynical range. Mrs. Lovett seems to be the only one that actually becomes more idealistic.
Merrily We Roll Along is a bizarre example in that it goes backwards. Therefore, it begins very, very cynically and becomes more and more idealistic until we eventually watch the three primary characters meet for the first time as young, wide-eyed artists with hopes of changing the world. A very idealistic ending indeed — besides the fact that the audiences already knows that their dreams, and their friendships, are going to fall apart in twenty years. Whether this makes the story cynical or idealistic is open to interpretation.
Frank Shepard (1976): Do you really not see that I’m ashamed of all this? That I am as sick of myself as you are? That I just try to keep acting like it all matters. To not let people see how much I hate my life, how much I wish the God damn thing was over —
Frank Shepard (1957):After this moment… this moment that the three of us are sharing here together… nothing’s ever going to be the way is was, not ever again. Do you guys realize that now we're going to be able to do anything? I mean anything we ever dreamed of. What a time to be starting out. What a time to be alive.
The musical Man of La Mancha is practically a plea for idealism... which is quite the contrast with its original inspiration, Don Quixote, who is in the cynic side but moves the slide back and forth for the sake of the funny.
The musical Chicago announces its cynicism even before the curtain goes up:
"Ladies and gentlemen, you are about to see a story of murder, greed, corruption, violence, exploitation, adultery and treachery—all those things we all hold near and dear to our hearts."
The play The Time of Your Life has an entire paragraph, which can be found at the beginning of the script, stating the ideals which the principal characters live by.
Little Shop of Horrors starts in cynicism, quickly lifts into idealism, and then slowly descends to a level more cynical than where it started.
The Rise and Fall of the City of Mahagonny is cynical enough, but Kurt Weill's next opera, after he split with Bertolt Brecht, Die Bürgschaft, might be even more cynical. Just as a commercial dispute between the protagonist and his friend is about to be resolved with an Arranged Marriage between their children, the country is taken over by the Great Powers, who impose their law, which is the Law of Money and the Law of Power. Subsequently the country is visited by war, inflation, hunger and disease. While the poor become poorer, the protagonist is too busy making himself richer to look after his dying wife or his missing daughter. Comes the revolution, and his old friend shamelessly betrays him to the bloodthirsty mob.
Each Flaherty and Ahren show is a bizarre mix of each - the general idea is that it starts with some plucky, idealistic heroes, pushes them all the way to the other side of the scale, but ends on an extremely cheery note despite this.
In Ragtime, the main character, Coalhouse, goes from madly in love to slightly annoyed to enraged and murderous, only to end with him singing an entire song about hope and idealism, albeit after he dies.
In Once On This Island, the story begins with a lovely, happy young peasant girl, Ti Moune, falling in love with a rich man named Daniel. By the end of the show, she dies, heartbroken. But she turns into a tree, and spreads the power of love to everyone.
If you've ever read Dr. Seuss's Horton Hears A Who!, you know the basic plot of Seussical. A nice, spirited elephant named Horton discovers a world on a dust speck on a clover, and, of course, everyone thinks he's gone insane when he tells them. He goes through trials and tribulations, and almost has to watch the clover get boiled in Beezlenut oil. But in the end, everyone ends up believing that there really are tiny people on that dust speck, agreeing that "a person's a person no matter how small."
Charlie and the Chocolate Factory (the 2013 West End musical) takes place in a world so cynical that even children seem ready to cast off creativity and wonder in favor of ruthless, mindless materialism as soon as they're able, and as grumpy sweetstall owner Mrs. Pratchett puts it early on, "You get nothing for nothing in this world." Poverty-stricken, sweet, imaginative Charlie Bucket and his family watch in increasing despair as the Golden Tickets that grant entrance to the mysterious Wonka Factory fall into the hands of greedy, even underhanded brats. And then, a little luck comes Charlie's way when he finds the last of the five tickets. As it turns out, Willy Wonka is a Sugar-and-Ice PersonalityAnti-Hero who, though he's Ambiguously Evil and has No Sympathy for those who would let their greed get the better of them, believes wholeheartedly in the importance of wonder, beauty, and imagination. In his Cloud Cuckooland, the greed that pays off in the outside world leads to horrible ends, whereas Charlie's goodness and creative drive to make the world a better place for those around him ultimately grant him and his family an incredibly happy ending, making this a rare idealistic Black Comedy.
Les Misérables is a bit difficult to place far from the center of the scale. The show takes place in the Crapsack World of revolutionary France, full of poverty and disease, not to mention shady inkeepers and plenty of war casualties. Even so, there's enough idealism and hope within the characters to keep things positive, bringing the ending to at least something of a hopeful and positive note. In this regard, it ends up with idealism, but barely so.
Hairspray, on the other hand, is unquestionably idealistic. By the end of the show, the antagonists receive their just deserts, prejudice is combated with integration on the dance show, and the heroes are happier and more united than ever.
Hamilton is an excellent example of the sliding scale itself.
Most of Act 1, especially towards the finale, is quite idealistic. The fervor of the American Revolution inspires Hamilton as he joins forces with George Washington and fellow revolutionaries, also becoming a husband and father in the meanwhile. The only sour spots come with the sadness of The sister of Hamilton's wife swallowing her pride after her sister marries the man she loves and the dawning of rivalry between Burr and Hamilton.
The show's finale, "Who Lives, Who Dies, Who Tells Your Story", ends on a note of subdued hope and contemplation, as Eliza Hamilton carries on the work and story of her late husband, proceeding to join the company and ask the audience who will tell their story. In this regard, the show seems idealistic in the end, it falls on the viewer to make the right choices and learn the right lessons.
Considering just how cynical their most famous work is, Robert Lopez, Trey Parker, and Matt Stone's ''The Book of Mormon is more idealistic than one might think. Yes, it's full of shocking humor and really dark moments, but by the show's end, it becomes surprisingly heartfelt and sincere, with the protagonists growing and actually helping their community. Even the Big Bad does a Heel–Face Turn. This was definitely intentional on the part of Parker and Stone, who wanted to make an idealistic show to celebrate and lovingly parody their love of Broadway musicals.
All over the place in The Hammer Trinity. No matter how well intentioned your actions when you play for high enough stakes (ala politics) somebody's bound to get hurt. Best exemplified with Rienne's chess game.