Subversion in Watchmen: Rorschach considers himself the Only Sane Man, but is batshit insane. In the end it gets double subverted, and it turns out that he was probably right.
Dr. Manhattan is an inversion—he's all but omniscient, but his irregular perception of the timeline causes him to seem insane (sociopathic, at the very least) to people with a regular linear perception of time.
Both Nite Owls are probably the legitimate examples, especially the first one; they realise how messed all superheroes are, including themselves, but can't do anything about it. They're still the most level-headed capes in the book.
Ironically the initial characterization of The DCU's Plastic Man, who was a straight man (with somewhat goofy powers) in a world full of total nutbars. Every incarnation of him since has made him a total nutbar instead.
Basically the entire point of normalman, where norm is the only, um, normal man on a planet full of violent superhumans who quite literally get off on crazy "action scenes". The fact that he's a Deadpan Snarker indicates how well he takes his situation.
In Twisted Toyfare Theater, Spider-Man is basically the only person in the entire world with a single lick of common sense. However, this has caused him to become so jaded he flat-out refuses to participate in any kind of action if he can avoid it, for example immediately taking the blue pill to go back to sleep when Morpheus offered to take him to The Matrix.
Well, Spider-Man might have company in the "not completely out of his mind" department in Doctor Doom, the series' other main character. Maybe.
Emp, Mindf**k or Maidman also played the sane man amongst the other capes, depending on the situation. So there we have bondage bait with a track record of always losing, a woman who survived torture from her crazy brother, lives alone on a space station and carried out a telepathic affair with another cape, and Batman if he'd dressed as a maid. The Empverse is wierd...
I Luv Halloween - Finch, a skull-mask wearing little kid who stuffs razor blades into apples as revenge for getting an apple for Halloween and sets a woman's head on fire, is actually the most level-headed and rational (next to Devil-lad) of the amoral cast of trick-or-treaters.
Astérix and Panoramix the Druid are the only two in their town who occasionally show a hint of sanity and common sense.
The Penguin, as one of the few major Batman villains who is typically considered sane (as such his sentencing would be completed at Blackgate Penn rather than Arkham), serves as this by default. When working with other villains he tends to act as a mediator, defusing arguments and ensuring everyone remains on track; however, he can become exasperated by the "eccentricities" of the other members of Batman's Rogues Gallery, and should he feel that the potential profit of the business arrangement is simply not worth the costs and risks associated with the crime at hand, that his input is being ignored, or that his life and livelihood are being groundlessly threatened by their erratic behavior, there is a strong chance he will wash his hands of the endeavor at his earliest convenience. This goes for the animated series, as well.
If they've really managed to piss him off in the process he'll sometimes spill his guts to Batman in exchange for immunity.
Zibarro from All-Star Superman is a very literal Only Sane Man: He's the only Bizarro on the planet who acts like a normal person, instead of a deranged backwards-speaking manchild.
If you're not aware, Zibarro was what happened when Bizarro Superman decided everyone on Earth should have a Bizarro-clone; Superman lives on Earth, so he has Bizarro Superman, but Bizarro lives on Earth, so he has Bizarro Bizarro: Zibarro.
Franklin from the Peanuts comics: he is the only character not to have some sort of quirk or obsession. He is also the only person to point out exactly how weird everyone else in Charlie Brown's neighbourhood is. And - in a twist that was particularly ironic in the late 1960s - he is the only black character in the strip.
Charlie Brown: Franklin! Where are you going?
Franklin: I'm going home, Charlie Brown. This neighborhood has me shook. I didn't mind the girl in the booth or the beagle with the goggles, but that business about the "Great Pumpkin" - no, sir!
Charlie Brown: But...
Schroeder: Hi! Did you guys know there are only sixty more days until Beethoven's birthday?