Music / Primal Scream
Primal Scream are a Scottish Alternative Rock
band, known for their eclectic, experimental sound, their status as Promoted Fanboys
(much like Oasis
, come to think of it), their Sex, Drugs and Rock & Roll
lifestyle and high turnover rate of members
. Oh, and also their really interesting, excellent music.
For the sake of expediency, their core and current lineup is as follows:
Phase One: What Are We Doing?
- Bobby Gillespie - vocals
- Robert "Throb" Young - guitar (1982-2006)
- Andrew Innes - rhythm guitar (joined 1987)
- Gary "Mani" Mounfield - bass (joined 1997)
- Martin Duffy - keyboards (joined 1989)
- Darin Mooney - drums (joined 1999)
Primal Scream's long and slightly complicated history begins in 1982, when frontman
, vocalist and chief mastermind Bobby Gillespie joined forces with his guitarist friend Jim Beattie. At first, PS was merely something Gillespie did in his spare time, with his full-time job being drumming for The Jesus and Mary Chain
(he's the one who plays drums on Psychocandy
). However, the band's lineup quickly expanded to include Robert Young on bass, Stuart May on guitar, drummer Tom McGurk and tambourine player Martin St. John. PS got a contract with notable alternative label Creation Records note
and released a single, "All Fall Down". Gillespie was then given an ultimatum to either dissolve Primal Scream and join JAMC full-time or resign, choosing the latter option.
While Primal Scream did gain some publicity from contributing the song "Velocity Girl" to the C86
compilation, the band suffered from lineup instability, with the lineup eventually paired down to Gillespie, Young, Beattie, Innes and a new drummer. Their debut Sonic Flower Groove
suffered from a torturous birth, being recorded at two separate studios with two separate producers and costing a total of £100,000, having nothing to show for it besides a batch of dull, jangly The Byrds
photocopies. The album barely got into the charts and received terrible reviews, prompting more resignations from the band.
Gillespie, Young and Innes regrouped in Brighton and made some more changes - Young moved to guitar, and a new rhythm section of Henry Olsen (bass) and Toby Tomanov (drums) was brought in. The lads also threw out their bright jangle pop for hard-edged, rock that drew from MC5
, The Stooges
and The Rolling Stones
. The resulting album, Primal Scream
, was greeted with confusion from their older fans and worse reviews. Shortly after the album's release, Felt keyboardist Martin Duffy joined the band as a full-time member.Phase Two: We Figured Out What We're Doing...Kinda
In their spare time after Primal Scream
, the band's members developed a taste for the then-thriving English acid house/rave scene. While attending one rave in 1990, they met DJ and producer Andrew Weatherall, who they asked to remix their song "I'm Losing More Than I'll Ever Have". Weatherall completely revamped the song with additional samples and turned it into a groove-focused dance-rock song. Now retitled "Loaded", it became the band's first big hit.
Primal Scream entered the studio with a Dream Team
's worth of producers including Weatherall, ambient house duo The Orb, Hugo Nicholson, Hypnotone and The Rolling Stones
knob-twiddler Jimmy Miller. The result, Screamadelica
, was a massive genre stew
, smashing together Alternative Rock
, Psychedelic Rock
, acid house, gospel and dub and including several nods to their influences ("Movin' on Up" borrowed lyrics from "Yoo Doo Right"
from "Monster Movie" (1968) and a cover of "Slip Inside This House" by The 13th Floor Elevators
). With the music's quality strong enough to weather its amateurish-looking cover, Screamadelica
became the band's first successful album.Phase Two Point Five: Actually, No, We Still Haven't
The resulting long tour in support of Screamadelica
was mired by drug abuse, and a quick EP named Dixie Narco
started a move away from dance-rock, towards blues-rock and P-Funk instead. Primal Scream next spent circa two years recording new material in London and Alabama, with an even more eclectic cast of collaborators that included Tom Dowd, George Drakoulias and George Clinton
behind the mixing desk, keyboardists Jim Dickinson and Benmont Tench, drummer Roger Hawkins and The Memphis Horns. The new material reverted to the band's traditional method of copying its influences - in this case, The Rolling Stones
, The Faces
, and numerous Funk
bands. Give Out But Don't Give Up
accordingly received mixed reviews - for every person who liked it despite its derivative nature there was one who agreed with NME's famous review that called them "dance traitors". Its failure on the charts and a long tour led to severe band tension and a long hiatus.Phase Three: Okay, Okay, We Finally Got It...Sorta. Maybe.
Primal Scream returned in 1997 with a new lineup, including former The Stone Roses
bassist Mani and drummer Paul Mulraney. Reuniting with former collaborators/producers Brendan Lynch and Andrew Weatherall, Vanishing Point
saw the band return to the electronic-rock fusion they found success with, but this time with a Darker and Edgier
bent and a bigger influence from Krautrock
, Trip Hop
and dub - quite appropriate for an album inspired by the film The Vanishing Point
. With this, Primal Scream Won Back The Crowd
they lost with Give Out
For their follow-up XTRMNTR
, the band recast themselves as angry-political revolutionaries, matching Anvilicious
, clumsy sociopolitical lyrics with the hardest, harshest songs they ever wrote, drawing inspiration this time from Industrial Metal
. The album featured contributions from Bernard Sumner
, Brendan Lynch, Adrian Sherwood, The Chemical Brothers and Kevin Shields
, the latter of whom continued to work and tour with the band for a while. Shields was never an official member of the band however, since My Bloody Valentine
never actually broke up and Primal Scream
never actually clarified if he was a member. They carried on with the angry-electro-metal Evil Heat
, which boasted a similarly impressive list of contributors - Jim Reid
, Robert Plant
, former member Paul Harte and... er, Kate Moss. She was part of the package.
Soon after Heat
, Shields ditched the band to return to doing absolutely nothing and eventually reuniting My Bloody Valentine
. The band carried on regardless, doing yet another Stones-Faces-whatever photocopy album called Riot City Blues
(with predictably bad reception) and an electro-Krautrock
album called Beautiful Future
. Longtime guitarist Young left sometime after Blues
Their tenth album More Light
was released May 13, 2013, returning the band to dancey psychedelic rock and consistently positive critical reception.
- Sonic Flower Groove (1987)
- Primal Scream (1989)
- Screamadelica (1991)
- Give Out But Don't Give Up (1994)
- Vanishing Point (1997)
- XTRMNTR (2000)
- Evil Heat (2002)
- Riot City Blues (2006)
- Beautiful Future (2008)
- More Light (2013)
- Beautiful Dreamer: "Shine Like Stars".
- Cluster F-Bomb: "Pills".
- Cover Version: "Slip Inside This House" by The 13th Floor Elevators, "Motörhead" by Hawkwind / Motorhead, "Some Velvet Morning" by Lee Hazlewood and Nancy Sinatra, "Over & Over" by Fleetwood Mac, "I'm Five Years Ahead of My Time" by The Third Bardo.
- Darker and Edgier: Vanishing Point and XTRMNTR
- Early Installment Weirdness: Sonic Flower Groove is a jangly, syrupy, Byrds-inspired Indie Pop record. It's gentle and polite, unlike every album they've done since. Primal Scream, influenced by The Rolling Stones and MC5, is also very unlike the Indie Rock/Psychedelia/Dance hybrid music they became known for, though they've recorded two albums since that try to do the straightforward Rock sound correctly.note
- Genre Roulette: More Light jumps from Dance Rock to Psychedelic Rock, Shoegazing, Rap Rock, and back again.
- House Music: Blended Acid House with Rock and Psychedelia in Screamadelica.
- New Sound Album: Every one:
- Primal Scream moved from gentle Jangle Pop to loud Garage Rock
- Screamadelica was a full-on House/Rock/Psychedelia hybrid
- Give Out But Don't Give Up tried straightforward British Trad Rock
- Vanishing Point took heavy dub and techno influence
- XTRMNTR took Industrial and Noise Rock influence
- Evil Heat combined the previous two albums' styles together
- Riot City Blues tried the Rock thing again
- Beautiful Future combined their electronic side with their bubblegum roots and Krautrock influences
- More Light returned to the Psychedelic/Indie/Dance hybrid style, with a greater focus on individual songs
- Out-of-Genre Experience: "Culturecide" is a Rap Rock song.
- Rearrange the Song:
- They turned "Slip Inside This House" into a pounding, psychedelic dance song and "Motörhead" into a techno-rock song.
- "Loaded" is Andrew Weatherall's remix of their earlier song "I'm Losing More Than I'll Ever Have", turning the original Rock ballad into unrecognizable Acid House.
- Self-Titled Album
- Sex, Drugs and Rock & Roll
- Textless Album Cover: Screamadelica, Give Out and More Light.