Eddie Vedder concocted that way of singing because it was his original way of expressing himself. It came from a really real place, but then it kind of got codified, and made into a formula that didn't even mean anything. It was just sort of like "you have to sing like that, because that signifies alt-rock
soulfullness." And it just kind of got repeated mindlessly.
Yarling is a singing style popularized in The Nineties
, in particular in Grunge
bands, and has featured in a lot of indie music since. It dates back much further
, however, having been popular with folk singers since at least the early twentieth century, and many famous rock singers (such as Jim Morrison
and Johnny Cash
) also employed a style strikingly similar decades prior. However, it was only given a name in the Post-Grunge era. Yarling from this period has also been dubbed the "grunge drone", "nose yodeling", and "Hunger Dunger Dang," an onomatopoeic rendition of what the lyrics allegedly sound like.
It is characterised by a nasal baritone drone, with many of the words being slurred or unenunciated, thus making singers who choose this style prone to becoming The Unintelligible
and their audience prone to Mondegreens
. Although widely popular when first popularized by Eddie Vedder
(and, to an extent, Layne Staley
), this type of singing is controversial among music fans with many claiming it to have killed previous, 'powerful' styles of singing. Fans of classic rock and heavy metal are most likely the ones persisting this negativity, since it's become a staple of Modern Rock and some alternative (don't be surprised to find many fans of Alternative against the style as well). It tends to add a rough edge to a song, which may or may not be desirable, depending on the genre.
While it was commonly used in Grunge
, it didn't become seen as a defining trope of the genre until many of the Post-Grunge
bands that Flanderized
it made this the main trait of the music by exaggerating this vocal style. Many critics claim that it, alongside Post-Grunge's usual Wangst and watered down comfort food simplicity, is the reason why rock and roll lost is power, while supporters point to its soulful, inoffensive style as the reason why rock expanded its boundaries during the new millennium. Because of the sheer number of successful late '90s/early '00s alternative rock bands that employed the technique, yarling is heard as a trait of the sound and a point of contention as to its quality as a form of singing.
The biggest point to be made is: Yarling is a dubious tool of Post-Grunge
and nowadays an easy ticket to critical backlash and commercial success.
See also: Perishing Alt Rock Voice
, which frequently overlaps with this trope. Both can be seen as vocal equivalents of Three Chords and the Truth
Noted users include:
- Aaron Lewis of Staind
- Eddie Vedder of Pearl Jam.
- Layne Staley, when he's not Metal Screaming.
- In the same vein, Sully Erna of Godsmack.
- Also Staley's replacement, William DuVall. Especially notable in The Devil Put Dinosaurs Here.
- Scott Weiland of Stone Temple Pilots. Employed much less often in Velvet Revolver.
- Wes Scantlin of Puddle of Mudd , which is done to imitate Layne Staley.
- Chester Bennington in Grey Daze, his band before Linkin Park. The accent he uses is quite overblown on songs such as "Morei Sky".
- Scott Stapp of Creed.
- Chad Kroeger of Nickelback.
- Chris Daughtry.
- Dallas Smith of Default.
- Shaun Morgan of Seether.
- Tyler Connolly of Theory of a Deadman.
- Dave Matthews.
- Brad Arnold of Three Doors Down.
- Pasi Koskinen of Amorphis (often alternated with Tomi Koivusari's Harsh Vocals)- A rare non-Alternative Rock example
- John Fogerty of Creedence Clearwater Revival.
- Chris Cornell of Soundgarden and Audioslave.
- Exaggerated / Parodied here
- Paul Isola of Breed 77, a rare metal example along with the aforementioned Sully and Pasi.
- Travis Meeks of Days Of The New, in a similar vein to Layne Staley
- Jon Harvey of Monster Truck, a rare stoner rock example
- Daniel Johns of Silverchair
- Scooter Ward of Cold
- Jason Ross of Seven Mary Three
- Doug Ingle of Iron Butterfly (could be considered an Ur Example)
- Roger Young of Cinder
- Darius Rucker of Hootie & the Blowfish. He's seen as one of the originators of the style, besides Eddie Vedder.
- Peter Steele of Type O Negative. Though not a full fledged yarl, his higher tones bare a striking resemblance.
- Ben McMillan of late '80s grunge band Gruntruck.
- Nick Pollock of My Sister's Machine, another original grunge act.
- Gavin Rossdale of Bush
- Dan Swanö from Edge Of Sanity yarls in some songs while clean singing in his middle register. Another metal example.
- Most noticeable with some of his recent works with his current band, Nightingale.
- Dax Riggs from Acid Bath has a very similar vocal style to Layne Staley, though he does mix it up with Harsh Vocals.