Not That Kind of Mage

Basically, this is when one type or tradition of mage is mistaken for another, or someone mistakenly assumes that the mage would fit an incorrect pop culture version of a wizard.

See also Not That Kind of Doctor, Our Mages Are Different, Magic A Is Magic A. (This is a case of Magic A is not Magic B.)

Often overlaps with Mutually Exclusive Magic. Un Equal Rites can be a result. See also Magicians Are Wizards.


    open/close all folders 

    Anime and Manga 
  • Early on in Mahou Sensei Negima!, Negi has to inform Asuna that her pop-culture expectations of magic (stuff like trees that grow money, etc.) isn't how magic actually works. There's also a section of the series dealing with differences between western mages and eastern mages.
  • In A Certain Magical Index, people occasionally confuse Espers and Magicians, resulting in a couple of attempts to develop esper powers by studying magic. However, actual magicians and residents of Academy City can usually tell the difference at a glance. More thorough confusion concerns the main character, who is neither.

    Fan Works 
  • In the Discworld/The Big Bang Theory crossover The Many Worlds Interpretation, wizard Ponder Stibbons arrives in Pasadena, California, where he makes friends with his Roundworld kindred spirit Leonard Hofstadter. Ponder realises the Caltech crew are steeped in what to them is fantasy fictionnote . He realises their perception of wizards only occasionally chimes with his reality. But using his knowledge of actual wizardry, he still manages to win every game of Mystic Warlords of Ka'a. And he finds a winning use for "Enchanted Bunny''.

  • The Dresden Files' Harry Dresden gets this a lot, even though his ad in the Yellow Pages states specifically what he will or won't do. Some of these are actual magical limitations, while others he follows according to his personal code or the laws of the White Council. And he doesn't do parties.
  • One Mercedes Lackey story (starring Tarma and Kethry) features an unusual variant where the one suffering misconceptions is the Mage; the antagonist has a very weak mage Talent, which means she can only handle a limited amount of raw power and is innately incapable of working many powerful magics. She just isn't very good at magic either. Yet she is thoroughly deluded that power and skill are irrelevant, and all one actually needs to become a full Adept is knowledge. She becomes obsessed with the idea that her teachers are keeping "the secret" of full Adepthood from her, and goes thoroughly crazy.
  • In the Dragonlance setting there are four types of magic, Wizardry (sometimes called High Sorcery, and draws from the world's three moons), Clerical Magic (Magic granted by the gods), Primal/Wild Sorcery(which draws from the planet Krynn itself) and Mysticism (which comes from all living things). The former two are called "Focused" magic, while the latter two are called "Ambient" magic. The first two are called Focused because they are focused through either the Moons or through a god, where as Ambient magic comes from Krynn itself and the living things on it. Mistaking a Wizard for a Sorcerer might annoy them a little bit. Mystics and Clerics tend to get along better.
  • In The Belgariad, sorcerers have a powerful form of Inherent Gift, while magicians summon and "control" demons. Calling a sorcerer a magician is seen as very insulting. (Ironically, Belgarath is both, though he normally relies on his sorcery and is smart enough to only summon a demon when a). he absolutely needs to and b). it's not very powerful. He still only does it once across ten books).
    • He's also not above disguising himself as a magician and using sorcerous illusions to make it look like he's summoned a demon. Again, though, once in ten books.
    • Beyond that, there are Witches (well, a witch). She even gets the differences confused at one point, asking Belgarath to perform a spell that she can't, then offering him the use of any spell components he needs (sorcery is a completely mental thing). There also exist wizards (Only one of whom is ever named, but an entire city of them exists at Kell), but the reader never sees any wizardry, and thus has no idea what they do. One of the sorcerers remarks on people's inability to keep the various varieties of magic straight, noting that most people take everything they've ever heard about any of them, and lump it all together with the assumption that any person who is capable of any of that fantastic stuff is capable of doing all of it.
      • Possibly averted in that Belgarath himself later in the series explains that all of these different magics come from the same source and talent and that the differences are, ultimately, cultural. Specifically Sorcerers were taught by Godsnote  and use pure Will to make things happen, Magicians use the Will to summon and (fail to) control demons, Witches use the Will to ask natural Spirits to intercede on their behalf (the aforementioned spell components being offerings to said spirits). And Wizards also do... something... with the Will.
  • This happens periodically in The Legends of Ethshar because magic is very complex indeed:
    • Wizards tap the fundamental chaos of the universe for powerful, and astoundingly unpredictable, results. (One was trying to create a sword sharpening spell and ended up creating a pillar of eternal flame the size of a mountain.)
    • Sorcery taps the fundamental order of the universe in order to make powerful magical devices. Sorcerers once went to war with Wizards so one assume they are fairly powerful, but they lost so they don't do all that much currently.
    • Warlockry allows one to rearrange the matter with their own mind; by communing with an Eldrich Horror (probably) that eventually eats the magic user (most likely).
      • At one point one villain discovers that there is another warlock power source that seems not to have any Eldrich Horror so a warlock who stays near this one and far from the original one gets safe and unlimited power. Although there is no Eldritch Horror in this new source, getting too powerful from it eventually gets you detected by the horror from the original source, despite the distance.
    • Witchcraft can do the same things as Warlockry on a much more limited basis. However, witches also have other 'ESP'-type abilities, including minor telepathy, clairvoyance, etc. The power for witchcraft comes from the user, which is why it's so much more limited in physical manipulation.
    • Demonology is the summoning and control of demons. Really handy for killing people, not so much good for cleaning the house.
    • Theurgy is summoning and attempting to talk gods into doing what you want them to do. Less handy then one might suppose as the gods tend to be difficult to work with at best.
  • Telemain from the Enchanted Forest Chronicles frequently gets mistaken for a wizard (who only knows one type of magic) when he is infact a magician (who studies many kinds of magic) albeit one who is particularly interested in finding out how wizard magic works and interacts with other types of magic. Also, nobody likes wizards in that series, and with good reason.
  • In the Circle of Magic series ambient magic can be very difficult to recognize, especially the rarer versions. Due to her lack of traditional mage traits (making things move, seeing images in the flame) most people assumed that Tris was possessed by demon, until it was revealed that she was an ambient weather mage.
  • Discworld:
    • In the novel Wyrd Sisters, Nanny Ogg is captured and placed in a dungeon, much to the surprise of a ghost who doesn't realise witchcraft mostly affects natural phenomena and people's minds.
      Verence: But surely to a witch, this is all just so much...
      Nanny: Solid iron. You might be able to walk through it, but I can't.
      Verence: I didn't realise. I thought witches could do magic.
      Nanny: Young man, you will oblige me by shutting up.
    • Ponder Stibbons represents a major break from accepted tradition at Unseen University. In the vanguard of a younger new wave of magic users, he spurns the old dribbly-candle, stuffed alligator and potions-made-from-miscellaneous-animal-glands school of thought for a more scientifically rigorous approach to the magical art. Indeed, science comes before magic in his priorities. He has never been seen to carry a staff, favours a drab olive-green robe with a hood, and, to the despair and bewilderment of his elders, is keener on co-operation with his peers rather than magical warfare. He also forgets to eat when something more interesting is going on, and remains pretty skinny and nerdy in a place full of three-hundred-pounder big eaters.

    Live-Action TV 
  • Kaamelott: Merlin often claims that the reason he's an Inept Mage is that he's a druid — stuff like having a roof over his head (for his laboratory) cuts his powers by half. However, it's also seen that he's not that great a druid either (he can't read druidic, for starters).

     Tabletop Games 
  • The Unknown Armies supplement "Post Modern Magick" notes that adepts have had problems with working in organised crime because the mobsters were uninformed about their powers and gave them orders like "make Vinnie's car invisible", when the adept talents ran more to, as an example, finding out secrets instead.
  • In most Dungeons & Dragons settings, most commoners are not expected to know the difference between a Wizard and a Sorcerer. This will probably get even more confusing to them when you include non-core full casters, like the Beguiler (a stealthy illusionist expert) or a Warmage (whose only spells that aren't straight up blasting are the "Light" cantrip, doing Exactly What It Says on the Tin, and Elemental summoning spells, which call up destructive embodiments of the classical elements). And there are mage-like classes who do things that aren't strictly casting spells, like the Tome of Magic classes (with the Binder — which lets himself be possessed by spirits for power in exchange for being influenced — it is even pointed out that while wizards and priests knows the difference and generally dislikes them, to the average peasant it's just a matter of welcoming the ones with healing hands and chasing away the ones with horns) and the two invocation classes...
    • And let's not forget mages who specialize in different schools of magic. A sorcerer who specializes in divination magic probably knows nothing about transmutation.
    • Pathfinder takes it up a notch. It has the traditional D&D core casters, but then adds in the Witch (a debuff/mezzer with light damage and healing), the Alchemist, the Summoner (a medium-duty caster with a pet monster), the Inquisitor (a leader-type hybrid of rogue/cleric), the Magus (a hybrid wizard/fighter), and the Oracle (a sorcerer-like divine caster) to the Core classes. Most of the old 3.X line is also compatible. It can overwhelm new players but also allow old players very different takes on the generic "caster" variants.
      • For bonus points there are specializations that seem intentionally designed to let you fake your way through pretending to be a different kind of caster. The most blatant example being the Sorcerer "arcane" bloodline, which grants the standard analysis spells favored by wizards, a wizard familiar, extra knowledge specialties, and the ability to use certain magic-related feats in a manner that looks like how a wizard uses them. Slap an oversized book of gibberish in your inventory and take advantage of bluff being a class skill and most wizards will think the character is a wizard.
  • Mages in Mage: The Ascension can do magic in any way that they believe can do magic. This occasionally leads to different subgroups who look superficially similar loudly insisting on their differences. For example, Technocrats will tell you at great length that the Sons of Ether are doing ridiculous pseudoscience, the Sons of Ether insist to the rest of the Traditions that their Inspired and Dynamic Science is fundamentally different from and better than the staid stuff the Technocracy does, and Hermetic Mages who have spent years studying alchemy, Kabbalah, and other aspects of traditional Western mysticism get really annoyed at Orphans doing mystic-looking stuff that they pulled out of a popular novel.

    Video Games 
  • Uncommon but still present in World of Warcraft. Mages, how many times have you been asked for a soulstone or summon? Warlocks, how many times have you been asked for a portal or food and water? Come on, we all know it's happened at least once.
    • Due to some classes having to chose to specialize in only one of multiple potential roles this would happen to many non mage classes. A druid may be invited to a party to heal when he has allocated all his talents to becoming a giant bear and mauling people, or to do damage when he had specialized in being a slow moving healing tree that couldn't even cast offensive magic in his preferred form. The Wrath of the Lich King expansion lowered the occurrence of this by allowing classes to specify which roles they could perform when looking for a group.
      • With the advent of Dual Specialization (being able to have two talent setups that the player can switch between at will), tanking and healing classes can still be hit with this. Generally the inactive talents are for one of those roles but some players use their inactive page for a Player Versus Player setup.

  • In this Oglaf comic a magician is called upon to use his magic to defend the town from a monster, and explains that he's a dentist wizard. Fortunately, it turns out that's exactly what the monster needs.
  • In The Order of the Stick, The Oracle of the Sunken Valley gets his prophecies from the Goddess Tiamat, so Haley assumes he's a cleric. The Oracle explains that he's not, and that this assumption happens a lot.

    Web Original 
  • Comes up in Unskippable with a mock conversation complaining about the weather and that the mage can't change it, and pointing out that Steve could do it. The retort is that Steve's a weather mage, so of course he could.
  • The Global Guardians master-villain known as the Empress was a hugely powerful wizard... as long as you needed a charm that let you control someone else's mind, altered the perceptions of other people to make them see what you wanted them to see, become invisible, read their mind, and other mental effects. If you wanted to blast a robot with a mystic bolt of lightning, you were better of asking someone else.
  • A running gag on the Giant Bombcast podcast is an ongoing debate on whether Ryu's Ki Manipulation counts as "magic," and whether this makes him a wizard.

     Western Animation 
  • The Venture Bros.: After 24's death, 21 asks Doctor Orpheus, a self-proclaimed Necromancer, to resurrect him, stating "That is the definition of what you do!" Orpheus explains the "Necromancer" title really only exists because the other words for his craft all sound silly by modern standards. However, this contradicts his efforts to resurrect the Venture brothers at the beginning of season two.