"... dogs come from the
moon, not the Sun!"
Alice says something ridiculous. Bob responds with this
Stock Phrase (or some close relative), then explains
why Alice's statement is ridiculous. Of course, Bob's justification is either as absurd, more absurd, or otherwise not a rebuttal one would normally make to the original statement.
Not quite the same as the usage of the phrase by
Funny Foreigner Balki Bartokomous in the sitcom
Perfect Strangers. (He would say it when suspected of doing something wrong, but usually wouldn't follow up with a nonsensical rebuttal.)
Often, Bob is
The Ditz, a
Cloudcuckoolander, or
The Wonka. Less often, Alice is likewise one of those characters.
A common variant is that Alice's original statement was an attempt to guess what Bob is planning or doing. ("So you're going to just storm the castle?" "Don't be absurd. I'm going to storm the castle
carrying this marionette. Sheesh.")
See
Insane Troll Logic. Somewhat related to
Voodoo Shark (when
Real Life fiction-creators are seen doing this themselves — albeit not in response to a theory they find absurd). May also involve
No, Except Yes ("No, I'm not eating an eraser. I'm eating
two erasers.") Compare
Worrying For The Wrong Reason ("Sharks? Don't be silly. The crocodiles will get you first.")
Examples:
open/close all folders
Anime & Manga
- Azumanga Daioh, after a third character posits that the existence of reindeer supports the existence of Santa Claus:
Tomo:
Bwahahaha! This moron believes in reindeer!
Yomi: Um... reindeer DO exist.
Tomo: You can't pull that one over on me! No deer in the world could fly like that!
- GA Geijutsuka Art Design Class, when the upcoming class is doing sketches in charcoal:
Nodamiki: And you need mayonnaise too!!
Tomokane: Mayonnaise?
Nodamiki: So I can put it on the crusts... and eat them!
* Bread is used as an eraser in charcoal drawing.
Tomokane: (holding up peanut butter) You don't use mayonnaise for the crusts!!
Kisaragi: Tomokane-san, that's not what you should be arguing about!!
Film
Literature
- In Tea With the Black Dragon by R. A. MacAvoy, during Martha's first conversation with Mayland Long, he tells her a version of the tale of Thomas the Rhymer, which continues past the usual ending point to talk about Thomas' son. When he finishes, she remarks that he tells it with such authority she could almost believe he'd had it from Thomas in person.
"From the Rhymer?" He leaned forward and lifted his eyebrows in mock wonderment. "How could that be? ... I have the story from the boy, of course. The Rhymer's son.
"Beautiful boy," he added, after a moment. "Resembled his mother."
- In So Long And Thanks For All The Fish, Arthur can't resist making the obvious The Importance of Being Earnest reference when he learns Fenchurch's name: was she found in a handbag in Fenchurch Street Station?
Fenchurch: And the answer is no.
Arthur: Fine.
Fenchurch: I was conceived there.
- In Rivers of London, Peter tells Toby the dog that Nightingale would probably turn him into mittens. Nightingale objects, a shorthair would make terrible mittens, but might make a nice hat.
Live Action TV
- Full House:
Jesse: (coming into the kitchen and seeing Danny scrubbing suds between his hands) Joey, it's finally happened — he's cleaning liquid soap.
Danny: Don't be silly. I am just cleaning my rubber gloves.
Joey: Danny, there is no shame in therapy...
- Fringe:
Walter: Don't be ridiculous. Perhaps a Pterodactyl...
- Doctor Who, "Day of the Moon":
River: Apollo 11's your secret weapon?
The Doctor: No, no, it's not Apollo 11. That would be silly. It's Neil Armstrong's foot.
- Shake It Up: (paraphrased)
Son: Dad, do you know Batman? 'Cuz I've been trying to contact him all day. (shows flashlight converted into a Batsignal)
Dad: That's ridiculous. You know as well as I do that Batman lives in Gotham City!
Theatre
- Spamalot:
"Where are we going to find a shrubbery?"
"Well, maybe we can build one? Out of cats."
"Don't be ridiculous. Where are we going to find cats?"
Video Games
Webcomics
- Darths & Droids, when the characters are surrounded by enemy ships:
Qui-Gon: I've got an idea!
Qui-Gon: Don't be stupid! That would only take one or two hits, at most. Tell them we're bringing up a load of the Queen's laundry.
- In The Order of the Stick, Roy has suggested that Elan sleep, but Elan is too worried to sleep. So...
Roy: Then go play quietly with your puppet or something!
Elan: Don't be ridiculous, Roy! You know
Banjo is even more worried than I am.
Western Animation
- Alice in Wonderland, when the Mad Hatter is "fixing" the White Rabbit's watch:
March Hare: Mustard?
Mad Hatter: Mustard, yes... Mustard?! Don't let's be silly! Lemon, that's more like it.
- Dexter's Laboratory had this in the Charlie and the Chocolate Parody "Golden Diskette", when Professor Hawk (a Stephen Hawking clone who's just a human head on a mechanical bird body) makes his big entrance.
Boy: It's a bird!
Girl: It's a plane!
Man: Don't be silly. It's just a man's head on a robot body.
