: Of course, you know your entire plan depended on me being a self-serving utter bastard. Nate
: Mmm, yeah, that's a stretch.
A complicated plan
that revolves entirely around people doing exactly what you'd expect
them to do. This trope relies heavily on Flaw Exploitation
manipulating, although it can work with virtues instead of "flaws" just as easily. Sometimes the flaw is that the villains are so predictable that they'll take the first chance they have to do something mean and underhanded
. Other times, the flaw is that the heroes are so heroic that they'll act for the greater good without even thinking about it
. A particularly Genre Savvy
person will recognize the fact that heroes always win
— and design a plan based on the assumption that they will succeed
Provided that a character is smart enough and manipulative enough, they can get the people around them to do just about anything. Sometimes this can be accomplished by the power of charisma, but other times it needs to be perpetrated through an elaborate scheme. This scheme takes into account everything that The Chessmaster
(as well as the viewer) knows about the characters being manipulated, and uses it against them. The patsies
in this scheme only act and respond as their own predictability dictates and all the pieces fall into place.
This is the essence of the Batman Gambit, which is a storytelling device that can be used by any unusually intelligent character, be they good or evil, to achieve what they want by using their own intelligence to make sure that the most probable outcome that is beneficial to them arises.
The key difference between the Xanatos Gambit
and the Batman Gambit is that while the former is structured so that any reasonable outcome will work to the advantage of the gambit instigator (and is thus "foolproof") the Batman Gambit does have a failure condition. Indeed, this failure condition will often be quite obvious and foreseeable to the audience, who have the benefit of perspective and objectivity. The victims of the gambit, however, may not enjoy those luxuries. To say this another way: the failure condition in a Batman Gambit relies on someone acting out of character - or, more accurately, however the planner perceives their character. Consequently, Batman Gambits are only as successful as their planner is knowledgeable and insightful about everyone involved. This is why the trope is named after Batman: as the World's Greatest Detective, he can often analyze and predict his foes' actions to psychic-like accuracy.
The key to making a Batman Gambit work is by carefully guiding and manipulating the motivations of those involved, so that the "obvious" course of action to them is to do what will make the gambit work and it never occurs to them to do things that would ruin the gambit. Because of the presence of this obvious failure mode, anyone who tries to pull off a Batman Gambit and fails will look like a fool.
In short, if there is any
reasonable action the pawns could take that would ruin the entire scheme, then it's a Batman Gambit. Because of this, a truly cunning planner will make it appear to their pawns that they do not have
such options in the first place. This is called a bluff because if the pawns see through the smokescreen then The Plan
will fall apart.
See also Manipulative Bastard
, for the character most likely to attempt/pull these off; Unwitting Pawn
, for the people who unwittingly help the Gambit along, and Spanner in the Works
/Unwitting Instigator of Doom
, for the people who unintentionally send it spinning into disaster
. Also see Evil Cannot Comprehend Good
for a common reason why villainous attempts fail.
Contrast with the MacGuffin Delivery Service
, and the failed attempt, Springtime for Hitler
. Also see Indy Ploy
for the lack of a plan. A gambit that relies on the victim knowing he's being "played" but not knowing how
is a Kansas City Shuffle
. If things do go wrong, but the person keeps adjusting things so that Plan A works anyway, he's playing Xanatos Speed Chess
. The Tape Knew You Would Say That
is a subtrope.
Not an Amalgam Universe
character. Also not a Slash Fic
You came from a failed link? No? Curses.