Literature / Tuck Everlasting

Tuck Everlasting is a 1975 fantasy novel exploring immortality and whether it's worth it.

In the late 1800s, Winnie Foster's life is boring. Nothing exciting ever happens, and being in a family of strait-laced blue bloods has cramped her style. She goes out exploring in the woods one day and meets the Tucks. The Tucks became immortal after drinking water from a spring. She is fascinated by Jesse Tuck, a boy who's really 104 years old. The family shares with her the secrets of the spring. However, a man in a yellow suit is also after the secret behind the Tucks' immortality. The Tucks are threatened by the man in a yellow suit until they are in grave danger. Winnie must choose whether to live forever, and find how to save the Tucks.

The story has been adapted into a film twice: in 1981 by Office of Communications and in 2002 by Walt Disney Productions.

Tropes used by the novel and films:

  • Adaptation Expansion: Some padding is to be expected. The book isn't very long after all. Also, the immortality is only claimed in the book, with no real evidence in the actual story to confirm it. The 2002 movie shows fully that the claims were true: Jesse gets shot but is otherwise undeterred. A literal Wham Shot.
  • Age Lift: Winnie is ten years old in the book, but in the 2002 movie, she's in her mid teens. This is probably to make the romance between her and Jesse less Squicky. (she's still underaged though...).
  • The American Civil War: Miles was a soldier in the 2002 movie
  • Be Careful What You Wish For: Mild example. Winnie wishes to get away from her family. Then she's kidnapped. But the experience turns out to be not so bad after all.
    • There's also the obvious one about desiring immortality. The Tucks take care to see that Winnie understands how staying young forever isn't as great as it sounds.
  • Bittersweet Ending: In the movie Jesse returns to the tree after a hundred years have passed to see if Winnie had taken the water and was waiting for him, only to find her tombstone instead, placed beneath it. Reading it, he finds out that she had a long and happy life with a husband and children. In the book Winnie is buried in the Treegap graveyard and Tuck is the one who finds her headstone.
  • Can't Grow Up: Obviously.
  • Complete Immortality: They don't age and they are Nigh Invulnerable.
  • Deal with the Devil: The Tucks are suspected of this in-story.
  • Did Not Get the Girl: Winnie grows up and dies instead of becoming immortal with Jesse.
  • Dramatic Irony: The Tucks notice a toad in the way of their wagon, and muse that it probably thinks it'll live forever, not knowing it's the same toad Winnie gave up her immortality water for.
  • Evil Detecting Cows: The first chapter of the book has the cows sensing something very wrong with the forest itself and quickly going around it.
  • The Film of the Book: There are two different adaptations.
  • Friendless Background: Winnie, due to her family's strict upbringing.
  • Immortality Seeker: The Man in the Yellow Suit is this.
  • Immortal Procreation Clause: The Tucks don't age, they don't die. Mrs. Tuck was past childbearing age when she drank from the spring, so it isn't an issue for the elder Tucks. However, the eldest Tuck son got married in the years after they drank from the spring and before they realized its effects; he had children, but his wife eventually thought he'd made a Deal with the Devil and left him.
  • The Jail Bait Wait: Jesse gave Winnie some of the water, intending for her to use it when she was of marriageable age. She gave the water to a toad instead.
  • The Magic Goes Away: In the Distant Finale, the immortality spring has been bulldozed over and destroyed.
  • Magic Realism: Other than the spring, there's nothing unrealistic in the book, and the reason the spring water does what it does is never explained.
  • Mama Bear: Mae's usually very sweet, but she kills The Man in the Yellow Suit to protect her family. Not to mention kidnapping Winnie for the same reason.
    • She's also this to Winnie. That's the main reason she kills The Man in the Yellow Suit. She didn't want him to force Winnie to drink the spring water and condemn her to an eternity of loneliness.
  • Mayfly–December Romance: Winnie (who is ten years old in the novel) wants to marry Jesse when she turns seventeen. In the movie, they changed her to be fifteen.
  • The Men in Black: The man in the yellow suit.
  • My Beloved Smother: Mrs. Foster
  • No Name Given: The Man in the Yellow Suit.
  • Of Corset Hurts: In the movie Winnie is forced to wear a corset. Her mother tells her "You must suffer to be beautiful, so say the French", to which Winnie replies "Well the French are crazy!". When Winnie is staying with the Tucks, Ma helps her remove the corset, commenting on how she can't understand why women torture themselves with them. The Tucks teach her how to live a very natural and easy lifestyle.
  • Pistol-Whipping: Mae Tuck smacks The Man in the Yellow Suit with a shotgun, fracturing his skull.
  • Promoted to Love Interest: Winnie in the 2002 movie.
  • Stockholm Syndrome: Winnie is technically kidnapped by the Tucks, but they didn't mean any harm by it.
  • Who Wants to Live Forever?: This is a major theme.