Proof that the remaining 10% is worth becoming part of Davy Jones' crew for here:
These are recommendations made by Tropers for Fan Fics, all of which have been signed. After a few samples, you will be able to judge whether you might be interested in the 'fic, based on who recommended it. No-name recommendations will be zapped. Nobody would back up the rec. Discussion of the recommendation is welcome on the discussion page. As such discussion is important, do remember to add the discussion page to the watchlist, if need be.
Do warn when a fanfic may head into homosexual or non-canon territory. Some people don't like it, and as we all know, Shipping is Serious Business.
Synopsis: Post-CotBP AU. Norrington's Dauntless has the Black Pearl trapped; Captain Sparrow's only hope of escape involves taking a desperate chance. POV shifts from ship to ship, drama ensues on both sides. Plenty of believable interactions amongst both pirates and navymen. Nautically-literate tall tale by one of the acknowledged Best Writers of PotC fanfic. PG-13 for some of the grittier realities of maritime battles.
Tag: Jack, Norrington, and a Cast Of Dozens- Adventure
Synopsis: Pre-CotBP. Jack relates an amusing tale of vengeful rum smugglers, priest impersonation, trouble-making donkeys, and the loss & recovery of a certain important hat. Irreverent, but no clerics were harmed in the spinning of this delightful yarn. PG for some impolite language & attitudes.
Tag: Jack Sparrow, A Pack Of O Cs- Humor, Adventure
Synopsis: Pre-CotBP. How Jack came to be accused of kidnapping... it wasn't really his fault. When a young stowaway is found aboard his ship, Captain Sparrow must balance his Piratical responsibilities against his natural fondness for whelps. Any resemblance to a similarly-named Kipling novel is deliberate. PG for mild adult refs.
Synopsis: Post-CotBP AU. Jack plays matchmaker for the jilted James. The Commodore is understandably suspicious. Lots of snarky Jack & James dialogue- nobody writes that better than Orpsgod! PG for mild adult refs.
Synopsis: Pre-CotBP. Jack is in his early teens, so it's time for Da to acquaint him with a few Facts Of Life. Teague is not looking forward to it. Kids- even pirate kids- can put you on the spot like nobody else. Hilarious, and as close to WAFF as a Teague fic ever gets. PG-13 for adult themes, tastefully handled.
Synopsis: Takes place during CotBP. Honorat describes every minute Jack and Liz spent on the rumrunner's island. It's amazing how many things two people can find to do on a godforsaken spit of sand. PG for minor adult refs.
Synopsis: Post-AWE AU. Suppose Jack found the Fountain of Youth and it worked- what historical events might he have witnessed, or participated in, over the centuries? Each chapter describes a different scenario; sad, funny, tragic, exhilarating or introspective. (Chapter 22 includes a course-change which should gladden the hearts of all James Norrington fans.) Stories are rated G to PG-13 for violence, minor adult themes, and a bit of impolite language.
Synopsis: Post-CotBP AU. Exactly What It Says on the Tin. A ticked-off Captain Sparrow goes to preposterous lengths to give Commodore Norrington a truly memorable holiday. Nobody dies... though James might not consider that the worst option. General audience.
Synopsis: Takes place during CotBP. The Dauntless has returned to port, Will Turner is pondering Jack's upcoming execution. Possibly the most believable explanation ever written for why Will risked everything to rescue Sparrow. PG for semi-graphic description of what death by hanging involves.
Synopsis: Post-CotBP. Jack pays Will a visit in his blacksmith shop. Will reveals something he probably shouldn't of. Jack overreacts. Liz finds a solution. A funny vignette with true-to-character dialogue. PG for a bit of cartoony violence.
Synopsis: Post-AWE AU. Elizabeth, now Will's wife and a member of Jack's crew, has an onshore experience that changes her perspective. Mypiratecat1 writes some of the best WAFF fics in the PotC fandom, and the Chocolat refs in this one can only help! General Audience.
Synopsis: Pre-CotBP. Encounters between Captain Sparrow and Cutler Beckett are usually no laughing matter, but there are exceptions- this fic was voted 'Best Humor' at the PotC Votes Livejournal Awards. Sparrow has just been cruelly branded and is determined to escape. Unfortunately, Fate loves playing tricks on our swashbuckler and she's about to do her very worst. PG-13 for some harsh references & language.
Synopsis: Pre-DMC. During the voyage to the Turkish prison, Gibbs and Jack share a peaceful interval under a nighttime sky. Even a pirate needs a friend to talk to now and then. Just-barely PG for brief mention of past unpleasantness.
Synopsis: Post-AWE AU. On his way to the Fountain of Youth, Jack (literally) runs into someone he never expected. What follows proves that Jack attracts weirdness, and the immortals aren't done with him yet. Continued in the 'Water of Life' and 'Lucifers Sword' series. This is a very long tale that's still a WIP, but the writing quality makes it worth the trip.
Synopsis: Pre-CotBP. The aftermath of Jack's branding. Bootstrap Bill rescues him from Beckett's custody and tends his wounds, but the mental lacerations will take longer to heal. A compelling explanation for why Sparrow traded the life of a law-abiding seaman for that of a pirate (with just a little help from Shakespeare.) PG-13 for refs to violent events.
Synopsis: Post-CotBP AU. On the rebound after losing Liz, Commodore Norrington goes to a party and meets Miss Right. But once she's got him in her clutch, she proves to be Miss Wrong-As-She-Could-Possibly-Be! James needs help, but who possesses enough cunning and guile to beat this treacherous wench at her own game...? You have to ask?? This being Orpsgod, look for more laugh-inducing situations and snarky dialogue than you can shake a cutlass at. PG for mild adult refs.
Synopsis: Very possibly the best Will Turner background story in Fan Fiction. William's years of apprenticeship to Mr. Brown include familial love, heartrending tragedy, learning mastery of forge & blade, and friendship with Elizabeth that gradually becomes something more. All framed by an account of that fateful day when Will first encountered a certain wily Pirate. No professional writer could have done better. PG-13 for some harsh events.
Tag: William Turner, some Jack Sparrow- Biography, Adventure
Synopsis: Takes place during CotBP. Jack, Liz and Will row towards the Dauntless after confirming the Pearl is gone. They all know what this means for Sparrow, and it's hard to say who regrets it most. PG for angst-ridden theme.
Synopsis: Takes place during CotBP. Barbossa is dead, but the Black Pearl has left Jack behind, and he's now a prisoner in the brig of the Dauntless. Sparrow's reflections during the voyage back to Port Royal... and the gallows. PG for impending character death.
Synopsis: Pre-CotBP. That latest Spanish/ English war has just concluded, provoking differing expectations amongst Navymen, civilians and pirates. Insightful glimpse into the human realities of that era. PG for a bit of suggestive dialogue.
Tag: Groves & Gillette, Norrington, Jack- Everyday Drama
Synopsis: Post-CotBP AU. In the aftermath of the Port Royal earthquake, Captain Sparrow finds a most unexpected calling. But before he can answer, he has some squalls and reefs to navigate, with a little help from friends old and new. PG-13 for natural disaster & violence.
Tag: Jack, Annamaria, Will, Liz, James, several O Cs- Adventure, some Angst and Romance
Synopsis: Post-AWE AU. During a 1935 hurricane, a young woman vagabond seeks refuge in an unusual place... and encounters an even more unusual man. At least one of them will never be the same. Wonderfully poetic writing recommends this portrait of Depression-era artistry, featuring an in-character 'future Jack.' (Sparrabeth mentioned in passing.) PG for minor adult refs.
Synopsis: Post-CotBP. Three men walk into a tavern, one of them starts to sing. If anyone wondered how all those improbable yarns about Captain Sparrow got started, here's the answer. (But who knew the pirate was a poet?) General Audience.
Chance Encounter A 5 part (each novel length) series which starts as a crossover and moves into Mega Crossover territory by the second instalment. Comedy, violence, badassery and occasional Aesops abound.
Synopsis: Post-AWE AU. Various obstacles and past acquaintances keep popping up, as Elizabeth journeys to find Will with Jack in tow. The chapters jump back and forth between two storylines, both of which involve danger and escapes (plus lots of funny scenes & dialogue.) PG for a bit of impolite language, occasional violence.
Tag: Jack, Liz, Barbossa, Beckett, and a cast of dozens- Adventure, Humor
Synopsis: Takes place during CotBP. WIP. As Jack's crew sails the Black Pearl away from Isla de Muerta, each member ponders the justifiability of 'keeping to the code'... and abandoning Jack to the gallows. The writing meets Honorat's usual high standards. PG for impending character death.
Tag: Gibbs, Anamaria & the Pearl crew- Angst, Character Study
Synopsis: Variant Times And Locales. A 'drabble' is a hundred-word (or close to it) story, and nobody writes better PotC drabbles than Geekmama. Here's more than 120 of 'em, encompassing every movie, focused on a wide range of subjects, characters and moods. What they have in common is quality. General Audience to PG-13.
Synopsis: The captain always goes down with the ship. Jack Sparrow's final thoughts as he makes his last stand on the deck of the Black Pearl. Takes place during the part where he gets taken by the Kraken.
Choosing a Side by Deidara the Arrancar Alchemist (author's name subject to change)
Recommended by Twoie92
Synopsis: What would have happened if Norrington DIDN'T die? What if he chose another side, a side that alters his destiny? Here is my view of Norrington's life if he became a pirate and fought alongside the Brethren Court. Enjoy, fellow buccaners!
Comments: An AU exploring what would happen if Norrington chose to go with Elizabeth in the third movie. Very well written.
Synopsis: Basic Hot tamale, I got sucked into the movie! idea. But with a real plot line. Involves me and my best friend and our mission to get back home while being thrown into the PotC story unintentionally.
Comments: So far away from what usually happens in these kinds of stories that it's hilarious.
Synopsis: Set between DMC and AWE. After the krakken does him in, Jack awakens in a strange place, amongst stranger company. But that never stopped him before... A largely lighthearted romp through the afterlife, with a bit of help from Greek Mythology. PG for morbid refs (kinna inevitable with a cast of dead people.)
Tag: Jack and a bunch of characters from classic literature- Afterlife Adventure
Synopsis: Can a ruthless pirate truly fall in love, at least once? Perhaps. A young doctor kidnapped by Barbossa comes to realize that she finds the captain more intriguing than she'd care to admit, and that there's a lot more to him than first meets the eye.
Comments: The first story is set before CotBP, and the author takes her time to make the interactions between canon characters and OC heartfelt and believable; the fact that she has real medical experience helps, too. The style (first-person narration) goes very well with the 17/18th century setting.
Note: Sadly, Nytd passed away in November 2013. The latest instalment in the series, A Rose Among the Thorns, will remain unfinished.
Synopsis: An in depth, novel-like rewrite of the Pirates trilogy.
Pairings: Willabeth, Jack/OC and James/OC.
Comments: A few typos here and there (but the author is working on correcting them), but apart from that, the story is very well written. The author has put a lot of time and effort into this, and it shows. Her original characters are also some of the best I've seen in the fandom.
Synopsis: Post-CotBP AU. A pressgang abducts Sparrow and Norrington, forcing them to join the crew of a privateer vessel bound for India. In this dangerous environment, the former enemies learn to rely on each other to survive, and eventually escape. And they fall in love. Professional-quality writing and nautical literacy greatly enhances this 26-chapter adventure tale. Includes illustrations, some NSFW. NC-17 for explicit slashy sex, Attempted Rape, some salty language.
Synopsis: Post-CotBP AU. Captain Sparrow has what it takes to pass for a woman, which just might save his life when he and James are obliged to hide out amongst a traveling troop of Shakespeare performers. This mutually-irritating masquerade lands them in one farcical situation after another... closely followed by lusty ones. Plenty of by-necessity cross-dressing, and some truly hilarious scenes! With illustrations, one NSFW. NC-17 for explicit slashy sex and impolite language.
Synopsis: In times of darkness, one can turn to the Lord, but it is good to have friends. When faced with the death of the man she has come to love, a young mermaid knows of only one way to save him. Takes place after On Stranger Tides.
Synopsis: (Taken from the Pit) One wicked and clever pirate. One singular and brilliant detective. One hundred and fifty years apart. An impossible meeting? Perhaps just improbable...
Comments: A very well written Sherlock Holmes crossover, that stays more true to that fandom than Pirates of the Caribbean, but is not any worse for it. It captures the characters perfectly, and I thought it was good enough for Sir Arthur Conan Doyle to have written it.
Synopsis: Based primarily on my fascination with The Flying Dutchman the opera and what the suave Erik would make of a certain tragic Scottish organ playing doppelganger...Expect chaos to ensue, of course. PotC and Phantom of the Opera COMPLETE AT LAST!
Pairings: Eh...well, Madame Giry/Davy Jones is the main one, but a lot of other Crossover Pairings hook up over the course of the story.