It's time for the second TV Tropes Halloween Avatar Contest, theme: cute monsters! Details and voting here.
Characters: Puella Magi Madoka Magica 3
A small, cute creature that communicates through telepathy. His duty is to form contracts with girls where they will become magical girls and fight witches in exchange for any one wish. He is intent on contracting Madoka due to her immense potential.
He's working torwards the fulfillment of a mysterious, overarching goal which is slowly unveiled as the story progresses.
- Adorable Abomination: Given that he's a Starfish Alien with Blue and Orange Morality, reality-warping wish-granting powers, and Resurrective Immortality that involves eating his own corpse, yeah, he qualifies.
- Aliens Are Bastards: Though they don't mean any malice, they'll still leave humans to die if they meet their quota. So much for the relationship being mutually beneficial.
- Anti-Hero: He's Type II at the end of the manga, following Madoka's wish because he's no longer a manipulative mastermind. Until then he was something of an Anti-Villain instead.
- Arch-Enemy: To Homura; They've been fighting for a long time.
- Art Evolution: Kyubey's original design gave him large pupils instead of small red eyes.
- Auto Cannibalism: Eats any body that dies; technically they're all himself.
- Big Bad: The show's conflict begins and ends with him. Then Madoka rewrites reality and he doesn't have to be evil anymore, but that's at the very end of the series.
- Blue and Orange Morality: He literally can not comprehend why humans would care if their souls have been ripped out of their bodies or not. In Episode 7, Homura states that "human values don't mean anything to it". Then in Episode 9 it reveals that "they", the heavily implied Hive Mind don't have any emotions, bizarre alien ones included. Indeed, emotion is considered to be a mental illness among his race. .
- Break Them by Talking: His usual tactic, typically employed against Madoka. It backfires, since he ends up giving her the necessary information to make her wish.
- Bystander Syndrome: Something doesn't involve magical girls hunting Grief Seeds? Then Kyubey doesn't have an opinion on it.
- Did you just throw away your friend's Soul Gem? I'd like to help you, but first let me explain why throwing that thing away is crazy.
- A massive Witch has been born and will destroy the whole earth in a matter of days? Good luck fighting it, I just harvested enough energy to meet my planetary quota.
- Catch Phrase: "Make a contract with me!"
- Cats Are Mean: His form is highly ambiguous, but his body and the way he moves seem to invoke a cat-like imagery (possibly a ferret instead - see Weasel Mascot below), and the things he says and does... he may not think he's being cruel, but everyone else disagrees.
- Cat Smile: It's creepy as hell due to its face being stuck semi-permanently in this expression. Whether this is its intention is a matter of much debate.
- Crossdressing Voices: Kyubey is considered to be male, but voiced by a woman since he has a high cheery voice. Granted, he's so inhuman he isn't either gender.
- In Drama CD 2, he claims to not see himself a male by human standards after walking in on Madoka taking a bath.
- In audio commentary to Episode 4, Gen Urobuchi said that Kyubey is/are genderless.
- Cute Is Evil: More amoral and without empathy than evil.
- Deadpan Snarker: In the alternate universe created by Madoka. He remarks that it'd be cool if magical girls could become witches, but even he has to admit that in that universe, that's not possible.
- Death Is a Slap on the Wrist: He has "many bodies" and can reincarnate himself instantly. The drama of him getting beaten up (and killed, then beaten up again) by Homura in the first episode was, presumably, an act to get Madoka to sympathize with him. Also, his method of clean-up when a new body is to eat his own corpse.
- Dissonant Serenity: In the anime he always wears that creepy smile and he almost always talks cheerfully in both versions regardless of context, only demonstrating any degree of distress a few times. He recognizes that his voice should show distress in situations of obvious danger, like when he's running from Homura, and, as later revealed, can also sound surprised but more nuanced emotions are too alien for him to mimic them convincingly.
- Emoticon: /人◕‿‿◕人\
- Even Evil Has Standards:
- Kyubey disapproves of Madoka killing Sayaka, be it ever so inadvertently, in her attempt to stop in-fighting amongst magical girls, and he even rebukes her for doing something "that's crazy." It was a waste of a perfectly good Soul Gem! He has standards in the same way that a person who objects to throwing away a half-eaten sandwich has standards. It's a waste.
- Kyubey doesn't approve of needless sacrifices. He notes in Episode 9 that he would have stopped Kyoko had her death been meaningless (but didn't because her death served the purpose of forcing Madoka into contracting). Compare to the second-to-last chapter of Kazumi Magica, where he warns Kazumi about what he sees as the pointlessness of her wish (she wishes to become human, and he points out that once she becomes human she will immediately become a Magical Girl; as he sees it, this will essentially cancel out the wish).
- He never forces anyone to make a contract because the Incubators "treat humans as sentient". He loves to take advantage of opportunities in which the magical girl candidate has little choice but to make the contract, and he certainly doesn't believe in the idea of informed consent, but he never ever holds a metaphoric gun to their head.
- Evil Albino: Fur instead of hair but it's still white and he's still...morally ambigious.
- Faux Affably Evil: He politely tricks girls into becoming liches.
- Frozen Face:
- Kyubey's face is normally frozen in the Cat Smile described above but there are exceptions to this such as in Episode 2 when Kyubey takes a bite of an omelette. It also closes its eyes at times, probably when it's supposed to be a smile.
- Also averted in the manga, where it has more facial expression.
- Glowing Eyes of Doom: Their glowing red eyes are often the only visible feature on their shadowed figure and they have brought doom to many easily manipulated little girls.
- The Heavy: See Big Bad above.
- Hive Mind: Confirmed by Word of God. See the main page.
- Invisible to Normals: Only magical girls or magical girl candidates can see him.
- Ironic Echo: When trying to persuade Madoka to become a Magical Girl, he often states that her potential is so great that any wish could be granted, and that she could even become a god if she wanted. He even repeats this moments before Madoka finally does make a wish, and is suitably horrified when she uses it to do just that.
- Jackass Genie: "Want to become a magical girl and have your own miracle? Great! Make a contract with me." "Oh, and, uh, it'll only cost you your soul and end with you dying. It's either that or you becoming the very thing you fight through sheer, eventual despair. Toodles!"
- Japanese Pronouns: Kyubey speaks in a rather tortured syntax, using only diminutive pronouns and entirely stripping out honorifics when talking to people. Its not so much disrespectful as it is just stilted, and gives the impression that he views people about the same way as he would furniture or cattle. He even makes that comparison later on.
- Just Desserts: Does this to himself in Episode 8 after Homura executes him by emptying a whole clip into him, even though it was not necessary, resulting in Swiss Cheese. She really hates the thing. And for a good reason.
- Karma Houdini: Along with the rest of the Incubators, he suffers no punishment for all the trickey he/they have done other than a less convenient bussiness model and all of his mustache-twirlingly-evil actions were undone by the Cosmic Retcon. Interestingly, in the new timeline he's implied to be a much better terms with the magical girls, or at least his behavior is much more benign.
- Kick the Dog: Although it was pretty obvious that there is something fishy about Kyubey, the scene where he makes Sayaka "experience real pain" just to prove a point makes it clear that he is evil, or at very least completely lacking in empathy. This could or could not be relevant to The Plan. His entire goal is to have the girls fall into despair so they can become witches. His KTD moment was his way of reinforcing leading Sayaka to thinking "I done screwed up!" and witchifying her.
- Lack of Empathy:
"It never fails. Whenever I tell you humans the simple facts, you always react the same way. It makes no sense at all. Why are humans so sensitive about the kind of container their souls are housed in?"
- Laughably Evil: Kyubey's complete obliviousness to human morality, standards and emotions can come off as quite funny sometimes.
- Leitmotif: "Sis puella magica!" is generally considered one for him and the series as a whole.
- Literal Genie: Kyubey says that it can grant any wish... ANY wish. With no strings attached. Kyubey will not willingly try to corrupt the wish. The price itself of making the wish is hefty, but the wish is carried out to its completion. The problem is that some people screw up anyway because they don't consider the implications of their wish, and Kyubey never points them out. What they wish for might not be entirely what they want, or if it is entirely what they want, there are unforeseen consequences for making that wish. That's what happened to the unfortunate Kyoko, Sayaka, and countless others.
- Make a Wish: Kyubey will grant a candidate one wish in return for them becoming a magical girl. He does not look for the worse interpretation. His explanation for bad things happening to wishers is that the power of the Wish creates equal parts despair and hope. (Like a magical version of two particles coming into being in vacuum fluctuation; both negative and positive thus equaling zero.) He cannot stop someone from making a wish that he wouldn't want them to make, and he can't force anyone to make a wish either.
- Rather than exploit Jerkass Genie, he simply gives them exactly what they asked for because what they ask for is never what they actually want. The girls are never honest with themselves about their desires, every selfless wish has a selfish motive behind it, and the despair sets in when they realize that their selfless wish being granted did not guarantee their selfish desire being granted as well.
- Manipulative Bastard: He may have trouble understanding human values and emotions, but he's very good at exploiting them. He asks the girls to make a contract with him at the exact moment when they'd have the most difficulty refusing and he will abusively call you, even if you refuse his offer. While it is indeed true that he never lies per se, he knows exactly how to twist his words and withhold information in such a way that he that he still technically tells the truth, but also tricks the girls into actions that helps him further his goals while making things worse for themselves.
- Meaningful Name/Names to Run Away From Really Fast: Incubator, one who incubates young witches into mature ones.
- Mentor Mascot:
- Metaphorically True: More or less everything that comes out of his mouth. While never technically lying, Kyubey makes it a point to only speak in half-truths. When pressed, he responds with either confusion or incredulity; after all, it's their fault for not asking him the right questions in the first place. He eventually tortures Madoka with the whole truth after Sayaka's funeral. Though it was probably not supposed to be torture but an explanation and a way to prove a point, from his point of view- being someone who wouldn't see why she would feel tortured by it.
- Mysterious Backer: He's a creature that our heroines know nothing about but accept Magical Girl power and wishes from.
- Nice Job Fixing It, Villain: His Info Dump toward Madoka about magical girl's role in history of humanity and his own confirmation that any of Madoka's wishes can be granted are what inspire Madoka to make her Cosmic Retcon wish.
- Nigh-Invulnerability: Of the Can Only Kill Part Of Him kind. An exact replica of it comes to eat its corpse after Homura riddles it with bullets in Episode 8. It claims it has unlimited number of substitutions. Word of God says he instantly creates a body from surrounding Mana.
- The Needs of the Many: The reason why he doesn't see his actions as evil. He argues to Madoka that the cycle of witches and magical girls are necessary to keep the universe from dying out, and it even has the side benefit of helping humanity to advance as a species, so he can't understand why she objects over the relatively few lives it destroys. When Gretchen threatens to destroy Earth, he has no problem with applying this reasoning to humanity as a whole. He filled his quota, so the universe doesn't really need humanity to go on any more.
- No Biological Sex: Most fans default to referring to Kyubey as "he", but the character doesn't have any physical sex. In the Japanese dub he refers to himself with "boku" so it's safe to say that if he isn't male he is pretending to be for the sake of brevity.
- Non-Action Big Bad: He's plenty active but none of it is fighting; 100 percent manipulation.
- No, You: No matter how someone says he did them wrong, he will ALWAYS claim via loophole that it's technically their fault. Whether he truly feels this way due to his lack of emotions or not is anyone's guess.
- Obliviously Evil: Downplayed. He knows that humans disprove of his actions but he doesn't understand why they disaprove. From his prespective, he's saving the universe.
- Oh, Crap: " It violates the laws of karmic destiny! Are you trying to become a god!?"
- Omniglot: Besides Japanese, Kyubey also speaks fluent French, English, Egyptian, Dutch, Norwegian, Swahili and you-name-it-he-speaks it. After all, known victims include Jeanne d'Arc, Cleopatra, Anne Frank, Viking and African children, not to mention countless others from presumably from every nation across our world. If ever he's forced to change jobs, Kyubey would make a lucrative career as a Professor of Linguistics.
- Omniscient Morality License: The Incubators use the powerful emotions given off by Magical Girls and witches to counter entropy and prevent the heat death of the universe. They ultimately consider humanity expendable.
- Perpetual Smiler: It's VERY creepy because it remains this face in the face of horror.
- Red Eyes, Take Warning: Eeep...◊
- Regular Caller: He's always the one making the Call to Adventure but The call is on reversed charges and international prices and there's a lifetime contract.
- Ridiculously Cute Critter: Who wouldn't want to make a contract with something this cute? Word of God says this is intentional to hide his true nature.
- Spell My Name with an "S": Kyuubey, Kyuubee, Kyubei, and QB are also floating around out there.
- "Cubey" was also a short-lived proposal since producers said that the "kyu" is as in "cute".
- "Kyubey" seems to be the most official, though, since it has been used in official promo materials and moreover, most fansubbers and scanlators actually doing the show are spelling it like this.
- Its name is also spelled quite bizarrely in original Japanese. It's half in katakana, half in hiragana, with an additional bonus for an unconventional use of small-sized katakana.
- It turns out that "Kyubey" is short for "Incubator".
- The runes in Episode 11 spell it as "Qbey". Which turns out to be completely accurate due to his intentions.
- The Spock: Incubators takes "logic" and The Needs of the Many to such extremes that it makes them a villainous version of the trope. Earth can blow up and he/they will not care as long as energy is collected.
- Starfish Alien: It explains why his moral compass is completely out of whack, his creepy cheerful expression and his powers.
- The Stoic: Of the "say something horrific without any emotions" variety. For example, his serene speeches in Episode 12. He calmly explains what's going on to Homura and seems to be more concerned about Madoka's fate, even when the Universe ends around him and he's already figured out that very soon he will cease to exist, to be recreated as a different version of self.
- Straw Vulcan: Claims to be non-emotional, but displays emotion constantly. While some of that is probably an act to trick the girls, even when talking to someone who knows better he displays smugness, gloating, exasperation, and a very dark sense of humor. Even his explanation that his race is unemotional has a distinct sarcastically-patronizing sound to it. Of course, his exact statement is that his race considers emotions a mental illness, so it's possible that he's just gone nuts and doesn't realize it.
- Super Empowering: This is its job. It's quite pushy about that and it doesn't give you a run-down of your powers, either.
- They Killed Kenny Again: Homura has probably "killed" him dozens of times by now, but it never sticks.
- Totalitarian Utilitarian: Kyubey's goal is to stave off the heat death of the universe, which he does by dooming teenage girls to lives of suffering (and eventual transformation into Eldritch Abominations that kill plenty of innocent people — and potentially entire planets — in the process).
- Villainous BSOD: Occurs when Madoka wishes to erase witches from existence. All the more poignant because Kyubey's race views emotions as a mental illness, so Madoka's game changing wish literally made Kyubey lose his mind.
- Troll: An intentional example. He does it to get more emotional energy out of the magical girls before they turn into witches or to speed up the transformation process.
- Villains Never Lie: If lie is defined as "saying something that is definitely and entirely untrue" then he has never lied. However, he deliberately invokes Exact Words to deceive.
- Walking Spoiler: As you can see. Even saying what Kyubey actually is, is a massive spoiler unto itself.
- Weasel Mascot: We do mean weasel, in the figurative sense.
- Well-Intentioned Extremist: How he... it... they... whatever view themselves, since the stated goal is to stop the entropy of the universe. How? Create magical girls and witches to unleash energy, of course! Once he gets his quota, Planet Earth and everyone on it becomes expendable. The irony is that Magical Girl Warrior villains most often plot to consume magical energy/lifeforce with the end goal of destroying the world, often for no rational reason. It's also said that the more power a witch consumes, the more energy is released when it's destroyed by a Magical Girl and it's grief seed consumed by an Incubator. Also, in the case of Madoka, it empowers itself every time some Despair Event Horizon converges to it.
- Wicked Weasel: A weasel like creature that engages in trickery.
- Will Not Tell a Lie: Kyubey never lies about anything and will happily cough up the truth if asked directly. It even seems offended at the idea that someone would accuse it of lying. It does however leave out a lot of vital information that would be to its disadvantage to reveal, invoking You Never Asked. It's not above speaking in half-truths either.
- When Kyoko asks if there is any way to return Sayaka to human form, Kyubey states that there's no precedent for it. It's an answer that is technically correct but baits Kyoko into believing that there could be a way.
- In Episodes 9 and 10. In 9 he states that his actions would preserve humanity's future among the stars. However, he phrases it in such a way that it doesn't reveal whether he cares if humanity goes to the stars or not. We find in Episode 10 that he does not care one bit about humanity or Earth, as long as his energy quota is reached, and an alternate timeline version in 8 dismissed the end of the world as "humanity's problem" after it filled said quota by unleashing it.
- Your Approval Fills Me with Shame: Gives one on occasion:
"Excellent work, Homura. You've made Madoka the most powerful witch ever."
Mysterious magical beings who feed on the despair of humans. They employ minions known as familiars, who, if left unchecked, can grow into duplicates of the original witch. It is a magical girl's duty to slay witches and collect the Grief Seeds they drop. All witches reside in private pocket dimensions known as barriers which reflect their broken psyches. The only known exception to this rule is the colossal Walpurgisnacht, who is powerful enough to simply impose barrier-like properties onto reality instead of retreating into an alternate space.
Tropes that apply to all witches
- All There in the Manual: There is a lot of information about each witch that is only found on the official website. It also provides information for witches that haven't been seen in the show. The You Are Not Alone guidebook also alludes to or outright states several of the witches' wishes.
- Always Chaotic Evil: (What, always?) Yes, always! (What, always?) Well... almost always.
- And I Must Scream: Implied in the TV series. Oktavia has that red silhouette strikingly similar to Sayaka's form overlapping on her visage, which literally crying its eyes out as a cue for Oktavia's berserk phase.
- And Then The Magical Girls Were Witches: The fate of every magical girl not killed in battle is to be consumed by despair and turn into a witch. The blackening of the soul gems show how much time there's left before this happens. The only way to stop this is to spend the rest of your life battling witches to have a steady supply of grief seeds to siphon off despair into, or be killed by external sources like Cleopatra, Anne Frank and Jeanne d'Arc were.
- Art Shift: As per their Lovecraftian vibes, both the witches and their barriers are usually animated in a style that is completely different from the main style of the anime, to every witch her own style.
- Ascended to a Higher Plane of Existence: This is presumably what happens to them all at the end of the anime, thanks to Madoka rewriting the universe. In fact, all magical girls (including ones in the past) never become witches in the first place...they just vanish instead, smiling peacefully, and possibly joining Madoka Out There.
- Asteroids Monster: The familiars are effectively part of the witch. If a familiar is separated from a witch, it can grow its own Grief Seed by causing suffering to other humans and become a copy of the original witch. As magical girls need Grief Seeds to maintain their powers, some unscrupulous ones leave familiars alone to get more Grief Seeds.
- Came Back Wrong
- Clipped Wing Angel: Witches are usually less powerful than the magical girls they spawn from, judging by the fact that even a relatively weak magical girl like Sayaka can destroy a witch like Elly with ease. Usually, that is. Some witches, however, can pack an impressive punch - like Charlotte (who utterly destroys Mami, albeit that might have been due to the shock factor of her own One-Winged Angel), Elsa Maria (who almost kills Sayaka), Oktavia von Seckendorff, or ultimate witches the likes of Walpurgisnacht and Gretchen.
- Conservation of Ninjutsu:
- Witches that fight alongside their familiars (Gertrud, Elly, Elsa Maria) fare far worse in combat than witches who mainly fight solo (Charlotte, Oktavia). Gretchen, the most powerful of all, doesn't seem to have any familiars. Meanwhile, Demons in the new world hunt in packs, and seem to be far weaker and more uniform in appearance than witches.
- Completely averted by Walpurgis Night. Both the Witch and the familiars seem to pack a pretty impressive punch.
- The Corruption: Inverted. Magical girls purify their Soul Gems by placing the darkness that grows inside of it into Grief Seeds. However, doing it too many times can allow the witch to regenerate. The trope is then played straight when it's revealed that Grief Seeds are fully corrupted Soul Gems.
- Creepy Doll: Some of them look like this.
- The Klarissas, Oktavia's familiars in Episode 10. They're just there to cheerfully dance around the witch that commands them, with creepy smiles on their faces and possessing limbs that look like they can be snapped with a single touch...
- Also, Charlotte's original form.
- Daniyyel and Jennifer, Kirsten's familiars.
- Kirsten herself looks something like one, as we see when Sayaka sends her flying out of a computer monitor.
- Albertine, as revealed in the official PSP game, somewhat resembles a giant female clown doll.
- Curb-Stomp Battle: Generally on the receiving end, but a few, such as Charlotte to Mami and Walpurgisnacht to everyone until Madoka wishes her out of existence give them.
- Cypher Language: The odd runes appear to be messages from the witch or the familiars. Often they seem like a Madness Mantra. Oh wait, they are.
- Eldritch Abomination: All the witches are horrific mind bending monsters.
- Emotion Eater: Witches feed off human suffering.
- Evil Makes You Monstrous: Cute girls becoming terrible monsters
- The Fair Folk: Some of them are described as acting in this fashion. It's ultimately averted as they are former magical girls.
- Fallen Heroine: Every witch who isn't a familiar-turned-copy was a magical girl who allowed her Soul Gem to fill up with The Corruption, causing it to break and become a Grief Seed.
- Family-Unfriendly Death: They can be on the giving or receiving end, and often give as good as they get.
- The Final Temptation: The Different Story shows that when a Magical Girl's Soul Gem is about to reach its limit, the girl's Witch form can appear to the Magical Girl and try to tempt her into falling into despair. Shown with Candeloro, who appears to Mami and tries to convince her to become a Witch.
- From Nobody to Nightmare: They're fallen Magical Girls who used up their Soul Gems or fell into despair.
- The Heartless: Said to be born of curses. The curses of magical girls.
- High-Pressure Blood: The Witches seem to bleed gallons, though the color of the bleeding is different from one another, when cut by sharp implements; Kirsten's monitor (but not Kirsten herself) bleeds dark green when Sayaka smashes her out of it, Elsa Maria's blood is bright red when Sayaka beheads her, while Oktavia's hand spews bluish black blood when Kyoko cuts it off to save Madoka.
- I'm a Humanitarian: Quite a few of the witches, specifically Charlotte and Elsa Maria. For the former, she turns into a giant worm and eats Mami alive, starting with her head while the latter believes eating those who get to close to her barrier is "saving" them.
- Immune to Bullets:
- Averted. As Homura demonstrates, military-grade firearms are enough to destroy them.
- Played semi-straight with Walpurgisnacht, as Homura throws what basically amounts to enough firepower to destroy the city (in fact, her salvo is responsible for most of the initial property damage in Episode 11) and it doesn't even have a scratch afterwards.
- Improbable Weapon User: Fitting with their surreal theme, quite a few Witches use very strange weaponry. Literally the first thing Gertrud (the first Witch seen in the anime) does against Mami is to throw the sofa she's sitting on at her. The crown, however, goes to Oktavia van Seckendorff, who fights primarily by throwing wheels at her enemies. This is far more effective than it has any right to be.
- Invisible to Normals: Witches and their familiars cannot be seen by people who haven't been "chosen" by Kyubey to become Magical Girls.
- Ironic Hell: A witch's personality, powers, and barrier often combine to form a sick subversion of her magical girl counterpart's wish. For example, Charlotte loves sweets and can create any sweet she likes save for her favorite (cheese), and lives in a cross between a candy shop and a hospital. Side materials strongly imply that her wish was for cheesecake, when she could've wished for her mother's disease to be cured.
- Meaningful Name: Several of the witches have names that relate to themselves.
- Charlotte is a type of dessert. Elsa Maria brings to mind a biblical prayer. Kirsten resembles a computer monitor, and so she has an "online handle": H.N. Elly. And Walpurgisnacht is the name of a real-world European festival during which legends state that witches gather together.
- The biggest one? In written Japanese, the characters for "witch" (魔女, phonetically pronounced "majo") are found in the characters for "magical girl". (魔法少女, phonetically pronounced "mahou shoujo"). Put another way, "magical girl" can be read as "young witch".
- Meaningful Rename: The witches have different names than the magical girls they came from.
- Mental World: A Witch's Labyrinth very much reflects the persona and psyche of the witch who makes it her home.
- Mercy Kill: To kill a witch is to let a poor and broken girl die in peace. Madoka does this on a cosmic scale by making them Ascend to a Higher Plane of Existence; witches are still created when a Magical girl loses her will to live and is consumed by darkness, but nobody understands where they go or what happens.
- Mind Control: Shown by the "witch's kiss", a mark that appears on a human who is being controlled by a witch. These victims become Brainwashed and Crazy.
- Mind Screw: All of the witches and their barriers and minions take this to an absurd level.
- Monster of the Week: A much Darker and Edgier version. Until Madoka rewrites the system to make sure this won't happen anymore.
- Mook: Their familiars.
- Nigh Invulnerable: The only way to defeat Walpurgisnacht without massive loss of lives is to wish her out of existence. She can technically be defeated regularly, but is tough enough to shrug off a hailstorm of heavy artillery.
- Nonstandard Character Design: Every Witch and everything associated with them is drawn in a different art style from the rest of the show. Charlotte does double duty by having the Witch herself drawn in Thick-Line Animation, while everything else in her barrier is constructed out of paper cutouts.
- One-Winged Angel: You could consider witches as this to magical girls.
- Our Monsters Are Weird: Witch designs vary from fairly standard (Elsa Maria) to eccentric (Oktavia) to nightmarish (Patricia) to cutesy (Charlotte). Walpurgisnacht in particular takes a few glances to figure out what she's supposed to be.
- Pocket Dimension: Witches can create these; they're bizarre areas, to say the least, and it keeps the more elaborate fights out of view of normal people.
- Psychic-Assisted Suicide: The intended result of a witch's kiss from the two times that the effects of a kiss have been seen.
- Ret Gone: Madoka's wish in the finale makes it so that the witches are deleted from existence and replaced with a different kind of monster altogether, so that the Incubators can still gather energy for their mission while not bringing misfortune to the girls.
- Self-Duplication: Familiars can become a copy of the original witch.
- Sliding Scale of Villain Effectiveness: As mentioned under Clipped Wing Angel, witches can appear anywhere on the scale. Most fall under the Inadvertent category, but the stronger witches - such as Walpurgis Night or Kriemhild Gretchen - can fall under the High or even Infinite levels.
- Soul Jar: The witch's Grief Seed, left behind after their death. A Grief Seed is capable of regenerating the witch, which is why Kyubey devours them before they reach that point.
- Stellar Name: All the witches and familiars appear to be named after celestial objects found in the solar system. Take a look.
- That Woman is Dead: A variation. All of the witches throw out their old names and are reborn with names of their own, though lingering elements of their past lives as Magical Girls still remain.
- Tragic Monster: All of them since despair is what made them into witches in the first place.
- The Unreveal: All There in the Manual example. Three of the witches described on the website are never seen in the series, and it doesn't show Walpurgisnacht's name.
- Walking Spoiler: It's hard to talk about some witches such as Oktavia without revealing that they are corrupted magical girls.
- Was Once A Girl: All witches are either corrupted magical girls or the mutated familiars of those witches.
- Witch Species: Ultimately averted. They are all corrupted magical girls instead of a true species.
- Butterfly of Death and Rebirth: She and her familiars have butterfly wings. The "death and rebirth" part makes sense when you consider that she was once human, and was reborn as a Magical Girl (a lich in this setting), then as a witch.
- Combat Tentacles: She uses vines, but same idea.
- Green Thumb: Her "head" looks like a deformed rosebush and she uses vines to slap intruders around.
- Starter Villain: The first witch to appear in a proper showdown with a magical girl, excluding Madoka's dream at the beginning of Episode 1.
- Porn Stache: Her Anthony and Adelbert familiars have these. In the case of the Anthonies, Gertrud puts these 'staches on them.
Kirsten / H.N. Elly
- I Have Many Names: H.N. Elly is her "computer handle" while Kirsten is her real name.
- Ill Girl: Charlotte's labyrinth gives off this is vibe and Word of Dante claims she was one though it's contradicted by some of the official material for her prototype where it states her mother was the Ill Girl.
- Killer Rabbit: She's the cutest thing in the show, but then she turns into a giant worm and eats Mami alive.
- Knight of Cerebus: Unusually for this trope, she's killed off at the end of the episode she appears in.
- Lethal Joke Character: On the outside, Charlotte may not look like one to be taken seriously, but in reality, as Mami infamously found out the hard way, she's not one to be trifled with.
- Level Ate: Being the witch of desserts, she has a barrier mostly made of sweets.
- No Pronunciation Guide: Her name can be pronounced both with and without treating the "te" at the end as a separate syllable.
- One-Winged Angel: Charlotte does this and becomes a giant worm.
- Wolverine Publicity: She gets as much merchandise as Kyubey, and is a major character in Rebellion.
Oktavia von Seckendorff
- Attack of the 50-Foot Whatever: A gigantic mermaid knight.
- BFS: Oktavia's weapon is an enormous sword. It looks like a massive version of Sayaka's sword, for good reason.
- Fairytale Motifs: Parallels The Little Mermaid. As Sayaka, she sacrificed her soul to win the love of Kyosuke, only to fall into despair when he fell in love with Hitomi.
- Improbable Weapon User: Throws wheels at anyone who enters her barrier.
- Knight in Shining Armor: Symbolically. Sayaka believed herself a "hero of justice", and when she becomes Oktavia she dons knight's armor and a three-eyed helmet.
- Love Hurts: She was born as a result of Sayaka seeing Hitomi confess to Kyosuke. To reflect this, she wears a heart-shaped high collar and the end of her mermaid tail is shaped like a broken heart.
- Sirens Are Mermaids:
- She and her familiar both. Oktavia is the mermaid witch because the story of her Magical Girl (Sayaka)'s downfall has parallels with the original Little Mermaid.
- Holger performs music which steals the souls of the audience.
- Songs of Solace: Oktavia has an orchestra of Holger familiars (who look like Kyosuke and play the violin). She won't allow anyone to disturb their playing.
- Third Eye: On her knight's helmet.
- Vocal Dissonance: Within seconds of appearing, she lets out a scream in Sayaka's voice. The effect is horrific.
- The Von Trope Family
- Animal Motifs: Her many arms, black clothing, the extra eyes on her Grief Seed (seen in the PSP game), and the many clotheslines surrounding her like a web are all evocative of a spider.
- Bare Your Midriff: The part of her that still looks human has this with a short skirt and very small top.
- Half the Man He Used to Be: Her familiars are simply school uniform skirts on top of legs with no upper bodies.
- I Just Want to Be Normal: She acts out ordinary school days in her labyrinth and has her familiars play the roles of her classmates.
- Multi-Armed and Dangerous: Though the extra arms are for creepiness (and symbolism) rather than combat.
- Off with Her Head!: It's not easy to notice since her screentime consists of about 20 seconds, but full-body views of her (such as this one◊) show that she has no head.
- Rape as Drama: A common theory pertaining to her past life as a magical girl, based on the multiple arms coming out of her skirt and the labyrinth made of clotheslines (interpreting the need to wash them over and over).
- Red and Black and Evil All Over: Her school uniform is mostly black in color and topped off with a red bow.
- School Uniforms are the New Black: The above-mentioned sailor fuku ensemble, as well as the clotheslines in her labyrinth, which are strung with white sailor suits. She is the class representative witch, after all.
- Trouser Space: She shoots her familiars out like bullets through her giant skirt.
- Birdcaged: She's the birdcage witch.
- Does Not Like Men: If something about her Gotz familiars' appearance, description and her own opinion about them is anything to go by.
- Feathered Fiend:
- Her Gotz familiars are brightly-colored birds that try to hit on her, but she pushes them away.
- The art style makes it difficult to tell, but Roberta herself also resembles a dove (or an angel) inside a birdcage.
- Hard-Drinking Party Girl: Roberta likes alcohol. Her name could be a reference to the Aunt Roberta, a drink so potent it is perfectly capable of killing people who drink it.
- Attack of the 50-Foot Whatever: A gigantic harlequin clockwork doll floating upside-down in the sky.
- Big Bad: Her immense power is what causes the "Groundhog Day" Loop, when she kills off everyone but Homura in the first timeline. In every timeline, the fight with her is the pivotal moment, that always ends with Homura having to reset time again. Either because Madoka is killed trying to fight her, or because the fight with her causes her to become a witch herself. Downplayed, because as a witch, Walpurgisnacht is less like a schemer, and more like a force of nature. Kyubey is the schemer, though not in league with Walpurgisnacht.
- Boss Warning Siren: Walpurgisnacht's countdown.
- Expy: In the manga adaptation, she summons shadow dopplegangers of Mami, Sayaka, and Kyoko. Combined with her general demeanor and the fact that All There in the Manual calls her the witch of stage construction, she may very well be a reference to Type-Moon's similarly named Night of Wallachia.
- Final Boss: Though depending on how you look at things, Kriemhild Gretchen could be seen as the True Final Boss and/or Post Final Boss, since she is encountered and destroyed after Walpurgisnacht and is much more powerful, but by the time she appears Madoka's wish destroys her.
- Fusion Dance: The website speculates Walpurgisnacht is this, but says nobody knows. Word of God confirms it, although adds that she started as a perfectly normal witch.
- Hero Killer: Well known among magical girls and strong enough that no one except Madoka can defeat her alone.
- The Hyena: She never. Stops. Laughing. Not even as Madoka is shooting her out of the sky.
- The Juggernaut: A nigh-indestructible witch that throws skyscrapers and triggers gigantic thunderstorms. Homura has tried dozens of times to kill her and has failed every single time.
- Laughing Mad
- Improvised Weapon: Walpurgisnacht uses every object, even entire skyscrapers, in battle.
- Only Known by Their Nickname: Amazingly enough, even the website doesn't reveal Walpurgisnacht's name, just listing it, and her familiars, as "?????".
- Playing with Fire: Walpurgis Night breathes fire. Excluding her power, it suddenly makes a lot more sense for Homura's artillery attacks to have no effect on her.
- Spell My Name with an "S": Her name can be written as Walpurgisnacht or Walpurgis Night. The Hulu subs go with Walpurgisnacht, as does the English dub. As an aside, one of the songs relating to this witch is named "Nox Walpurgis", which of course is simply Latin for the same.
- Wolverine Publicity: Shades of this, appearing in merchandise and promotion long after her death.