While most remember the nightmare fuel from Episode 3 onwards, the Nightmare Fuel was there as early as Episode 1, with the Anthonies. See how freaky those things are?◊ Now look at them in action — the animation for them is deliberately jittery, and their babble translates to planning to cut Sayaka and Madoka up and present them to Gertrud.
The whole mob of Anthonies chants in synch, like they're reciting a poem they've all memorized, but the German translates to a back-and-forth discussion between two people. Eerie.
Mami's death. Her head is bitten off by a monstered-out Charlotte, shortly before the rest of her is eaten as well.
The first two episodes interlaced the credits with the action. The third had a ending theme song and a video. Just in case you weren't paying attention during Episode 3, it would fit in with the Higurashi crowd. (High note: Madoka, floating in a fetal position... which is revealed after the camera zooms out to be taking place inside the eye socket of the Mephisto mask from a Nazi-era stage production of Faust.)
Mami ties Homura with yellow ribbons. Later, after Mami's death, we see Homura tied with red ribbons, which then leak through her fingers...
A huge group of people enchanted to commit mass suicide, who all turn on Madoka once she wrecks their plan.
Madoka is drawn into a witch's barrier... by being torn apart and drawn into the barrier, piece by piece through several monitors, before being reconstituted within. If that wasn't enough, the witch preys on Madoka's grief by replaying Mami's death over and over, to convince her to give up as she's stretched and nearly torn apart for good. Lovely little Body Horror there. For a change, all of these horrors are strangely absent from the manga.
Episode 6 proves itself as a Wham Episode by turning the premise into Nightmare Fuel: The Soul Gems are the literal crystallization of the soul. As in, the Soul Gem is the true magical girl, and the body is simply a puppet.
Kyubey sees absolutely nothing wrong with this, because as he puts it, this way their bodies can't die so long as their Soul Gem remains intact (though they still age, mature, etc. as evidenced by Kyouko). In summary, "magical girl" here is a fancy term for lich. Considering what magical girls go through, he's probably right. Whether that makes it more or less horrifying is a subjective issue.
In another moment in the episode, Sayaka has discovered that Kyousuke was discharged early from the hospital and neglected to tell her. While she is standing heartbroken outside his house, Kyouko shows up and taunts Sayaka, saying that if she really wants Kyousuke to be hers, then she's got an idea for her...
Kyouko:"If you're so caught up on making him yours, I've got an even better idea. Take the magic you just got and march in there, and break his hands and his legs until he can never use them again. Make him completely helpless. Then he'll wholly be yours... heart and soul. If you're too shy to do it, I'd be happy to take your place. Just as a favor to my new colleague. It'd be so easy..."
At the beginning of the episode, Kyubey was torturing Sayaka through her Soul Gem, and then pushing her towards the berserker rage she uses to attack Elsa Maria. That much cruelty to someone vulnerable is repulsive. This is even worse when you remember that she is only 12 years old. We are talking a twelve year-old girl being subjected to the pain of impalement. One would still get shivers, watching the scene where Sayaka crumples down to the floor, gasping for breath, while Kyubey sits there smiling as though the whole thing was no big deal.
Kyoko's backstory was drawn up as a puppet show. The stick figures added to some really creepy imagery and especially the burning scene which was accompanied by a scene of her father hanging himself.
After Homura guns Kyubey down, a second Kyubey appears and devours the corpse of the first one. If that didn't frighten you, then Kyubey's last line of the episode should.
Kyubey: "So this country calls maturing women "girls", right? Well, for you all on the way to become witches, wouldn't it make sense to call you "magical girls"?
Sayaka's transformation into Oktavia von Seckendorff. Absolutely terrifying.
"When you're ready to die for the universe, call me. I'll be waiting."
[Madoka, now Kriemhild Gretchen, is not simply a witch; and Walpurgisnacht (easily the most powerful witch in the Madoka universe up to this point) is merely a blip compared to her. She's become something that Yui Ikari would envy and that Remina would fear. To make things even worse, take a look at her witch's card. That thing? That giant, mountainous thing? That's the witch of SALVATION.
Homura's fate is also worth some mention. Specifically, she constantly goes back in time to prevent Madoka's death/corruption. She has to watch the suffering of Madoka and the other Magical Girls over and over again, and the outcomes are crueler with every timeline. At one point, she was forced to shoot Madoka's Soul Gem to prevent her transformation into Gretchen. That was at Madoka's own request.
In an interview with the director, he stated the the number of times Homura has re-wound time is approaching 100. If we consider that Homura left the hospital in the middle of March and Walpurgisnacht appears at the end of April, that means that Homura's been lost in time for about 12 years. In other words, she has been at war against witches and Kyubey for 12 years. On the other hand, this also makes all those HomuMado implications seriously creepy.
Oktavia's new familiar in the third timeline, Klarissa, raise more Fridge Horror in how they resemble Hitomi. In this timeline, or another one, did Sayaka perhaps threaten, injure, or even kill her?
Of all people, Mami going through Sanity Slippage is pretty chilling. In one timeline, after failing to rescue Sayaka from her witch form, Mami restrains Homura, and then delivers a Mercy Kill to Kyouko by shooting her Soul Gem. Then, her end is quickly met after Madoka fires an arrow at Mami's Soul Gem. It's just a straight up minute or so of the remaining Magical Girls losing their minds over their fate and it's just awful and scary to witness.
Kyubey talks with Madoka about the relationship between incubators and mankind through history. Its eyes. ITS FUCKING EYES. When asked about why he has no feelings to the girls' tortures...
Madoka's body during the last part of it, dear Lord. She goes into the freaking fetal position while begging Kyubey to stop talking. By the end she moves out of the fetal position, places her head back and her body goes limp.
"You don't feel sorry for cows, do you?" Then they show quick shots of farm animals in pens, done in that creepy "stained glass" art style.
The universe-ending witch Madoka was unsettling. That enormous Eldritch Abomination with two halves of a face? Completely engulfing the earth? Dear Madokami.. Yes, that thingis Kriemhild Gretchen, the witch form of our adorable protagonist.Every new timeline sees her absorb all the magical energy of the previous universes that Homura has went through, meaning that each time, Kriemhild Gretchen is bigger and stronger—way beyond what Walpurgisnacht could ever hope to be. The wish that created that... thing was infinitely stronger than any other wish, powered by 100+ universes worth of magical potential. There's a reason that version of Kriemhild Gretchen is using celestial objects for eyes.
Sayaka's conspicuous absence from the scene with Madoka talking with Kyoko and Mami. There's so much focus on the suffering and deaths of the magical girls that what happens to the Grief Seeds tends to get overlooked. She's not there because she's not dead. She's been annihilated. The others were killed because their Soul Gems were broken, but Sayaka became a Witch and was defeated. The Magical Girls don't just lose their souls; their souls are destroyed.
The last scene in the series is Fridge Horror. It shows a desert and Homura on her own. This implies that in Madokami's new timeline, the magical girls still lose against the demons and the Earth is left as their personal playground to do with as they please.
Madoka in the middle of her transformation into Kriemhild Gretchen in the PSP version is certainly creepy, if not terrifying. From the way it looks like the grief seed is splitting Madoka's body in half, and the silhouette of what used to be Madoka... -shudder-
There's an event that happens if Charlotte eats Sayaka's Soul Gem and Madoka and Homura, being inexperienced, can't find Charlotte's barrier. We learned in Episode 6 that Soul Gems are Soul Jars, and the body is useless without it. Add that to the fact that Magical Girls die when they lose contact with their Soul Gems for 2 days, and that's pretty creepy on it's own. They had to make it even creepier by adding that when a Magical Girl loses contact with her soul gem, she starts to decompose.Luckily, Kyouko kills Charlotte before Sayaka dies. Happy ending, right? Wrong. Sayaka's body had already started decomposing before her Soul Gem came back. So she wakes up, unaware of what she looks like, and just happens to meet Kyousuke. Who FREAKS. OUT.You can guess what happens next.
Just like how Evangelion ruined classical music and orange juice for some people forever, you may now get a chill whenever you hear the world "contract" or see any other media about characters being offered miraculous wishes.
The Witches and their Familiars, of course. It would be easy to just say "all of them", but since this is the NF page, we might as well describe in detail how they're scary, just like we described how the characters are Woobies in The Woobie page. The fact that many of them are animated in Uncanny Valley-riffic cut-and-paste animation courtesy of Gekidan Inu Curry (the graphic studio that animated Sayonara, Zetsubou-Sensei's trippiersequences have helped earn this anime a seat in Japan's Nightmare Fuel Hall of Fame.
The Anthonies are pictured above and described under the entry for Episode 1. Their mistress Gertrud looks like a butterfly with a cut-and-paste rosebush for a head (which almost looks more like a glob of snot shaped like Cthulhu). Also, after they've sucked the life out of their human victims, they use their bodies to fertilize Gertrud's precious rose garden; (a theme we shall be revisiting).
Albertine (seen only in the video game) resembles a Creepy Doll. Her familiar Anja is a living childish scribble (also animated in a flighty Uncanny Valley style, with a Creepy Laugh provided by none other than Madoka's seiyuu Aoi Yuuki), who turns her human victims into balls that bounce for each lie they've ever told.
Patricia (the "Class Representative Witch") not only has multiple limbs but also no head, and shoots spiderwebs from between her legs.
If you've read this far, you probably know that the Witches are corrupted magical girls, and you might've expected to have become numb to that concept by now. Rereading (and describing) their Eldritch Abomination appearances, vicious abilities, and To Serve Man status brings the horror back in full force.
It's bad enough that MG's become undead in this 'verse. Remember how they "recharge" using Grief Seeds? They're basically classic cannibal zombies as well! And since Witches have destroyed the Earth at least once, PMMM is basically a glorified Zombie Apocalypse, on a scale George Romero never would've dreamed of.
It's even creepier when you pay closer attention to the center panel. There are blood stains trailing behind her sword. Yeah...A remainder to those who think of Magical Girls as cute and pretty. Being warriors, their magic is aimed at KILLING, not just flash and entertainment... and the target doesn't necessarily have to be other magical beings...
It's even more upsetting once you know that the guys' dialog happened in real life. Urobuchi heard two guys talking like that while he was on the train (albeit he said that the anime dialog was a short version of what they talked about because they talked a lot). what if magical girls actually exist and Urobuchi told a story where a magical girl killed two dudes?
Of course, the real scariest part of this is that there are indeed people out there who seriously hold such opinions and feel confident enough in themselves (or at least after getting drunk) to spout them in public. You may have heard people voicing similar opinions today...
While Madoka's witch form, Kriemhild Gretchen never shows fully or properly up in the anime, what few things we see of her are◊ freakingterrifying◊.
The concept of Kyubey is the stuff nightmares are made of. Appearing in a form that is psychologically appealing to young girls for the "cutesy" element and playing on the natural inferiorities the girls possess, to manipulate them into making a contract that ultimately results in their death for the good of the universe. There's a reason he doesn't chose current world victims that are old enough to understand the concept of trust...
Adult Fear: Kyubey is guilty of the crime of HUMAN TRAFFICKING, and his exploitative recruitment methods are comparable to Child Porn. A Manipulative Bastard who uses the emotion and desperation of little girls in order to scam them into a Deal with the Devil and force them in a dangerous job as enslaved prostitutes, er, "Magical Girls". Plus, being Invisible to Normals means that those who contracts cant talk about him to anyone lest people think they're crazy.
In addition, with his Resurrective Immortality and unlimited supply of bodies Kyubey is incapable of being killed ever. No matter how many times you finish him off, HE. WILL. JUST. KEEP. COMING. BACK. Homura's been shooting him who knows how many times and it hasn't stuck. The only way to kill him off permanently would be to wish him out of existence. However, if what he says about the Incubators' mission is true, then that leaves us with the heat death of the universe to worry about.
What makes him even worse is that his utilitarian philosophy is no different from that of Real Life Politics. In other words, we are more alike to him than previously though. That alone makes for serious Fridge Horror.