I originally put it in YMMV because it was mentioned that it fit better in that section
than in her character folder.
That said, I concur with 742mph. It's an interpretation that has a fair amount of fans agreeing with it even if its not a fandom wide consensus.
They can leave it, but they should change it so that it's not an "ambiguously bi" entry in disguise.
Edited by Luisdalas
I saw the edit you made about half an hour ago, Luisdalas, and I don't think it was warranted. If we're not allowed to discuss the issue of interpreting Ruby's sexual orientation in general on the non-YMMV trope pages, and we're not allowed to discuss it on the YMMV page, where are we allowed to discuss it?
Just make it different than an ambiguously bi/gay entry.
Edited by Luisdalas
It already was different from an Ambiguously Bi entry before you edited it, because it explicitly contextualized the issue in terms of fan interpretation, befitting a YMMV entry.
Since no one else has posted in this thread in a bit, I've gone ahead and made an edit that will hopefully be acceptable to everyone.
Little Gamer
I saw some people on Twitter compare Oshi no Ko to Penguindrum and Kana from the former to Ringo from the latter, and I was stewing in my thoughts in thinking that Oshi no Ko is more of a Spiritual Antithesis than a Spiritual Successor. I need to gather my thoughts on why but I'm curious if anyone thinks that.
Edited by kirakirasunshine Hide / Show Replies
The similarities don't feel intentional enough to warrant mention IMO. Have Aka or Mengo ever made public comments about Penguindrum?
~Tropers/{{742mph}} ~Luisdalas ~AK47Productions for the sake of Edit War prevention, it's preferable if the dispute with this example is handled here and escalated to Ask The Tropers if there's no agreement.
TroperWall / WikiMagic Cleanup Hide / Show Replies