Needs Help: Magical Girl

Still on the collage. 1.1. is good enough.

...has anyone even contacted the artist of the current?

I don't think a collage is really necessary, there's not that much variety that a single image cannot convey. So 1.1.

Changing my vote to 1.1

I like the one showing magical girls from different parts of the globe.

Votes bump. 3 in green.

I'm late to this, but what's the balance of subtropes in that collage? We don't want to lean too far towards Magical Girl Warrior over other types, so it would be good to have some really old-school examples. Maybe some manga cover with a girl holding a wand or mascot but dressed in civilian clothes?

It looks like no one will win in the crowner. If that happens, then no pic for now ?

Edited by StalkerGamer on Mar 14th 2023 at 3:36:47 PM

Going by the IP Guidelines, if none of the options reach consensus by the time the crowner closes, the crowner would considered "failed" and the thread will be closed. Since the current doesn't have consensus, we would have to just pull it and close if none of the crowner options reach concerns us by then.

I guess we can wait an extra two days to see if the crowner improves.

Huh? The crowner currently has 2 green options.

None of the crowner options have a ratio of 2:1 yet and that's what's needed for consensus.

Edited by MacronNotes on Mar 14th 2023 at 6:23:14 AM

Votes bump, two in the green and neither in consensus range.