I admit that I changed some of them but they did t seem to be locked in by the image pickin threads so I thought it was okay
I humbly ask not to be suspended or banned over this one
Hi! :3
- Annihilation - 1
- Bei - 3
- Idyll III - 3
- Isca - 2
- Lodus Logos - 3
- Nameless - 2
- Pollux - 2
- Sevyr Blackmore - 2
- Sobunar - 2
- Solem - 2
- Summoner - 2
- Tarn - 2
- War - 3
- Weaponless Zsen - 2
- White Sword - 1
he/him
Annihilation - 1
Bei - 3
Idyll - 3
Isca - 2
Lodus Logos - 3
Nameless - 2
Pollux - 2
Sevyr - 2*
Sobunar - 2
Solem - 2*
Summoner - 2
Tarn - 3
War - 3
Zsen - 2*
White Sword - 2
With the caveat that there are very recent or just-about-to-be-released comics with the * characters, who've previously only had a few appearances, so we may get some new strong candidates from those during (or just after) this discussion.
I'll go ahead and count the closer/alternative crops as quality upgrades to simplify this discussion.
Hi! :3
![[up]](https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/smiles/arrow_up.png "[up]"){kind=icon}
Close then ?
he/him
So that takes Pollux and Summoner out of any further discussion, as their only changes were crops. Sounds like a plan. ![[tup]](https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/Thumbs_up_emoticon_3268.png "[thumb up]"){kind=small}
(Out of interest, does that mean they do, or don't, get IP tagged when this is all resolved?)
Edited by Mrph1 on Nov 12th 2022 at 7:21:51 PM
Hi
Usually (at least for me) when a thread results in a pic just getting a quality swap, I'll note the thread in the edit reason but not actually tag the page. Something like "Quality upgrade per [[link Image Pickin' thread]]".
he/him
Conscious this one has gone very quiet (and that we're at 60 threads, so could do with closing a couple soon).
In the event that we don't get a consensus, what's the default outcome on a "Changed w/o discussion" case - revert or leave as is?
I kept meaning to make a crowner for this one but it took a lot of time and thinking I didn't have the abilities for until now.
Big reversion crowner hooked. Like I said above, I treated alternative crops as quality upgrades, so Idyll and War only have one option.
Votes bump, three in green.
Votes bump, same.
Calling to revert Annihilation, White Sword, and Tarn. That's done and their respective folders (as well as the page itself) is tagged. Closing.
As mentioned here
, we've got fifteen characters on the X-Men: Arakko page with images that have been changed in some way, and no Image Pickin' notes visible - I started looking at some of the most recent examples (one was my own error), then found more. Some are just crop changes, but most are complete replacements.
Generally speaking, I think the newer images do look much better - but conscious they don't seem to have gone through the proper Image Pickin' route to agree that.
Annihilation
Replaced by ~Furygildeman November, 2020
Bei
Replaced by ~eduardoalamo22 October, 2020 - then again by ~Furygildeman February, 2022
Idyll III ('Idyll the Future Seer')
Replaced by ~Furygildeman June, 2022 - then again by ~eduardoalamo22 July, 2022
Isca
Replaced by ~eduardoalamo22 April, 2022
Lodus Logos
Replaced by ~Furygildeman June, 2022 - then again by ~eduardoalamo22 July, 2022
Nameless
Replaced by ~Furygildeman March, 2022
Pollux
Replaced by ~Furygildeman July, 2021
Sevyr Blackmore
Replaced by ~Furygildeman July, 2021
Sobunar
Replaced by ~Furygildeman August, 2022
Solem
Replaced by ~Furygildeman October, 2020
Summoner
Replaced by ~forgottenjedi October, 2020
Tarn
Replaced by ~Furygildeman June, 2022 - then again by ~mrph1 (me) Sept, 2022
Replaced by ~forgottenjedi October, 2020 - then again by ~Furygildeman November, 2020
Weaponless Zsen
Replaced by ~Eduardoalamo22 September, 2022
White Sword
Replaced by ~Eduardoalamo22 October, 2020
Edited by Mrph1 on Nov 10th 2022 at 9:03:38 AM