Follow TV Tropes
If hooking works the way I think the hooker got a message saying they blocked me and with the gunsmith gone only the hooker and cop have any abilities so by not saying anything I'm risking that the maffia knows I'm the cop this way even if I am wrong the others villagers know it as well, whether they believe me or not
Edited by dutchguy1986 on Jul 11th 2019 at 5:29:28 PM
What I meant was that the hooker doesn't find out the role of the person they hooked, right? So nobody gets too nervous after being hooked, the hooker can hook everyone and never find out who was the cop, which is the best for us all.
I don't know if the hooker finds out or not last round I didn't, but I only hooked someone who turned out to be villager so I know you don't hear it if you failed but not if you do hear it if you succeed
I see. Thanks, never played a hooker in this game. (Only in Town of Salem.)
Don't take what I'm saying as pure fact I only played hooker once and I never got to block anyone with an ability
Just to clarify, the hooker doesn't know the role of the person they block. Regardless if it's a success or not.
Edited by unfortunatezorua on Jul 11th 2019 at 7:10:08 PM
Ah ok thanks mod.
I think the hooker would be a little too OP if that were the case lmao
So, I think the next course of action is obvious. As dutch and Taco are confirmed town, and I know I'm town, then by process of elimination, Tropes and akane are obviously mafia.
So, let's see. Eenie, meanie, miney.... Vote: akanesarumara
Afterwards votes akanesarumara
I mean I can't fault a vote based on what one of us coming out as cop said, but I'm still holding my vote for a bit if y'all don't mind.
In my case the problem is that Afterwards, akanesarumara and Tropes Forever all can be maffia and I don't know enough to tell
Oooh goodness this whole thing is sketchy.
Alright, what do we know: After came out the gate suspecting Tropes, and now heís suspecting Akane.
Now, that doesnít necessarily mean Afterís the Inno. Afterís a crafty dude, Iím sure heíd be willing to bump off his comrade, but the fact of the matter is, Akaneís taking the nomination, and taking it lightly. And more often than not, thatís sign of a maf who knows theyíve still got a shot at a posthumous win.
Now, Iím trying to look at things like this; If Afterís Mafia, would either of his nominations leave Mafia without blood? I think one would.
After got to a start by nominating Tropes, but he should know by now that no one has killed the first person voted for for no reason. So, he might have turn-voted to save Tropes.
Or maybe After made two random votes, who knows.
Either way, Akaneís shady, Afterís shady, and Iím also suspicious of Tropes.
Thereís something rotten in the state of Denmark. As much as I hate to do this, I think that the person who makes most sense, to me, is one of the quietest people here.
I vote Tropes
I might be making the dumbest move, but I gotta make a move.
Edited by TacoBadger on Jul 12th 2019 at 3:28:31 AM
TacoBadger votes TropesForever
As for me taking it and taking it calmly, I don't have proof to support my claim that I am a townie, same as nobody but the mod having any actual, 100% proof about the cop's identity, so I didn't want to dig myself in deeper, but that's neither here nor there.
What I do agree with Taco on, is that Tropes is awfully quiet, though.
I vote Tropes.
Edited by akanesarumara on Jul 12th 2019 at 12:14:04 PM
Careful about editing votes in, there.
That said, to be fair to Tropes (assuming he is town of course, which he isn't), he could just be busy, or asleep, or maybe he forgot about this game. But, since I know I'm town, he's obviously mafia.
akanesarumara votes TropesForever
I'm pretty much dead anyway, but I'm gonna vote akane as per After.
I don't know if you'll be convinced if I say I was quiet because I haven't played this game in a while and got confused.
Edited by TropesForever on Jul 12th 2019 at 8:35:09 PM
As for editing in votes, I apologize, didn't want to doublepost ^^"
TropesForever votes akanesarumara
Looks like it's up to Dutch to hammer now.
I'm not sure but Taco has been great at this game so far, so I'll follow his lead and vote Tropes
TropesForever, the villager, was hung from a tree.
Victory goes to the Mafia!
Ah well, looks like the wrong choice was made. Congrats to Afterwards and Akaneóall of the mafia seem to be doing pretty well so far. Maybe it's the reads, or maybe it's the roles? But anyway, that's it for this game.
Classic Mafia Signups
Edited by unfortunatezorua on Jul 13th 2019 at 8:20:10 PM
I'll join again and try and actually remember how to play this time.
I have to say, you guys almost had me convinced I was Mafia.
Edited by TropesForever on Jul 12th 2019 at 8:59:15 PM
DAMN my break ended and i missed the entire climax!!!!
i was gonna make one last post too to goad the cop, going on about how "it's all up to you" and "we put our trust in your capable hands". but i missed the chance!!!
Ah well, great game yall! This was actually my first time ever on the mafia side lol, it was fun. Towards the end I kept thinking up scenarios in my head of every possibility, making plans for every contingency. Much more fun than in town of salem where you only get like half a minute to make any decisions lol
I'm defs in for next
That said, this game seems pretty short? If we had voted someone off on day one, the game could only last till the following night - it does seem the mafia have an unfair advantage there. Maybe it'd be better to play with one more townie, or start during the day phase?
Or maybe cop should out their reports and mafia should start claiming as cop to shake things up a little
Community Showcase More
How well does it match the trope?