The Place for Purging Porn and Pedo-Pandering (AKA P5 flag evaluations)

Clopfic works...mostly because the use of "clop" in any sort of sexual situation sounds like it'd be kind of painful. Like most clopfics are to the non-bronies.

edited 23rd Jul '12 9:34:14 AM by Raidouthe21st

I'l take clop over clap any day.

I second that emotion.

Anyway, can someone tell me what's the deal with Collar6? Goggling it tells me that it's a fetish comic; perhaps someone more familiar with it can clue me in on this?

edited 23rd Jul '12 10:01:16 AM by Komodin

Best Typo.

It's been talked about a few times before. Yeah, it's a fetish webcomic. Involving bondage. Compared to that Nana To Kaoru manga that was reviewed, it's firmly on the side of unrealistic. Paedophillic, nope. Pornographic? Well...it's fairly open about most of the characters being there for the eye-candy. There's one instance of an actual depiction of sex, but that's apparently so late into the actual comic it's not representative of the entire comic as a whole. I'm told that it's primarily about the romantic relationship between the main two characters, and it...does seem like that, in a way.From what little I remember of it, it focuses more on the eye candy and the idea of S&M being titillating then it does on their plot.

Think someone should take a closer look. Mostly because I just found the colors eye-searing and I can't stand to look at it any further.

Is the reader supposed to be fapping to this S&M?

so the answer is probably no

edited 23rd Jul '12 10:27:50 AM by animeg3282

Here's some links to previous posts on it.

https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/posts.php?discussion=13345387140A33840100&page=55#1353
https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/posts.php?discussion=13349331300A11026600&page=122#3034
https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/posts.php?discussion=13349331300A11026600&page=115#2862
https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/posts.php?discussion=13349331300A11026600&page=219#5461

A few pages back, you inquired about whether or not it would be appropriate to make a page for Sakuran, yes? While I can't speak for the rest of us, I don't think preemptive censorship of uncreated pages is within our defined powers. If the others agree, I would say go ahead and make it. If it is problematic, let it go through the same process as other works.

//We now return to your regularly scheduled discussion of Collar6.

I agree with tdgoodrich1 on that particular issue.

Yeah. I listed your defense of it or whatever in case it does get flagged but right now I don't see any reason you can't go ahead.

"Is the reader supposed to be fapping to this S&M? "

Don't think so.
Especially as it turned from focusing on BDSM relationship to "BDSM gives you superpowers like actually setting the whip on fire with your mind and making shields to block that too". The villain turned from just a bitch that inserted herself into the Love Dodecahedron to actually having a goal, find and free her super-powerful husband, and utilising mind control to get the information she needed to do so. Now she's done it and the heroes are invading their base to pack them back down (there is a sex scene between her and that guy, but it's just a short bit of the arc).

They still wear latex Spy Catsuits, fight with spanking crops and talk about dominant/submissive energy, but focus is the actual plot with a side order of eye candy rather than just daily life in a BDSM relationship.

edited 23rd Jul '12 12:45:21 PM by Adannor

Wow, thats a lot of crazy stuff going on.

edited 23rd Jul '12 1:00:01 PM by shadis

Crazy? Perhaps.

Porn? It doesn't seem so. I'll give it an angelhead; I'm not one to doom works just because it deals with fetishes I don't care for.

Edit: Omamori Himari... hm. I'll be honest here: that page image, coupled with the summary, has me a little worried. How bad is it?

edited 23rd Jul '12 1:08:44 PM by Komodin

Gave Collar6 third angelhead, disposition to restore.

Omamori Himari: It's...complicated. I viewed it during my marathon round before I left for Haiti, but am a little at a loss. For the most part it's bog-standard ecchi but there is one scene in the manga that can't be justified. At all. IIRC, the equivalent scene in the anime still raises an eyebrow. I'll see if I can dig up what I thought.

EDIT: OK, found it. Here ya go

edited 23rd Jul '12 1:24:59 PM by tdgoodrich1

So there's also two new things on the list. The Sex Star and Zestar Apple Flambe.

Well The sex star is from Literotica thats almost as bad asstr.

As for the other its a mlp fic.

Oh, great. Another clopfic...

Geez, another? I only have so much gin to keep me sane...

I can take a look at it since it's only a few chapters long. It looks like it's going to end up cut for pedo pandering though.

I flipped through a bit of The Sex Star and it looks really porn-y from what I saw.

I haven't looked through Zestar Apple Flambe yet, but right off the bat, it seems to involve the sex and pregnancy of Apple Bloom, who appears to be one of the young kid characters.

Please do. We can always use another take on these.

OK, Thanks. About what I figured given that it was on Literotica.

edited 23rd Jul '12 6:34:12 PM by tdgoodrich1

From looking through the first two chapters, it seems Applebloom and Spike are both teenagers. Chapter 1 has no sex scenes, chapter 2 has an implied sex scene. So far, it's seeming like Porn with Plot.

By "teen" I assume older then 14 or so?

Just to nitpic, teenage horses are adults.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horse#Lifespan_and_life_stages

Either way, some how I doubt pedophiles are interested in horses. That would be the zooaphiles.

Of course, if it is porn, it should be cut for being porn.

Okay, finished reading it. In my opinion, it can probably be kept. The only sex scene is implied, and all other chapters are pretty plot heavy. In addition, it's also rated Teen.

edited 23rd Jul '12 7:06:31 PM by strawberryflavored