Complaining: Series.Dude What Would Happen

Much like the CN Real article, the entire Dude What Would Happen page was nothing but Complaining and the YMMV page was just as worse. I tried to clean it up, but I don't think it really helped in any way. I propose that we do a serious cleanup or we simply nuke it. Your thoughts?

edited 5th Mar '12 5:54:36 PM by HotelCalifornia

I have tried removing most of the bile. I don't know if such negativity is allowed on YMMV pages, so I didn't axe all of it there, but I'm pretty sure Creator's Pet, The Scrappy, and X-Pac Heat had nothing to do with anything.

I also moved the show to the correct namespace. Is more cleaning necessary, or can this thread be closed?

I put back X-Pac Heat. Seems appropriate to me. In fact, we wouldn't be having this thread if it weren't for the X-Pac Heat these guys get.

And The Fandom Rejoiced is probably Not An Example, but that trope doesn't really have clear definition anyway, so, whatever.

The rest of the page looks good.

edited 6th Mar '12 2:59:34 PM by abk0100

Did Not Do The Research there looks like it's actually Fridge Logic in disguise. Recycled In Space doesn't seem like a correct usage.

It doesn't seem to me like it's the actors the viewers hate, but the characters. If they hate the actors it's probably because of the characters, which is the opposite of X-Pac Heat. I have not seen the show or know much about the hatedom, however.

Maybe I should add The Scrappy and/or Creator's Pet back.

Ninja'd.

Moved Did Not Do The Research to the Fridge page. Removed Recycled In Space, because there was no "gimmick" in the show that would qualify it for that trope.

edited 6th Mar '12 3:11:01 PM by FinalStarman