Bad Image: Screw The Rules, I'm Beautiful!: Ptitle95epjcl 2

First: The image is backwards. It's an english wiki, put your stuff in the english direction

Two: The image is all text. It works as well as a quote:

No matter what I may do, I will always be forgiven. Why you ask? It is because I am beautiful!

Look ! We've lost nothing, and in fact, this is EASIER TO READ!

Seems ok to me....Didn't we already have this thread?

Third, that is really small text.

Pulled.

We did already have this thread, but I have to agree with Ghilz and INUH. The image itself is completely superfluous. And might actually detract a little, as the woman doesn't appear to be especially attractive.

The image is fine, but a properly-sized cut would be better.

good point... I was more talking about the pulling because of right to left was a bad reason alone which the other thread went over.

I am drawing a blank on a replacement image though.

Yeah, really, this had no reason to be pulled. Can we find another image? Maybe. But as it stands it's a good enough image.

Un-pulled until we come up with a better one.

edited 8th Feb '11 11:59:00 AM by ThePope

What about Dahlia Hawthorne◊ from the Ace Attorney series?

She's a great example, but that image doesn't show the trope.

Doesn't show she gets her way because of her looks.

The text bubbles of the former image say: "No matter what I do, I will always be forgiven. Why, you ask? It is because I am beautiful!" The graphics communicate virtually no information, except possibly that a female is speaking, which seems unimportant.

Depending on many variables, it may be okay if the text does a lot of work, but all of it? Bad image.

edited 8th Feb '11 5:18:39 PM by rodneyAnonymous

There is a scene of she literaly kicking a puppy in the anime, only for everyone to promptly cheer her on after she fakes a moe apology.

Two screenshots couldwork, maybe?

I'm thinking just put that line of hers in as a page quote and leave it at that. I did a search but this◊ is about all I could come up with, and that's not much better than the current one.

^ That one, cropped and stacked.

That doesn't really fit the "Screw the Rules" part of the trope very well.

Yeah, it needs that first panel for the setup.

Bump...should we go with a new version of the last webcomic example or just leave this with a quote or two and no pic?

Looks good, but I'd resize it down to a small enough point that the smaller text in the last panel is still legible...as is, it'll be huge on the page.

edited 31st May '11 12:25:53 PM by Willbyr

How's this?

Bump...any other thoughts?

I think the last panel alone works for the trope.

Mmmmm...no, the last panel alone feels like a trope other than this one.

One last bump.