- Americans Hate Tingle: A lot of the English speaking fandom seems to dislike Azusa. On the flip side, there are pages of fanart of him on pixiv.
- Fanon Discontinuity: There's no Starry Sky anime!
- Ho Yay: You'd have to be blind not to see it.
- "You saying my name sends shivers down my spine..."
- Tears of the Polestar Drama CD has heavy subtext as well, since the guys interact a lot with each other, and usually only with each other.
- Just Here for Godzilla: Since the quality of the writing varies from route to route, most people only play the games for hearing the seiyuu's voices.
- Les Yay: Koharu, Kotaru (Libra)'s sister, feeds Tsukiko in one of the drama CDs for Autumn. Yes, seriously.
- Homare's older twin sister, Amane, wanted to give her a sponge bath when she got sick while staying at their home... among other things.
- The Scrappy: For whatever reason, a lot of people don't like Yoh...
- The "In Spring" game is probably the least popular of them all.
YMMV / Starry☆Sky