YMMV / I Came By

• Nightmare Fuel:
  • Hector Blake. To most of the world, a stately, well-spoken and well-meaning gentleman. His true self is an utterly malevolent sociopath committing utterly sadistic acts to avenge a childhood grudge. This man is They Look Like Everyone Else personified.
  • Tobey glimpsing the inside of the locked cellar. A Scare Chord plays and Tobey leaps backwards in horror, but the viewer isn't shown what's inside.
  • The moment Blake closes the cellar door and pulls a Nightmare Face to tell the female police officer that she isn't smart enough to catch him.