Frustrated everyone is finding out their magical identity before him, Oliver follows Susie for the day in hopes she'll just tell him.
- Bloodsucking Bats: Not shockingly, Max (a bat who works part time at a vampire video store) turns out to be a vampire.
- Comically Missing the Point: Despite Susie doing everything short of wearing a neon sign saying "YOU'RE PART MONSTER", Oliver completely misses what she's trying to hint at him.
- Figure It Out Yourself: What Susie intends Oliver to do when she has him follow her on various monster related errands. She doesn't count on Oliver being dense as a neutron star however.
