Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / TsubasaReservoirChronicle

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
renamed to Clone Angst


** It's also simply heartbreaking to see the situation Sakura goes through, especially if the reader were to have grown up watching ''Manga/CardcaptorSakura'': she spends half the story disappointed in herself that she's nothing but a DamselInDistress that burdens Syaoran and the others, [[spoiler:sees her love interest critically injure Fai and essentially be replaced with someone who claims to be the real one]], and by the time she actually becomes an ActionGirl, she's also clearly a ''very'' BrokenBird, not the cheerful and adorable Sakura that readers were most familiar with. [[spoiler:And that's not even edging into the CloningBlues thing...]]

to:

** It's also simply heartbreaking to see the situation Sakura goes through, especially if the reader were to have grown up watching ''Manga/CardcaptorSakura'': she spends half the story disappointed in herself that she's nothing but a DamselInDistress that burdens Syaoran and the others, [[spoiler:sees her love interest critically injure Fai and essentially be replaced with someone who claims to be the real one]], and by the time she actually becomes an ActionGirl, she's also clearly a ''very'' BrokenBird, not the cheerful and adorable Sakura that readers were most familiar with. [[spoiler:And that's not even edging into the CloningBlues clone thing...]]

Added: 830

Changed: 17

Removed: 541

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removing some items that are no longer YMMV things.


* IKnewIt:
** Some of the fans actually guessed the [[spoiler:MyOwnGrampa]] thing more than two months before chapter 223 was published.
** Some figured out the names of the real Syaoran and Sakura a long time ago, although most if not all of the people who Knew It only knew one or the other.
** At least one person guessed that [[spoiler:[[DeadAllAlong Yuuko was dead]]]] long before it was actually revealed.



* QuestionableCasting: The Spanish dub of the movie, which came to Spain before the anime itself and was made by another company, received a overwhelmingly negative reception. Aside from the awful translation, which was bad enough to have got the ''very title'' wrong (see Narm above), most complaints focused in the even worse casting choices, pointing out that it looked as if the voice actors had been chosen at random.



* SpiritualAdaptation: A small group of characters, one of them a sword-wielding 14 years old boy and other two a wizard from a kingdom and a royal fighter from another, travelling through the multiverse in a magic quest to find heart-related items connected to a childhood female friend of the boy, and visiting worlds with AlternateUniverse versions of other characters made by the creators? With all of this, the series could perfectly be considered CLAMP's answer to the ''Franchise/KingdomHearts'' videogame franchise. Given that the first game was released a year before ''Tsubasa'', the inspirations probably are right there, not to mention that the protagonists of both series, Sora and Syaoran, share the same japanese voice actor, Creator/MiyuIrino.

to:

* SpiritualAdaptation: SpiritualSuccessor: A small group of characters, one of them a sword-wielding 14 years old boy and other two a wizard from a kingdom and a royal fighter from another, travelling through the multiverse in a magic quest to find heart-related items connected to a childhood female friend of the boy, and visiting worlds with AlternateUniverse versions of other characters made by the creators? With all of this, the series could perfectly be considered CLAMP's answer to the ''Franchise/KingdomHearts'' videogame franchise. Given that the first game was released a year before ''Tsubasa'', the inspirations probably are right there, not to mention that the protagonists of both series, Sora and Syaoran, share the same japanese voice actor, Creator/MiyuIrino.



* TrueArtIsIncomprehensible: One ''hell'' of a MindScrew.



* WhatDoYouMeanItWasntMadeOnDrugs: The second half of the series.



* WTHCastingAgency: The Spanish dub of the movie, which came to Spain before the anime itself and was made by another company, received a overwhelmingly negative reception. Aside from the awful translation, which was bad enough to have got the ''very title'' wrong (see Narm above), most complaints focused in the even worse casting choices, pointing out that it looked as if the voice actors had been chosen at random.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Tokyo Revelations'' and ''Tsubasa Shunraiki'', on the other hand, are [[AvertedTrope far less frowned upon]] because the art, pacing and animation are worlds better than the anime (and have the same people on the soundtrack!). Not to mention that it actually follows the manga up to 90% of the time and the other 10% can be forgiven.

to:

* ** ''Tokyo Revelations'' and ''Tsubasa Shunraiki'', on the other hand, are [[AvertedTrope far less frowned upon]] because the art, pacing and animation are worlds better than the anime (and have the same people on the soundtrack!). Not to mention that it actually follows the manga up to 90% of the time and the other 10% can be forgiven.

Changed: 731

Removed: 321

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FanonDiscontinuity:
** How most fans treat the anime adaptation due to its numerous problems (OffModel art, loads of {{filler}}, awful pacing, etc.) Even Creator/{{CLAMP}} themselves despise it for the liberties taken, one of them actually broke the series's plot and had to be retconned later.
** ''Tokyo Revelations'' and ''Tsubasa Shunraiki'', on the other hand, are far less frowned upon because the art, pacing and animation are worlds better than the anime (and have the same people on the soundtrack!). Not to mention that it actually follows the manga up to 90% of the time and the other 10% can be forgiven.

to:

* FanonDiscontinuity:
**
FanonDiscontinuity: How most fans treat the anime adaptation due to its numerous problems (OffModel art, loads of {{filler}}, awful pacing, etc.) Even Creator/{{CLAMP}} themselves despise it for the liberties taken, one of them actually broke the series's plot and had to be retconned later.
** * ''Tokyo Revelations'' and ''Tsubasa Shunraiki'', on the other hand, are [[AvertedTrope far less frowned upon upon]] because the art, pacing and animation are worlds better than the anime (and have the same people on the soundtrack!). Not to mention that it actually follows the manga up to 90% of the time and the other 10% can be forgiven.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SpiritualAdaptation: A small group of characters, one of them a sword-wielding 14 years old boy and other two a wizard from a kingdom and a royal fighter from another, travelling through the multiverse in a magic quest to find heart-related items connected to a childhood female friend of the boy, and visiting worlds with AlternateUniverse versions of other characters made by the creators? With all of this, the series could perfectly be considered CLAMP's answer to the ''Franchise/KingdomHearts'' videogame franchise. Given that the first game was released a year before ''Tsubasa'', the inspirations probably are right there.

to:

* SpiritualAdaptation: A small group of characters, one of them a sword-wielding 14 years old boy and other two a wizard from a kingdom and a royal fighter from another, travelling through the multiverse in a magic quest to find heart-related items connected to a childhood female friend of the boy, and visiting worlds with AlternateUniverse versions of other characters made by the creators? With all of this, the series could perfectly be considered CLAMP's answer to the ''Franchise/KingdomHearts'' videogame franchise. Given that the first game was released a year before ''Tsubasa'', the inspirations probably are right there.there, not to mention that the protagonists of both series, Sora and Syaoran, share the same japanese voice actor, Creator/MiyuIrino.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''Tsubasa World Chronicle'' seemed to gather some contention within the fanbase. Some were happy that CLAMP is bringing back the series after its confusing ending and that they will fix the flaws that the last previous chapters had been suffering. Others are dissatisfied that CLAMP put their other two ongoing works ( ''Drug and Drop'' and ''Gate 7'') on a hiatus just to work on this and that they should have continue them along with the other series, like ''Manga/{{X1999}}'', which had been put on a hiatus for a decade. For now, the sequel and ''xxxHolic: Rei'' are on CLAMP's work load and fans of their other works are certainly not pleased.

to:

** ''Tsubasa World Chronicle'' seemed to gather some contention within the fanbase. Some were happy that CLAMP is bringing back the series after its confusing ending and that they will fix the flaws that the last previous chapters had been suffering. Others are dissatisfied that CLAMP put their other two ongoing works ( ''Drug and Drop'' and ''Gate 7'') on a hiatus just to work on this and that they should have continue them along with the other series, like ''Manga/{{X1999}}'', which had been put on a hiatus for a decade. For now, the sequel and ''xxxHolic: Rei'' are on CLAMP's work load and fans of their other works are certainly not pleased.
Tabs MOD

Added: 811

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FanNickname: Quite a few.
** The names Fai gave everyone in Outo became quite popular among the fans: "Big Doggy" for Kurogane, "Little Doggy" for Syaoran, "Big Kitty" for Fai, and "Little Kitty" for Sakura.
** Fai-mommy and Kuro-daddy are also canon nicknames that have taken on a second life in fandom.
** Ass-Chin for Fei Wong.
** "Cloney" for [[spoiler:Syaoran's heartless clone, sometimes called C Syaoran in contrast to R Syaoran]].
** Junior [[spoiler:or Syaoran-jr when Real Syaoran turned out not to be a real at all, but Sakura and Syaoran Li's son taking his father's name.]]
** For ''Franchise/TombRaider'' fans, Sakura, due to having a similar outfit in the Tokyo arc as Lara Croft, is "Sakura Croft".
** Fans refer to Tokyo in the Tokyo arc as "Acid Tokyo".
** [[spoiler:Tsubasa-kun and Tsubasa-chan]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Foe Yay has been cut


* FoeYay:
** Looks like Fuma didn't have enough of this with Kamui in ''X/1999'' and this time he wants a more gentle approach.
** Then there is Ashura-o and Yasha-o even if [[spoiler:the latter was dead all along.]]

Added: 209

Removed: 229

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FunnyAneurysmMoment: Ohkawa commented in the Clamp no Kiseki guides that the first half was carefully written so that the young readers would understand it as she believes her stories tend to be complicated. Come second half...


Added DiffLines:

** Ohkawa commented in the Clamp no Kiseki guides that the first half was carefully written so that the young readers would understand it as she believes her stories tend to be complicated. Come second half...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Misuse. Does not mention audience avoiding work.


* EndingAversion: Both the manga and anime, for different reasons. The manga, mostly because of the [[MindScrew final arc.]] Then again the final volume is praised for ShowDontTell as it actually explores the MindScrew and makes it nonexistent in the end. The anime, because it interrupts mid-series and technically has no ending.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FanWorkOnlyFans: The series is a crossover fanfic magnet because its initial premise of its cast travelling to alternate universes to retrieve Sakura's scattered memory feathers makes it very easy to insert them into universes of other series without contrived reasons. Because of this, some fans only get into ''Tsubasa'' primarily because of that potential alone and only need to read the first few chapters of the manga or watch the first few episodes of the anime to get the basic gist of this before going wild with their ideas. Many such fanfics will typically take place before the [[spoiler:[[WhamEpisode Acid Tokyo Arc]]]] because of the simpler plot. Fanfics after the arc are not unheard of, but are generally rarer and harder to write because of the shift in [[MindScrew complexity]] and [[DarkerAndEdgier darker tone]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Also [[spoiler:Fuuma and Kamui]] in Acid Tokyo and, obviously, [[spoiler:Subaru and Seishirou]], despite the fact we never actually see them together in story, though [[http://mangafox.me/manga/tsubasa_reservoir_chronicle/c190/1.html this splash page]] shows the ill-fated pair together.

to:

** Also [[spoiler:Fuuma and Kamui]] in Acid Tokyo and, obviously, [[spoiler:Subaru and Seishirou]], despite the fact we never actually see them together in story, though [[http://mangafox.me/manga/tsubasa_reservoir_chronicle/c190/1.html this a splash page]] page shows the ill-fated pair together.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
We don't trope our own words.


** In Tokyo [[IncrediblyLamePun Syaoran is an adventurer who takes an arrow to the knee]]. [[VideoGame/TheElderScrollsVSkyrim Sounds familiar]]?

to:

** In Tokyo [[IncrediblyLamePun Tokyo, Syaoran is an adventurer who takes an arrow to the knee]].knee. [[VideoGame/TheElderScrollsVSkyrim Sounds familiar]]?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Misuse of trope. This entry doesn't fit the main description of Gateway Series which is about the work introducing a Genre to newcomers not a franchise or a creator's work,


* GatewaySeries: ''Tsubasa'' is the medium which many people cite as their gate to the complex multiverse of CLAMP, counting specially on the people who watched it thinking it was somehow related to ''Manga/CardcaptorSakura'' without knowing its crossover nature.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The anime version of Tsubasa. Some fans, particularly non-manga readers enjoy its AdaptationExpansion such as Kurogane's backstory as well as its SugarWiki/AwesomeMusic, others dislike it for its poor pacing, endless fillers, and lack of faithfulness to the story tones. [[DisownedAdaptation CLAMP agrees with the latter]].

to:

** The anime version of Tsubasa. Some fans, particularly non-manga readers enjoy its AdaptationExpansion such as Kurogane's backstory as well as its SugarWiki/AwesomeMusic, others dislike it for its poor pacing, endless fillers, and lack of faithfulness to the story tones. [[DisownedAdaptation [[CreatorBacklash CLAMP agrees with the latter]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The anime version of Tsubasa. Some fans, particularly non-manga readers enjoy its AdaptationExpansion such as Kurogane's backstory as well as its SugarWiki/AwesomeMusic, others dislike it for its poor pacing, endless fillers, and lack of faithfulness to the story tones. CLAMP agrees with the latter.

to:

** The anime version of Tsubasa. Some fans, particularly non-manga readers enjoy its AdaptationExpansion such as Kurogane's backstory as well as its SugarWiki/AwesomeMusic, others dislike it for its poor pacing, endless fillers, and lack of faithfulness to the story tones. [[DisownedAdaptation CLAMP agrees with the latter.latter]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ContinuityLockout: ''Tsubasa Shunraiki'' OVA skips the Infinity and Celes arcs and goes straight into the Nihon arc instead. This means anime-only viewers would never know about Fai's past. It's even stranger that the opening minutes of ''Shunraiki'' showed Celes [[spoiler:on the brink of destruction]].

Top