History YMMV / TheLegendOfTheTitanic

* NightmareFuel:
** The highly inappropriate comment Smile makes about being taken to "Doggy Hell". Imagine how many children were struck with the thought of their beloved pets being sent to Hell.
** [[spoiler:The scene at the end, when the escaped rats are all seen in an insane asylum. Especially the nurse giggling madly while the doctor talks about how there's no hope of them recovering and makes a horrifying face]]. [[ProtagonistCenteredMorality The protagonists all laugh when they see this.]]

* OneSceneWonder: Broomali only has one effective scene where he explains his situation and blows up an enemy ship. However, his character concept is so goddamn insane, nonsensical and out of nowhere that it is a massive endeavor to just forget he exists.

* BigLippedAlligatorMoment: Broomali's scene. A girl doll appears, reveals itself to be a Scot who's been cursed to look that way, though the curse in question is really just having a wit and makeup put on him. He then asks for the chance to remove his curse, removed his wig, kills an enemy, is made general, and never appears again.

* AudienceAlienatingPremise: One of the most {{egregious}} and utterly ''unforgivable'' examples in all of media. The very idea of a film where the ''Titanic'' disaster is not only treated as a "legend", but a '''misunderstanding where no one died''' would turn off pretty much anyone, especially those who were personally affected by it in some way.

* AudienceAlienatingPremise: One of the most egregious and unforgivable examples in all of media. The very idea of a film where the ''Titanic'' disaster is not only treated as a "legend", but a '''misunderstanding where no one died''' would turn off pretty much anyone, especially those who were personally affected by it in some way.

* UncannyValley: The face of the octopus; there's just ''something'' offputting about a very doglike cartoon face plastered on a character designed like this.

* SugarWiki/AwesomeMusic: The closing credits song, 'Ocean Dreams' (or 'Ocean of Dreams') sung by Cynthia Z.

** The whole romance between Elizabeth and Don Juan, given that it’s founded on pretty much nothing other than Don Juan [[PervertedSniffing sniffing]] the former’s glove. They don’t exchange a single line before deciding that they are meant for each other. It’s like the filmmakers were trying to one-up the LoveAtFirstSight trope from vintage Disney films.
** Then there’s Don Juan’s apparent shyness about approaching Elizabeth personally, despite the fact that he’s a ''prince'', making it look like he has very lousy confidence.

** When the Carpathia shows up to rescue everyone, the film tries to have a serious moment where Connors sheds a tear and reminds Ronnie of the "heroes" who gave their lives to make sure everyone else survived. But it rings hollow given that the only ones who died in the movie were Camembert the mouse and Tentacles the octopus. Everyone else, ''including the captain'', survived. [[spoiler: And then it turns out that Camembert and Tentacles survived too.]]
** Additionally it's hard to take Camembert's death seriously given it happens due to having electric wires tied to his mustache.
* NightmareFuel: The absolutely pointless scene where Geoffreys imagines what his boss will do to him if he doesn't follow orders, ''[[EatenAlive feed him to Razorteeth.]]'' While it may not be gory, the ImagineSpot is gratuitous and considering Geoffreys doesn't undergo any redemption here, the scene only seems to serve the purpose of scarring whatever poor kids have parents stupid enough to let them watch this.

** Maltravers’s manservant Geoffreys is a total MinionWithAnFInEvil, who even feels immense guilt just for ''spying'' on Elizabeth and Don Juan, and it’s shown that he’s mainly serving Maltravers out of fear of retribution, as the [[BadBoss latter]] makes it abundantly clear that he’ll [[YouHaveFailedMe feed Geoffreys to the sharks should he fail him]], and yet Geoffreys is never given a chance to perform an HeelFaceTurn and suffers the same fate as his boss and Rachel at the end. Though he finally does get redemption at the end of ''Fantasy Island''.
** Taken to the extreme with Rachel and her sister’s two cats. Unlike all the other animals, they are entirely [[FurryConfusion non-anthropomorphic]], and they spend all of their screentime either in the women’s arms or being carried around in pet carriers, [[AnimalJingoism never once do they cross paths with or menace the mice or cause trouble for Smiley and the other dogs]]. And yet they somehow still deserve to get lost (and presumably die) in the polar waters with the human villains, just because of CatsAreMean?
*** Connors does have a throwaway line where he tells Ronnie that they are “snotty rich cats who kill for fun”. The thing is, [[ShowDontTell we never see them kill anything]], let alone for fun, and neither does Connors. So it just comes off like he’s [[FantasticRacism profiling them]].
** The elderly officer who tells Don Juan that he needs to keep his dog on a leash. Mind you, the man was just doing his job and spoke to Juan in a polite manner, and yet the latter just snubs him and lets his entourage gang up on the poor man and basically cow him into submission with threats of violence. And then, Smiley comes back to ''piss'' on the man’s leg, just for shits and giggles, and we’re somehow supposed to find this cathartic? ProtagonistCenteredMorality much?

** Old Top Connors’ voice. He sounds like a bad impression of [[WesternAnimation/ChipNDaleRescueRangers Professor Nimnul]]. The same applies to Geoffreys’ SimpletonVoice.

* TooDumbToLive: Tentacles is this trope incarnate. Firstly, he is easily duped by [[ObviouslyEvil Ice and his gang]] into throwing an iceberg in the path of the ''Titanic'', despite his friends’ warnings and Ice’s bad rap. Secondly, after being told the truth, he runs off to sulk in his cave instead of simply swimming up and ''moving the iceberg out of the way''. [[RuleOfThree And finally]], after saving every last passenger (including the captain) he still clings on to the ''Titanic'' as it goes under and gets crushed to death! [[UnexplainedRecovery Though he still somehow survives that]]?

* BrokenBase: Which animated ''Titanic''-movie is worse? This one or [[WesternAnimation/TitanicTheLegendGoesOn the other?]] The arguments made in "favor" of this movie is that it has the far more disrespectful retelling of the story, is way more off-the-walls, and has next to no WillingSuspensionOfDisbelief.

** The way Pingo tells our heroes that they can't go back home. Rather than using any kind of bedside manner, he performs a creepy song and dance routine before happily blurting it out. Don Juan claims the delivery was actually a good thing, but Smiles' and especially Elizabeth's reactions clearly contradict this.

** [[spoiler:The scene at the end, when the escaped rats are all seen in an insane asylum. Especially the nurse giggling madly while the doctor talks about how there's no hope of them recovering and makes a horrifying face]]. [[MoralDissonance The protagonists all laugh when they see this.]]

* FunnyAneurysmMoment: "This liquid looks pretty! Let's drink it.". The said liquid is colored green. In these days, one of the more well-known drug detectors will turn the drink green when it discovers a date rape drug.

* CriticalResearchFailure: Even more so than [[WesternAnimation/TitanicTheLegendGoesOn that other Titanic cartoon]]. While ''The Legend Goes On'' had talking Mexican mice and a rapping dog, this one has [[WhatDoYouMeanItWasntMadeOnDrugs talking mice, gangster sharks, magic flying dolphins, and a giant talking octopus with a face like a dog!]] [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking And nobody dies aboard the Titanic.]]
** When the ship hits the iceberg, everyone on board can feel it and the scene quickly dissolves into panic. And even without the involvement of the whales, an officer can be heard shouting that there's room for everyone on board the lifeboats. None of this is true to what actually happened. There weren't enough lifeboats for everyone, and even then, many were not lowered at full capacity due to passengers not believing that the situation was as serious as it was until it was too late.
** Then there’s the fact that the sharks have to hold the rudder in order to prevent the ship from simply turning away from the iceberg, never mind the fact that by the time the iceberg was spotted, the ship would have had too much momentum to simply turn on a dime. Turning an ocean liner around isn’t the same as turning a car around.

* CriticalResearchFailure: "Historically inaccurate" doesn't even ''begin'' to describe these two catastrophes. If the cartoonish premise and talking mice didn't already drive it home for you, the film claiming from the very beginning that ''nobody died aboard the Titanic'' will certainly do it.

** [[{{Kaiju}} Tentacles']] abrupt introduction during the third act of the film.

** The elderly officer who tells Don Juan that he needs to keep his dog on a leash. Mind you, the man was just doing his job and spoke to Juan in a polite manner, and yet the latter just snubs him and lets his entourage gang up on the poor man and basically cow him into submission with threats of violence. And then, Smiley comes back on piss on the man’s leg, just for shits and giggles, and we’re somehow supposed to find this cathartic? ProtagonistCenteredMorality much?

* RootingForTheEmpire: Just about everyone who's seen this movie sympathizes with the rats for [[UnintentionallySympathetic many]] [[LesserOfTwoEvils reasons]], namely because they want to get out of Atlantis and kill Pingo. It should be noted that they ''do'' want to take over the world, but if the people on the surface are anything like our protagonists (Which is pretty likely given the radio-host calling the Titanic ''[[CriticalResearchFailure "mythical"]]''), then it's pretty easy to say [[TooDumbToLive they deserve to be taken over by rats.]]

* RootingForTheEmpire: Just about everyone who's seen this movie sympathizes with the rats for [[UnintentionallySympathetic many]] [[LesserOfTwoEvils reasons]], namely because they want to get out of Atlantis kill Pingo. It should be noted that they ''do'' want to take over the world, but if the people on the surface are anything like our protagonists (Which is pretty likely given the radio-host calling the Titanic ''[[CriticalResearchFailure "mythical"]]''), then it's pretty easy to say [[TooDumbToLive they deserve to be taken over by rats.]]

* AudienceAlienatingPremise: One of the most egregious and unforgivable examples in all of media. The idea of a film where the ''Titanic'' disaster is not only treated as a "legend", but a '''misunderstanding where no one died''' would turn off pretty much anyone, especially those who were personally affected by it in some way.

** The highly inappropriate comment Smiley makes about being taken to "Doggy Hell". Imagine how many children were struck with the thought of their beloved pets being sent to Hell.

* RootingForTheEmpire: Just about everyone who's seen this movie sympathizes with the rats for [[UnintentionallySympathetic many]] [[LesserOfTwoEvils reasons]], namely because they want to kill Pingo. It should be noted that they ''do'' want to take over the world, but if the people on the surface is anything like our protagonists (Which is pretty likely given the radio-host calling the Titanic ''[[CriticalResearchFailure "mythical"]]''), then it's pretty easy to say [[TooDumbToLive they deserve to be taken over by rats.]]

* {{Sequelitis}}: Even though the first movie was one of the worst adaptations of the ''Titanic'' sinking, this movie was ''[[FromBadToWorse even]] [[UpToEleven worse]]'' than its predecessor.

* Ice constantly using gratuitous [[JiveTurkey gangster slang]] while talking to Geoffreys.

** A lot of "fans" (for a given value of that word) like to think that the old mouse telling the story was either making it up entirely to entertain his grandchildren, or completely deluded about what actually happened to the ''Titanic.''

* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: A lot of "fans" (for a given value of that word) like to think that the old mouse telling the story was either making it up entirely to entertain his grandchildren, or completely deluded about what actually happened to the ''Titanic.''

** [[{{Kaiju}} Tentacles]] abrupt introduction during the third act of the film.

** The whole romance between Elizabeth and Don Juan, given that it’s founded on pretty much nothing other than Don Juan [[PervertedSniffing]] sniffing the former’s glove. They don’t exchange a single line before deciding that they are meant for each other. It’s like the filmmakers were trying to one-up the LoveAtFirstSight from vintage Disney films.