Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / TheHuntForRedOctober

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Soviet [[ThePoliticalOfficer political officer]] who is named ''[[UsefulNotes/VladimirPutin Putin]]''. Who bears a striking resemblance to ol' Vlad, as well as him having been a KGB officer in his youth[[note]]He was an OfficeDrone, not a field agent[[/note]].

to:

** The Soviet [[ThePoliticalOfficer political officer]] who is named ''[[UsefulNotes/VladimirPutin Putin]]''. Who bears a striking resemblance to ol' Vlad, as well as him having been a KGB officer in his youth[[note]]He was an OfficeDrone, not a field agent[[/note]].youth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Indeed,the ''Magazine/{{Mad}}'' satire of the film ''at the time'' was called "Search For Last October"!

to:

* ** Indeed,the ''Magazine/{{Mad}}'' satire of the film ''at the time'' was called "Search For Last October"!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Indeed,the ''Magazine/{{Mad}}'' satire of the film ''at the time'' was called "Search For Last October"!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* StockFootageFailure: During the ComingInHot scene mentioned above, the footage of the "[=F-14=] Tomcat" crashing on landing is actually of an [=F9F=] Panther, [[JustPlaneWrong an aircraft that had been retired for almost 30 years at the time the film was set]]. The crash footage had also previously been used in a number of other films.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Soviet [[ThePoliticalOfficer political officer]] who is named ''[[UsefulNotes/VladimirPutin Putin]]''. Who bears a striking resemblance to ol' Vlad.

to:

** The Soviet [[ThePoliticalOfficer political officer]] who is named ''[[UsefulNotes/VladimirPutin Putin]]''. Who bears a striking resemblance to ol' Vlad.Vlad, as well as him having been a KGB officer in his youth[[note]]He was an OfficeDrone, not a field agent[[/note]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NightmareFuel: The Political Officer's death. Ramius suddenly grabs him and slam him into the table before brutally crushing his windpipe, leaving him to fall onto the floor where's he's lets out a final breath has his face is contorted in a silent scream.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IdiotBall: An ''Alfa''-class nuclear attack submarine is by design both extremely swift and nimble, whereas the ''Typhoon''-class (the largest submarine class ever built) are half as fast and not nearly as maneuverable. Despite this, at several points in the final battle the ''Typhoon''-class ''Red October'' (while operating on a skeleton crew) outmaneuvers the ''Alfa''-class ''Konovalov'', even managing to get behind the ''Konovalov'' without its captain even noticing. This is analogous to a Lamborghini being outmaneuvered by a school bus, and basically only possible because the ''Konovalov'''s captain is both an "arrogant ass" and colossally incompetent.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** "You've lost ''another'' submarine?"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In one scene, Mancuso says "Central Intelligence Agency? Now, there's a contradiction in terms." Creator/ScottGlenn, who plays Mancuso, would star in ''Film/TheBourneUltimatum'' as [[TheManBehindTheMan CIA director Ezra Kramer]].

to:

** In one scene, Mancuso says "Central Intelligence Agency? Now, there's a contradiction in terms." Creator/ScottGlenn, who plays Mancuso, would star in ''Film/TheBourneUltimatum'' as [[TheManBehindTheMan CIA director Ezra Kramer]]. On top of that, the CIA director he replaces from ''Film/TheBourneSupremacy'', Martin Marshall, is played by Creator/TomasArana, who plays Loginov here (a ''Russian'' secret agent).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Creator/GatesMcFadden, already known for playing [[Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration Dr. Beverly Crusher]] plays Cathy Ryan. In "Film/JackRyanShadowRecruit," Jack himself would be played by [[Creator/ChrisPine Captain]] [[Film/StarTrek2009 Kirk.]]

to:

** Creator/GatesMcFadden, already known for playing [[Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration Dr. Beverly Crusher]] Crusher]], plays Cathy Ryan. In "Film/JackRyanShadowRecruit," Jack himself would be played by [[Creator/ChrisPine Captain]] [[Film/StarTrek2009 Kirk.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**Creator/GatesMcFadden, already known for playing [[Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration Dr. Beverly Crusher]] plays Cathy Ryan. In "Film/JackRyanShadowRecruit," Jack himself would be played by [[Creator/ChrisPine Captain]] [[Film/StarTrek2009 Kirk.]]

Added: 723

Changed: 719

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: The movie seems to imply that the real reason for Ramius defecting was less anger of his wife's death and more [[ScrewTheRulesImDoingWhatsRight concern]] over the fact that the Red October's primary purpose would be to start a nuclear war due to its stealth. In that context, Ryan's [[AdaptationExplanationExtrication comments]] about Ramius's wife are more that he no longer has any reason to go back home.

to:

* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: AlternativeCharacterInterpretation:
**
The movie seems to imply that the real reason for Ramius defecting was less anger of his wife's death and more [[ScrewTheRulesImDoingWhatsRight concern]] over the fact that the Red October's primary purpose would be to start a nuclear war due to its stealth. In that context, Ryan's [[AdaptationExplanationExtrication comments]] about Ramius's wife are more that he no longer has any reason to go back home.



* CommonKnowledge: "Sean Connery plays a Russian sub commander". Except Ramius is Lithuanian, which is a key plot point in his defection. So, he is a commander of a Russian sub, but not a Russian commander of a Russian sub. (It's like a "large animal hospital" - is it a large hospital, or a hospital for animals that are large?)

to:

* CommonKnowledge: CommonKnowledge:
**
"Sean Connery plays a Russian sub commander". Except Ramius is Lithuanian, which is a key plot point in his defection. So, he is a commander of a Russian sub, but not a Russian commander of a Russian sub. (It's like a "large animal hospital" - is it a large hospital, or a hospital for animals that are large?)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Jack's uneasiness with handling a gun, coupled with Ramius explicitly warning him, "Be careful what you shoot at", is quite uncomfortable after Creator/AlecBaldwin fired a gun that was accidentally loaded with real bullets while making the film ''Rust'', killing the cinematographer Halyna Hutchins and injuring the director Joel Souza in October 2021. As an eerie coincidence, Hutchins grew up in Murmansk, the site of ''Red October'''s launch within the film.

to:

** Jack's uneasiness with handling a gun, coupled with Ramius explicitly warning him, "Be careful what you shoot at", is quite uncomfortable after Creator/AlecBaldwin fired a gun that was accidentally loaded with real bullets while making the film ''Rust'', killing the cinematographer Halyna Hutchins and injuring the director Joel Souza in October 2021.2021, and was later charged with accidental manslaughter. As an eerie coincidence, Hutchins grew up in Murmansk, the site of ''Red October'''s launch within the film.

Removed: 3803

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* CriticalResearchFailure: Overlaps with outright DanBrowned in some instances:
** The novel has a whole bunch of critical research failures regarding the internal layout of the Typhoon class missile submarine that, while understandable, also betrays a serious case of ArtMajorPhysics (a submarine with a pressure hull that flattened would have an ''enormously'' compromised diving depth), which also extends to the properties of the impellers used in the Caterpillar Drive[[note]]nowhere nearly as exotic as depicted; British Trafalgar-class submarines new in 1984 beginning from HMS ''Torbay'' onwards used Jet Pumps, which are a form of impeller and needed no special laws of hydrodynamics[[/note]] and the ultra-high-pressure reactor plant used in the Alfa-class submarines [[note]]all made up, and water wouldn't function as a working fluid in such conditions - incidentally, Clancy dismisses a liquid metal reactor when that's what the real Alfa(Lyra/Project 705) class had![[/note]]. The movie averts this with the Caterpillar Drive being turned into a magnetohydrodynamic propulsion system, which is more plausible and which have actually been built, but which are severely speed-restricted and wouldn't be worth using even on a missile submarine.
** The novel has Jack give the president and Jeffrey Pelt a run-down on how Soviet missile submarines differ from American ones - except that it's absolutely ''wrong''. Soviet missile submarines from the Project 667 ("Yankee" and "Delta") classes were configured nearly identically to their American counterparts. Only the ''Typhoons'' had the differences in question.
** Again from the novel - a major Russian naval base would have more than one surgeon on duty, and given the rivalry between the military and the Communist party, a drunk surgeon using his party connections to attempt to get away from a court-martial offense would have created one ''hell'' of an uproar and would be harshly punished for it. If Ramius had lost his wife to a drunk surgeon who was the son of a party official in the real USSR, he would have had his retribution pretty quickly and be backed up by his superiors all the way to the highest ranks.
*** This is partially justified: The novel goes into considerable detail on Ramius' life and the events that lead up to his decision to defect. His wife dying from a botched surgery by a drunk surgeon--who worked for a clinic that served the Party Elite and not the military--was just one of several unjust events he had been witness to or experienced. Ultimately, Ramius blamed the State for his wife's death. The final straw came at her funeral. The state had robbed him of being able to pray for her soul at her funeral and the comfort--or even just the illusion--that he may be reunited with her in the afterlife.
** The novel's scheme of blowing up the USS ''Ethan Allen'' to confuse the Russians into believing that the Red October had sunk is ridiculous because the ''Ethan Allen'' class of missile submarine displaced in the range of 6000 tons, a full 1000 tons less than a ''Los Angeles''-class sub like the ''Dallas'' and a ''fifth'' of ''Red October's'' whopping 30,000+ ton mass. Unless the Soviets were brain-dead they'd notice there was far too little debris for such a large submarine.
*** Partially acknowledged in-universe: while the ''Ethan Allen'' provided some debris and a SONAR signature from the explosion, the main part of the deception involved a depth gauge removed from ''Red October'' and dumped in the debris field along with an SS-20 Seahawk missile, bearing their serial numbers and other identifying marks. The location was also just a few hundred miles off the US Eastern Coast in deep water which makes it difficult for the Russians to make any attempt to salvage the wreckage themselves.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Narm}}: To some native Russian speakers, Creator/SeanConnery speaking Russian in his trademark Scottish accent is ''hilarious''. It's kind of justified in that Connery's character is Lithuanian, so Russian wouldn't be his native language to begin with. Of course, that still doesn't make sense why a person from a Baltic country would sound Scottish. Also, Creator/AlecBaldwin's American accent when speaking Russian is so thick as to be unintelligible.

to:

* {{Narm}}: To some native Russian speakers, Creator/SeanConnery speaking Russian in his trademark Scottish accent is ''hilarious''. It's kind of justified in that Connery's character is Lithuanian, so Russian wouldn't be his native language to begin with. Of course, that still doesn't make sense why a person from a as Baltic country would sound accents (Lithuanian and Latvian) sounds nothing like Scottish. Also, Creator/AlecBaldwin's American accent when speaking Russian is so thick as to be unintelligible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Rear Admiral Painter (played by actor and Tennessee senator Fred Thompson) has a small, but very memorable role in the film.

to:

** Rear Admiral Painter (played by actor and Tennessee senator Fred Thompson) Creator/FredThompson) has a small, but very memorable role in the film.

Added: 783

Changed: 301

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnintentionalPeriodPiece: It's naturally become quite amusing to see how much Creator/TomClancy gushes over then-cutting edge computing technology in 1984, to say nothing of its prominent focus on the UsefulNotes/ColdWar, which at the time had been seeing the highest levels of hostility since the Cuban Missile Crisis in 1962.

to:

* UnintentionalPeriodPiece: UnintentionalPeriodPiece:
**
It's naturally become quite amusing to see how much Creator/TomClancy gushes over then-cutting edge computing technology in 1984, to say nothing of its prominent focus on the UsefulNotes/ColdWar, which at the time had been seeing the highest levels of hostility since the Cuban Missile Crisis in 1962.1962.
** Like the novel, the film became an inevitable one as a result of its heavy focus on the UsefulNotes/ColdWar, which was technically still occurring at the time. Although the situation had rapidly deescalated between the novel's publication in 1984 and the film's release in 1990 (with the Soviet Union already being a hair's length away from total collapse), the idea of [[MakeTheBearAngryAgain rogue generals being eager to reignite the flames]] was still an open possibility.

Added: 329

Changed: 9

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Jeffrey Jones has a single scene as Tyler, who is a subtle MrExposition for BackStory of the Caterpillar tech.

to:

** Jeffrey Jones Creator/JeffreyJones has a single scene as Tyler, who is a subtle MrExposition for BackStory of the Caterpillar tech.


Added DiffLines:

* UnintentionalPeriodPiece: It's naturally become quite amusing to see how much Creator/TomClancy gushes over then-cutting edge computing technology in 1984, to say nothing of its prominent focus on the UsefulNotes/ColdWar, which at the time had been seeing the highest levels of hostility since the Cuban Missile Crisis in 1962.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Ramius says "A little revolution now and then is a healthy thing." A year later, the USSR and the Steel Curtain collapses, with students tearing down the Berlin Wall.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Much of this confusion comes from the fact that the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics was technically [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin many different republics unified under a single soviet]], which was a type of governing council. Each of the republics (to include Russia) had their own soviets, though all were subservient to the Supreme Soviet. So technically, the Soviet Union wasn't Russia, and not all Soviets Russians, although in practical terms Russia more or less ruled the Soviet Union, leading to the common conflation in the west. This also led to the weird but important historical footnote that the last country to declare independence from the Soviet Union was Russia, at which point the USSR effectively disintegrated.

to:

** Much of this confusion comes from the fact that the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics was technically [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin many different republics unified under a single soviet]], which was a type of governing council. Each of the republics (to include Russia) had their own soviets, though all were subservient to the Supreme Soviet. So technically, the Soviet Union wasn't just Russia, and not all Soviets Russians, although in practical terms Russia more or less ruled the Soviet Union, Union and dominated it demographically and culturally by a very large margin, leading to the common conflation in the west.West. This also led to the weird but important historical footnote that the last country to declare independence from the Soviet Union was Russia, at which point the USSR effectively disintegrated.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Jack's uneasiness with handling a gun is quite uncomfortable after Alec Baldwin fired a gun that was accidentally loaded with real bullets while making the film ''Rust'', killing the cinematographer and injuring the director.

to:

** Jack's uneasiness with handling a gun gun, coupled with Ramius explicitly warning him, "Be careful what you shoot at", is quite uncomfortable after Alec Baldwin Creator/AlecBaldwin fired a gun that was accidentally loaded with real bullets while making the film ''Rust'', killing the cinematographer Halyna Hutchins and injuring the director.director Joel Souza in October 2021. As an eerie coincidence, Hutchins grew up in Murmansk, the site of ''Red October'''s launch within the film.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Jack's uneasiness with handling a gun is quite uncomfortable after Alex Baldwin fired a gun that was accidentally loaded with real bullets while making the film ''Rust'', killing the cinematographer and injuring the director.

to:

** Jack's uneasiness with handling a gun is quite uncomfortable after Alex Alec Baldwin fired a gun that was accidentally loaded with real bullets while making the film ''Rust'', killing the cinematographer and injuring the director.

Added: 404

Changed: 173

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HarsherInHindsight: The fate of ''Konovalov'' in the book is very close to that of ''[[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kursk_submarine_disaster Kursk]]'', right up to the rescue buoy being stuck.

to:

* HarsherInHindsight: HarsherInHindsight:
**
The fate of ''Konovalov'' in the book is very close to that of ''[[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kursk_submarine_disaster Kursk]]'', right up to the rescue buoy being stuck.stuck.
** Jack's uneasiness with handling a gun is quite uncomfortable after Alex Baldwin fired a gun that was accidentally loaded with real bullets while making the film ''Rust'', killing the cinematographer and injuring the director.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Much of this confusion comes from the fact that the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics was technically [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin many different republics unified under a single soviet]], which was a type of governing council. Each of the republics (to include Russia) had their own soviets, though all were subservient to the Supreme Soviet. So technically, the Soviet Union wasn't Russia, and not all Soviets Russians, although in practical terms Russia more or less ruled the Soviet Union, leading to the common conflation in the west. This also led to the weird but important historical footnote that the last country to declare independence from the Soviet Union was Russia, at which point the USSR effectively disintegrated.

Added: 1076

Changed: 187

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GeniusBonus: "I have become Death, destroyer of worlds", an "ancient Hindu text", was also uttered by Oppenheimer during the explosion of the atomic bomb (a fact to which Ramius alludes in the film).

to:

* GeniusBonus: GeniusBonus:
**
"I have become Death, destroyer of worlds", an "ancient Hindu text", was also uttered by Oppenheimer during the explosion of the atomic bomb (a fact to which Ramius alludes in the film).film).
** It's mentioned early on in the film that orders have come down directly from the USSR's leader, UsefulNotes/KonstantinChernenko, for the Soviet navy to find and sink the ''Red October'', which is treated by the American characters as a sign of how dire the situation is (before Jack [[SpottingTheThread spots the thread]] and realizes that Ramius actually intends to defect). In real-life Chernenko was in extremely poor health throughout his brief tenure as Soviet leader[[note]](Something which then-Vice President UsefulNotes/GeorgeHWBush saw first-hand at the funeral of Chernenko's predecessor, UsefulNotes/YuriAndropov, and thus wasn't much of a secret even in the west)[[/note]] and delegated most of the important decisions to his subordinates, indicating just how serious things were if the Soviet military actually thought it important enough to be worth bothering him with.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** This is partially justified: The novel goes into considerable detail on Ramius' life and the events that lead up to his decision to defect. His wife dying from a botched surgery by a drunk surgeon--who worked for a clinic that served the Party Elite and not the military--was just one of several unjust events he had been witness to or experienced. Ultimately, Ramius blamed the State for his wife's death. The final straw came at her funeral. The state had robbed him of being unable to pray for her soul at her funeral and the comfort--or even just the illusion--that he may be reunited with her in the afterlife.

to:

*** This is partially justified: The novel goes into considerable detail on Ramius' life and the events that lead up to his decision to defect. His wife dying from a botched surgery by a drunk surgeon--who worked for a clinic that served the Party Elite and not the military--was just one of several unjust events he had been witness to or experienced. Ultimately, Ramius blamed the State for his wife's death. The final straw came at her funeral. The state had robbed him of being unable able to pray for her soul at her funeral and the comfort--or even just the illusion--that he may be reunited with her in the afterlife.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OlderThanTheyThink: The caterpillar drive is very similar to the 'underwater jet' in ''[[Literature/TomSwift Tom Swift Jr. and His Jetmarine]]'', first published in the 1950s
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SugarWiki/AwesomeMusic: Hymn to Red October, written by Music/BasilPoledouris.

to:

* SugarWiki/AwesomeMusic: Hymn Courtesy of Music/BasilPoledouris. Particularly the Soviet-like choirs of "Hymn to Red October, written by Music/BasilPoledouris.October" and "Ancestral Aid".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** "Russians don't take a dump, son, without a plan."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Unapproved by the MB thread.


** Note: Ramius wasn't responsible for the torpedo. That was Captain Mancuso, commanding an unfamiliar Soviet missile sub with what couldn't even be described as a skeleton crew made up of a handful of Soviet officers and a smaller handful of American sailors, with the timely help of his first officer, Lt. Commander Thompson, using ''Dallas'' to DrawAggro on the torpedo before using countermeasures and evasive maneuvers to evade it themselves.

Top