Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / RubberSoul

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG:[[center:[-Music/TheBeatles '''[[YMMV/TheBeatles Main YMMV Page]]'''\\
''YMMV/PleasePleaseMe'' | ''YMMV/WithTheBeatles'' | ''YMMV/AHardDaysNight'' | ''YMMV/BeatlesForSale'' | ''YMMV/{{Help}}'' | '''''Rubber Soul''''' | ''YMMV/{{Revolver|BeatlesAlbum}}''\\
''YMMV/SgtPeppersLonelyHeartsClubBand'' | ''YMMV/MagicalMysteryTour'' | ''YMMV/TheWhiteAlbum'' | ''YMMV/YellowSubmarine'' | ''YMMV/AbbeyRoad'' | ''YMMV/LetItBe''\\
''YMMV/PastMasters'' | ''YMMV/TheBeatlesAnthology'' | ''YMMV/TheBeatlesGetBack''-]]]]]
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GrowingTheBeard: Many regard this as the Beatles' first truly ''great'' album from an artistic standpoint. This was the album where the band started their experiments with sound and instruments, evolving away from the guitar-pop music of their earlier albums, as well as writing more introspective lyrics on songs such as "Nowhere Man" and "In My Life". Hell, the mangled American version of the album was ''still'' so good it inspired Music/BrianWilson to grow his own beard with Music/TheBeachBoys' ''Music/PetSounds''.

to:

* GrowingTheBeard: Many While ''Music/{{Help}}'' was the band's first album to be viewed as art, many regard this as the Beatles' first truly ''great'' album from an artistic standpoint. This was the album where the band started their experiments with sound and instruments, evolving away from the guitar-pop music of their earlier albums, as well as writing more introspective lyrics on songs such as "Nowhere Man" and "In My Life". Hell, the mangled American version of the album was ''still'' so good it inspired Music/BrianWilson to grow his own beard with Music/TheBeachBoys' ''Music/PetSounds''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


** "Run For Your Life", in which Lennon seems to advocate for ''spousal murder''. This was hardly noticed at the time, but soon enough even Lennon himself considered it [[CreatorBacklash the worst song he wrote for the band]]. Doesn't help that there's an overwhelming about of LyricalDissonance within it. [[PoesLaw Was he intending for it to be a serious love song with an unintentionally unhealthy perspective, or was it made to make fun of people who would actually believe such ideologies?]] Pop songs from 60s girl groups playing StalkerWithACrush straight would probably indicate the former with the style of the time; plus, Lennon [[CreatorBacklash coming to regret making the song]] only increases the likelihood of [[UnfortunateImplications the song intending to actually be romantic]]. Another possible consideration was that a song with a more aggressive lyrical bent might have been a ploy to appeal to male fans more. In interviews at the time the band fretted the perception that their fanbase consisted of screaming teen girls, and admitted that one reason they started getting more adventurous in their music was to get more male listeners.

to:

** "Run For Your Life", in which Lennon seems to advocate for ''spousal murder''. This was hardly noticed at the time, but soon enough even Lennon himself considered it [[CreatorBacklash the worst song he wrote for the band]]. Doesn't help that there's an overwhelming about of LyricalDissonance within it. [[PoesLaw Was he intending for it to be a serious love song with an unintentionally unhealthy perspective, or was it made to make fun of people who would actually believe such ideologies?]] Pop songs from 60s girl groups playing StalkerWithACrush straight would probably indicate the former with the style of the time; plus, Lennon [[CreatorBacklash coming to regret making the song]] only increases the likelihood of [[UnfortunateImplications the song intending to actually be romantic]].romantic. Another possible consideration was that a song with a more aggressive lyrical bent might have been a ploy to appeal to male fans more. In interviews at the time the band fretted the perception that their fanbase consisted of screaming teen girls, and admitted that one reason they started getting more adventurous in their music was to get more male listeners.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RefrainFromAssuming: The second track is officially titled "Norwegian Wood (This Bird Has Flown)", but people nearly always omit the parenthetical bit.

Added: 697

Changed: 202

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: The scenario played out in the lyrics of "Norwegian Wood" is presented in a vague, somewhat elliptic manner that makes the whole thing open to interpretation. The easy take is that the narrator is a {{Jerkass}} who burned down a woman's house simply because she wouldn't sleep with him. But she comes across as a bit of a MasterOfTheMixedMessage, inviting him to her house, offering him alcohol, then waiting until late in the night before revealing that she had to go to work in the morning, then, to top it off, she still let him sleep in her bathroom, and he didn't try to force himself onto her...so he says. UnreliableNarrator might also be in play here.



** "Norwegian Wood" is an elegant little waltz about a date not going well, and it implies strongly that the narrator, after his date took him to her place but nixed having sex with him, lit her house on fire in retaliation. With more awareness about consent and entitlement issues and the repudiation of the notion that anyone is ''owed'' sex, it's not uncommon for the song to leave a bad taste in the mouth of some modern-day listeners. Others would argue the PlotTwist is meant to show that the narrator was a {{Jerkass}} all along, but was being [[UnreliableNarrator unreliable]] before. It's worth mentioning that it wasn't even Music/JohnLennon, the principal songwriter, but Music/PaulMcCartney who threw that ending in, as a ''joke!''

to:

** "Norwegian Wood" is an elegant little waltz about a date not going well, and it implies strongly that the narrator, after his date took him to her place but nixed having sex with him, lit her house on fire in retaliation. With more awareness about consent and entitlement issues and the repudiation of the notion that anyone is ''owed'' sex, it's not uncommon for the song to leave a bad taste in the mouth of some modern-day listeners. Others would argue listeners, though, as mentioned in Alternative Character Interpretation above, the PlotTwist whole song is meant to show that the narrator was a {{Jerkass}} all along, but was being [[UnreliableNarrator unreliable]] before.quite ambiguous. It's worth mentioning that it wasn't even Music/JohnLennon, the principal songwriter, but Music/PaulMcCartney who threw that ending in, as a ''joke!''

Changed: 1327

Removed: 658

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Glurge}}: It's hard to piece together the angle John Lennon was aiming for with "Run For Your Life" thanks to the overwhelming about of LyricalDissonance within it. [[PoesLaw Was he intending for it to be a serious love song with an unintentionally unhealthy perspective, or was it made to make fun of people who would actually believe such ideologies?]] Pop songs from 60s girl groups playing StalkerWithACrush straight would probably indicate the former with the style of the time; plus, Lennon [[CreatorBacklash coming to regret making the song]] only increases the likelihood of [[UnfortunateImplications the song intending to actually be romantic]].



** "Norwegian Wood" is an elegant little waltz about a date not going well, and it implies strongly that the narrator, after his date wouldn't sleep with him, lit her house on fire in retaliation. Nowadays, as most modern feminists will often tell you, men are ''not'' owed sex for any reason, and thus it's not uncommon for the song to leave a bad taste in the mouth of a modern-day listener. And it wasn't even Music/JohnLennon, the principal songwriter, but Music/PaulMcCartney who threw that ending in, as a ''joke!''
** "Run For Your Life", in which Lennon seems to advocate for ''spousal murder''. This was hardly noticed at the time, but soon enough even Lennon himself considered it [[CreatorBacklash the worst song he wrote for the band]].

to:

** "Norwegian Wood" is an elegant little waltz about a date not going well, and it implies strongly that the narrator, after his date wouldn't sleep took him to her place but nixed having sex with him, lit her house on fire in retaliation. Nowadays, as most modern feminists will often tell you, men are ''not'' owed sex for any reason, With more awareness about consent and thus entitlement issues and the repudiation of the notion that anyone is ''owed'' sex, it's not uncommon for the song to leave a bad taste in the mouth of a some modern-day listener. And listeners. Others would argue the PlotTwist is meant to show that the narrator was a {{Jerkass}} all along, but was being [[UnreliableNarrator unreliable]] before. It's worth mentioning that it wasn't even Music/JohnLennon, the principal songwriter, but Music/PaulMcCartney who threw that ending in, as a ''joke!''
** "Run For Your Life", in which Lennon seems to advocate for ''spousal murder''. This was hardly noticed at the time, but soon enough even Lennon himself considered it [[CreatorBacklash the worst song he wrote for the band]]. Doesn't help that there's an overwhelming about of LyricalDissonance within it. [[PoesLaw Was he intending for it to be a serious love song with an unintentionally unhealthy perspective, or was it made to make fun of people who would actually believe such ideologies?]] Pop songs from 60s girl groups playing StalkerWithACrush straight would probably indicate the former with the style of the time; plus, Lennon [[CreatorBacklash coming to regret making the song]] only increases the likelihood of [[UnfortunateImplications the song intending to actually be romantic]]. Another possible consideration was that a song with a more aggressive lyrical bent might have been a ploy to appeal to male fans more. In interviews at the time the band fretted the perception that their fanbase consisted of screaming teen girls, and admitted that one reason they started getting more adventurous in their music was to get more male listeners.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GrowingTheBeard: Many regard this as the Beatles' first truly ''great'' album from an artistic standpoint. This was the album where the band started their experiments with sound and instruments, evolving away from the guitar-pop music of their earlier albums, as well as writing more introspective lyrics on songs such as "Nowhere Man" and "In My Life". The album inspired Music/BrianWilson to grow his own beard with Music/TheBeachBoys' ''Music/PetSounds''.

to:

* GrowingTheBeard: Many regard this as the Beatles' first truly ''great'' album from an artistic standpoint. This was the album where the band started their experiments with sound and instruments, evolving away from the guitar-pop music of their earlier albums, as well as writing more introspective lyrics on songs such as "Nowhere Man" and "In My Life". The Hell, the mangled American version of the album was ''still'' so good it inspired Music/BrianWilson to grow his own beard with Music/TheBeachBoys' ''Music/PetSounds''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Glurge}}: It's hard to piece together the angle John Lennon was aiming for with "Run For Your Life" thanks to the overwhelming about of LyricalDissonance within it. [[PoesLaw Was he intending for it to be a serious love song with an unintentionally unhealthy perspective, or was it made to make fun of people who would actually believe such ideologies?]] Pop songs from 60s girl groups playing StalkerWithACrush straight would probably indicate the former with the style of the time, but Lennon [[CreatorBacklash coming to regret making the song]] only complicates matters further.

to:

* {{Glurge}}: It's hard to piece together the angle John Lennon was aiming for with "Run For Your Life" thanks to the overwhelming about of LyricalDissonance within it. [[PoesLaw Was he intending for it to be a serious love song with an unintentionally unhealthy perspective, or was it made to make fun of people who would actually believe such ideologies?]] Pop songs from 60s girl groups playing StalkerWithACrush straight would probably indicate the former with the style of the time, but time; plus, Lennon [[CreatorBacklash coming to regret making the song]] only complicates matters further.increases the likelihood of [[UnfortunateImplications the song intending to actually be romantic]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Glurge}}: It's hard to piece together the angle John Lennon was aiming for with "Run For Your Life" thanks to the overwhelming about of LyricalDissonance within it. [[PoesLaw Was he intending for it to be a serious love song with an unintentionally unhealthy perspective, or was it made to make fun of people who would actually believe such ideologies?]] Pop songs from 60s girl groups playing StalkerWithACrush straight would probably indicate the former with the style of the time, but Lennon [[CreatorBacklash coming to regret making the song]] only complicates matters further.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** "Run For Your Life", in which Lennon seems to advocate for ''spousal murder''. This was hardly noticed at the time, but soon enough even Lennon himself considered it the worst song he wrote for the band.

to:

** "Run For Your Life", in which Lennon seems to advocate for ''spousal murder''. This was hardly noticed at the time, but soon enough even Lennon himself considered it [[CreatorBacklash the worst song he wrote for the band.band]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** "Norwegian Wood": The narrator burns down a woman's apartment for refusing to sleep with him.
** "Run for Your Life": John Lennon threatens to kill a lover who walks out on him.

to:

** "Norwegian Wood": The narrator burns down Wood" is an elegant little waltz about a woman's apartment for refusing to date not going well, and it implies strongly that the narrator, after his date wouldn't sleep with him.
**
him, lit her house on fire in retaliation. Nowadays, as most modern feminists will often tell you, men are ''not'' owed sex for any reason, and thus it's not uncommon for the song to leave a bad taste in the mouth of a modern-day listener. And it wasn't even Music/JohnLennon, the principal songwriter, but Music/PaulMcCartney who threw that ending in, as a ''joke!''
**
"Run for For Your Life": John Life", in which Lennon threatens seems to kill a lover who walks out on him.advocate for ''spousal murder''. This was hardly noticed at the time, but soon enough even Lennon himself considered it the worst song he wrote for the band.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GermansLoveDavidHasselhoff: On a regional level, the American version was particularly popular among the San Francisco Bay Area counterculture and was a major influence on the nascent psychedelia scene, including bands like Music/JeffersonAirplane

to:

* GermansLoveDavidHasselhoff: On a regional level, the American version was particularly popular among the San Francisco UsefulNotes/SanFrancisco Bay Area counterculture and was a major influence on the nascent psychedelia scene, including bands like Music/JeffersonAirplaneMusic/JeffersonAirplane.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GermansLoveDavidHasselhoff: The American version was particularly popular among the San Francisco Bay Area counterculture and was a major influence on the nascent psychedelia scene, including bands like Music/JeffersonAirplane

to:

* GermansLoveDavidHasselhoff: The On a regional level, the American version was particularly popular among the San Francisco Bay Area counterculture and was a major influence on the nascent psychedelia scene, including bands like Music/JeffersonAirplane
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GermansLoveDavidHasselhoff: The American version was particularly popular among the San Francisco Bay Area counterculture and was a major influence on the nascent psychedelia scene, including bands like Music/JeffersonAirplane
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GenreTurningPoint: ''Rubber Soul'' marked the point where rock musicians started to focus on albums rather than singles.

to:

* GenreTurningPoint: ''Rubber Soul'' marked the point where rock musicians started to focus on albums rather than singles. It was also the point that critics started to take the band, and popular music as a whole, more seriously.

Added: 489

Removed: 488

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CrowningMomentOfHeartwarming: "In My Life" where a man stops and reflects on the loves and friends from days past he misses now. Almost a TearJerker song except that the man is still happy to have known them, realizes he will ''not forget them'', and compares them favorably to a current lover he knows he loves most of all.
-->''Though I know I'll never lose affection\\
For people and things that went before\\
I know I'll often stop and think about them\\
In my life I love you more...''


Added DiffLines:

* SugarWiki/HeartwarmingMoments: "In My Life" where a man stops and reflects on the loves and friends from days past he misses now. Almost a TearJerker song except that the man is still happy to have known them, realizes he will ''not forget them'', and compares them favorably to a current lover he knows he loves most of all.
-->''Though I know I'll never lose affection\\
For people and things that went before\\
I know I'll often stop and think about them\\
In my life I love you more...''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Woolseyism}}: A few fans feel that the original US version works better as a whole album than its UK equivalent, since it's more musically uniform (with a focus on the acoustic side of the band).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EpilepticTrees: "Norwegian Wood" was the first Beatles song with cryptic lyrics, so it's invited some oddball interpretations, particularly over the significance of "Norwegian". Among the more amusing takes are that "Norwegian Wood" was John goofing around with the phrase "knowing she would", or that "wood" is a code word for marijuana.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CutAndPasteTranslation: As with every Beatles album up to ''Music/{{Revolver}}'' in its original U.S. release.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CutAndPasteTranslation: As with every Beatles album up to ''Music/{{Revolver}}''.

to:

* CutAndPasteTranslation: As with every Beatles album up to ''Music/{{Revolver}}''.''Music/{{Revolver}}'' in its original U.S. release.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GenreTurningPoint: ''Rubber Soul'' marked the point where rock musicians started to focus on albums rather than singles.

Added: 4

Changed: 66

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GrowingTheBeard: Many regard this as the Beatles' first truly ''great'' album from an artistic standpoint. This was the album where the band started their experiments with sound and instruments - evolving away from the guitar-pop music of their earlier albums - as well as writing more introspective - "Nowhere Man," "In My Life" - lyrics. The album inspired Music/BrianWilson to grow his own beard with ''Music/PetSounds''.

to:

* GrowingTheBeard: Many regard this as the Beatles' first truly ''great'' album from an artistic standpoint. This was the album where the band started their experiments with sound and instruments - instruments, evolving away from the guitar-pop music of their earlier albums - albums, as well as writing more introspective - lyrics on songs such as "Nowhere Man," Man" and "In My Life" - lyrics. Life". The album inspired Music/BrianWilson to grow his own beard with Music/TheBeachBoys' ''Music/PetSounds''.



** "Run for your Life": John Lennon threatens to kill a lover who walks out on him.

to:

** "Run for your Your Life": John Lennon threatens to kill a lover who walks out on him.him.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GrowingTheBeard: Many regard this as the Beatles' first truly ''great'' album from an artistic standpoint.

to:

* GrowingTheBeard: Many regard this as the Beatles' first truly ''great'' album from an artistic standpoint. This was the album where the band started their experiments with sound and instruments - evolving away from the guitar-pop music of their earlier albums - as well as writing more introspective - "Nowhere Man," "In My Life" - lyrics. The album inspired Music/BrianWilson to grow his own beard with ''Music/PetSounds''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** "Run for your Life": Yes, it's about threating to kill an unfaithful lover.

to:

** "Run for your Life": Yes, it's about threating John Lennon threatens to kill an unfaithful lover.a lover who walks out on him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GrowingTheBeard: Many regard this as the Beatles' first truly ''great'' album from an artistic standpoint.

to:

* GrowingTheBeard: Many regard this as the Beatles' first truly ''great'' album from an artistic standpoint.standpoint.
* ValuesDissonance:
** "Norwegian Wood": The narrator burns down a woman's apartment for refusing to sleep with him.
** "Run for your Life": Yes, it's about threating to kill an unfaithful lover.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DoNotDoThisCoolThing: It doesn't matter how horrible [[MisogynySong the sentiments]] expressed in "Run For Your Life" are, Music/JohnLennon just makes them sound so damn cool.

to:

* DoNotDoThisCoolThing: It doesn't matter how horrible [[MisogynySong the sentiments]] expressed in "Run For Your Life" are, Music/JohnLennon just makes them sound so damn cool.cool.
* GrowingTheBeard: Many regard this as the Beatles' first truly ''great'' album from an artistic standpoint.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CrowningMomentOfHeartwarming: "In My Life" where a man stops and reflects on the loves and friends from days past he misses now. Almost a TearJerker song except that the man is still happy to have known them, realizes he will ''not forget them'', and compares them favorably to a current lover he knows he loves most of all.
-->''Though I know I'll never lose affection\\
For people and things that went before\\
I know I'll often stop and think about them\\
In my life I love you more...''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CutAndPasteTranslation: As with every Beatles album up to ''Music/{{Revolver}}''.
* DoNotDoThisCoolThing: It doesn't matter how horrible [[MisogynySong the sentiments]] expressed in "Run For Your Life" are, Music/JohnLennon just makes them sound so damn cool.

Top