History YMMV / PeanutButterGamer

* Peebs is known for his love of ''WesternAnimation/{{Arthur}}''. Come the finale [[spoiler: where a TimeSkip shows Arthur as a 28-year-old...and he looks like PBG]].

** "I apologize for that!"[[labelnote:Explanation]] A line from his [[VideoGame/TheLegendOfZeldaCDIGames Link: The Faces of Evil]], in reaction to the WebAnimation/YouTubePoop he made for the video. Appropriately, it became a meme in [=YouTube=] Poop itself, often used as an apology for A. a particularly [[CrossesTheLineTwice line-crossing joke]] B. use of an overused meme, or C. as LampshadeHanging for StylisticSuck moments.[[/labelnote]]

** In his "Top 10 Suckiest Enemies in Video Games" video, PBG said this: "Usually I don't talk about the [[https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/VideoGame/TheLegendOfZeldaCDiGames Zelda CD-i games]]. Like Nintendo, I just prefer to pretend like they never existed.” Two years later, he did a video on The Faces of Evil for Zelda Month. And then he did The Wand of Gamelon for the following Zelda Month.

** In his Super Mario 64 Hacking video he quickly mentions a hack that causes Mario's health to decrease over time. In his Chaos Edition Playthrough, the health drain simply doesn't let PBG win, and activates itself whenever it causes the most problems.

** In Part 3 of his review of the Super Mario Bros. Super Show Cartoon, PBG does a sketch where he tries to introduce a celebrity cameo, only for some random weirdo (also played by PBG) to appear instead. The celebrity Peebs was expecting? Chris Pratt, who has now been cast as Mario himself in an upcoming movie!

* HoYay: He frequently calls [[Franchise/SuperMarioBros Luigi]] sexy. His song to Luigi in ''HACKING Mario Galaxy!'' is really...[[UpToEleven something]].

** In Part 3 of his review of the Super Mario Bros. Super Show Cartoon, PBG does a sketch where he tries to introduce a celebrity cameo, only for some random weirdo (also played by PPB) to appear instead. The celebrity Peebs was expecting? Chris Pratt, who has now been cast as Mario himself in an upcoming movie!

* HeartwarmingInHindsight: Mixed with HilariousInHindsight. In his ''VideoGame/AnimalCrossingNewHorizons'' review, there's a segment where he lamented that some features and characters are absent from the game, one of them being Crazy Redd. However, just a few weeks after his video was released, Redd was reintroduced to ''New Horizons'' in an update. Brewster would also be subsequently reintroduced via an update planned for October 2021.

* HeartwarmingInHindsight: Mixed with HilariousInHindsight. In his ''VideoGame/AnimalCrossingNewHorizons'' review, there's a segment where he lamented that some features and characters are absent from the game, one of them being Crazy Redd. However, just a few weeks after his video was released, Redd was reintroduced to ''New Horizons'' in an update.

* FunnyAneurysmMoment: In his ''VideoGame/TomodachiLife'' video, he notes that when playing ''Tomodachi Life'', the Mii he made of LetsPlay/ProJared continually tried to romance the Mii he made of Unicornism (his real-life girlfriend), and when his Mii and Unicornism's Mii eventually have a child together, he warns [=ProJared=] to "keep his hands off her". This became somewhat funnier to watch in hindsight after [=ProJared=] was accused of cheating on his wife.

** His Nintendogs review features his new puppy, Namira, pretty heavily. However, she sadly [[http://unicornism.tumblr.com/post/113090954146 had to be put to sleep a year later]].

** In his [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5NEjty8etUA Top 10 Best Nintendo Wii Games]] video, he makes a joke about being reported as missing, only to be found playing ''VideoGame/HarvestMoonAnimalParade''. two years later, another famous gaming [=YouTuber=], WebVideo/{{Etika}}, was reported to have gone missing, right after posting a video about his suicidal thoughts, about five days later, his belongings, including his wallet, ''UsefulNotes/NintendoSwitch'' and phone, were found on the Manhattan Bridge, about 20 hours later, his body was found dead about half a mile away from his belongings.

--> '''PBG:''': I feel like I'm, like, letting my pet go or something. He wasn't really a warrior, but he was funny... I liked him...

** His review of VideoGame/SonicHeroes basically mirrors what a lot of critics of the series have said for years (such as the characters speaking too much and how having Sonic as the sole playable character would be an "improvement"), as well as stating that cannons are not an effective mode of transportation as well as the fact that the game's Pinball Zone is not an enjoyable place to live.

* HoYay: He frequently calls [[Franchise/SuperMarioBros Luigi]] sexy. His song to Luigi in ''HACKING Mario Galaxy!'' is really... [[UpToEleven something]].

* FunnyAneurysmMoment: In his ''VideoGame/TomodachiLife'' video, he notes that when playing ''Tomodachi Life'', the Mii he made of LetsPlay/ProJared continually tried to romance the Mii he made of Unicornism (his real-life girlfriend), and when his Mii and Unicornism's Mii eventually have a child together, he warns [=ProJared=] to "keep his hands off her". This became somewhat funnier to watch in hindsight after [=ProJared=] was falsely accused of cheating on his wife.

** In his ''Putt-Putt Does Some Things'' video, he jokingly talks about how the lawn-mowing minigame in ''VideoGame/PuttPutt Joins the Parade'' teaches children that "[[FamilyUnfriendlyAesop hard work is for chumps]]" since you don't have to actually mow the whole lawn. Later on, [[https://youtu.be/39ZWiR22i58?t=2m42s in a developer commentary for one of the other games]], a former writer for Humongous revealed that they actually got a complaining letter from an upset mother who wondered how she was supposed to teach her kid to work hard when the game taught him the exact opposite, under the ''exact same scenario''.

* FunnyAneurysmMoment: In his ''VideoGame/TomodachiLife'' video, he notes that when playing ''Tomodachi Life'', the Mii he made of LetsPlay/ProJared continually tried to romance the Mii he made of Unicornism (his real-life girlfriend), and when his Mii and Unicornism's Mii eventually have a child together, he warns [=ProJared=] to "keep his hands off her". This becomes a lot harder to watch after [=ProJared=] cheated on his wife.

** His review of VideoGame/SonicHeroes basically parrots what a lot of haters of the series have said for years (such as the characters speaking too much and having Sonic as the sole playable character would be an "improvement"), as well as making really [[Main/MST3KMantra nitpicky]] complaints such as cannons not being an effective mode of transportation or the game's PinballZone not being an enjoyable place to live.

* FunnyAneurysmMoment: In his ''VideoGame/TomodachiLife'' video, he notes that when playing ''Tomodachi Life'', the Mii he made of ProJared continually tried to romance the Mii he made of Unicornism (his real-life girlfriend), and when his Mii and Unicornism's Mii eventually have a child together, he warns ProJared to "keep his hands off her". This becomes a lot harder to watch after ProJared cheated on his wife.

** During the seventh episode of Goodwill Games, PBG repeatedly jokes about how close he is to the two million subscriber milestone; sure enough, he soon passed that threshold...only to fall back below it due to losing a bunch of subscribers from the crossfire of the Projared incident.[[note]]To explain, when news of the scandal first broke, PBG posted a comment expressing skepticism of the accusations; he later apologized for this, admitting that he had initially been afraid to believe that someone he'd been friends with for so long could do such a thing, but by that point the damage had been done.[[/note]]

%%* TheWoobie: Poor, poor Jeff. He has worse luck than LetsPlay/ProtonJon, LetsPlay/JohneAwesome, LetsPlay/MasaeAnela and [[LetsPlay/WiiRikeToPray Spence]] combined.

%%** Similarly, in his Tomodachi Life review, he made a joke about how in-game Projared keeps trying to flirt with in-game Unicornism, aged completely poorly with the Projared incident.

* AlasPoorScrappy: When [[spoiler:Drunky [=McPanda=] the Spinda]] died in the [[VideoGame/PokemonRubyAndSapphire Pokémon Alpha Sapphire]] Nuzlocke, PBG initially jokes about about how he won't be missed due to how useless he was in battle, but then quickly goes back on what he said a few minutes later when he actually has to release him in the Pokémon Box.

** In his [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5NEjty8etUA Top 10 Best Nintendo Wii Games]] video, he makes a joke about being reported as missing, only to be found playing ''VideoGame/HarvestMoonAnimalParade''. two years later, another famous gaming [=YouTuber=], WebVideo{{Etika}}, was reported to have gone missing, right after posting a video about his suicidal thoughts, about five days later, his belongings, including his wallet, ''UsefulNotes/NintendoSwitch'' and phone, were found on the Manhattan Bridge, about 20 hours later, his body was found dead about half a mile away from his belongings.

** In his [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5NEjty8etUA Top 10 Best Nintendo Wii Games]] video, he makes a joke about being reported as missing, only to be found playing ''VideoGame/HarvestMoonAnimalParade''. two years later, another famous gaming Youtuber, Etika, was reported to have gone missing, right after posting a video about his suicidal thoughts, about five days later, his belongings, including his wallet, ''UsefulNotes/NintendoSwitch'' and phone, were found on the Manhattan Bridge, about 20 hours later, his body was found dead about half a mile away from his belongings.

* EarWorm:
** "I Like to Ski", from ''The Top Ten Jerks in Gaming''.
** The "Smash The Truck" rap from the ''VideoGame/MySims Agents'' review.
** Him singing "Riding Dirty" in his Hacking Wind Waker video qualifies both as this and a [[SugarWiki/FunnyMoments CMOF]].
** The ''Zelda'' rap from ''Ocarina of Time Hacking''.
** The Charlie Churchmouse song.

* FunnyAneurysmMoment:
** In his review of ''VideoGame/TomodachiLife'', he makes multiple jokes about [=ProJared=] being overly lewd, with one of the most notable ones being him trying to steal Unicornism away from PBG. Funny at the time, but now it seems more like unintentional foreshadowing. And then there's PBG talking about his daughter [=ChickenNug=].
--> '''PBG:''': Keep your hands off her, Jared! I'm watching you...
** During his review of {{VideoGame/Kinectimals}}, PBG accepted his pet Azura as his new best friend jokeily while trading off Projared in the process, declaring he is not his best friend anymore. After the cheating scandal of Projared, it led to PBG dissociating from him for real.

** And as mentioned above under FunnyAneurysmMoment, his {{VideoGame/TomodachiLife}} video, where he recreates many other Youtubers as Miis, contains jokes about Jared constantly trying to steal his girlfriend and creeping on their in-game daughter.

** And as mentioned above under FunnyAneurysmMoment, his {{VideoGame/TomodachiLife}} video, where he recreates many other Youtubers as Miis, he jokes about Jared constantly trying to steal his girlfriend and creeping on their in-game daughter.

** And speaking of ProJared, his {{VideoGame/TomodachiLife]}} video, where he recreates many other Youtubers as Miis, he jokes about Jared constantly trying to steal his girlfriend.