History YMMV / FromJustinToKelly

** On that note, considering all of their communication breakdowns throughout the movie, why did it never occur to Justin and Kelly that ''she'' might find ''his'' phone number useful?

* FridgeLogic: The phone number Kelly tries to give Justin has a 972 area code, which corresponds with the Dallas area. The phone number Alexa gives him has a 239 area code, which corresponds with southwest Florida, even though the girls are all from Texas and they are in ''southeast'' Florida for most of the movie.

* TravelingAtTheSpeedOfPlot: Based on Kelly's phone number, we can deduce that the girls live somewhere in the Dallas area, which means their last-minute road trip to Miami would require over 19 hours of driving.

* StrangledByTheRedString: Justin and Kelly have almost no real chemistry, to the point where it seems like they don't even want to touch one another, in spite of the fact that [[http://www.eonline.com/news/513139/justin-guarini-reveals-past-romance-with-kelly-clarkson-during-post-american-idol-days they had begun dating in real life ''while filming'']].

* StrangledByTheRedString: Justin and Kelly have almost no real chemistry, to the point where it seems like they don't even want to touch one another.

** On that note, considering all of their communication breakdowns throughout the movie, why did it never occur to Justin and Kelly that ''she'' might find 'his'' phone number useful?

* TravelingAtTheSpeedOfPlot: Based on Kelly's phone number, we can deduce that the girls live somewhere in the Dallas area, which means their last-minute road trip to Miami would take over 19 hours.

* TravelingAtTheSpeedOfPlot: Depending on their exact starting point in Texas, the last-minute road trip the girls take to Miami would take anywhere from 16 to 28 hours.

* SoBadItsGood: Some people who don't loathe the movie have this opinion of it. This includes GoldenRaspberryAward founder John Wilson, who describes ''From Justin to Kelly'' [[https://books.google.com/books?id=bLpJHjGFNk8C&pg=PT34 in his book]] as "stupid when it means to be clever, garishly clubfooted when it wants to be graceful, and bearing no resemblance to anything a modern teenager would be caught dead watching".

* SoBadItsGood: Some people who don't loathe the movie have this opinion of it.

* TookTheBadFilmSeriously: Todd In The Shadows points out in his review that the actor who played Carlos seemed "too real" to be in the movie. Justin Guarini put in a lot of effort as well since his celebrity career depended on this movie's success.

* TookTheBadFilmSeriously: Todd In The Shadows points out in his review that the actor who played Carlos seemed "too real" to be in the movie. Likewise, Justin Guarini put in a lot of effort as well, since his celebrity career depended on this movie's success.

* TookTheBadFilmSeriously: Todd In The Shadows points out in his review that the actor who played Carlos seemed "too real" to be in the movie.

* TheDanza: Justin and Kelly playing Justin and Kelly. Furthermore, their character's last names belong to Justin and Kelly's respective father and stepfather.

* TheyJustDidntCare: Let's just say that Kelly Clarkson's dislike of the film isn't hard to see. Furthermore, the movie is riddled with costume and scene continuity errors and at one point the entire set crew can be seen.

* CharacterShilling: Other characters often comment on how "nice" Kelly is, even though over the course of the film she mostly seems bitter and angry.
** Also, during one scene, Kelly makes a point of saying that Kaya is smart, despite nothing in the movie showing that Kaya has any remarkable intelligence.

* IdiotPlot: The whole tension of the story is that Justin lost Kelly's number and Alexa gave him the wrong one when he asked her for it (rather than just asking Kelly for it again).
** Somehow Alexa thought this would cause Justin to lose interest in Kelly and end up with her instead.
** Justin doesn't take "not interested" for an answer, nor is he put off when Kelly gives him a face full of whipped cream.

** Neither Kelly nor Justin ever ask the other about the text mishaps, until...
** Towards the end of the movie Alexa just sits there and lets Kelly look at her phone and see the series of texts from Justin.

* CharacterShilling: Everyone talks about how great and nice Kelly is.

* TheyJustDidntCare: Let's just say that Kelly Clarkson's dislike of the film isn't hard to see. Furthermore, the movie is riddled with costume and scene continuity errors and at one point the entire set crew can be seen.

** Kelly doesn't realize that Alexa is screwing with her relationship ''[even after someone tells her that Alexa is screwing with her relationship]''.

** Kelly doesn't realize that Alexa is screwing with her relationship [i]even after someone tells her that Alexa is screwing with her relationship[/i].

* IdiotPlot: The whole tension of the story is that Justin lost Kelly's number and Alexa gave him the wrong one when he asked her for it (rather than just asking Kelly for it again). Somehow Alexa thought this would work out for her.
** Ironically, Justin was ready to dump Kelly for not returning his texts, so maybe it would have...

* TheyJustDidntCare: Let's just say that Kelly Clarkson dislike of the film isn't hard to see. Furthermore, the movie is riddled with costume and scene continuity errors and at one point the entire set crew can be seen.