History YMMV / DCLeagueOfSuperPets

** The film's versions of Superman and Lois Lane have been praised by DCU fans for being near pitch-perfect renditions of the characters, to where many want a movie directly focused on them.

* UnexpectedCharacter: Even with Creator/DwayneJohnson starring as Krypto, no one expected that he would also be pulling double duty as [[spoiler:Black Adam, who he also played in [[Film/BlackAdam2022 the character's then-upcoming solo feature]].]]

* AndYouThoughtItWouldFail: at the time the trailers where being released, it was met mostly with mixed-to-negative reaction from aundiences for its humor, especially considering the overly long scene where Ace pees in the fountain, changing the line-up and to a lesser extent Ace changing species and personality, with many believing the movie would at best receive mixed reviews; when the film released, people were actaully surprised that the movie received positive reviews from both critics and audiences.

** Many people are hyped for the film based solely on one element: Creator/KeanuReeves as Batman.

* {{Squick}}: the scene where Ace [[ToiletHumor pees in the fountain]] while Krypto gives a speech to both him and the other shelter pets; it is way too long, and was one of the reasons viewers had a bad impression of the movie, as it was prominently featured in the first two trailers.

* UnexpectedCharacter: Even with Creator/DwayneJohnson starring as Krypto, no one expected that he would also be pulling double duty as [[spoiler:Black Adam, who he's due to play in [[Film/BlackAdam2022 the character's solo feature]].]]

* AndYouThoughtItWouldFail: at the time the trailers where being released, audience reaction was met mostly with mixed-to-negative reaction for its humor, especially considering the overly long scene where Ace pees in the fountain, changing the line-up and to a lesser extent Ace changing species and personality, with many believing the movie would at best receive mixed reviews; when the film released, people were actaully surprised that the movie received positive reviews from both critics and audiences.

* AndYouThoughtItWiouldFail: at the time the trailers where being released, audience reaction was met mostly with mixed-to-negative reaction for its humor, especially considering the overly long scene where Ace pees in the fountain, changing the line-up and to a lesser extent Ace changing species and personality, with many believing the movie would at best receive mixed reviews; when the film released, people were actaully surprised that the movie received positive reviews from both critics and audiences.

* DarthWiki/NightmareFuel:
** Whiskers, full stop. She’s a WalkingArmory who takes sadistic glee in trying to murder the Super-Pets, all while speaking in a [[SoftSpokenSadist very creepy child-like voice]]. Her scene is pretty much ripped straight from a horror movie.

* EnsembleDarkhorse: The film's versions of Superman and Lois Lane have been praised by DCU fans for being near pitch-perfect renditions of the characters, to where many want a movie directly focused on them.

* AuthorsSavingThrow: Based on the first trailer, some fans didn't like the perspective of Ace not being connected to Batman in this universe, along with having invulnerability for a BadassNormal pet. The Batman-centric trailer shows that, eventually, Batman will have some kind of partnership with this Ace [[spoiler:(specifically, Ace becoming Batman's pet, as expected)]]. The fact that he's voiced by Creator/KeanuReeves is a nice bonus.

* JustHereForGodzilla: Many people are hyped for the film based solely on one element: Creator/KeanuReeves as Batman.

* DuelingDubs: Waffles has three different English voice actors. In the British version, he was voiced by English television presenter and actor Richard Arnold. In the Malaysian version, he was voiced by Malaysian actor Sean Lee.

* EnsembleDarkhorse: The films versions of Superman and Lois Lane have been praised by DCU fans for being near pitch-perfect renditions of the characters, to where many want a movie directly focused on them.

* WinBackTheCrowd: After three [[WesternAnimation/{{SCOOB}} critical]] [[Film/TomAndJerry2021 failure]] [[Film/SpaceJamANewLegacy adaptations]] from Warner Animation Group (no thanks to the loss of the Toys/{{LEGO}} license, their former critical cash cow), this movie received postive reviews from critics and audiences.