Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / ClashOfTheElements

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
YMMV can't be played with.


* ArcFatigue: The final battle of Part 1, which takes over ten chapters before it finally comes to an end, could noticeably have been cut down by a couple more if some {{Padding}} was cut and some chapter's events merged together. Averted in Part 2's final battle though.

to:

* ArcFatigue: The final battle of Part 1, which takes over ten chapters before it finally comes to an end, could noticeably have been cut down by a couple more if some {{Padding}} was cut and some chapter's events merged together. Averted in Part 2's final battle though.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* ChaoticEvil: Joe Dark
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Cackletta [[spoiler: Sacrificing one million lives and destroying Rogueport as the Shadow Queen just so she can prolong her own life]] is merely ONE of many instances where she crossed the MEH.
** [[spoiler: There is also Dimentio, who crossed this again when it is revealed that he purposely ruined Blumiere and Lady Timpani's life just to further his plans to get the Chaos Heart.]] What is particularly bad about this example is that [[spoiler: this is a MEH crossed by hundreds upon hundreds of alternate universe Luigis as well.]]

to:

** Cackletta [[spoiler: Sacrificing one million lives and destroying Rogueport as the Shadow Queen just so she can prolong her own life]] is merely ONE of many instances where she crossed the MEH.
line.
** [[spoiler: There is also Dimentio, who crossed this again when it is revealed that he purposely ruined Blumiere and Lady Timpani's life just to further his plans to get the Chaos Heart.]] What is particularly bad about this example is that [[spoiler: this is a MEH crossed by hundreds upon hundreds of alternate universe Luigis as well.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Cut out Complete Monster entry due to lack of qualifications.


* CompleteMonster: Unsurprisingly considering the game he originated from, [[spoiler: [[{{VideoGame/SuperPaperMario}} Dimentio]] qualifies for this trope. The atrocities he committed in that game still apply, but as he eventually reveals, not only is he the creator of the [[{{ArtifactOfDoom}} Dark Prognosticus]], but he is the one responsible for Blumiere's descent into madness, since he killed and disguised himself as his father and banished his love Lady Timpani in order to break his mind. AffablyEvil or not, this behavior cannot also excuse the fact that he continuously rubs his misdeeds into Luigi and Driad's faces in order to piss them both off. He is such a despicable villain that unlike his companion Smithy, his final moments do NOT qualify him for an AlasPoorVillain death just because he is such a morale-depraved individual!]]
** [[spoiler: Cackletta is this without any doubt. Not only is she responsible for the genocide and sinking of Old Rogueport as the Shadow Queen, but she casually killed off everyone who tried to go for the Elemental Stones simply so she could get her desired target. The lengths she goes to accomplish her goals basically suggest that she has such a low or no grip at all on any morality, and to prove this point she has stated that she has been in the [[{{KingdomHearts}} Realm of Darkness]] for two-thousand years, meaning that she has had a heart thick with darkness for all that time to avoid being turned into a Heartless. It looks like this trope may have been subverted via a FreudianExcuse that suggested that she was a WoobieDestroyerOfWorlds because of a rejection of love from the Dark King, but then she somehow [[{{Up To Eleven}} FURTHERS]] her own levels of monstrosity by admitting straight up that her OmnicidalManiac based plan was perfectly fine so long as she kills the one who stole the Dark King's attention from her. It REALLY says something when the above CompleteMonster even says that Cackletta is out of her mind.]]

Changed: 40

Removed: 506

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WoobieDestroyerofWorlds: [[spoiler: Smithy]]
** [[spoiler: Chaos Alex]] qualifies for this as well. On top of being [[spoiler: He starts off his "new" life by witnessing his mother/creator die before his eyes, and before he can do anything he is instantly taken over by the Dark Star, and act of which causes a lot of pain before he frees himself. And even after that he continues to be unaware of how callous his mother truly is as he goes out to fulfill her plans. And this isn't even getting into what happens as he fights his good counterpart...]]

to:

* WoobieDestroyerofWorlds: [[spoiler: Smithy]]
** [[spoiler: Chaos Alex]] qualifies for this as well. On top of being [[spoiler: He starts off his "new" life by witnessing his mother/creator die before his eyes, and before he can do anything he is instantly taken over by the Dark Star, and act of which causes a lot of pain before he frees himself. And even after that he continues to be unaware of how callous his mother truly is as he goes out to fulfill her plans. And this isn't even getting into what happens as he fights his good counterpart...]]
TheWoobie:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
These aren\'t YMMV. Moving.


* KarmaHoudini: Very, VERY Averted in the What-If for Movie 1. [[spoiler: Despite manipulating Tabuu for her goals, Cackletta is given a rightful punishment in the epilogue.]]
* MindScrew: Besides the aforementioned BigLippedAlligatorMoment entry, there is also the aftermath of [[spoiler: Cackletta's]] defeat in Chapter 42, which was actually done on purpose [[spoiler: by her]] to mess with Alex's head.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Alas Poor Villain is being moved back to Main. Examples that don\'t describe the moment or are purely editor opinion are being deleted.


* AlasPoorVillain: [[spoiler: Smithy]]
** [[spoiler: Tabuu]] subverts this though [[spoiler: because he wasn't a villain]]

Top