Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WesternAnimation / WhyCharlieBrownWhy

Go To

OR

Added: 211

Changed: 49

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GrewASpine: Linus not only learns to stand up to his domineering sister but also to a classmate who was bullying Janice at the playground.

to:

* GrewASpine: Linus not only learns to stand up to his domineering sister but also to a classmate playground bully who was bullying Janice at the playground.humiliating Janice.



* KnowNothingKnowItAll: Lucy genuinely believes that cancer is contagious like the common cold, to which Linus tries to correct her on. Lucy, of courses, refuses to listen; Linus calls her out on this big time.



** Following Linus's visit to the hospital and him calling out Lucy, we get a cute scene of Snoopy taking Woodstock and his friends sledding, probably to give the viewer a breather.

to:

** Following Linus's Linus' visit to the hospital and him calling out Lucy, we get a cute scene of Snoopy taking Woodstock and his friends sledding, probably to give the viewer a breather.

Added: 1151

Changed: 1535

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GreenEyedMonster: Downplayed with Janice's sisters; they reveal to Linus that since she got sick, they've received fewer presents or attention from their family, although they do understand why that's happening. When Linus lets them vent, and tells them they really do care about their sister, they do take time to appreciate her pile of presents knowing how happy she'll be.
** Surprisingly, there's no jealousy on Sally's part in this special, even though her "Sweet Babboo" clearly fancies Janice instead of her.
* HarmfulToMinors: A sobering case because it's all too realistic. A little girl in your class becomes sick for no reason, and develops a potentially incurable disease. The special was made when modern chemotherapy (which was as close to a "miracle cure" for leukemia as you could get) was just coming out of its infancy and into wide circulation[[note]]a significant part of the point of the special was to encourage ''parents'' who might otherwise hesitate to subject their child to the harshness of chemotherapy to go for it[[/note]]; up until the 1950s-60s, childhood-onset leukemia was a death sentence, as afflicted children would simply bleed to death from the lack of platelets. Charlie Brown and Linus demonstrate this fear best:

to:

* GreenEyedMonster: GreenEyedMonster:
**
Downplayed with Janice's sisters; they reveal to Linus that since she got sick, they've received fewer presents or attention from their family, although they do understand why that's happening. When Linus lets them vent, and tells them they really do care about their sister, they do take time to appreciate her pile of presents knowing how happy she'll be.
** Surprisingly, there's there is no jealousy on Sally's part in this special, even though her "Sweet Babboo" clearly fancies Janice instead of her.
* HarmfulToMinors: GrewASpine: Linus not only learns to stand up to his domineering sister but also to a classmate who was bullying Janice at the playground.
* HarmfulToMinors:
**
A sobering case because it's all too realistic. A little girl in your class becomes sick for no reason, and develops a potentially incurable disease. The special was made when modern chemotherapy (which was as close to a "miracle cure" for leukemia as you could get) was just coming out of its infancy and into wide circulation[[note]]a significant part of the point of the special was to encourage ''parents'' who might otherwise hesitate to subject their child to the harshness of chemotherapy to go for it[[/note]]; up until the 1950s-60s, childhood-onset leukemia was a death sentence, as afflicted children would simply bleed to death from the lack of platelets. Charlie Brown and Linus demonstrate this fear best:



* InsaneTrollLogic: Lucy believes that Linus caught cancer from Janice because he touched the latter's forehead, even though that's not how it actually works. Linus tries to correct her on this, but she refuses to listen, prompting Linus to call her out on her behavior.



* NotAfraidOfYouAnymore: Linus does this upon Lucy discovering he was visiting Janice, and had checked her forehead for a fever. Since Linus knew he can't catch cancer like a cold, he yells at his normally bully of a sister for her remarks. Linus goes as far as standing up against a schoolyard bully for making fun of Janice's baldness, a side-effect of chemotherapy.

to:

* NotAfraidOfYouAnymore: Linus does this upon Lucy discovering he was visiting Janice, Janice and had checked her forehead for a fever. Since Linus knew he can't catch cancer like a cold, he yells at his normally bully of a sister for her remarks. Linus goes as far as standing up against a schoolyard bully for making fun of Janice's baldness, a side-effect of chemotherapy.



* OOCIsSeriousBusiness: Linus, all the way! You know he's way out of character when he finds it in himself to actually yell at Lucy, a person who usually intimidates him with her fists, and verbally tearing a bully apart for mocking Janice's condition. He's also not seen with his blanket at all! Not even '''once'''. In fact, the latter was even a deliberate choice BY Schulz to emphasize the seriousness of the subject matter.

to:

* OOCIsSeriousBusiness: Linus, all the way! way. You know he's he is way out of character when he finds it in himself to actually yell at Lucy, a person who usually intimidates him with her fists, and verbally tearing a bully apart for mocking Janice's condition. He's He is also not seen with his blanket at all! Not all -- not even '''once'''. In fact, the latter was even a deliberate choice BY ''by'' Schulz to emphasize the seriousness of the subject matter.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removed per thread.


* AnAesop:
** Bad things happen to everyone and there isn't really an answer for it. However, that doesn't mean you should give up hope.
** Even in the toughest of times and changes, it is important to stay positive and live life to the fullest.
** A more minor one, regarding Janice's baldness: Don't pick on someone who looks different. You never know what they're going through.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


First aired on Creator/{{CBS}} (and in Canada on Creator/{{CBC}}) in 1990, this ''Franchise/{{Peanuts}}'' special (the 33rd overall) is notable as the first animated cartoon to tackle the subject of cancer. Sadly, ''Peanuts'' creator Charles Schulz would lose his own battle with the disease a decade later, but his approach to the topic was a brave move and has been celebrated and replayed for decades.

to:

First aired on Creator/{{CBS}} (and in Canada on Creator/{{CBC}}) in 1990, this ''Franchise/{{Peanuts}}'' special (the 33rd overall) is notable as the first animated cartoon to tackle the subject of cancer. Sadly, ''Peanuts'' creator Charles Schulz Creator/CharlesSchulz would lose his own battle with the disease a decade later, but his approach to the topic was a brave move and has been celebrated and replayed for decades.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BaldnessMockery: PlayedForDrama. Janice goes through [[BaldnessMeansSickness chemotherapy due to her leukemia, which makes her lose her hair]]. A rude kid [[TheBully laughs at her for it]], driving her to tears. Linus then [[TheReasonYouSuckSpeech sets the guy straight]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Surprisingly, there's no jealousy on Sally's part in this special, even though her "Sweet Babboo" clearly fancies Janice instead of her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdvertisedExtra: Janice appeared in this special and this special alone, but also appears in various postcards, puzzles and get-well cards. She's also appeared as a non-speaking background character in contemporary productions of ''Theater/YoureAGoodManCharlieBrown''.

to:

* AdvertisedExtra: Janice appeared in this special and this special alone, but also appears in various postcards, puzzles and get-well cards. She's also appeared as a non-speaking background character in contemporary productions of ''Theater/YoureAGoodManCharlieBrown''.''Theatre/YoureAGoodManCharlieBrown''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdvertisedExtra: Janice appeared in this special and this special alone, but also appears in various postcards, puzzles and get-well cards.

to:

* AdvertisedExtra: Janice appeared in this special and this special alone, but also appears in various postcards, puzzles and get-well cards. She's also appeared as a non-speaking background character in contemporary productions of ''Theater/YoureAGoodManCharlieBrown''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** A more minor one, regarding Janice's baldness: Don't pick on someone who looks different. You never know what they're going through.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


First aired on Creator/{{CBS}} in 1990, this ''Franchise/{{Peanuts}}'' special (the 33rd overall) is notable as the first animated cartoon to tackle the subject of cancer. Sadly, ''Peanuts'' creator Charles Schulz would lose his own battle with the disease a decade later, but his approach to the topic was a brave move and has been celebrated and replayed for decades.

to:

First aired on Creator/{{CBS}} (and in Canada on Creator/{{CBC}}) in 1990, this ''Franchise/{{Peanuts}}'' special (the 33rd overall) is notable as the first animated cartoon to tackle the subject of cancer. Sadly, ''Peanuts'' creator Charles Schulz would lose his own battle with the disease a decade later, but his approach to the topic was a brave move and has been celebrated and replayed for decades.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RememberTheNewGuy: Janice is a CanonForeigner that happens to be friends with Linus, Charlie Brown and Sally.

to:

* RememberTheNewGuy: Janice is a CanonForeigner that happens to be friends with Linus, Charlie Brown and Sally. She would later appear as a non-speaking background character in updated productions of ''Theatre/YoureAGoodManCharlieBrown'', but otherwise hasn't appeared in the ''Peanuts'' canon since 1990.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* InnocentlyInsensitive: When Janice explains to them that she has cancer, Charlie Brown directly asks her if that means she's going to die. Obviously he's not doing it out of malice, but Linus still gets annoyed by it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IdenticalStranger: Janice's sisters resemble Frieda[[note]]The girl with the naturally curly hair[[/note]] and Patty[[note]]Not ''Peppermint'' Patty, the original Patty who was a major character in earlier years of the comic strip[[/note]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdvertisedExtra: Janice appeared in this special and this special alone, but also appears in various postcards, puzzles and even get-well cards.

to:

* AdvertisedExtra: Janice appeared in this special and this special alone, but also appears in various postcards, puzzles and even get-well cards.



* FromTheMouthsOfBabes: Very notable.

to:

* FromTheMouthsOfBabes: Very notable.FromTheMouthsOfBabes:



* OOCIsSeriousBusiness: Linus, all the way! You know he's way out of character when he finds it in himself to actually yell at Lucy, a person who usually intimidates him with her fists, not to mention verbally tearing a bully apart for mocking Janice's condition. What's also notable is that he's not seen with his blanket at all! Not even '''once'''. In fact, the latter was even a deliberate choice BY Schulz to emphasize the seriousness of the subject matter.

to:

* OOCIsSeriousBusiness: Linus, all the way! You know he's way out of character when he finds it in himself to actually yell at Lucy, a person who usually intimidates him with her fists, not to mention and verbally tearing a bully apart for mocking Janice's condition. What's He's also notable is that he's not seen with his blanket at all! Not even '''once'''. In fact, the latter was even a deliberate choice BY Schulz to emphasize the seriousness of the subject matter.



* TheTopicOfCancer: The special is notably the first animated cartoon to tackle the subject of cancer, and the subject is treated with appropriate seriousness.

to:

* TheTopicOfCancer: The special is notably the first animated cartoon to tackle the subject of cancer, and the subject is treated with appropriate seriousness.



* VerySpecialEpisode: An extremely notable example -- this special was the first to address cancer in an animated format, at least in the English language. A great many of the Very Special Episodes about illness and whatnot in the [=90s=] and beyond were attempting to copy this special and achieve the same impact it had (and said impact was significant).

to:

* VerySpecialEpisode: An extremely notable example -- this This special was the first to address cancer in an animated format, at least in the English language. A great many of the Very Special Episodes about illness and whatnot in the [=90s=] and beyond were attempting to copy this special and achieve the same impact it had (and said impact was significant).

Removed: 186

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
As written, this doesn't look like an example of "listing a small thing after multiple big things".


* ArsonMurderAndJaywalking: As Janice describes her treatment, Charlie Brown reacts viscerally to her describing them taking samples of her blood and bone marrow and asks her if it hurt.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Lots of children's programming averts this. It's not really notable to mention it.

Removed: 413

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Lots of children's programming averts this. It's not really notable to mention it.


* NeverSayDie: Probably one of the biggest, most notable aversions in modern children's programming; the special makes absolutely no bones about the fact that Janice's condition is life-threatening and is willing to discuss it at length. Charlie Brown even famously comes right out and asks Janice if she's going to die from her illness. It's also one of the elements that makes the special as effective as it is.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Berserk Button is supposed to be for minor issues.


* BerserkButton: The normally weak Linus finds the courage in himself to defend Janice from Lucy and a bully when they mock her, yelling at the former and almost getting into a fight with the latter. He previously scolded Charlie Brown for asking Janice if she was going to die, although Janice assured him it was okay.

Added: 1562

Changed: 128

Removed: 1272

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdultFear: A little girl in your class becomes sick for no reason, and develops a potentially incurable disease. The special was made when modern chemotherapy (which was as close to a "miracle cure" for leukemia as you could get) was just coming out of its infancy and into wide circulation[[note]]a significant part of the point of the special was to encourage ''parents'' who might otherwise hesitate to subject their child to the harshness of chemotherapy to go for it[[/note]]; up until the 1950s-60s, childhood-onset leukemia was a death sentence, as afflicted children would simply bleed to death from the lack of platelets. Charlie Brown and Linus demonstrate this fear best:
** Charlie Brown says that cancer sounds scary and asks, "Are you going to die?"
** Linus does the TitleDrop because he cannot find an answer for why someone he likes, and who has done nothing to deserve it, is struck at random with cancer. The special is about him being the depressed one for once, and realizing that there is not an answer for everything.
** Janice's sisters bear the emotional burden of watching their sister go through painful treatments while being accidentally neglected in turn. After venting to Linus, they manage to say that Janice's pile of presents looks nice.



* HarmfulToMinors: A sobering case because it's all too realistic. A little girl in your class becomes sick for no reason, and develops a potentially incurable disease. The special was made when modern chemotherapy (which was as close to a "miracle cure" for leukemia as you could get) was just coming out of its infancy and into wide circulation[[note]]a significant part of the point of the special was to encourage ''parents'' who might otherwise hesitate to subject their child to the harshness of chemotherapy to go for it[[/note]]; up until the 1950s-60s, childhood-onset leukemia was a death sentence, as afflicted children would simply bleed to death from the lack of platelets. Charlie Brown and Linus demonstrate this fear best:
** Charlie Brown says that cancer sounds scary and asks, "Are you going to die?"
** Linus does the TitleDrop because he cannot find an answer for why someone he likes, and who has done nothing to deserve it, is struck at random with cancer. The special is about him being the depressed one for once, and realizing that there is not an answer for everything.
** Janice's sisters bear the emotional burden of watching their sister go through painful treatments while being accidentally neglected in turn. After venting to Linus, they manage to say that Janice's pile of presents looks nice.



* LittlestCancerPatient: Janice Emmons.

to:

* LittlestCancerPatient: Janice Emmons.Emmons develops leukemia, which fortunately her parents caught early thanks to Linus advising her to go to the nurse.



* TruthInTelevision: The scene with Snoopy dressed as a surgeon and eating junk food from the hospital cafeteria is very true. Owing to the stress of training and being on call, many doctors in hospitals will eat available ComfortFood.



** Subverted in one case; Linus calls out Charlie Brown for asking Janice [[AdultFear "Are you going to die?"]] but Janice says it's okay, since she asked her doctors the same question. She then proceeds to explain to them about the process of her treatment.

to:

** Subverted in one case; Linus calls out Charlie Brown for asking Janice [[AdultFear [[HarmfulToMinors "Are you going to die?"]] but Janice says it's okay, since she asked her doctors the same question. She then proceeds to explain to them about the process of her treatment.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


On an autumn day, Linus notices his classmate Janice is getting a lot of bruises and feeling tired, so he convinces her to see the nurse. When he learns about Janice and her cancer diagnosis, Linus starts to go through a change. As Janice's treatment for cancer progresses, the seasons changes to symbolize this, and Linus becomes stronger for being emotionally affected by the issues, even going as far as to [[TookALevelInBadass chew out Lucy and a schoolyard bully]] for their picking on Janice.

to:

On an autumn day, Linus notices his classmate Janice is getting a lot of bruises and feeling tired, so he convinces her to see the nurse. When he learns about Janice and her Janice's cancer diagnosis, Linus starts to go through a change. As Janice's treatment for cancer progresses, the seasons changes to symbolize this, and Linus becomes stronger for being emotionally affected by the issues, even going as far as to [[TookALevelInBadass chew out Lucy and a schoolyard bully]] for their picking on Janice.



* CanonForeigner: Janice Emmons, who was invented specifically for this special (though apparently [[RememberTheNewGuy Charlie Brown, Linus, and Sally already knew her]]). She didn't end up integrated into the wider ''Peanuts'' cast, [[TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter to the frustration of some]].

to:

* CanonForeigner: Janice Emmons, who was invented specifically for this special (though apparently [[RememberTheNewGuy Charlie Brown, Linus, and Sally already knew her]]). She didn't end up integrated into the wider ''Peanuts'' cast, [[TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter to the frustration of some]].some fans]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Bad things happen to everyone and there is not really an answer for it. However, that doesn’t mean you should give up hope.

to:

** Bad things happen to everyone and there is not isn't really an answer for it. However, that doesn’t doesn't mean you should give up hope.



* BaldnessMeansSickness: Janice becomes bald after getting chemotherapy. Though she wears a hat to hide it, it eventually gets knocked off to reveal that she's gone bald, and she breaks down in tears when a boy bullies her because of it.

to:

* BaldnessMeansSickness: Janice becomes bald after getting chemotherapy. Though she wears a hat to hide it, it eventually gets knocked off to reveal that she's gone bald, and she breaks down in tears [[KickTheDog when a boy bullies her because of it.it]].



* BewareTheNiceOnes: A bully removes Janice's hat, which covered her baldness, and then loudly mocking her baldness until she cried. Linus then proceeds to verbally destroy him.
* CanonForeigner: Janice Emmons, who was invented specifically for this special (though apparently [[RememberTheNewGuy Charlie Brown, Linus, and Sally already knew her]]). She didn't end up integrated into the wider ''Peanuts'' cast, to the frustration of some.

to:

* BewareTheNiceOnes: A bully removes Janice's hat, which covered her baldness, and then loudly mocking her baldness until she cried. Linus then proceeds [[TheReasonYouSuckSpeech to verbally destroy him.
him]].
* CanonForeigner: Janice Emmons, who was invented specifically for this special (though apparently [[RememberTheNewGuy Charlie Brown, Linus, and Sally already knew her]]). She didn't end up integrated into the wider ''Peanuts'' cast, [[TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter to the frustration of some.some]].



* KickTheDog: The bully does this to Janice by tossing away her hat and announcing loudly that she's bald. [[RageBreakingPoint He ends up paying for it]].

to:

* KickTheDog: The bully does this to Janice by tossing away her hat and announcing loudly that she's bald. [[RageBreakingPoint He ends up paying for it]].it [[RageBreakingPoint thanks to Linus]].



* NotAfraidOfYouAnymore: Linus does this upon Lucy discovering he was visiting Janice, and had checked her forehead for a fever. Since Linus knew he can't catch cancer like a cold, he yells at his normally bully of a sister for her remarks. Linus goes as far as standing up against a school yard bully for making fun of Janice's baldness, a side-effect of chemotherapy.

to:

* NotAfraidOfYouAnymore: Linus does this upon Lucy discovering he was visiting Janice, and had checked her forehead for a fever. Since Linus knew he can't catch cancer like a cold, he yells at his normally bully of a sister for her remarks. Linus goes as far as standing up against a school yard schoolyard bully for making fun of Janice's baldness, a side-effect of chemotherapy.



* VerySpecialEpisode: An extremely notable example - this special was the first to address cancer in an animated format, at least in the English language. A great many of the Very Special Episodes about illness and whatnot in the [=90s=] and beyond were attempting to copy this special and achieve the same impact it had (and said impact was significant).

to:

* VerySpecialEpisode: An extremely notable example - -- this special was the first to address cancer in an animated format, at least in the English language. A great many of the Very Special Episodes about illness and whatnot in the [=90s=] and beyond were attempting to copy this special and achieve the same impact it had (and said impact was significant).



** Played straight when Lucy freaks out on Linus touching Janice to check for a fever, worried that he'll pass on "cancer germs" to Lucy. Linus first tries to calmly explain to Lucy that you can't catch cancer the way that you have a cold, but she won't listen and orders him to take away the glass of milk he just brought her. Linus [[TranquilFury refuses]], because he doesn't want to [[IronicEcho catch her crabbiness]].

to:

** Played straight when Lucy freaks out on Linus touching Janice to check for a fever, worried that he'll pass on "cancer germs" to Lucy. Linus first tries to calmly explain to Lucy that you can't catch cancer the way that you have a cold, but she won't listen and orders him to take away the glass of milk he just brought her. Linus [[TranquilFury calmly refuses]], because he doesn't want to [[IronicEcho catch her crabbiness]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheTopicOfCancer: The special is notably the first animated cartoon to tackle the subject of cancer, and the subject is treated with appropriate seriousness.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Bad things happen to everyone and there is not really an answer for it. However, that doesn’t mean you should be give up hope.

to:

** Bad things happen to everyone and there is not really an answer for it. However, that doesn’t mean you should be give up hope.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
YMMV tropes may not appear outside YMMV pages.


First aired on Creator/{{CBS}} in 1990, this ''Franchise/{{Peanuts}}'' special (the 33rd overall) is notable as the first animated cartoon to tackle the subject of cancer. Sadly, ''Peanuts'' creator Charles Schulz [[HarsherInHindsight would lose his own battle with the disease a decade later]], but his approach to the topic was a brave move and has been celebrated and replayed for decades.

to:

First aired on Creator/{{CBS}} in 1990, this ''Franchise/{{Peanuts}}'' special (the 33rd overall) is notable as the first animated cartoon to tackle the subject of cancer. Sadly, ''Peanuts'' creator Charles Schulz [[HarsherInHindsight would lose his own battle with the disease a decade later]], later, but his approach to the topic was a brave move and has been celebrated and replayed for decades.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
removed because Bald Women is being disambiged


* BaldWoman: Janice becomes one after getting chemotherapy. Though she wears a hat to hide it, it eventually gets knocked off to reveal that she's gone bald, and she breaks down in tears when a boy bullies her because of it.

to:

* BaldWoman: BaldnessMeansSickness: Janice becomes one bald after getting chemotherapy. Though she wears a hat to hide it, it eventually gets knocked off to reveal that she's gone bald, and she breaks down in tears when a boy bullies her because of it.

Top