Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WMG / TheWestWing

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trope has been renamed to Chuck Cunningham Syndrome.


[[WMG: [[{{BrotherChuck}} Mandy]] willingly quit her job at the White House to...]]

to:

[[WMG: [[{{BrotherChuck}} Mandy]] Mandy willingly quit her job at the White House to...]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

WildMassGuessing for ''Series/TheWestWing''.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Agreed. Saving a group of astronauts' lives at the price of revealing the existence of a top secret shuttle is exactly the kind of thing Bartlet would do if it were just him making the decision. But since he's the President, that's not the kind of choice he can make. And the fact that someone on his senior staff, someone he's known and trusted for years, deliberately went behind his back and took that choice away from him probably ranks as the most damning sort of betrayal. But even then, he doesn't fire Toby because of personal reasons; indeed, when he passes down his judgment, he's much calmer than in the rest of the conversation, telling Toby, "I can't accept your resignation for this, Toby. I have to fire you." It shows that he's not firing Toby because of his betrayal of Bartlet personally, but because the magnitude of his security breech was so great that the public wouldn't accept anything less as a punishment. Letting Toby resign would show tact approval for his actions in the public eye, which would be political suicide. And even the decision to write a pardon came at (almost literally) the last minute.

to:

** Agreed. Saving a group of astronauts' lives at the price of revealing the existence of a top secret shuttle is exactly the kind of thing Bartlet would do if it were just him making the decision. But since he's the President, that's not the kind of choice he can make. And the fact that someone on his senior staff, someone he's known and trusted for years, deliberately went behind his back and took that choice away from him probably ranks as the most damning sort of betrayal. But even then, he doesn't fire Toby because of personal reasons; indeed, when he passes down his judgment, he's much calmer than in the rest of the conversation, telling Toby, "I can't accept your resignation for this, Toby. I have to fire you." It shows that he's not firing Toby because of his betrayal of Bartlet personally, but because the magnitude of his security breech was so great that the public wouldn't accept anything less as a punishment. Letting Toby resign would show tact tacit approval for his actions in the public eye, which would be political suicide. And even the decision to write a pardon came at (almost literally) the last minute.




to:

* Or just back to the Wizarding world and everyone was Obliviated.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Josiah Bartlet is Dolores Landingham's [[StarWars padawan]]]]

to:

[[WMG: Josiah Bartlet is Dolores Landingham's [[StarWars [[Franchise/StarWars padawan]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* This also means that ''Film/TheTrialOfTheChicago7'' could be an entirely accurate account of how the events of the movie played out in TWW's history. It would also explain why certain phrases (aka Sorkinisms) could be repeated in that movie, because the characters may have been friends with the characters from TWW in their later years.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[WMG: The show takes place in the same reality as ''Series/ThePlotAgainstAmerica'']]
The final episode of ''Series/ThePlotAgainstAmerica'' shows a special Presidential election taking place in 1942, which would mean that future elections would be two years off elections in the real world in that universe too.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In fact, red hair is disproportionately common among Ashkenazi Jews.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Josh is the political savant of the cast and Leo knows he would recognize a great candidate when everyone else might be looking in a different direction - and he knows Josh is the one most likely to run a successful campaign. Furthermore, he knows that being CoS is Josh's main career goal and he wants his surrogate son to be able to do so for a "fresh", new president with at least four years ahead of him. Appointing him Bartlet's CoS would have locked him in, but by finding his own candidate and running his campaign he would be able to take the CoS job from the very starting point of a new administration. Essentially, Leo wanted Josh to be able to do what Leo himself had done with Bartlet - and it worked.

to:

Josh is the political savant of the cast and Leo knows he would recognize a great candidate when everyone else might be looking in a different direction - and he knows Josh is the one most likely to run a successful campaign. Furthermore, he knows that being CoS Chief of Staff is Josh's main career goal and he wants his surrogate son to be able to do so for a "fresh", new president with at least four years ahead of him. Appointing him Bartlet's CoS [=CoS=] would have locked him in, but by finding his own candidate and running his campaign he would be able to take the CoS [=CoS=] job from the very starting point of a new administration. Essentially, Leo wanted Josh to be able to do what Leo himself had done with Bartlet - and it worked.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* His last name is Casper, as in the Friendly Ghost? That's a made-up name if I ever heard one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: President Bartlet actually ''did'' serve in the military.]]
Despite complaints by several people, (especially in Season 1's ''Take Out the Trash Day'' and Season 4's ''Red Haven's On Fire'',) Jed Bartlet fought in Vietnam, but was registered under a pseudonym, [[Film/ApocalypseNow Captain Benjamin Willard]].
Being a Special Operations assassin with skills to basically go it alone, with missions as sensitive as taking down a rogue colonel in a supposedly-neutral country, would need utter secrecy, hence the "Willard" pseudonym. He got back his real name after the war.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* This is a theory that even Coulson's own actor Creator/ClarkGregg supports.

to:

* This is a theory that even Coulson's own actor Creator/ClarkGregg supports.
[[https://twitter.com/clarkgregg/status/205790235668385793 supports]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Quasi-{{canon}}ical because the show features skewed election cycles to the ones in the real world, but over the years many fans have suggested various jumping off points for when the timeline skew happened. A popular one is that Nixon was impeached and a special election was held, restarting the 4-year Presidential cycle at 1974. Perhaps, since Ford didn't pardon Nixon, he wins the 1976 election instead of losing narrowly as in our universe. By the time Ronald Reagan gets a chance to be elected, he's considered far too old or showing clear signs of Alzheimner's. There's never a "Reagan Revolution," and the whole US political climate is less viciously partisan. This explains why everyone seems much more polite and reasonable on TheWestWing, and why a Democratic White House could hire two Republican lawyers, which would be impossible (or at least controversial) in our universe.

to:

Quasi-{{canon}}ical because the show features skewed election cycles to the ones in the real world, but over the years many fans have suggested various jumping off points for when the timeline skew happened. A popular one is that Nixon was impeached and a special election was held, restarting the 4-year Presidential cycle at 1974. Perhaps, since Ford didn't pardon Nixon, he wins the 1976 election instead of losing narrowly as in our universe. By the time Ronald Reagan gets a chance to be elected, he's considered far too old or showing clear signs of Alzheimner's. There's never a "Reagan Revolution," and the whole US political climate is less viciously partisan. This explains why everyone seems much more polite and reasonable on TheWestWing, ''Series/TheWestWing'', and why a Democratic White House could hire two Republican lawyers, which would be impossible (or at least controversial) in our universe.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** I remember hearing Sam and Ainsley mentioned at least once after their characters had disappeared. I don't recall what it was for Ainsley, but after Josh had a particularly disastrous TV appearance someone mentioned to him that Sam had called to ask how he was doing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Alternate Solution: They chose not to invoke the fourth section, or didn't have time. A president has only been shot once in real life since the 25th Amendment was passed (Ronald Reagan) and the fourth section was not invoked; according to The Other Wiki, it's because Vice President Bush was on a plane at the time so couldn't assemble the cabinet. If I recall Hoynes had to be yanked from a speaking engagement elsewhere in the country and Bartlet's surgery took at most a few hours so I'm not sure it would've been possible to invoke it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** But didn't Lassiter directly precede Bartlet? I'm not sure they ever outright said that, but the fact that Newman and Walken were the only living former presidents at the time of Lassiter's funeral makes it unlikely that there was another president in there somewhere, especially considering the series starts less than a year into Bartlet's presidency, so this phantom president would've had to have died a few months after leaving office for there to not be any mention of his funeral.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ...return to her [[{{OneTreeHill}} hometown in North Carolina with her teenaged son.]] Her real name was Karen, and "Mandy" was just a professional pseudonym she took up while working in Washington. Bartlett and the White House security had to know "Mandy"/Karen's real name, of course, for security purposes (because after all, this ''is'' TheWhiteHouse), but the public only knew her as "Mandy" in order to protect her privacy and allow her son to have a relatively normal life. Eventually when Karen moved back to Tree Hill, nobody seemed to even realize that she had been one of Bartlett's staff members.

to:

* ...return to her [[{{OneTreeHill}} [[{{Series/OneTreeHill}} hometown in North Carolina with her teenaged son.]] Her real name was Karen, and "Mandy" was just a professional pseudonym she took up while working in Washington. Bartlett and the White House security had to know "Mandy"/Karen's real name, of course, for security purposes (because after all, this ''is'' TheWhiteHouse), but the public only knew her as "Mandy" in order to protect her privacy and allow her son to have a relatively normal life. Eventually when Karen moved back to Tree Hill, nobody seemed to even realize that she had been one of Bartlett's staff members.



<<|WildMassGuessing|>>


to:

<<|WildMassGuessing|>>

<<|WildMassGuessing|>>
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[WMG: Leo insisted on CJ as Chief of Staff because he wanted Josh to go out and find the next democratic president]]
Josh is the political savant of the cast and Leo knows he would recognize a great candidate when everyone else might be looking in a different direction - and he knows Josh is the one most likely to run a successful campaign. Furthermore, he knows that being CoS is Josh's main career goal and he wants his surrogate son to be able to do so for a "fresh", new president with at least four years ahead of him. Appointing him Bartlet's CoS would have locked him in, but by finding his own candidate and running his campaign he would be able to take the CoS job from the very starting point of a new administration. Essentially, Leo wanted Josh to be able to do what Leo himself had done with Bartlet - and it worked.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: FBI Special Agent Mike Casper is merely a cover identity for SHIELD Agent [[Film/TheAvengers Phil Coulson]]]]

to:

[[WMG: FBI Special Agent Mike Casper is merely a cover identity for SHIELD Agent [[Film/TheAvengers [[Film/TheAvengers2012 Phil Coulson]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


When Sam meets Will and Elsie working on their Californian campaign, he instantly assumes that they are, or were, romantically involved. It's a reasonable assumption for an Aaron Sorkin show - two young, attractive people of the appropriate gender working together are almost guaranteed to have some kind of romantic history, the more excruciating the better. But Will describes Elsie as his "stepsister", so that's out. And yet - why make her a ''step''sister? For the same reason Boone and Shannon on {{Lost}} were stepsiblings - so they could have a shocking incestuous affair without genetic issues. This would explain why Will is so reluctant to work in the White House - he's afraid of being found out and causing yet another scandal for the administration. Presumably, this storyline was quietly dropped when Aaron Sorkin left the show, and Elsie with him.

to:

When Sam meets Will and Elsie working on their Californian campaign, he instantly assumes that they are, or were, romantically involved. It's a reasonable assumption for an Aaron Sorkin show - two young, attractive people of the appropriate gender working together are almost guaranteed to have some kind of romantic history, the more excruciating the better. But Will describes Elsie as his "stepsister", so that's out. And yet - why make her a ''step''sister? For the same reason Boone and Shannon on {{Lost}} ''Series/{{Lost}}'' were stepsiblings - so they could have a shocking incestuous affair without genetic issues. This would explain why Will is so reluctant to work in the White House - he's afraid of being found out and causing yet another scandal for the administration. Presumably, this storyline was quietly dropped when Aaron Sorkin left the show, and Elsie with him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This is the generally accepted explanation. Ford then won the 1974 election, then lost in 1978 to D W Newman (a JimmyCarter analogue), who would in turn lose in 1982 to Owen Lassiter (a RonaldReagan analogue), who would serve two terms before being succeeded by an unnamed centrist Republican (judging by how Leo was a cabinet member despite being a Democrat), who also served two terms before Bartlet's first win in 1998.

to:

** This is the generally accepted explanation. Ford then won the 1974 election, then lost in 1978 to D W D.W. Newman (a JimmyCarter UsefulNotes/JimmyCarter analogue), who would in turn lose in 1982 to Owen Lassiter (a RonaldReagan UsefulNotes/RonaldReagan analogue), who would serve two terms before being succeeded by an unnamed centrist Republican (judging by how Leo was a cabinet member despite being a Democrat), who also served two terms before Bartlet's first win in 1998.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Alternately, the third is currently on-orbit and unavailable (the Shuttle's orbital delta-V with a smallish payload is only about a kilometer per second).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: FBI Special Agent Mike Casper is merely a cover identity of SHIELD Agent [[Film/TheAvengers Phil Coulson]]]]
[[Film/IronMan Tony]] was righter than he knew when he said that Coulson's first name was agent...

to:

[[WMG: FBI Special Agent Mike Casper is merely a cover identity of for SHIELD Agent [[Film/TheAvengers Phil Coulson]]]]
[[Film/IronMan Tony]] Tony Stark]] was righter than he knew when he said that Coulson's first name was agent...
"agent"...
*This is a theory that even Coulson's own actor Creator/ClarkGregg supports.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* There are red-haired Jews, just as there are blonde Jews and black Jews and so forth. Not all Jews have "Jewish" names. Since many immigrants to the U.S. changed or shortened their names, her ancestors could have been, for instance, Polish Jews with a name that started with "wy-" and they just changed it to Wyatt.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Alternatively, his fiancee is Laurie, the law student prostitute. She went to California to escape the media circus and reunited with Sam.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[WMG: Jed Bartlet is actually adopted, and the biological son of [[Series/MadMen Peggy Olson]]]]
A childless wealthy couple from New Hampshire wanted a heir, and fortunately, there was a young girl up in New York with an illegitimate baby. Sure, being born in 1960 might make him a little young for how he looks on the show, but MS and the Presidency would age anyone. Jed's father's resentment of him is not just envy of his intellect but the living reminder of his own infertility. This would, of course, make his REAL mother Catholic as well, which might make it all the more important to have him raised as such. And of course, it explains Zoey.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Mandy was an [[HarryPotter Auror]]]]

to:

[[WMG: Mandy was an [[HarryPotter [[Franchise/HarryPotter Auror]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: The First Lady Abagail Bartlet was once known as [[Film/{{Grease}} Rizzo]]

to:

[[WMG: The First Lady Abagail Bartlet was once known as [[Film/{{Grease}} Rizzo]]Rizzo]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: The First Lady Abagail Bartlet was once known as [[Film/Grease Rizzo]]]]

to:

[[WMG: The First Lady Abagail Bartlet was once known as [[Film/Grease Rizzo]]]][[Film/{{Grease}} Rizzo]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: The First Lady Abagail Bartlet was once known as [[Film/Grease Rizzo]]]]
Her relationship with Danny Zuko didn't last and she decided to clean up her act. She decided to change her name, go to med school and attended Notre Dame. Only Jed knows about her wild past and her exceptional singing ability.

Top