Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WMG / StarTrekTheOriginalSeries

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The problem here is production order vs order episodes aired, som episodes were aired close to their production date and som much earlier or later, this involved differences in terminology, (consider terms such as Vulcanian rather than Vulcan.) As even now there is inconsistency in terminology due to age, location, experience and so on, it is really just that here as well.

to:

* The problem here is production order vs order episodes aired, som some episodes were aired close to their production date and som some much earlier or later, this involved differences in terminology, (consider terms such as Vulcanian rather than Vulcan.) As even now there is inconsistency in terminology due to age, location, experience and so on, it is really just that here as well.

Added: 378

Changed: 228

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** While the Enterprise was a training vessel at the time, Spock was the captain of the ship in ''Film/StarTrekIITheWrathOfKhan''. So somebody with authority thought he was captain material. He is addessed as captain in rank.



* It's common knowledge that Walter Koenig's "Russian accent" is spectacularly bad, which sort of lent to the NarmCharm of the character. However, from an InUniverse point of view, what if Chekov actually suffers from a kind of speech impediment that leaves hum unable to pronounce "v's" correctly? The nu-Chekov "Wiktor... wiktor..." scene sort of supports it, given that he's struggling to pronounce it.

to:

* It's common knowledge that Walter Koenig's "Russian accent" is spectacularly bad, which sort of lent to the NarmCharm of the character. However, from an InUniverse point of view, what if Chekov actually suffers from a kind of speech impediment that leaves hum him unable to pronounce "v's" correctly? The nu-Chekov "Wiktor... wiktor..." scene sort of supports it, given that he's struggling to pronounce it.


Added DiffLines:

* The problem here is production order vs order episodes aired, som episodes were aired close to their production date and som much earlier or later, this involved differences in terminology, (consider terms such as Vulcanian rather than Vulcan.) As even now there is inconsistency in terminology due to age, location, experience and so on, it is really just that here as well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the episode [[Recap/StarTrekS1E19TomorrowIsYesterday "Tomorrow Is Yesterday"]] we find the ship's computer was given a female voice after being repaired on Cygnet [=XIV=], a planet dominated by women. Those in charge of repairing the computer reprogrammed the computer so that it speaks in a female voice, constantly calling the Captain "dear" and having "an unfortunate tendency to giggle", explained by Spock in deadpan seriousness as because they "felt it lacked personality". Much to the annoyance of Captain Kirk, naturally, and providing some comic relief for the audience.\\\

to:

* In the episode [[Recap/StarTrekS1E19TomorrowIsYesterday "Tomorrow Is Yesterday"]] we find the ship's computer was given a female voice after being repaired on Cygnet [=XIV=], a planet dominated by women. Those in charge of repairing the computer reprogrammed the computer so that it speaks in a female voice, constantly calling the Captain "dear" and having "an unfortunate tendency to giggle", explained by Spock in deadpan seriousness as seriousness, because they "felt it lacked personality". Much to the annoyance of Captain Kirk, naturally, and providing some comic relief for the audience.\\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Alternatively, this being a gangster planet, and the fact the mooks were obviously tricked, it ended up becoming an elaborate confidence game.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Secondary edit since i almost ran out of time with the first one.


In "The Corbomite Maneuver", Kirk says the Enterprise is a ''United Earth'' ship. the U.E. is the same governing body that Archer and his crew answered to, and it's not until "Arena" (the 19th episode) that Kirk speaks of the Federation. All of this could suggest that the ''Temporal Cold War'' ended inbetween Kirk's missions to Beta VI and Cestus III.

to:

In "The Corbomite Maneuver", Kirk says the Enterprise is a ''United Earth'' ship. the U.E. is the same governing body that Archer and his crew answered to, and it's not until "Arena" (the 19th episode) that Kirk speaks of the Federation. All of this could suggest that the when the ''Temporal Cold War'' ended inbetween Kirk's missions to Beta VI and Cestus III.III, every mission Kirk went on before ''Arena'' were only in timelines created by the various factions, and that were all erased after Archer stopped the Na'Kuhl in 1944.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added a theory.

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: The first 18 episodes never happened.]]

In "The Corbomite Maneuver", Kirk says the Enterprise is a ''United Earth'' ship. the U.E. is the same governing body that Archer and his crew answered to, and it's not until "Arena" (the 19th episode) that Kirk speaks of the Federation. All of this could suggest that the ''Temporal Cold War'' ended inbetween Kirk's missions to Beta VI and Cestus III.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: In "Court Martial", Kirk's ex-girlfriend Shaw was purposefully trying to get him convicted.]]

Shaw, a prosecutor, highly recommends Kirk goes to a defense lawyer called Cogley, claiming he's great at what he does. But it very quickly becomes apparent he's, er ... no [[Series/BetterCallSaul Saul]] [[Series/BreakingBad Goodman]]. He declines to cross examine any witnesses, only calls Kirk himself to the stand, and rests for the defense without putting up much of a fight. It's only thanks to Spock's last minute intervention that Kirk is exonerated.

So, maybe Shaw wasn't quite as magnanimous over their breakup as she'd been acting like she was, and purposefully recommended a barely-competent lawyer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


{{Series/Highlander}} showed there were were several immortals. But during the Eugenics wars, World War III and the Post-Atomic Horror, many died out. Flint was one of the last who made it off world. Prior to the events of Recap/StarTrekS3E19RequiemForMethuselah, Flint made sure that he had the resources to get off world as soon as that was possible. He played the markets and bought an out of the way planet. McCoy's tricorder just picked up how the Highlander immortality works - notice that Flint didn't flich whem McCoy offered his theory. Also - by being away from Earth, many immortals started to lose their power. Those who didn't hide like Flint likely died during the wars prior to Kirk's time.

to:

{{Series/Highlander}} showed there were were several immortals. But during the Eugenics wars, World War III and the Post-Atomic Horror, many died out. Flint was one of the last who made it off world. Prior to the events of Recap/StarTrekS3E19RequiemForMethuselah, Flint made sure that he had the resources to get off world as soon as that was possible. He played the markets and bought an out of the way planet. McCoy's [=McCoy's=] tricorder just picked up how the Highlander immortality works - notice that Flint didn't flich whem McCoy flinch when [=McCoy=] offered his theory. theory as to why Flint was immortal. He already knew how, he just didn't think that being away from ''Earth'' would weaken him. Also - by being away from Earth, many immortals started to lose their power. Those who didn't hide like Flint likely died during the wars prior to Kirk's time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Flint is a Highlander.]]

{{Series/Highlander}} showed there were were several immortals. But during the Eugenics wars, World War III and the Post-Atomic Horror, many died out. Flint was one of the last who made it off world. Prior to the events of Recap/StarTrekS3E19RequiemForMethuselah, Flint made sure that he had the resources to get off world as soon as that was possible. He played the markets and bought an out of the way planet. McCoy's tricorder just picked up how the Highlander immortality works - notice that Flint didn't flich whem McCoy offered his theory. Also - by being away from Earth, many immortals started to lose their power. Those who didn't hide like Flint likely died during the wars prior to Kirk's time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Or alternately, that it's a cast full of Bi but no one feels the need to talk about it, as it's just a non-issue at that point. The one time Stamets (ten years before TOS's first season) mentions his sexuality directly is when he's challenged on it by a person from the Mirror Universe.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Corrected English mistake.


Especially at the end of the war, when the Romulans were already retreading, the highlight of many Coalition (the Federation's predecessor - see [[Series/StarTrekEnterprise ENT]]) victory parties were the bottles with that tasty alcoholic drink in it, which the fleeing Romulans had left behind. (The Romulans did take great care in destroying every bit of critical data and technology before they retreaded from a conquered planet - but drinks were apparently considered a not all too important "technology".)\\\

to:

Especially at the end of the war, when the Romulans were already retreading, the highlight of many Coalition (the Federation's predecessor - see [[Series/StarTrekEnterprise ENT]]) victory parties were the bottles with that tasty alcoholic drink in it, which the fleeing Romulans had left behind. (The Romulans did take great care in destroying every bit of critical data and technology before they retreaded retreated from a conquered planet - but drinks were apparently considered a not all too important "technology".)\\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Star Fleet covered up M-5's breakdown.]]
* In the entry for "The Ultimate Computer", there's a question about why Kirk wasn't immediately relieved of command until there had been a full investigation of the war games incident. The answer: Star Fleet covered it up to avoid all sorts of legal hassles. Remember, [=McCoy=] had noted that the Federation had still bought the M-5 concept, even though Daystom's earlier models had been "not entirely successful". Couple that with Daystom's increasingly apparent psychological issues, and the families of the dead crewmembers are going to wonder why the test was done with insufficient precautions taken (like having an "off" switch that could be overridden). In Star Fleet's eyes, it's better to sweep it under the rug. Just box up the M-5, send Daystom to a hospital, inform the families the crewmembers were killed in "an unfortunate accident", leave Kirk in the center seat, and conduct the most quiet and classified review possible of the incident.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Ruth was an older woman, (at least somewhat older than the young cadet Kirk), so either she can’t be Carol Marcus, or else somebody was lying.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Paris



to:

*Or: The TOS we're watching is one of Tom Paris' retro TV series inspired holonovels like Captain Proton. This time he's recreating the adventures of the TOS Enterprise in the style of shows like 'Lost In Space' or 'Galaxy Quest'.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Ehheh, there's a page for full-series WMG's. Moved it there.


[[WMG: The warp drive is fed from the leavings of the replicators and transporter]]
* This is more a WMG for the entire series. Converting energy to matter generates an equal ammount of {{antimatter}}, which, of course, is what the ship runs on. So they teleport the antimatter straight into the reactor. Since we never see them actually mining/making antimatter and it has to come from somwhere...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Converting energy to matter generates an equal ammount of {{antimatter}}, which, of course, is what the ship runs on. So they teleport the antimatter straight into the reactor. Since we never see them actually mining/making antimatter and it has to come from somwhere...

to:

* This is more a WMG for the entire series. Converting energy to matter generates an equal ammount of {{antimatter}}, which, of course, is what the ship runs on. So they teleport the antimatter straight into the reactor. Since we never see them actually mining/making antimatter and it has to come from somwhere...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[WMG: The warp drive is fed from the leavings of the replicators and transporter]]
* Converting energy to matter generates an equal ammount of {{antimatter}}, which, of course, is what the ship runs on. So they teleport the antimatter straight into the reactor. Since we never see them actually mining/making antimatter and it has to come from somwhere...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removed the Rule of Cautious Editing Judgement pothole in line with this thread: https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/posts.php?discussion=15962256090A28973800&page=1


Gene Roddenberry being supposedly wanting to portray a humanistic, post-religious vision of the future, it might not be surprising if the episode was meant to highlight the dangers of too-closely emulating a book that describes the culture of a historical but alien civilization- which is an accusation critics of religion often levelled at those who use Literature/TheBible the same way in Western societies ([[Administrivia/RuleOfCautiousEditingJudgment and that, naturally, is all we'll say about that...]]).

to:

Gene Roddenberry being supposedly wanting to portray a humanistic, post-religious vision of the future, it might not be surprising if the episode was meant to highlight the dangers of too-closely emulating a book that describes the culture of a historical but alien civilization- which is an accusation critics of religion often levelled at those who use Literature/TheBible the same way in Western societies ([[Administrivia/RuleOfCautiousEditingJudgment and that, naturally, is all we'll say about that...]]).
societies.

Added: 100

Changed: 207

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* After Pike's first visit, visit is prohibited (DIS: "If Memory Serves"), however no mention is made of capital punishment.
* In that same episode and TOS: "The Menagerie", the Talosians are shown to be adept at producing incredibly advanced illusions for whatever purposes they need, including the prevention of visitors.
* It is well established in other episodes of TOS, ENT, and DIS that United Earth and the Federation did not have capital punishment from well before 2266. While it's not impossible to bring back the death penalty, it seems unlikely for these circumstances
* Three years later, Janice Lester tries to take the ''Enterprise'' back to Talos IV. When the crew objects, they cite General Order 4, not 7, which is a weird oversight to make when talking about something exceptional like execution.

to:

* After Pike's first visit, trip, visit is prohibited (DIS: "If Memory Serves"), however no mention is made of capital punishment.
punishment and no one acts like going there is any worse of a violation of orders than usual.
* In that same episode and TOS: "The Menagerie", the Talosians are shown to be adept at producing incredibly advanced illusions for whatever purposes they need, including the prevention the...discouragement of visitors.
* It is well established in other episodes of TOS, ENT, and DIS that United Earth and the Federation did not have capital punishment from well before 2266. in the years before, or contemporary to, TOS: "The Menagerie". While it's not impossible to bring back the death penalty, it seems unlikely for these circumstances
circumstances.
* Three years later, Janice Lester tries to take the ''Enterprise'' back to Talos IV.IV in an odd ploy to get Kirk killed. When the crew objects, they cite General Order 4, not 7, which is a weird oversight to make when talking about something exceptional like execution.


Added DiffLines:


Visiting Talos IV would probably make a dent in your career, but it hardly seems worth killing over.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
new wmg re: Talos IV

Added DiffLines:


[[WMG: There was never a death penalty for travelling to Talos IV. It was simply another part of the illusion to get Pike there.]]
It's the simplest conclusion to the many inconsistencies surrounding it:
* After Pike's first visit, visit is prohibited (DIS: "If Memory Serves"), however no mention is made of capital punishment.
* In that same episode and TOS: "The Menagerie", the Talosians are shown to be adept at producing incredibly advanced illusions for whatever purposes they need, including the prevention of visitors.
* It is well established in other episodes of TOS, ENT, and DIS that United Earth and the Federation did not have capital punishment from well before 2266. While it's not impossible to bring back the death penalty, it seems unlikely for these circumstances
* Three years later, Janice Lester tries to take the ''Enterprise'' back to Talos IV. When the crew objects, they cite General Order 4, not 7, which is a weird oversight to make when talking about something exceptional like execution.

Thus, it seems more likely that the death penalty was never in play at all. Maybe the later mistake was due to older crew misremembering the fake law, or maybe the Talosians noticed the ''Enterprise'' was coming back '''yet again''' and hastily threw up the old execution ploy but got it wrong, but hey, who cares, we still want you to go away.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** I distinctly remember reading at least one fanfic just like this. It was rather fluffy - Spock realised the problem and got Bones to seek help (by which I mean "dragged him to Vulcan to a specialist").
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[WMG: Fizzbin actually developed into a real card game on Sigma Iota II.]]
If their reputation for adaptability is anything to go by. [[https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Fizzbin#Background The writers even appear to have suggested it!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG:Spock is a direct descendant of SherlockHolmes.]]

to:

[[WMG:Spock is a direct descendant of SherlockHolmes.Literature/SherlockHolmes.]]

Changed: 106

Removed: 745

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Combining the two "The Mirror Universe was created by the Guardian of Forever" entries


[[WMG: The Mirror Universe was created by the Guardian of Forever.]]
* When [=McCoy=] saved Edith Keeler, he created an alternate timeline where the Nazis won WWII and conquered the world, destroying Federation civilization and replacing it with the fascist Terran Empire. When Kirk and Spock travelled back in time to stop [=McCoy=] from saving her, they were able to return to their own timeline, but because of a temporal paradox created by the Guardian, the Alternate Universe wasn't destroyed and remained intertwined with the original universe, allowing occasional crossovers under certain conditions. Historical changes prior to WWII, such as the literary differences noted by Dr. Phlox, are actually historical revisionism or propaganda.



* When [=McCoy=] saved Edith, causing Hitler to win WWII and take over the world, the changes rippled further in time, to the mindset that led to the shooting of the Vulcan emissary in 2063, and further to the creation of the Terran Empire that has persisted in the mirror universe throughout Trek history. Consider:

to:

* When [=McCoy=] saved Edith, causing Hitler to win WWII and take over the world, the changes rippled further in time, to the mindset that led to the shooting of the Vulcan emissary in 2063, and further to the creation of the Terran Empire that has persisted in the mirror universe throughout Trek history. Both universes have since remained intertwined, allowing occasional crossovers under certain conditions. Consider:

Top