Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WMG / StarTrek

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


There are a lot of things that don't fit for a direct prequel, and in "Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow" Sera mentions the Eugenics wars moving from the 90s (as stated in TOS) to the mid 21st century (as La'an remembers) due to various attempts to change the timeline.

to:

There are a lot of things that don't fit for a direct prequel, and in "Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow" Sera mentions the Eugenics wars moving from the 90s (as stated in TOS) to the mid 21st century (as La'an remembers) due to various attempts to change the timeline.timeline.

[[WMG: In-universe, ''Dilithium" is a trademark, not the actual name of the material.]]
There is a substance called "dilithium" in the real world. It's a form of lithium in the gaseous state, where every molecule is formed by two bound atoms (di-lithium, two atoms of lithium). Why would chemists give the same name to a completely different material?

The answer is that they didn't. The function of "dilithium", in Star Trek, is to ''dilute'' matter, to contain and regulate the matter/antimatter reaction in the warp drive. It operates a ''dilution'''. The person who named the material knew its function, but not enough chemistry to actually give it a chemically correct name, so, instead, they operated from a marketing perspective. They registered a trademark based on an intentional misspelling of its function, to make it distinctive and give it an easy to remember name that merely sounds technical.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Discovery and Strange New Worlds take place in a slightly different timeline to TOS.]]

to:

[[WMG: Discovery ''Discovery'' and Strange ''Strange New Worlds Worlds'' take place in a slightly different timeline to TOS.]]

Added: 363

Changed: 10

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Add example


Ditto for the Klingons and Cardassians. Don't get me started on the Ferengi. Furthermore, while the federation is using dilithum to power their ships, the Romulans are using a forced quantum singularity, moving them up a little further along the Kardashev scale than anyone else. Their smugness might just be deserved, in that they feel like they're dealing with the retarded kid from down the street that keeps picking fights with them and losing.

to:

Ditto for the Klingons and Cardassians. Don't get me started on the Ferengi. Furthermore, while the federation is using dilithum to power their ships, the Romulans are using a forced quantum singularity, moving them up a little further along the Kardashev scale than anyone else. Their smugness might just be deserved, in that they feel like they're dealing with the retarded stupid kid from down the street that keeps picking fights with them and losing.



If you've messed about with Stable Diffusion or [=ChatGPT=] or whatever you'll know how possible it is to have the software generate content from a reasonably detailed prompt. Now look at how characters on Star Trek can seemingly program the holodeck by entering a verbal prompt. Or how Picard (I think) on first using the Dixon Hill programs marvels at the level of extra historical detail that is put into the program that doesn't need to be there- how is that achieved? Well, it could be an advanced form of machine learning...

to:

If you've messed about with Stable Diffusion or [=ChatGPT=] or whatever you'll know how possible it is to have the software generate content from a reasonably detailed prompt. Now look at how characters on Star Trek can seemingly program the holodeck by entering a verbal prompt. Or how Picard (I think) on first using the Dixon Hill programs marvels at the level of extra historical detail that is put into the program that doesn't need to be there- how is that achieved? Well, it could be an advanced form of machine learning...learning...

[[WMG: Discovery and Strange New Worlds take place in a slightly different timeline to TOS.]]
There are a lot of things that don't fit for a direct prequel, and in "Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow" Sera mentions the Eugenics wars moving from the 90s (as stated in TOS) to the mid 21st century (as La'an remembers) due to various attempts to change the timeline.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
And a couple more...


If you've messed about with Stable Diffusion or [=ChatGPT=] or whatever you'll know how possible it is to have the software generate content from a reasonably detailed prompt. Now look at how characters on Star Trek can seemingly program the holodeck by entering a verbal prompt. Or how Picard (I think) on first using the Dion hill programs marvels at the level of extra historical detail that is put into the program that doesn't need to be there- how is that achieved? Well, it could be an advanced form of machine learning...

to:

If you've messed about with Stable Diffusion or [=ChatGPT=] or whatever you'll know how possible it is to have the software generate content from a reasonably detailed prompt. Now look at how characters on Star Trek can seemingly program the holodeck by entering a verbal prompt. Or how Picard (I think) on first using the Dion hill Dixon Hill programs marvels at the level of extra historical detail that is put into the program that doesn't need to be there- how is that achieved? Well, it could be an advanced form of machine learning...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fixing typos


If you've messed about with Stable Diffusion or [=ChatGPT=] or whatever you'll know how possible it is to have the software generate content from a reasonably detailed prompt. Now look at how characters on Star Trek can seemingly progrma the holodeck by entiering a verbal prompt. Or how Picard (I think) on first using the Dion hill programs marvels at the level of extra historical detail that is put into the program that doesn't need to be there- how is that acheived? Well, it could be an advanced form of machine learning...

to:

If you've messed about with Stable Diffusion or [=ChatGPT=] or whatever you'll know how possible it is to have the software generate content from a reasonably detailed prompt. Now look at how characters on Star Trek can seemingly progrma program the holodeck by entiering entering a verbal prompt. Or how Picard (I think) on first using the Dion hill programs marvels at the level of extra historical detail that is put into the program that doesn't need to be there- how is that acheived? achieved? Well, it could be an advanced form of machine learning...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: (Insert Star Trek Series Here) was created by LightNovel/HaruhiSuzumiya]]

to:

[[WMG: (Insert Star Trek Series Here) was created by LightNovel/HaruhiSuzumiya]]Literature/HaruhiSuzumiya]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


If you've messed about with Stable Diffusion or ChatGPT or whatever you'll know how possible it is to have the software generate content from a reasonably detailed prompt. Now look at how characters on Star Trek can seemingly progrma the holodeck by entiering a verbal prompt. Or how Picard (I think) on first using the Dion hill programs marvels at the level of extra historical detail that is put into the program that doesn't need to be there- how is that acheived? Well, it could be an advanced form of machine learning...

to:

If you've messed about with Stable Diffusion or ChatGPT [=ChatGPT=] or whatever you'll know how possible it is to have the software generate content from a reasonably detailed prompt. Now look at how characters on Star Trek can seemingly progrma the holodeck by entiering a verbal prompt. Or how Picard (I think) on first using the Dion hill programs marvels at the level of extra historical detail that is put into the program that doesn't need to be there- how is that acheived? Well, it could be an advanced form of machine learning...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--> '''Atkins:''' Whenever you give a man something for nothing[,] the first person he comes to dislike is you. If the pump is going to work at all, it has to be their pump, not mine.

to:

--> '''Atkins:''' Whenever you give a man something for nothing[,] the first person he comes to dislike is you. If the pump is going to work at all, it has to be their pump, not mine.mine.

[[WMG: The holodeck is an advanced version of AI content generators of the early 21st century.]]
If you've messed about with Stable Diffusion or ChatGPT or whatever you'll know how possible it is to have the software generate content from a reasonably detailed prompt. Now look at how characters on Star Trek can seemingly progrma the holodeck by entiering a verbal prompt. Or how Picard (I think) on first using the Dion hill programs marvels at the level of extra historical detail that is put into the program that doesn't need to be there- how is that acheived? Well, it could be an advanced form of machine learning...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Face it, KlingonPromotion isn't all that easy to pull off in-universe. You risk being killed in the attempt, or if you survive but fail, torture and execution is more or less inevitable. Even successful attempts, if Mirror!Chekhov's dialogue (along the lines of "Starfleet Command won't question the assassination of a Captain who disobeys orders") is anything to go by, may be questioned by the higher-ups. And this disorder might only be endemic by the 23rd century- if I recall, the reaction to Archer [[spoiler: and later, Sato]] in ''Enterprise'' by a few characters seems to be much more "what the hell?" but this could be simply out of their sheer audacity.

to:

Face it, KlingonPromotion isn't all that easy to pull off in-universe. You risk being killed in the attempt, or if you survive but fail, torture and execution is more or less inevitable. Even successful attempts, if Mirror!Chekhov's dialogue (along the lines of "Starfleet Command won't question the assassination of a Captain who disobeys orders") is anything to go by, may be questioned by the higher-ups. And this disorder might only be endemic by the 23rd century- if I recall, the reaction to Archer [[spoiler: and later, Sato]] in ''Enterprise'' by a few characters seems to be much more "what the hell?" but this could be simply out of their sheer audacity.
audacity. Either way, it's much easier to curry favour with your superiors (and/or [[SleepingTheirWayToTheTop sleep with them]]).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Alternately, the Mirror Universe survives ChronicBackstabbingDisorder due to internal logic of its own.]]
Face it, KlingonPromotion isn't all that easy to pull off in-universe. You risk being killed in the attempt, or if you survive but fail, torture and execution is more or less inevitable. Even successful attempts, if Mirror!Chekhov's dialogue (along the lines of "Starfleet Command won't question the assassination of a Captain who disobeys orders") is anything to go by, may be questioned by the higher-ups. And this disorder might only be endemic by the 23rd century- if I recall, the reaction to Archer [[spoiler: and later, Sato]] in ''Enterprise'' by a few characters seems to be much more "what the hell?" but this could be simply out of their sheer audacity.


Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: The Terran Empire is prone to the OrwellianRetcon.]]
We only have Mirror!Phlox's word for it that the histories of the Prime and Mirror Universe are of the NeverWasThisUniverse variety. And to be fair it's not unlike tyannical regimes down the ages to rewrite history to suit their own interests, the Terran Empire is surely no exception. Cochrane's behaviour at First Contact could well have been a dividing point.

[[WMG: Gender politics in the Mirror Universe depends on the gender of the Emperor.]]
Look at the outfits in the Original Series and ''Enterprise'', which range from somewhat CustomUniformOfSexy to outright SexyWhateverOutfit in the latter. Then look at ''Discovery''. Notice how much more martial and badass looking they are, even (especially, even!) given the ExcessiveEvilEyeshadow? Not to mention in both the former series, female characters seem to be a lot more about SleepingTheirWayToTheTop (and getting seually harassed). Then you realise that the Emperor in ''Discovery'' is [[[spoiler: Philippa Georgiou]]... and it all makes sense.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


The ones that fail die or go crazy. The ones that succeed, even to a small degree, pull off feats of greater-than-0%-is-100%-Awesome that should be impossible for any mere AI. A side effect of this is the prevalence of PinocchioSyndrome among such successful beings, like [[Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration Data]] and [[Series/StarTrekVoyager The Doctor]].

to:

The ones that fail die or go crazy. The ones that succeed, even to a small degree, pull off feats of greater-than-0%-is-100%-Awesome that should be impossible for any mere AI. A side effect of this is the prevalence of PinocchioSyndrome BecomeARealBoy among such successful beings, like [[Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration Data]] and [[Series/StarTrekVoyager The Doctor]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** See Janis Ian's "[[https://archives.janisian.com/reading/internet.php The Internet Debacle]]" and "[[https://archives.janisian.com/reading/fallout.php Fallout]]". Everything is proceeding as she has foreseen.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** [[Series/StarTrekPicard Well, you called that one!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Mary Suetopia has been cut per TRS: [1]. Appropriate examples are moved to Utopia


** Or the result of exploring the ramifications of Roddenberry's MarySuetopia.

to:

** Or the result of exploring the ramifications of Roddenberry's MarySuetopia.{{Utopia}}.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** This of course is the setup for the events in the first ''Star Trek'' novel, ''Spock Must Die'' by Creator/JamesBlish.



*** Spock said that ''pon farr'' was a "thing that no outworlder may know, except those very few who have been involved," "even we do not speak of it among ourselves," and that it was a "deeply personal thing."

to:

*** Spock ''Spock'' said that ''pon farr'' was a "thing that no outworlder may know, except those very few who have been involved," "even we do not speak of it among ourselves," and that it was a "deeply personal thing."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Wiki/ namespace clean up.


** But... isn't this basically true for ''every work of fiction on Wiki/TVTropes''?

to:

** But... isn't this basically true for ''every work of fiction on Wiki/TVTropes''?
Website/TVTropes''?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Pyrrhic Villainy has been merged into Pyrrhic Victory per TRS decision


This may also account for the occasional anomalies in various characters' behavior patterns: whenever Mirror Kirk does something irrational that leads to someone living who would otherwise have died, that's because his counterpart is rescuing the very same person in his universe. Whenever the regular Kirk takes a foolish chance that gets a RedShirt killed, that's because Mirror Kirk is having that very same RedShirt executed for some infraction or other in his universe. This goes as far back as Archer's time or maybe even further: Forrest ultimately was doomed to die in the one universe because he had already died in the other. Likewise, though Hitler may actually have won World War II in the Mirror Universe, he may ultimately have succumbed to a case of PyrrhicVillainy that ultimately gave the USA greater influence over the Terran Empire.

to:

This may also account for the occasional anomalies in various characters' behavior patterns: whenever Mirror Kirk does something irrational that leads to someone living who would otherwise have died, that's because his counterpart is rescuing the very same person in his universe. Whenever the regular Kirk takes a foolish chance that gets a RedShirt killed, that's because Mirror Kirk is having that very same RedShirt executed for some infraction or other in his universe. This goes as far back as Archer's time or maybe even further: Forrest ultimately was doomed to die in the one universe because he had already died in the other. Likewise, though Hitler may actually have won World War II in the Mirror Universe, he may ultimately have succumbed to a case of PyrrhicVillainy PyrrhicVictory that ultimately gave the USA greater influence over the Terran Empire.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added arguments against the Federation anti-matter theories. Antimatter is not a natural resource, since starships have onboard antimatter generators, and the Federation has a clean antimatter manufacturing process they use, in comparison to the more polluting one the Malon use.



to:

* Unlikely, since the Federation has [[https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Antimatter_generator Antimatter generators onboard]], which would suggest that they synthesise the material. {{Jossed}} by the events of ([[Recap/StarTrekVoyagerS5E1Night VOY: "Night"]]), which state that the Federation has an improved antimatter creation process that does not cause polluting byproducts.



* Converting energy to matter generates an equal ammount of antimatter, which, of course, is what the ship runs on. So they teleport the antimatter straight into the reactor/fuel tanks.

to:

* Converting energy to matter generates an equal ammount of antimatter, which, of course, is what the ship runs on. So they teleport the antimatter straight into the reactor/fuel tanks.
* This would have taken care of Voyager's fuel issues from the get-go. That they needed to go look for fuel, and that they were running out of fuel in the first place would suggest otherwise.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

* ''WMG/StarTrekStrangeNewWorlds''

Added: 452

Changed: 45

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The Borg might be an intergalactic power.



to:

[[WMG: The Borg are an intergalactic power.]]
In ''Series/StarTrekVoyager'', Seven of Nine mentions that the Borg have journeyed outside of this galactic cluster, and mentions some species offhand. Being an intergalactic power would be facilitated by a transwarp network. The Voyager finale [[Recap/StarTrekVoyagerS7E23Endgame "Endgame"]] shows that a transwarp conduit can take someone across the galaxy in seconds to minutes. The Borg might have a transwarp hub dedicated to intergalactic travel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In that book, which is a novel abot the US mostly faling diplomacy in the fictional country of Sarkhan,the main good guy believes that (and I could find a relevant quote that would explain better when I feel like it, but I found one on the books page here) to truly help the Sarkhanians he should use technology that they can understand, so they can be partners in the project, uses pedal power because Sarkan has a lot of bicycles. Also, this year (2022) I heard about a way missionaries were going to help get people clean water by basically building a box, filling it with rocks, pebbles and sand, and filtering the water with that much like the Earth does. The missionaries thought this was genius, and I agree.

to:

In that book, which is a novel abot the US mostly faling diplomacy in the fictional country of Sarkhan,the main good guy believes that (and I could find a relevant quote that would explain better when I feel like it, but I found one on the books page here) to truly help the Sarkhanians he should use technology that they can understand, so they can be partners in the project, uses pedal power because Sarkan has a lot of bicycles. Also, this year (2022) I heard about a way missionaries were going to help get people clean water by basically building a box, filling it with rocks, pebbles and sand, and filtering the water with that much like the Earth does. The missionaries thought this was genius, and I agree.agree.
That quote on ''Literature/TheUglyAmerican'' 's page is:
--> '''Atkins:''' Whenever you give a man something for nothing[,] the first person he comes to dislike is you. If the pump is going to work at all, it has to be their pump, not mine.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: The Prime Directive exists because somone, in-universe or not, read ''The Ugly American''.]]
In that book, which is a novel abot the US mostly faling diplomacy in the fictional country of Sarkhan,the main good guy believes that (and I could find a relevant quote that would explain better when I feel like it) to truly help the Sarkhanians he should use technology that they can understand, so they can be partners in the project, uses pedal power because Sarkan has a lot of bicycles. Also, this year (2022) I heard about a way missionaries were going to help get people clean water by basically building a box, filling it with rocks, pebbles and sand, and filtering the water with that much like the Earth does. The missionaries thought this was genius, and I agree.

to:

[[WMG: The Prime Directive exists because somone, in-universe or not, read ''The Ugly American''.''Literature/TheUglyAmerican''.]]
In that book, which is a novel abot the US mostly faling diplomacy in the fictional country of Sarkhan,the main good guy believes that (and I could find a relevant quote that would explain better when I feel like it) it, but I found one on the books page here) to truly help the Sarkhanians he should use technology that they can understand, so they can be partners in the project, uses pedal power because Sarkan has a lot of bicycles. Also, this year (2022) I heard about a way missionaries were going to help get people clean water by basically building a box, filling it with rocks, pebbles and sand, and filtering the water with that much like the Earth does. The missionaries thought this was genius, and I agree.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Mentions of Leningrad, meanwhile, are simply referring to the still-extant oblast (county) rather than the city currently known as St. Petersburg.

to:

Mentions of Leningrad, meanwhile, are simply referring to the still-extant oblast (county) rather than the city currently known as St. Petersburg.Petersburg.

[[WMG: The Prime Directive exists because somone, in-universe or not, read ''The Ugly American''.]]
In that book, which is a novel abot the US mostly faling diplomacy in the fictional country of Sarkhan,the main good guy believes that (and I could find a relevant quote that would explain better when I feel like it) to truly help the Sarkhanians he should use technology that they can understand, so they can be partners in the project, uses pedal power because Sarkan has a lot of bicycles. Also, this year (2022) I heard about a way missionaries were going to help get people clean water by basically building a box, filling it with rocks, pebbles and sand, and filtering the water with that much like the Earth does. The missionaries thought this was genius, and I agree.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: The warp drive is fed from the leavings of the replicators and transporter]]
* Converting energy to matter generates an equal ammount of {{antimatter}}, which, of course, is what the ship runs on. So they teleport the antimatter straight into the reactor. Since we never see them actually mining/making antimatter and it has to come from somwhere...

to:

[[WMG: The warp drive is fed on part from the leavings of the replicators and transporter]]
* Converting energy to matter generates an equal ammount of {{antimatter}}, antimatter, which, of course, is what the ship runs on. So they teleport the antimatter straight into the reactor. Since we never see them actually mining/making antimatter and it has to come from somwhere...
reactor/fuel tanks.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: The warp drive is fed from the leavings of the replicators and transporter]]
* Converting energy to matter generates an equal ammount of {{antimatter}}, which, of course, is what the ship runs on. So they teleport the antimatter straight into the reactor. Since we never see them actually mining/making antimatter and it has to come from somwhere...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Its the other way around - Starfleet's main purpose is to "seek out new life and new civilizations", after all, with defense as a secondary concern. Picard's not a soldier who sometimes acts as a diplomat, he's a diplomat who sometimes acts as a soldier.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: TheGreatPoliticsMessUp ''did'' happen.]]

to:

[[WMG: TheGreatPoliticsMessUp The Cold War ''did'' happen.end.]]

Top