Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WMG / FateGrandOrder

Go To

OR

Changed: 1263

Removed: 1260

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Since the ritual must be performed by mages, it might be speculated that the entirety of mages is preserved from losing the power after the end of the Age of Gods by the World, so that they still be able to trigger the failsafes, but I digress.
The VII is an odd one - while the [[spoiler:Foreign World]] does try to preserve humanity through drastic means, [[spoiler:U-Olga-Marie]]'s behavior and stats are not consistent with the rest. Since it can produce Alter-Egos without issue, it might also be able to graft some Beast-like parts on a Saint-Graph as well, thus fooling the observers.
Tying into another WMG and Koyanskaya's comments - there might be a completely different candidate.
To foil [[spoiler:Marisbury's Grand Order]] one must restore humanity to Earth, thus - to force [[spoiler:CHALDEAS]] to do it. There's not much ways for this, but one of them - to take the Human Order as a hostage, for example, with Kadoc's Sirius Light, and thus - to endager it. Doing this and fighting against [[spoiler:Foreign World]] in general would mean employing Anti-Human Order. Thus the Beast VII candidate would be noone but Fujimaru, and their Logos would be Determination - persevering despite all odds against the superior threat, motivated by love for humanity, with possibility of going off the deep end without some sort of checks and counter-balances. Except that this time they ''do'' have these - Novum Chaldea, thus, unlike the rest, not fighting alone and employing the Beast system properly.

to:

* Since the ritual must be performed by mages, it might be speculated that the entirety of mages is preserved from losing the power after the end of the Age of Gods by the World, so that they still be able to trigger the failsafes, but I digress.
digress. The VII is an odd one - while the [[spoiler:Foreign World]] does try to preserve humanity through drastic means, [[spoiler:U-Olga-Marie]]'s behavior and stats are not consistent with the rest. Since it can produce Alter-Egos without issue, it might also be able to graft some Beast-like parts on a Saint-Graph as well, thus fooling the observers.
observers. Tying into another WMG and Koyanskaya's comments - there might be a completely different candidate.
candidate. To foil [[spoiler:Marisbury's Grand Order]] one must restore humanity to Earth, thus - to force [[spoiler:CHALDEAS]] to do it. There's not much ways for this, but one of them - to take the Human Order as a hostage, for example, with Kadoc's Sirius Light, and thus - to endager it. Doing this and fighting against [[spoiler:Foreign World]] in general would mean employing Anti-Human Order. Thus the Beast VII candidate would be noone but Fujimaru, and their Logos would be Determination - persevering despite all odds against the superior threat, motivated by love for humanity, with possibility of going off the deep end without some sort of checks and counter-balances. Except that this time they ''do'' have these - Novum Chaldea, thus, unlike the rest, not fighting alone and employing the Beast system properly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The problem with this theory is that there is ''nothing'' about Chaldean that really screams Marisbury. His hair and eye colours are both paler than what Chaldean has, and of what we have seen of Marisbury's personality, he doesn't seem like he would be that weirded out about the inhabitants of the Lostbelts like Chaldean is. Plus if he really was Marisbury, then other characters like Wodime would react to it like that. The only way for him to be Marisbury if he became a HeroicHost to whomever is piloting the body.

to:

* The problem with this theory is that there is ''nothing'' about the Chaldean that really screams Marisbury. His hair and eye colours are both paler than what the Chaldean has, and of what we have seen of Marisbury's personality, he doesn't seem like he would be that weirded out about the inhabitants of the Lostbelts like Chaldean is. Plus if he really was Marisbury, then other characters like Wodime would react to it like that. The only way for him to be Marisbury if he became a HeroicHost to whomever is piloting the body.



CHALDEAS is a simulation of Earth but is also the Foreign World, the cause behind the Lostbelts and Tree of Emptiness, which are simulations of pruned timelines. The purpose of the trees is to impose a new order over the world, with each one basically competing against the others. This would mean the goal of the Foreign World CHALDEAS would be to impose a new order on Earth. Daybit states the Foreign World's goal is to save humanity, but its actions would make humanity despised by the universe. The only action that would cause such a reaction is simple, killing Gaia, or the Earth. Thus, it is likely the goal of CHALDEAS is to impose a new order on the world where humanity is supreme, which would destroy Gaia as a separate entity, the purpose of the Lostbelts is to blind the Counter Force, either by creating a world where it doesn't exist, or where there is something powerful enough to counter it.

to:

CHALDEAS is a simulation of Earth but is also the Foreign World, the cause behind the Lostbelts and Tree Trees of Emptiness, which are simulations of pruned timelines. The purpose of the trees is to impose a new order over the world, with each one basically competing against the others. This would mean the goal of the Foreign World CHALDEAS would be to impose a new order on Earth. Daybit states the Foreign World's goal is to save humanity, but its actions would make humanity despised by the universe. The only action that would cause such a reaction is simple, killing Gaia, or the Earth. Thus, it is likely the goal of CHALDEAS is to impose a new order on the world where humanity is supreme, which would destroy Gaia as a separate entity, the purpose of the Lostbelts is to blind the Counter Force, either by creating a world where it doesn't exist, or where there is something powerful enough to counter it.



* He sees the CHALDEAS as his enemy. It was established very early on that Galahad doesn't aprove in any capacity the shit that Marisbury did while he was in charge.

to:

* He sees the CHALDEAS as his enemy. It was established very early on that Galahad doesn't aprove in any capacity the shit that Marisbury did while he was in charge.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[WMG: Some bits about Beasts]]
The Beasts are not "merely" Evils of Humanity incarnate, they're ''yet another'' defense mechanism of the World, meant against truly apocalyptic threats - motivated by honest love for mankind and empowered by its evil side, i. e. primary driver for achievement and overcoming. That's because most of the shown ones can actually fullfill a certain function or another:
* I - meant to oppose a singular foe of a planetary scale [[spoiler:(CHALDEAS/ORT)]]
* II - can repopulate the Earth should the population be thoroughly wiped/distorted too much by some corrupting agent
* III - unclear, but both versions can change the minds of a whole planet, possibly negating someone else's brainwashing or overly dangerous trends of society
* IV - keeps humanity from destroying the rest of the planet
* V - notoriously missing, but:
** sub-WMG: Angra-Mainyu is confirmed by Word of God to be a candidate for a Beast of Retribution, but in all shown timelines was subdued or never happened, thus accounting both for the position and it being empty
* VI - ok, I kinda miss the idea here
* VII - see below
Unfortunarely, the system is not fool-proof, and thus prone to misfiring, producing a lot of collateral damage, re-interpreting the prime directive in a destructive way, and going off the rails in general, hence the need for another failsafe - Grand Servants and their summoning ritual.
* Since the ritual must be performed by mages, it might be speculated that the entirety of mages is preserved from losing the power after the end of the Age of Gods by the World, so that they still be able to trigger the failsafes, but I digress.
The VII is an odd one - while the [[spoiler:Foreign World]] does try to preserve humanity through drastic means, [[spoiler:U-Olga-Marie]]'s behavior and stats are not consistent with the rest. Since it can produce Alter-Egos without issue, it might also be able to graft some Beast-like parts on a Saint-Graph as well, thus fooling the observers.
Tying into another WMG and Koyanskaya's comments - there might be a completely different candidate.
To foil [[spoiler:Marisbury's Grand Order]] one must restore humanity to Earth, thus - to force [[spoiler:CHALDEAS]] to do it. There's not much ways for this, but one of them - to take the Human Order as a hostage, for example, with Kadoc's Sirius Light, and thus - to endager it. Doing this and fighting against [[spoiler:Foreign World]] in general would mean employing Anti-Human Order. Thus the Beast VII candidate would be noone but Fujimaru, and their Logos would be Determination - persevering despite all odds against the superior threat, motivated by love for humanity, with possibility of going off the deep end without some sort of checks and counter-balances. Except that this time they ''do'' have these - Novum Chaldea, thus, unlike the rest, not fighting alone and employing the Beast system properly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** No.

Added: 107

Changed: 141

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Paper Moon's Ordeal Call apparently dealt with Alter Egos. Question to the tropers that completed the chapter: has one ascended afterwards?


Added DiffLines:

* Apparently jossed: Paper Moon dealt with [[spoiler:Alter-Egos]], but no [[spoiler:Moriarty]] was present.

Added: 138

Changed: 12

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


- if this troper's memory serves correctly , isn't kuku technically a playable (albeit waifu'd up) ORT?

to:

- if * If this troper's memory serves correctly , correctly, isn't kuku Kukulkan technically a playable (albeit waifu'd up) ORT?ORT?
** She's the avatar of its deified heart/reactor, and her personality is considered a separate entity (thus being capable of fighting it).

Changed: 108

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
someone help me clear this confusion up..



to:

- if this troper's memory serves correctly , isn't kuku technically a playable (albeit waifu'd up) ORT?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: ORT will become playable]]
Now that it wrote itself into the Throne, and there apparently existing no ways to properly block someone from summoning and being very hard to remove them from the Throne, it will eventually be summoned as well, albeit not as a Grand, but in a demoted form, subject to gameplay balance. The base form will look like ORT Xibalba, and ascension will transform it into Star Cell. Its alignment would be a string of incomrehensible alien symbols, as probably at least a part of its bio, and all its lines would be just as unintelligible. Despite that it will eventually start hanging out with Ritsuka and display affection at higher bond level, in its own, alien way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Kadoc's Sirius Light will be used to destroy CHALDEAS]]
Daybit's lecture was clearly important, and his main goal is to overturn Marisbury's Grand Order.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Primate Murder: He could share the same "Homonidae" Servant advantage and "Demonic Beast" Servant disadvantage that Koyanskaya had, but in this instance he wouldn't have the Caster disadvantage...maybe replace that with Moon Cancer considering his background in Tsukihime.

to:

* Primate Murder: He could share the same "Homonidae" Servant advantage and "Demonic Beast" Servant disadvantage that Koyanskaya had, but in this instance he wouldn't have the Caster disadvantage... maybe replace that with Moon Cancer considering his background in Tsukihime.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Not really in FGO, but Toru Okawa and Mai Nakahara joined in [[Literature/FateApocrypha Apocrypha]] as Gordes and Reika, respectively. Also, Aya Suzaki joined in [[Anime/FatePrototype Fragments Drama CD]] as Elsa. Recent announcement of VideoGame/FateExtellaLink, Kazuhiko Inoue voice a new Ruler Servant, Karl der Große (the historical version of Charlemagne). Creator/DaisukeHirakawa voices Melvin Weinz in ''LightNovel/LordElMelloiIICaseFiles''. Creator/YoshimasaHosoya voice Tiberius in the fifth Prototype Fragments Drama CD. Soma Saito voices Wodime, one of the Crypters.

to:

*** Not really in FGO, but Toru Okawa and Mai Nakahara joined in [[Literature/FateApocrypha Apocrypha]] as Gordes and Reika, respectively. Also, Aya Suzaki joined in [[Anime/FatePrototype Fragments Drama CD]] as Elsa. Recent announcement of VideoGame/FateExtellaLink, Kazuhiko Inoue voice a new Ruler Servant, Karl der Große (the historical version of Charlemagne). Creator/DaisukeHirakawa voices Melvin Weinz in ''LightNovel/LordElMelloiIICaseFiles''.''Literature/LordElMelloiIICaseFiles''. Creator/YoshimasaHosoya voice Tiberius in the fifth Prototype Fragments Drama CD. Soma Saito voices Wodime, one of the Crypters.



* In the anime only episode of ''LightNovel/LordElMelloiIICaseFiles'', the patriarch of the an offshoot family (Ernest Fargo) of the Animuspheres tries to make himself a god using the Heliocentric model of Astrology. Lord El-Melloi II explained that ultimately the symbolism depicted Ernest as the Sun, or a god. Ernest doesn't quite make it, so he tries to hijack the body of his daughter while making the needed corrections.

to:

* In the anime only episode of ''LightNovel/LordElMelloiIICaseFiles'', ''Literature/LordElMelloiIICaseFiles'', the patriarch of the an offshoot family (Ernest Fargo) of the Animuspheres tries to make himself a god using the Heliocentric model of Astrology. Lord El-Melloi II explained that ultimately the symbolism depicted Ernest as the Sun, or a god. Ernest doesn't quite make it, so he tries to hijack the body of his daughter while making the needed corrections.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[WMG: The real nature of Subject E]]
So, the branch like being that is known as Subject E is heavily implied to be a still living human, but their appearance is very weird for it. But it is heavily implied Subject E is tied to CHALDEA in some form. Now it is well known CHALDEA is a planet and have a gravity mass akin to a black hole. The fate of anyone sent through a black hole is spaghettification, the vertical stretching and horizontal compression of objects into long thin shapes like spaghetti over an eternity. Wouldn’t you say Subject E looks like that? Yeah, Subject E is the spaghettificated remains of a human who is trapped being alive.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
archer emiya could get a beast version to round out the fate extra trio all having beast forms ( tamamo - >amaratsu , nero = Sodom's beast / draco)



to:

* archer emiya/ nameless

Added: 12

Changed: 42

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* A version of BB who became a full Beast.
* Kazuradrop

Added: 995

Changed: 74

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Thankfully Jossed

(Addition after Ordeal Call and Arcade collaboration event) While Noah’s absence in the event’s story is very jarring considering he was the Grand Servant who got assigned to deal with Draco, in Arcade Babylon he never identified ''which'' Sixth Beast he was supposed to vanquish, so there’s a possibility that he got the wrong Beast VI half. As he was shown befriending Arthur during Chaldea Summer Garden, maybe, just like him, Noah’s true target is Beast VI/G, and he was deliberately sent to lose against Draco so that he would meet Arthur and exchange informations with him. Also, some keywords in Ordeal Call trailer imply that one of the trials might involve a Holy Grail War set in Tokyo, Prototype’s setting. Furthermore, depending on the game’s production schedule going forward, by the time Ordeal Call is implemented, Noah might be “allowed” to appear in the mobile version with little changes, as it will be over one year since his playable debut in Arcade.
But, again, we shall see…




to:

* Manaka Sajyou with Beast of Revelations as her “ride”
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Abe no Seimei
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Beast Kingprotea, with Tiamat being her active component instead of Airavata (Much like how Melt = Saraswati, Lambda = Leviathan)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Future Beast-Class Servants]]
With Lasengle releasing the most hyped Servant Class yet in the form of the Beast class, it's likely we're going to see an influx of new Beast-class Servants to fill in slots and encourage players to roll for them on the gacha. With previous Beasts of Humanity already summonable, we're likely going to see Beast-class variants of them. Potential future Beast-class Servants include:
* Goetia, possibly with "Romani Archaman" as his first Ascension, "Solomon" as his second, and Goetia as his third.
* U-Olga Marie
* Camazotz
* Kama, this time in his widely-demanded male form.
* Ultimate Elisa X, to complete Elisabeth's set of a variant in all classes.
* Dark Sakura
* Primate Murder
* Merlin
* Thia Escardos
* Neco-Arc
* Tanaka
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG:Playable Beast advantages/disadvantages]]
Sodom's Beast/Draco was released in F/GO as the game's first-ever playable Beast, where she's strong against the main seven classes but weak against the Extra classes. However, the game's director has stated that this will be exclusive to Draco herself. With this in mind, it makes one wonder what the other Beasts will be like in terms of advantages and disadvantages. The current ones in the game right now:
* Goetia: He was effectively Pretender (strong against Knight classes, weak against Cavalry classes) before Oberon made those resistances official, though Goetia also deals less damage to Avengers. I feel like the team could tweak Goetia to set himself apart from Pretenders.
* Camazotz: He's generally identical to Goetia, except he's also strong against Foreigners and weak against Moon Cancers.
* Tiamat: The Beast Tiamat we've fought had effectively a Shielder-class neutrality to all damage.
* Kiara Sessyoin: Beast Kiara is weak to Alter Egos and Moon Cancers, but otherwise took neutral damage.
* Kama: Beast Kama/Mara is identical to Kiara, except the Moon Cancer weakness is swapped out for that of Foreigner.
* Koyanskaya: The only Beast out of all of them to majorly not have advantages/disadvantages tied to Servant class (Save for dealing less damage to Casters), Koyanskaya dealt had advantage over Homonidae Servants and disadvantage against Demonic Beast Servants.
* U-Olga Marie: Much like Tiamat, U-Olga has effectively Shielder-class.

There are still a few more Beasts that haven't had an in-game appearance: Pan-Human History Beast IV (Primate Murder a.k.a. our beloved Fou), Beast V, and the other Lostbelt Beasts. Let's speculate on this:
* Primate Murder: He could share the same "Homonidae" Servant advantage and "Demonic Beast" Servant disadvantage that Koyanskaya had, but in this instance he wouldn't have the Caster disadvantage...maybe replace that with Moon Cancer considering his background in Tsukihime.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** I think this is position [[spoiler:is already taken by ORT...though I dunno if the pruning of LB7 means the slot's now open]].

to:

** I think this is position [[spoiler:is already taken by ORT... though I dunno if the pruning of LB7 means the slot's now open]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: The Crypters who were dead were there to take Fujimaru Rokka back with them to the afterlife.]]
They knew they were dead; both Ophelia and Kirschtaria made references to this.

Added: 2163

Changed: 3

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** '''Rulers''': While Rulers are an established PHH class, as seen in ''Literature/FateApocrypha'', they are not supposed to be contracted with a Master. Rulers are supposed to act as completely independed regulators that do not hunt for the Grail themselves and do not fight unless it's to regulate the participants of a Holy Grail War. Chaldea not only has summoned several Rulers and contracted already summoned ones (literally the FIRST THING WE DID post Singularity F), we threw them straight in the thick of battle too.

to:

** '''Rulers''': While Rulers are an established PHH class, as seen in ''Literature/FateApocrypha'', they are not supposed to be contracted with a Master. Rulers are supposed to act as completely independed independent regulators that do not hunt for the Grail themselves and do not fight unless it's to regulate the participants of a Holy Grail War. Chaldea not only has summoned several Rulers and contracted already summoned ones (literally the FIRST THING WE DID post Singularity F), we threw them straight in the thick of battle too.


Added DiffLines:

[[WMG:The Chaldean could actually be Galahad.]]
The Chaldean, now called Romani Archaman in the game, confirms that he is ''not'' Dr. Roman, but that leaves the question of who he is. Wodime is pretty sure that he is Goetia, but there is another theory out there; that he's actually Galahad. The eveidence goes as following:
* Galahad left Mash at the end of the Solomon arc.
* The Chaldean and Galahad have the same eye colour. We see that Mash has golden eyes when under Galahad's direct control.
* He is stated to fight with a thin sword in [=LB1=].
* The only thing he does during the Lostbelts is defend people, and he cannot grasp why they would want to repay him for that.
* His bounded field around the villages in Scandinavia are described as "designed to ward from outside attacks, like a shield or fortress wall". He is also shown being able to protect himself from attacks strong enough to wound Zeus, so that's one hell of a defensive power.
* The person who stole one of Solomon's rings after he was erased as a Heroic Spirit is still unknown.
* If what he is possessing is indeed Romani's corpse, then it is a body used to house a Heroic Spirit, like it did with Solomon.
* When he praises Morgan in [=LB6=], she feels as if he's mocking her. That's a reasonable impression if Morgan gets praised by a member of the original Round Table, of all people.
* In [=LB7=], he is pissed when dealing with the protagonist, and gets even angrier when Mash is brought up. He sort of implies that Mash is his BerserkButton of some sort. In the Moonlight Lostroom, Galahad treats the protagonist quite horribly, and his treatment of Mash throughout the game isn't exactly stellar.
* When he talks about Ordeal Call, he mentions four extra classes before he corrects himself and says three, mentioning that "he took care" of the fourth. Galahad is an Extra Class servant.
* He sees the CHALDEAS as his enemy. It was established very early on that Galahad doesn't aprove in any capacity the shit that Marisbury did while he was in charge.
Mind you all of this is a theory I don't personally support, but it makes sense to a degree and I'd like to see what others think of it.

Added: 1755

Removed: 867

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Ordeal Calls are based on Apostles of the Foreign God]]
Classes more troublesome from the World's point of view (aliens and their proxies, glitches in the matrix, and walking lies) are conspicuous by their absence. Meanwhile, Rasputin, Muramasa and Douman are Alter-Egos, [[spoiler:Holmes]] and Moriarty are Rulers, and the most well-known Count Servant, who's also canonically helping Chaldea - [[spoiler:Edmond Dantes]], is an Avenger. Teased chapter titles might also hint at them - [[spoiler:Holmes]] is explicitly called a fair arbitrator at one point, while [[spoiler:Dantes]] has a prominent fire motif. Romani initially says there are four Ordeals, before backpedalling and insisting there are only three - the last one then is most likely related to [[spoiler:U-Olga-Marie]], whose class cannot be determined by the system and current state is dubious.


Added DiffLines:


[[WMG: Ordeal Calls are based on Apostles of the Foreign God]]
*Rewriting this WMG for clarity.

There're some curious points. Circumstantial evidence is that classes more troublesome from the World's point of view (aliens and their proxies, glitches in the matrix, and walking lies) are conspicuous by their absence (barring Chaldean's slip of the tongue). More direct evidence is the names for the upcoming Ordeal Call chapters:
* Arbitrator Upholding the Balance: Pilgrimage Toward Awareness of One's Uncertain Sins - perfectly matches [[spoiler:Holmes]], with being explicitly called an arbitrator of balance once and discovery of sins, uncertain due to [[spoiler:his amnesia]]. Summoned as a Ruler.
* Perpetual Avenger: All-Consuming Flame of Vengeance - pretty good match for [[spoiler:Monte-Cristo]], an Avenger and one of the few Counts in employ of Novum Chaldea.
* Personality Split Off From the Ego: Confrontation with One's Inner Self - ok, either there's a double meaning in the Japanese version, or that indeed matches the definition of Alter-Ego class, but it can be streched to mean [[spoiler:Moriarty]], who was split from his main story nearly at the origin point and mostly emulates his own vision of himself proper (instead of, well, being himself).
Additional point is that Chaldean discusses how the Foreign World appointed three of its apostles to be assistants to Chaldea (the Detective, the Count and the Professor) shortly before explaining the Ordeal Calls to Chaldea.
Yet another point that the Foreign World is now [[spoiler:the last bastion of the Human Order]] per Chaldean's words, and thus Novum Chaldea must justify the violation of the ban by the Foreign World, with them also using the same Servants as a sort of a coincidence.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** I think this is position [[spoiler:is already taken by ORT...though I dunno if the pruning of LB7 means the slot's now open]].

Added: 60

Changed: 363

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Beast Angra Mainyu, depicting him as the EldritchAbomination he would have become had he been reincarnated through the Fuyuki Grail -- possibly as the Shadow from "Heaven's Feel", his partially manifested form from the ''Anime/FateStayNightUnlimitedBladeWorks'' anime, the blackened Greater Grail from ''Literature/FateZero'', or "Grail-kun" from ''Anime/CarnivalPhantasm''.

to:

* Beast Angra Mainyu, depicting him as the EldritchAbomination [[EldritchAbomination Beast of Retribution]] he would have become had he been reincarnated through the Fuyuki Grail -- possibly as the Shadow from "Heaven's Feel", his partially manifested form from the ''Anime/FateStayNightUnlimitedBladeWorks'' anime, the blackened Greater Grail from ''Literature/FateZero'', or "Grail-kun" from ''Anime/CarnivalPhantasm''.




to:

* Avenger Altria, where she stops resisting Aŋra Mainiiu's corruption and fully embraces All the World's Evil
* Avenger Vortigern, depicting his BlackKnight form from PHH




to:

* Grand Foreigner: Randolph Carter: The protagonist of Lovecraft's Dream-Quest saga has already been confirmed to exist, and his repeated interactions with eldritch entities would make him the perfect candidate.



** '''Foreigners:''' Foreigners are a very important part of PHH. ORT is only here on Earth because of the presence of humanity. Velber's invasion (who is established as a Foreigner in the EXTELLA games) was so important that two different Lostbelts spawned from that invasion having a different outcome (not to mention the long term consequences, like Attila the Hun, the current form of the Olympus Gods, the creation of the Valkyries and Tametomo, and who knows what else). Then there are PHH figures talking about Foreigners, like Lovecraft and Gilles, and finally there's the ''man-made'' Foreigner Voyager. Voyager in particular carries explicit and undeniable proof of the existence of PHH.

to:

** '''Foreigners:''' Foreigners are a very important part of PHH. ORT is only here on Earth because of the presence of humanity. Velber's invasion (who is established as a Foreigner in the EXTELLA games) invasion was so important that two different Lostbelts spawned from that invasion having a different outcome (not to mention the long term consequences, like Attila the Hun, the current form of the Olympus Gods, the creation of the Valkyries and Tametomo, and who knows what else). Then there are PHH figures talking about Foreigners, like Lovecraft and Gilles, and finally there's the ''man-made'' Foreigner Voyager. Voyager in particular carries explicit and undeniable proof of the existence of PHH.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Counterpoint to this one: Foreigners are, by definition, ''not of the human order''. Why would PHH permit them when less-anomalous classes are banned? Furthermore, the story has the Chaldean start to say "four" before correcting himself to "three" so presumably one banned class has just recently had the restriction removed. Since this is in the immediate aftermath of the creation of Grand Foreigner, that presumably means Foreigner was, at first, on the "ban list" as well, and that the existence of a Grand Class is the key to that lock. Also note how literally every Foreigner in PHH either formed there (Voyager, Abby, Hokusai) or is an eldritch abomination so powerful it can brute-force its way past PHH's "you cannot exist" defenses (Velber, ORT).

Added: 137

Changed: 115

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I know the WMG have long since been partially confirmed, but it's fun to keep all pieces of foreshadowing here.


* In the FGO mats, Sigurd takes special notice of him and then has a DoubleTake. He also seems confused about him in his material profile. The fact that Sigurd noticed Caster is odd, but it should also be noted that Sigurd encountered Odin a number of times in his legend, thus making him one of the most likely people to recognize him.

to:

* In the FGO mats, Sigurd takes special notice of him and then has a DoubleTake. He also seems confused about him in his material profile. The fact that Sigurd noticed Caster is odd, but it should also be noted that Sigurd encountered Odin a number of times in his legend, thus making him one of the most likely people to recognize him.



* The recent Lostbelt 6 update also adds fuel to the fire. In My Room dialogues, Scáthach tells him that his Rune magic is slightly different from what she taught him. He asks Sigurd not to look at him with the glasses, when he sees Brynhildr he muses that this must be fate/karma and specifically refers to Scáthach-Skadi as "Lostbelt Skadi."

to:

* The recent Lostbelt 6 update also adds fuel to the fire. In My Room dialogues, Scáthach tells him that his Rune magic is slightly different from what she taught him. He asks Sigurd not to look at him with the glasses, when he sees Brynhildr he muses that this must be fate/karma and specifically refers to Scáthach-Skadi as "Lostbelt Skadi."Skadi", which contrasts how all other Celtic Servants address her.


Added DiffLines:

* Caster is seen alongside Hildr in the "Dance Tournament in the Land of Shadows" event, even though he should have no connection to her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[WMG: Why these specific Classes for Ordeal Call?]]
So at the beginning of Ordeal Call, we are told that PHH is barring us entry specifically for using Rulers, Avengers, and Alter Egos. This comes of as weird considering there are several extra classes. This is what I think explains the situation:
* Banned Classes:
** '''Rulers''': While Rulers are an established PHH class, as seen in ''Literature/FateApocrypha'', they are not supposed to be contracted with a Master. Rulers are supposed to act as completely independed regulators that do not hunt for the Grail themselves and do not fight unless it's to regulate the participants of a Holy Grail War. Chaldea not only has summoned several Rulers and contracted already summoned ones (literally the FIRST THING WE DID post Singularity F), we threw them straight in the thick of battle too.
** '''Avengers''': That class is straight up not supposed to exist. The only reason it exists is because the Einzberns messed with the Fuyuki Grail. While there are several PHH Avengers, it's heavily implied that none of them would be in that class if not for the existence of Angra Manyu. In addition, the [[Characters/FateGrandOrderAvengers Avengers]] page points out that each of them plays like they belong in a different class (like Dantes playing like a Rider of an Archer, or Salieri playing like an offensive Caster). Us utilizing a class that should not exist and has already been established as an anomaly goes against Human Order.
** '''Alter Egos''': Technically the class started as BB experimenting, but now everyone and their grandmother can be summoned in it. The issue is that all Alter Egos are an amalgamation of partial and/or mangled Spirit Origins fused with also partial and mangled Divine Spirit origins. It was already established in Babylonia that full blown Divine Spirits are A Big Deal, so screwing with them like that goes against the order of things. Also, it is far from a contained phenomenon. This is another class that should not exist, it messes with the natural order of the Throne, abuses the Pseudoservant system and has gotten out of control.
* Permitted Classes:
** '''Shielders''': We already know there are PHH Shielders, like Galahad. My headcanon is that there are a lot of servants that qualify for this class but just get summoned in more convetional ones. Example, Achilles who has a shield Noble Phantasm.
** '''Moon Cancers''': While this hits many of the same boxes as Alter Ego, it is a ''contained'' phenomenon. With the exception of Archetype Earth, all Moon Cancers are directly connected to the Moon Cell and BB. In fact, it's implied that you need ''BB's permission'' to be part of this class. Yes, Summer Kiara did hijack it, but she still plays within the pre-established system set by BB. In other words, this class has an active regulator that severely restricts access to the class, and that access is connected to a very specific computer in a very specific branch of PHH.
** '''Foreigners:''' Foreigners are a very important part of PHH. ORT is only here on Earth because of the presence of humanity. Velber's invasion (who is established as a Foreigner in the EXTELLA games) was so important that two different Lostbelts spawned from that invasion having a different outcome (not to mention the long term consequences, like Attila the Hun, the current form of the Olympus Gods, the creation of the Valkyries and Tametomo, and who knows what else). Then there are PHH figures talking about Foreigners, like Lovecraft and Gilles, and finally there's the ''man-made'' Foreigner Voyager. Voyager in particular carries explicit and undeniable proof of the existence of PHH.
** '''Pretenders:''' By definition this class slips under the radar as they can disguise themselves as several different classes. In addition, there ARE PHH Pretenders. Examples are Hephastion (as in Fate the current depiction of Alexander are based on her), Mexico City, quite possibly Amanojaku from [=GUDA6=] (would explain Okuni's append and fit his modus operandi), and also quite possibly Ieyasu who changes classes every five minutes. Furthermore, their presence is an active hindrance to the Foreign God, as seen in [=LB6=]. With all that taken into account, PHH either can't find them or lets them slide.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[LightNovel/FateZero The Magus Killer Kiritsugu Emiya]], as it turns out.

to:

** [[LightNovel/FateZero [[Literature/FateZero The Magus Killer Kiritsugu Emiya]], as it turns out.



* Beast Angra Mainyu, depicting him as the EldritchAbomination he would have become had he been reincarnated through the Fuyuki Grail -- possibly as the Shadow from "Heaven's Feel", his partially manifested form from the ''Anime/FateStayNightUnlimitedBladeWorks'' anime, the blackened Greater Grail from ''LightNovel/FateZero'', or "Grail-kun" from ''Anime/CarnivalPhantasm''.

to:

* Beast Angra Mainyu, depicting him as the EldritchAbomination he would have become had he been reincarnated through the Fuyuki Grail -- possibly as the Shadow from "Heaven's Feel", his partially manifested form from the ''Anime/FateStayNightUnlimitedBladeWorks'' anime, the blackened Greater Grail from ''LightNovel/FateZero'', ''Literature/FateZero'', or "Grail-kun" from ''Anime/CarnivalPhantasm''.



*** Not really in FGO, but Toru Okawa and Mai Nakahara joined in [[LightNovel/FateApocrypha Apocrypha]] as Gordes and Reika, respectively. Also, Aya Suzaki joined in [[Anime/FatePrototype Fragments Drama CD]] as Elsa. Recent announcement of VideoGame/FateExtellaLink, Kazuhiko Inoue voice a new Ruler Servant, Karl der Große (the historical version of Charlemagne). Creator/DaisukeHirakawa voices Melvin Weinz in ''LightNovel/LordElMelloiIICaseFiles''. Creator/YoshimasaHosoya voice Tiberius in the fifth Prototype Fragments Drama CD. Soma Saito voices Wodime, one of the Crypters.

to:

*** Not really in FGO, but Toru Okawa and Mai Nakahara joined in [[LightNovel/FateApocrypha [[Literature/FateApocrypha Apocrypha]] as Gordes and Reika, respectively. Also, Aya Suzaki joined in [[Anime/FatePrototype Fragments Drama CD]] as Elsa. Recent announcement of VideoGame/FateExtellaLink, Kazuhiko Inoue voice a new Ruler Servant, Karl der Große (the historical version of Charlemagne). Creator/DaisukeHirakawa voices Melvin Weinz in ''LightNovel/LordElMelloiIICaseFiles''. Creator/YoshimasaHosoya voice Tiberius in the fifth Prototype Fragments Drama CD. Soma Saito voices Wodime, one of the Crypters.



* Angra Mainyu, not as Avenger from ''VisualNovel/FateHollowAtaraxia'' but as [[EldritchAbomination All the World's Evil]], the blackened Greater Grail and/or the Shadow from ''LightNovel/FateZero'' and ''VisualNovel/FateStayNight''. Nasu has stated that when Avenger was defeated in the 3rd Grail War the Fuyuki Grail tried to grant the wishes of the ancient Zoroastrians and turn him into the incarnation of All the World's Evil, and had it done so he would have been reborn as a genuine GodOfEvil; and his All the World's Evil form is noted to be eerily similar to Tiamat in the Babylonia chapter. Furthermore, in ''Unlimited Blade Works'' Gilgamesh calls it one of the "great evils of mankind," a moniker also used to refer to the Beasts. Ergo, it's possible that Angra Mainyu - or an AU version of him successfully incarnated as All the World's Evil - would qualify as a Beast.

to:

* Angra Mainyu, not as Avenger from ''VisualNovel/FateHollowAtaraxia'' but as [[EldritchAbomination All the World's Evil]], the blackened Greater Grail and/or the Shadow from ''LightNovel/FateZero'' ''Literature/FateZero'' and ''VisualNovel/FateStayNight''. Nasu has stated that when Avenger was defeated in the 3rd Grail War the Fuyuki Grail tried to grant the wishes of the ancient Zoroastrians and turn him into the incarnation of All the World's Evil, and had it done so he would have been reborn as a genuine GodOfEvil; and his All the World's Evil form is noted to be eerily similar to Tiamat in the Babylonia chapter. Furthermore, in ''Unlimited Blade Works'' Gilgamesh calls it one of the "great evils of mankind," a moniker also used to refer to the Beasts. Ergo, it's possible that Angra Mainyu - or an AU version of him successfully incarnated as All the World's Evil - would qualify as a Beast.



With the ''LightNovel/TheGardenOfSinners'' Event returning, to everyone's surprise, and introducing a new Servant in the form of Asagami Fujino, it's possible that when we reach the reruns of the next collaboration events, they will also introduce new Limited Servants:

Fate/Zero: Kiritsugu and Irisviel have already been made Servants, and the rest of the human cast of LightNovel/FateZero is either not noteworthy enough to become a Servant or have already been made Demi-Servants (Waver, Rin, and Sakura)--except that if there's one thing LightNovel/FateZero is, it's that it's the OriginStory of the legend of Shirou Emiya, using Sengo Muramasa as a complement to his power like Waver does. Like the two forms of Rin, he may appear as a Limited Servant. It would indeed be the perfect opportunity to bring the EnsembleDarkhorse and former protagonist into the gacha.

to:

With the ''LightNovel/TheGardenOfSinners'' ''Literature/TheGardenOfSinners'' Event returning, to everyone's surprise, and introducing a new Servant in the form of Asagami Fujino, it's possible that when we reach the reruns of the next collaboration events, they will also introduce new Limited Servants:

Fate/Zero: Kiritsugu and Irisviel have already been made Servants, and the rest of the human cast of LightNovel/FateZero Literature/FateZero is either not noteworthy enough to become a Servant or have already been made Demi-Servants (Waver, Rin, and Sakura)--except that if there's one thing LightNovel/FateZero Literature/FateZero is, it's that it's the OriginStory of the legend of Shirou Emiya, using Sengo Muramasa as a complement to his power like Waver does. Like the two forms of Rin, he may appear as a Limited Servant. It would indeed be the perfect opportunity to bring the EnsembleDarkhorse and former protagonist into the gacha.



[[WMG: The completed FGO version of ''LightNovel/FateZero'' will be radically different.]]

to:

[[WMG: The completed FGO version of ''LightNovel/FateZero'' ''Literature/FateZero'' will be radically different.]]



[[WMG: Kiyohime had an early onset of [[{{LightNovel/DDD}} Abnormal Agonist Syndrome]].]]

to:

[[WMG: Kiyohime had an early onset of [[{{LightNovel/DDD}} [[{{Literature/DDD}} Abnormal Agonist Syndrome]].]]



** This is called The World Egg phenomonom. It was how [[Videogame/MeltyBlood Dust Of Osiris]] was going to end the world. ...it's how [[LightNovel/TheGardenOfSinners Araya]] was going to as well.

to:

** This is called The World Egg phenomonom. It was how [[Videogame/MeltyBlood Dust Of Osiris]] was going to end the world. ...it's how [[LightNovel/TheGardenOfSinners [[Literature/TheGardenOfSinners Araya]] was going to as well.



There is also one other thing supporting the idea that the Galahad we see is his true self, and the one the knights knew was a mask: LightNovel/FateRequiem introduces a Saber Servant as one of the major characters: ''Galahad Alter''. Alterhad is explicitly said to have abandoned the Knights Creed and his identity as "The Perfect Knight", and acts a lot more like how he's described by his fellow knights, and more like his father Lancelot, being a HandsomeLech. Alter servants are specifically described as alternate versions of Servants due to various circumstances. Edgemiya was broken enough due to his actions as a Counter Guardian he's pretty much an EmptyShell. Salter is one who feels cruelty and hatred is needed to achieve her goals. [[spoiler:[[Literature/FateStrangeFake Alcides]] is Heracles forced to abandon his ideals and relive his trauma, turning him into the NayTheist and a dark killer.]] So Alterhad is one who abandoned the persona he had to bear, and was no longer pure. He became as the others described him, but only because he was tired of the burden being "The Perfect Knight" brought him.

to:

There is also one other thing supporting the idea that the Galahad we see is his true self, and the one the knights knew was a mask: LightNovel/FateRequiem Literature/FateRequiem introduces a Saber Servant as one of the major characters: ''Galahad Alter''. Alterhad is explicitly said to have abandoned the Knights Creed and his identity as "The Perfect Knight", and acts a lot more like how he's described by his fellow knights, and more like his father Lancelot, being a HandsomeLech. Alter servants are specifically described as alternate versions of Servants due to various circumstances. Edgemiya was broken enough due to his actions as a Counter Guardian he's pretty much an EmptyShell. Salter is one who feels cruelty and hatred is needed to achieve her goals. [[spoiler:[[Literature/FateStrangeFake Alcides]] is Heracles forced to abandon his ideals and relive his trauma, turning him into the NayTheist and a dark killer.]] So Alterhad is one who abandoned the persona he had to bear, and was no longer pure. He became as the others described him, but only because he was tired of the burden being "The Perfect Knight" brought him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Unsurprisingly jossed: Subject E is [[spoiler: a human... from ''the foreign world CHALDEAS'' (a fact which trips up every analysis made for some reason), and may in fact be the player character's counterpart from it]].

Top