Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WMG / Clannad

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* QuantumMechanicsCanDoAnything. Even SaveScumming. You cannot subjectively experience your own death, so reality has to snap back to the point at which you may choose a different path.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Clannad broke the forth wall in episode 22 of ''After Story''.]]

to:

[[WMG: Clannad broke the forth fourth wall in episode 22 of ''After Story''.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Let's recapitulate: Tomoya's mother dies in his early childhood. His dreams of being a basketball player are shattered by his father who accidentally breaks his shoulder. Then, Tomoya's father, full of angst, drinks and wastes his money at gambling. Then Tomoya marries Nagisa, sees her dying by childbirth at home while a snow tempest blows outside. Then he leaves his daughter Ushio to her grandparents until he wakes up five years later and takes her back from them so they can finally cry for their daughter. And finally, Ushio, who was pretty healthy until then, suddenly becomes ill and dies in the street in his father's arms (under the snow, of course). At this rate, a third season of Clannad might feature the Furukawas' bakery burning down to the ground (with them in it), a major earthquake crumbling down the whole city while Tomoya is hunting starfishes at the beach, and end with a homeless and drunk Tomoya dying, eaten alive by boars. And more snow.

to:

Let's recapitulate: Tomoya's mother dies in his early childhood. His dreams of being a basketball player are shattered by his father who accidentally breaks his shoulder. Then, Tomoya's father, full of angst, drinks and wastes his money at gambling. Then Tomoya marries Nagisa, sees her dying by childbirth at home while a snow tempest blows outside. Then he leaves his daughter Ushio to her grandparents until he wakes up five years later and takes her back from them so they can finally cry for their daughter. And finally, Ushio, who was pretty healthy until then, suddenly becomes ill and dies in the street in his father's arms (under the snow, of course). At this rate, a third season of Clannad might feature the Furukawas' bakery burning down to the ground (with them in it), a major earthquake crumbling down the whole city while Tomoya is hunting starfishes at the beach, and end with a homeless and drunk Tomoya dying, eaten alive by boars. [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking And more snow.snow]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added a WMG


While the fact that Ryou's life was in danger is the main reason, but [[spoiler: the buscrash]] makes it even harder for her.

to:

While the fact that Ryou's life was in danger is the main reason, but [[spoiler: the buscrash]] makes it even harder for her.her.

[[WMG: The "Another World" chapters take place in a universe where Nagisa's illness ''did'' kill her as a child.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




to:

\n*Actually, we only see him in the suit once, and that is on his way to job interviews. In the game Tomoyo After his "recycling job" is much more blue collar. He rides around in a truck collecting broken appliances that he can repair or sell for parts.

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Namespace


Based on previous WMG. Just listen to them. They sound [[MaiNakahara exactly the same]], and they both love cute things. They're also both in after-school clubs.

to:

Based on previous WMG. Just listen to them. They sound [[MaiNakahara [[Creator/MaiNakahara exactly the same]], and they both love cute things. They're also both in after-school clubs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Time for an elaboration. The city gets it's satisfaction when people cross the DespairEventHorizon. When Nagisa was nearly dying, the city knew that her death will only affect her parents and thus will not satisfy it. Around this time, they also noticed Tomoya's depressing relation with his father. It decided to have Tomoya follow in his father's foot steps. So what do they do? Time for a GambitRoulette! First, the city gives Nagisa some of it's life force to keep her going until she meets and eventually falls in love with Tomoya. Soon during After Story, when Nagisa is preggers, the city decides it's time to kill her off. Bonus points if you can consider the city may have the power to control the "[[KamenRiderDouble WEATHER!]]" (sorry, couldn't resist.) After being satisfied with the death and grieving, they decide to bother Tomoya's life when he reunites with his daughter by ''taking her life force away''. This winds up killing Tomoya too. So that reset button ending? It was Fuuko behind it all, and how does Tomoya clearly recall the downer ending? Because it's like being traumatized, you can never block it out of your mind.

to:

* Time for an elaboration. The city gets it's satisfaction when people cross the DespairEventHorizon. When Nagisa was nearly dying, the city knew that her death will only affect her parents and thus will not satisfy it. Around this time, they also noticed Tomoya's depressing relation with his father. It decided to have Tomoya follow in his father's foot steps. So what do they do? Time for a GambitRoulette! First, the city gives Nagisa some of it's life force to keep her going until she meets and eventually falls in love with Tomoya. Soon during After Story, when Nagisa is preggers, the city decides it's time to kill her off. Bonus points if you can consider the city may have the power to control the "[[KamenRiderDouble "[[Series/KamenRiderDouble WEATHER!]]" (sorry, couldn't resist.) After being satisfied with the death and grieving, they decide to bother Tomoya's life when he reunites with his daughter by ''taking her life force away''. This winds up killing Tomoya too. So that reset button ending? It was Fuuko behind it all, and how does Tomoya clearly recall the downer ending? Because it's like being traumatized, you can never block it out of your mind.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Kotomi went to America to work at [[HalfLife Black Mesa]].]]

to:

[[WMG: Kotomi went to America to work at [[HalfLife [[VideoGame/HalfLife Black Mesa]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG:Fuko will team up with [[FateZero Fate/Zero´s Caster]] and conquer the world with starfish]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Misae Sagara is the daughter of [[FullMetalPanic Kaname Chidori and Sousuke Sagara.]]]]

to:

[[WMG: Misae Sagara is the daughter of [[FullMetalPanic [[LightNovel/FullMetalPanic Kaname Chidori and Sousuke Sagara.]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** It is possible that the real Shiima wished for his cat to grant Misae's wish in his place. Once Misae made her wish to Shiima and he granted it himself by remaining with her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added a WMG


2. Alternatively, neither of their wishes were actually granted. I hate to bring up the image of a parasite, but that might be what it was. Why was Shiima human in the first place? Someone may have wished he was, most likely his former owner before he died. If so, why did Shiima revert back to a cat? It is possible that keeping Shiima a human for the rest of his life would have been too difficult, requiring more magical power than an orb can provide.This also explains why it took more than one to bring Ushio and Nagisa back to life, and why Nagisa was only temporarily saved at the beginning. Eventually the orb became used up, in trying to keep Shiima a human. And when it was gone, there was no more power to keep his humanity.

to:

2. Alternatively, neither of their wishes were actually granted. I hate to bring up the image of a parasite, but that might be what it was. Why was Shiima human in the first place? Someone may have wished he was, most likely his former owner before he died. If so, why did Shiima revert back to a cat? It is possible that keeping Shiima a human for the rest of his life would have been too difficult, requiring more magical power than an orb can provide.This also explains why it took more than one to bring Ushio and Nagisa back to life, and why Nagisa was only temporarily saved at the beginning. Eventually the orb became used up, in trying to keep Shiima a human. And when it was gone, there was no more power to keep his humanity.humanity.

[[WMG: The reason of Kotomi's breakdown in 12. episode is that she is reminded of [[spoiler: the ending of Little Busters]] (Major spoilers for another Key VN) ]]

While the fact that Ryou's life was in danger is the main reason, but [[spoiler: the buscrash]] makes it even harder for her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Finally, when things calm down and Akio is well enough to go run the bakery again, Nagisa and Tomoya feel it's the right time to start their own family. Nagisa, healthy over the sickness caused by the plains being destroyed have passed and Ushio was brought into the world safely.

to:

Finally, when things calm down and Akio is well enough to go run the bakery again, Nagisa and Tomoya feel it's the right time to start their own family. Nagisa, healthy over the sickness caused by the plains being destroyed have passed and Ushio was brought into the world safely.safely.

[[WMG: Misae wasn't the one who made the wish during her highschool days, and Shiima may have been using it to exist as a human]]
When Shiima showed her the charm, there wasn't anything in it. Without an orb to wish upon, logically it shouldn't have been her wish that got granted.

1. Who's wish was granted then? Well obviously it must have been Shiima's. I just played through the route in the vn and both of Misae's and Shiima's wishes were practically identical. The wish was to love them forever. And if it was indeed Shiima's wish that got granted, then that was indeed successful, Misae forever loved him. In her route, she resigned herself to being alone because she couldn't imagine herself with another because like the wish, she still loved Shiima and she would forever.

2. Alternatively, neither of their wishes were actually granted. I hate to bring up the image of a parasite, but that might be what it was. Why was Shiima human in the first place? Someone may have wished he was, most likely his former owner before he died. If so, why did Shiima revert back to a cat? It is possible that keeping Shiima a human for the rest of his life would have been too difficult, requiring more magical power than an orb can provide.This also explains why it took more than one to bring Ushio and Nagisa back to life, and why Nagisa was only temporarily saved at the beginning. Eventually the orb became used up, in trying to keep Shiima a human. And when it was gone, there was no more power to keep his humanity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* I was working on the assumption that it was a kind of chronic fatigue syndrome - which is a diagnosis given when doctors don't know why someone is always tired and sick.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Alternately, an [[PuellaMagiMadokaMagica Incubator]] is behind it all, trying to harvest despair without turning people into Magical Girls.

to:

** Alternately, an [[PuellaMagiMadokaMagica [[Anime/PuellaMagiMadokaMagica Incubator]] is behind it all, trying to harvest despair without turning people into Magical Girls.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Both towns ARE stated to be somewhat sentient, and have a degree of reality warping ability.

to:

Both towns ARE stated to be somewhat sentient, and have a degree of reality warping ability.ability.

[[WMG: In the Visual Novel. The reason why the story ends with Akio's route is because everything is happy afterwards]]
To elaborate: in the visual novel, there is a point where you can go into Nagisa's after story route and the life of Ushio will come to be and all of the pain afterwards.

The other option was to encourage Akio to join a theater group however the bus Akio is on is high jacked and Akio saves everyone, but himself resulting in getting stabbed. However, they bring him to a hospital so he can recover.

One morning, without letting anyone know, Akio sneaks out to go for a smoke and Sanae catches him. Akio promises he'd never leave and you obtain a light orb. This is where the game would just end, telling you to start from the beginning of After Story again or start from one of your saves. Why?

A few things: The hospital Akio was sent to was the same hospital that was constructed in the plains where Nagisa was saved. As such, the tilling and construction of the hospital already had it's toll on Nagisa, however she didn't have to give birth due to possibly being completely side tracked by her father going to the hospital.

Finally, when things calm down and Akio is well enough to go run the bakery again, Nagisa and Tomoya feel it's the right time to start their own family. Nagisa, healthy over the sickness caused by the plains being destroyed have passed and Ushio was brought into the world safely.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Both AIDS and Lupus can be diagnosed through medical tests. It's said that the best medical professionals couldn't diagnose Nagisa's illness, and they couldn't work out what was causing her to become so sick.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Essentially correct. Tomoya and Nagisa (and to a lesser extent the rest of the characters) vaguely remember dredges of memory from their time with her (like remembering the stars are actually star''fish''), but don't remember Fuko properly when she shows up from time to time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Fuuko only appears in the finale.]]

The character running around and giving everyone starfish is either an entity trying to grant Fuuko's wishes, or possibly an entity trying to make Kouko Ibuki happy. It's the same thing that happens in Misae's story.

The difference between Fuuko's ghost and Shima's cat is that Shima's cat has one of the light orbs, so he can have an impact on the world. Fuuko's ghost gets forgotten because without the light orb, she's just the lingering wishes of the real Fuuko. And neither of them can hold their form after they've achieved their goals. Neither of them can be seen by close relatives (Shima's mom or Kouko) because they're not powerful to overcome the contradiction, and it's impossible for either to "return home" since they're impostors to begin with.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


If we are to personify the city and make it seem like a character, then we might as well consider this [[CompleteMonster option as well]].

to:

If we are to personify the city and make it seem like a character, then we might as well consider this [[CompleteMonster option as well]].well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


I mean, just look at her. She has the same blue hair as him! My theory behind this is that Okazaki didn't want his little sister to grow up with the crappy life that he has, so he had Sunohara's family look after her, and Sunahara's parents just told him that she was his sister. And he's stupid enough to believe it.

to:

I mean, just look at her. She has the same blue hair as him! My theory behind this is that Okazaki didn't want his little sister to grow up with the crappy life that he has, so he had Sunohara's family look after her, and Sunahara's parents just told him that she was his sister. And he's stupid enough to believe it.it.


[[WMG: The town that the story takes place is the diametric opposite answer to Silent Hill]]
Both towns ARE stated to be somewhat sentient, and have a degree of reality warping ability.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


So... the city has a plan. Time for a XanatosGambit!

to:

So... the city has a plan. Time for a XanatosGambit!
ThePlan.



## it was a XanatosGambit to get the other gang's leader to back down and ''listen to what she had to say'' for a change. If you watch After Story episodes 7 and 8, you'll notice the members of the other gang dismiss right away, without pausing to consider the situation, what she's trying to tell them (i.e.: "we can avoid this meaningless fight"). How do you get a manly-man to listen to what a "weak girl" has to say? [[{{Moe}} Secret]] [[TheWoobie weapon]]!

to:

## it was a XanatosGambit [[ThePlan plan]] to get the other gang's leader to back down and ''listen to what she had to say'' for a change. If you watch After Story episodes 7 and 8, you'll notice the members of the other gang dismiss right away, without pausing to consider the situation, what she's trying to tell them (i.e.: "we can avoid this meaningless fight"). How do you get a manly-man to listen to what a "weak girl" has to say? [[{{Moe}} Secret]] [[TheWoobie weapon]]!



* Time for an elaboration. The city gets it's satisfaction when people cross the DespairEventHorizon. When Nagisa was nearly dying, the city knew that her death will only affect her parents and thus will not satisfy it. Around this time, they also noticed Tomoya's depressing relation with his father. It decided to have Tomoya follow in his father's foot steps. So what do they do? Time for a XanatosRoulette! First, the city gives Nagisa some of it's life force to keep her going until she meets and eventually falls in love with Tomoya. Soon during After Story, when Nagisa is preggers, the city decides it's time to kill her off. Bonus points if you can consider the city may have the power to control the "[[KamenRiderDouble WEATHER!]]" (sorry, couldn't resist.) After being satisfied with the death and grieving, they decide to bother Tomoya's life when he reunites with his daughter by ''taking her life force away''. This winds up killing Tomoya too. So that reset button ending? It was Fuuko behind it all, and how does Tomoya clearly recall the downer ending? Because it's like being traumatized, you can never block it out of your mind.

to:

* Time for an elaboration. The city gets it's satisfaction when people cross the DespairEventHorizon. When Nagisa was nearly dying, the city knew that her death will only affect her parents and thus will not satisfy it. Around this time, they also noticed Tomoya's depressing relation with his father. It decided to have Tomoya follow in his father's foot steps. So what do they do? Time for a XanatosRoulette! GambitRoulette! First, the city gives Nagisa some of it's life force to keep her going until she meets and eventually falls in love with Tomoya. Soon during After Story, when Nagisa is preggers, the city decides it's time to kill her off. Bonus points if you can consider the city may have the power to control the "[[KamenRiderDouble WEATHER!]]" (sorry, couldn't resist.) After being satisfied with the death and grieving, they decide to bother Tomoya's life when he reunites with his daughter by ''taking her life force away''. This winds up killing Tomoya too. So that reset button ending? It was Fuuko behind it all, and how does Tomoya clearly recall the downer ending? Because it's like being traumatized, you can never block it out of your mind.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Let's recapitulate : Tomoya's mother dies in his early childhood. His dreams of being a basketball player are shattered by his father who accidentally breaks his shoulder. Then, Tomoya's father, full of angst, drinks and wastes his money at gambling. Then Tomoya marries Nagisa, sees her dying by childbirth at home while a snow tempest blows outside. Then he leaves his daughter Ushio to her grandparents until he wakes up five years later and takes her back from them so they can finally cry for their daughter. And finally, Ushio, who was pretty healthy until then, suddenly becomes ill and dies in the street in his father's arms (under the snow, of course). At this rate, a third season of Clannad might feature the Furukawas' bakery burning down to the ground (with them in it), a major earthquake crumbling down the whole city while Tomoya is hunting starfishes at the beach, and end with a homeless and drunk Tomoya dying, eaten alive by boars. And more snow.

to:

Let's recapitulate : recapitulate: Tomoya's mother dies in his early childhood. His dreams of being a basketball player are shattered by his father who accidentally breaks his shoulder. Then, Tomoya's father, full of angst, drinks and wastes his money at gambling. Then Tomoya marries Nagisa, sees her dying by childbirth at home while a snow tempest blows outside. Then he leaves his daughter Ushio to her grandparents until he wakes up five years later and takes her back from them so they can finally cry for their daughter. And finally, Ushio, who was pretty healthy until then, suddenly becomes ill and dies in the street in his father's arms (under the snow, of course). At this rate, a third season of Clannad might feature the Furukawas' bakery burning down to the ground (with them in it), a major earthquake crumbling down the whole city while Tomoya is hunting starfishes at the beach, and end with a homeless and drunk Tomoya dying, eaten alive by boars. And more snow.



[[WMG:''CLANNAD'' is a corrupted retelling of ''[[VideoGame/TheLegendOfZeldaOcarinaOfTime Ocarina of Time]]'' in a MagicRealism setting (a.k.a. Tomoya is a reincarnation of [[TheLegendOfZelda Link]]).]]

to:

[[WMG:''CLANNAD'' is a corrupted retelling of ''[[VideoGame/TheLegendOfZeldaOcarinaOfTime Ocarina of Time]]'' ''VideoGame/TheLegendOfZeldaOcarinaOfTime'' in a MagicRealism setting (a.k.a. Tomoya is a reincarnation of [[TheLegendOfZelda Link]]).Link).]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** FUCK YES. Look, Akio even has a huge friggin' bat just like Keiichi!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


I mean, just look at her. She has the same blue hair as him! My theory behind this is that Okazaki didn't want his little sister to grow up with the crappy life that he has, so he had Sunohara's family look after her, and his parents just told him that she was his sister. And he's stupid enough to believe it.

to:

I mean, just look at her. She has the same blue hair as him! My theory behind this is that Okazaki didn't want his little sister to grow up with the crappy life that he has, so he had Sunohara's family look after her, and his Sunahara's parents just told him that she was his sister. And he's stupid enough to believe it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The first season ends with an alternate-universe story where Tomoyo wins, and tells the story of how Tomoya is made to break up with her so that she can succeed as student council president without his bad influence. At a few points, we cut to a shot of a railway gate raising on a sunny day. At the end of the episode, we see Tomoya waiting behind this gate to encounter Tomoyo on the other side, who has brought a box lunch for him. A happy future in this timeline? No! In this timeline, Tomoya gets a lousy office job at a recycling facility, and wears a suit as he rides the train to work. But in this scene, Tomoya is wearing his power company work clothes, which is the job he gets in After Story ''on the main timeline''. So, it's likely we're meant to read this episode as Tomoya seeing Tomoyo and having a fleeting fancy of "what could have been", seen as the events of the alternate timeline.

to:

The first season ends with an alternate-universe story where Tomoyo wins, and tells the story of how Tomoya is made to break up with her so that she can succeed as student council president without his bad influence. At a few points, we cut to a shot of a railway gate raising on a sunny day. At the end of the episode, we see Tomoya waiting behind this gate to encounter Tomoyo on the other side, who has brought a box lunch for him. A happy future in this timeline? No! In this timeline, Tomoya gets a lousy office job at a recycling facility, and wears a suit as he rides the train to work. But in this scene, Tomoya is wearing his power company work clothes, which is the job he gets in After Story ''on the main timeline''. So, it's likely we're meant to read this episode as Tomoya seeing Tomoyo and having a fleeting fancy of "what could have been", seen as the events of the alternate timeline.timeline.


[[WMG: Mei is Okazaki's sister, not Sunohara.]]
I mean, just look at her. She has the same blue hair as him! My theory behind this is that Okazaki didn't want his little sister to grow up with the crappy life that he has, so he had Sunohara's family look after her, and his parents just told him that she was his sister. And he's stupid enough to believe it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Is because while they were sleeping, [[HaruhiSuzumiya a closed space enveloped their school, and the world was reset/recreated/what-have-you.]]

to:

Is because while they were sleeping, [[HaruhiSuzumiya [[LightNovel/HaruhiSuzumiya a closed space enveloped their school, and the world was reset/recreated/what-have-you.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In reference to one of the theories on the ''{{Air}}'' [[WMG/{{Air}} WMG]] page, here's an idea that Yuuichi or Mai obtained a Light Orb from Ushio or Tomoya when the Illusory World collapsed. As a result, Ayu wakes up from her coma after ten years.

to:

In reference to one of the theories on the ''{{Air}}'' ''VisualNovel/{{Air}}'' [[WMG/{{Air}} WMG]] page, here's an idea that Yuuichi or Mai obtained a Light Orb from Ushio or Tomoya when the Illusory World collapsed. As a result, Ayu wakes up from her coma after ten years.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG:''CLANNAD'' is a corrupted retelling of ''{{Ocarina of Time}}'' in a MagicRealism setting (a.k.a. Tomoya is a reincarnation of [[TheLegendOfZelda Link]]).]]

to:

[[WMG:''CLANNAD'' is a corrupted retelling of ''{{Ocarina ''[[VideoGame/TheLegendOfZeldaOcarinaOfTime Ocarina of Time}}'' Time]]'' in a MagicRealism setting (a.k.a. Tomoya is a reincarnation of [[TheLegendOfZelda Link]]).]]

Added: 354

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Illusionary world time, if anything, runs backwards


[[WMG: Time is meaningless in the Illusionary World/it has it's own dimension of time]]

to:

[[WMG: Time is meaningless in the Illusionary World/it has it's its own dimension of time]]


Added DiffLines:

* Another way to think of its time is that the illusionary world is called into existence by Ushio's death (episode 21), but ends with Ushio's birth and Nagisa's survival (chronologically episode 16, revisted and altered in episode 22). It's a paradox: the event that creates the Illusionary World happens ''after'' the Illusionary World ceases to exist.

Top