Follow TV Tropes

Following

History UnintentionallySympathetic / LiveActionTV

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)


** [[AdiposeRex Robert]] [[FailureHero Baratheon]], as well. Back in Season 1, he's portrayed as a pathetic man who is stuck in the past, particularly for how he's unable to let go of [[TheLostLenore Lyanna]]. The showrunners clearly intended Robert to be an unsympathetic ruler due to his hounding of GloryDays as well as his whoring attitude. However, TheReveal of the true nature of her and Rhaegar's relationship through this episode painted Robert in a more sympathetic light in the eyes of fans. To realize Robert destroyed his life pining after a cheating woman who never loved him, which ruined his marriage and caused his death. Also, for all misunderstandings of Rhaegar's motives, he still saved the realm from the Mad King. [[spoiler:And Robert was further vindicated in Season 8, where his views regarding the last Targaryens were completely right, with Daenerys, the woman Robert wanted to execute, finishing the plot her father started, and being generally right in regarding the Targaryens and the Dothraki as a threat.]]

to:

** [[AdiposeRex Robert]] [[FailureHero Baratheon]], as well. Back in Season 1, he's portrayed as a pathetic man who is stuck in the past, particularly for how he's unable to let go of [[TheLostLenore Lyanna]]. The showrunners clearly intended Robert to be an unsympathetic ruler due to his hounding of GloryDays as well as his whoring attitude. However, TheReveal of the true nature of her and Rhaegar's relationship through this episode painted Robert in a more sympathetic light in the eyes of fans. To realize Robert destroyed his life pining after a cheating woman who never loved him, which ruined his marriage and caused his death. Also, for all misunderstandings of Rhaegar's motives, he still saved the realm from the Mad King. [[spoiler:And Robert was further vindicated in Season 8, where his views regarding the last Targaryens were completely right, with Daenerys, the woman Robert wanted to execute, finishing the plot her father started, and being generally right in regarding the Targaryens and the Dothraki as a threat.threat (though he's RightForTheWrongReasons, as Daenerys is mainly a threat because of her dragons, which Robert never expected).]]

Added: 1087

Changed: 1092

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[MagnificentBastard Paul Young]] from ''Series/DesperateHousewives'' has this. In season 1, [[PosthumousNarration his wife]] commits [[DrivenToSuicide suicide]]. As it turns out, she was being blackmailed by [[NosyNeighbor Martha Huber]], who didn't even care, she just wanted money. Paul then murders her with the blender she stole from him. After this, we meet [[SuspiciouslySimilarSubstitute her sister]], Felicia Tillman, who knew Paul from the past. Suspicious of Paul, but lacking proof, she [[FramingTheGuiltyParty cuts off her fingers and spills blood in his house]]. He's caught, arrested, and sentenced to life in prison. During this time, not a single one of his neighbors, who were best friends with his wife and had known him for years, came to visit him. When Felicia is discovered, he is released. Unsurprisingly, he [[RoaringRampageofRevenge wants to ruin the lives of those who betrayed him]]. And, when you consider what the housewives have pulled, involving leaving a man to die, and that they have forgiven far greater acts, like [[MurderTheHypotenuse Katherine Mayfair]], who can honestly blame him?

to:

* ''Series/DesperateHousewives'':
**
[[MagnificentBastard Paul Young]] from ''Series/DesperateHousewives'' has this.Young]]. In season 1, [[PosthumousNarration his wife]] commits [[DrivenToSuicide suicide]]. As it turns out, she Mary Alice was being blackmailed by [[NosyNeighbor Martha Huber]], who didn't even care, she just wanted money. Paul then murders her with the blender she stole from him. After this, we meet [[SuspiciouslySimilarSubstitute her sister]], Felicia Tillman, who knew Paul from the past. Suspicious of Paul, but lacking proof, she [[FramingTheGuiltyParty cuts off her fingers and spills blood in his house]]. He's caught, arrested, and sentenced to life in prison. During this time, not a single one of his neighbors, who were best friends with his wife and had known him for years, came to visit him. When Felicia is discovered, he is released. Unsurprisingly, he [[RoaringRampageofRevenge wants to ruin the lives of those who betrayed him]]. And, when you consider what the housewives have pulled, involving leaving a man to die, and that they have forgiven far greater acts, like [[MurderTheHypotenuse Katherine Mayfair]], who can honestly blame him?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In "The Bozeman Reaction", Sheldon and Leonard's apartment is broken into and ransacked with numerous valuables stolen. For the remainder of the episode, Sheldon is paranoid about the burglars returning, is uncomfortable sleeping and being alone in the apartment, asks for a security system to be installed, and finally decides he no longer feels safe in Pasadena and is moving to Bozeman, Montana. While moving to a different state is admittedly a bit of an overreaction, all of the other ways Sheldon reacts to the robbery are perfectly understandable after dealing with such a frightening experience, yet the cast treats it like it's his usual antics. In fact, Leonard seems more upset with Sheldon's behavior than he does over the robbery despite the fact that his laptop was stolen as a result.

to:

** In "The Bozeman Reaction", Sheldon and Leonard's apartment is broken into and ransacked with numerous valuables stolen. For the remainder of the episode, Sheldon is paranoid about the burglars returning, is uncomfortable sleeping and being alone in the apartment, asks for a security system to be installed, and finally decides he no longer feels safe in Pasadena and is moving to Bozeman, Montana. While moving to a different state is admittedly a bit of an overreaction, all of the other ways Sheldon reacts to the robbery are perfectly understandable after dealing with such a frightening experience, yet the cast treats it like it's his usual antics. In fact, [[SkewedPriorities Leonard seems more upset with Sheldon's behavior behavior]] than he does over the robbery despite the fact that his laptop was stolen as a result.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The DesignatedVillain of ''Series/{{The Twilight Zone|1959}}'' episode "[[Recap/TheTwilightZoneS1E8TimeEnoughAtLast Time Enough at Last]]", where a bookworm type who spends the whole episode being abused by every person he meets, and only wants to be alone with his books. Then a nuke wipes out the city while he's safe in a bank vault, and he's finally free to read his books in peace...until his reading glasses break. While WordOfGod says that this was his just punishment for [[LonersAreFreaks his misanthropy]], the character comes off as very sympathetic in a world where people act like such jerks. Serling's case is further hurt by one scene in which as a cruel joke, the bookworm's wife asks him to read poetry from one of his books to her; he eagerly obliges, only to find that she has drawn lines over the text on every page.

to:

* The DesignatedVillain of ''Series/{{The Twilight Zone|1959}}'' episode "[[Recap/TheTwilightZoneS1E8TimeEnoughAtLast "[[Recap/TheTwilightZone1959S1E8TimeEnoughAtLast Time Enough at Last]]", where a bookworm type who spends the whole episode being abused by every person he meets, and only wants to be alone with his books. Then a nuke wipes out the city while he's safe in a bank vault, and he's finally free to read his books in peace...until his reading glasses break. While WordOfGod says that this was his just punishment for [[LonersAreFreaks his misanthropy]], the character comes off as very sympathetic in a world where people act like such jerks. Serling's case is further hurt by one scene in which as a cruel joke, the bookworm's wife asks him to read poetry from one of his books to her; he eagerly obliges, only to find that she has drawn lines over the text on every page.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/LawAndOrderCriminalIntent'' has Dr. Kelmer from “The Good Doctor” is a depicted as an [[DomesticAbuse abusive]], {{Jerkass}}, ControlFreak and while that is true throughout the episode he generally comes across as just a guy whose wife has repeatedly disappeared before and he's just tired of dealing with her and her enabling friends and family. [[GoodAdulteryBadAdultery His wife is shown to be cheating on him, repeatedly disappears on binges and has a history of drugs abuse, multiple affairs and suicide attempts]]. Her enabling family who don't deny any of this while [[OffstageVillainy claiming he was abusive yet nothing is ever shown onscreen]] instantly suspect him when he calls looking for her don't even seem to care about finding her body making him the only one actively looking for her. They had no body, no forensic evidence; they couldn't even prove that she was dead. Goren even flat out stated that he wanted to prosecute the guy because of how smug he is. Even the circumstantial evidence they did have didn't hold up to AudienceAwarenessAdvantage. His flight was shown but he didn't have a body as the attendant was there with him when he took off. Her cousin said her therapist told her that he was going to harm her yet the therapist stood behind doctor patient confidentiality. In the end it is out right said that he was convicted for being a SmugSnake. While he wasn't a nice guy nothing shown proved that he was a killer and given the MoralMyopia he had to deal with his actions come across as far more understandable.

to:

* ''Series/LawAndOrderCriminalIntent'' has Dr. Kelmer from “The Good Doctor” Doctor”. He is a depicted as an [[DomesticAbuse abusive]], {{Jerkass}}, ControlFreak and while that is true ControlFreak throughout the episode episode. But he generally comes across as just a guy whose wife has repeatedly disappeared before and he's just tired of dealing with her and her enabling friends and family. [[GoodAdulteryBadAdultery His wife is shown to be cheating on him, repeatedly disappears on binges and has a history of drugs abuse, multiple affairs and suicide attempts]]. Her enabling family who don't does not deny any of this this, while [[OffstageVillainy claiming he that Kelmer was abusive yet nothing is ever shown onscreen]] onscreen]]. They instantly suspect him when he calls looking for her her, and they don't even seem to care about finding her body making body. Making him the only one actively looking for her. They had no body, no forensic evidence; they couldn't even prove that she was dead. Goren even flat out stated that he wanted to prosecute the guy because of how smug he is. Even the circumstantial evidence they did have didn't hold up to AudienceAwarenessAdvantage. His flight was shown but he didn't have a body as the attendant was there with him when he took off. Her cousin said her therapist told her that he was going to harm her yet the therapist stood behind doctor patient confidentiality. In the end it is out right said that he was convicted for being a SmugSnake. While he wasn't a nice guy guy, nothing shown proved that he was a killer and given killer. Given the MoralMyopia he had to deal with with, his actions come across as far more understandable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Wyatt's sisters on ''Series/CrashAndBernstein'' are intended to be seen girls who don't seem to respect the fact that Wyatt is a boy who likes boy things and are trying to get rid of Crash. However, it's easy to see things from their perspective: they're fed up with all the hijinx Crash is causing around the house and in their lives in general, so it's hard to blame them for not liking him. But no, TheComplainerIsAlwaysWrong.

to:

* Wyatt's sisters on ''Series/CrashAndBernstein'' are intended to be seen as girls who don't seem to respect the fact that Wyatt is a boy who likes boy things and are trying to get rid of Crash. However, it's easy to see things from their perspective: they're fed up with all the hijinx Crash is causing around the house and in their lives in general, so it's hard to blame them for not liking him. But no, TheComplainerIsAlwaysWrong.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Grammar


** Adar (an Elf who was captured and corrupted by Morgoth) garnered a great more sympathy than intended particularly in the scene where Galadriel is brutally interrogated by him. His anguished cries while chained up that he has as much right to live as much anyone else in the world is utterly heartbreaking and Galadriel responding to this by stating [[FinalSolution he’s a blight that needs to be wiped out]] is horribly cruel. Not helping this is that Galadriel got AdaptationalJerkass into a DarkerAndEdgier and less likeable character so it’s not too difficult to feel sorry for Adar in this instance.

to:

** Adar (an Elf who was captured and corrupted by Morgoth) garnered a great more sympathy than intended particularly in the scene where Galadriel is brutally interrogated by interrogates him. His anguished cries while chained up that he has as much right to live as much anyone else in the world is utterly heartbreaking and Galadriel responding to this by stating [[FinalSolution he’s a blight that needs to be wiped out]] is horribly cruel. Not helping this is that Galadriel got AdaptationalJerkass into a DarkerAndEdgier and less likeable character so it’s not too difficult to feel sorry for Adar in this instance.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/{{Empire}}'': Cookie's older sister Candace is portrayed as an uptight, snobbish sell-out who married a rich white man [[MRSDegree she met in college]]. The implication is that she forgot [[WrongSideOfTheTracks where she came from]] after marrying into money, whereas Cookie has always been true to her roots. However, Candace still grew up in the ghetto and watched both of her sisters get mixed up with drugs: Cookie became a convicted felon for selling dope, and Carol sank into addiction. Candace may be a snob, but her only "crimes" are seeking out a better life for herself and her children, and wanting little to do with the endless complexities of Cookie's life.

to:

* ''Series/{{Empire}}'': Cookie's older sister Candace is portrayed as an uptight, snobbish sell-out who married a rich white man [[MRSDegree she met in college]]. The implication is that she forgot [[WrongSideOfTheTracks where she came from]] after marrying into money, whereas Cookie has always been true to her roots. However, Candace still grew up in the exact same ghetto and watched both of her sisters get mixed up with drugs: Cookie became a convicted felon for selling dope, and Carol sank into addiction. Candace may be a snob, but her had the same struggles growing up. Her only "crimes" are seeking out wanting a better life for herself and her children, and wanting little to do with the endless complexities of Cookie's life.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Despite being a large, carnivorous dinosaur, the ''Ceratosaurus'' in ''Series/JurassicFightClub'' is an unusual example from a documentary (albeit of the [[SpeculativeDocumentary speculative kind]]). Compared to the ''Allosaurus'', it is repeatedly stated to be smaller, weaker, and an obsolete relic from a bygone age, destined to be usurped by the [[AlwaysSomeoneBetter superior]] ''Allosaurus''. Except, the ''Ceratosaurus'' is the combatant who gets humanized far more, being both the underdog in the scenario and having a mate (who the ''Allosaurus'' kills), [[SmarterThanYouLook and is apparently smart enough to feel grief for his mate’s death]] and [[CrusadingWidow attack his enemy because of it]], while the ''Allosaurus'' is depicted as a bloodthirsty loner who barges into the territory belonging to the ''Ceratosaurus'' pair and instead of simply chasing them away (since they don’t pose a threat to him), he kills both of them in cold blood. The end result makes the ''Ceratosaurus'' look like an innocent couple lost in the woods while the ''Allosaurus'' is the AxCrazy serial killer [[CurbStompBattle who mercilessly slaughters them with ease]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Series/TheWitcher2019'', the first episode concerns a dilemma between Stregobor, a wizard who wants to kill a former princess he claims is a dangerous monster, and Renfri, said former princess. Renfri is ''intended'' to be causing just as many problems as Stregobor, despite being somewhat sympathetic, as the point of the episode is that Geralt doesn't want to help either of them because they're ''both'' wrong. Stregobor's theory about the "Black Sun Princesses" and why they need to die is mostly if not entirely incorrect and later episodes show that he's murdered innocent girls because of it, and Renfri, in her quest for revenge on Stregobor, is callously putting innocent people at risk, willing to throw their lives away as long as she gets to kill him. Except the episode doesn't do a very good job of actually ''showing'' that she's putting innocents in danger for 90% of the runtime, so this is easy for viewers to miss. The result is that right up until Renfri takes a teenager hostage, she doesn't seem to be doing anything wrong and just seems like she's on a straightforwardly justified quest of vengeance.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/StrangersWithCandy'': The whole show is a DeconstructiveParody of 1970s Series/{{Afterschool Special}}s and anti-drug [=PSAs=]. But if you actually take Jerri Blank's life into consideration -- her history of prostitution, drug abuse, issues with her appearance, relationships with her family and the world at large, her lack of general common sense -- it makes scenes like the end of "A Blank Stare" a bit poignant: [[spoiler:Jerri, saved by her friends and family, but still rejected when she attempts to hug them, simply wraps her arms around herself while standing alone in a basement]].

to:

* ''Series/StrangersWithCandy'': The whole show is a DeconstructiveParody DarkParody of 1970s Series/{{Afterschool Special}}s and anti-drug [=PSAs=]. But if you actually take Jerri Blank's life into consideration -- her history of prostitution, drug abuse, issues with her appearance, relationships with her family and the world at large, her lack of general common sense -- it makes scenes like the end of "A Blank Stare" a bit poignant: [[spoiler:Jerri, saved by her friends and family, but still rejected when she attempts to hug them, simply wraps her arms around herself while standing alone in a basement]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** In "[[Recap/StarTrekDeepSpaceNineS04E11Homefront Homefront]]", O'Brien discusses the recent bombing of a diplomatic conference on Earth, lamenting on how frustrating it can be to see something you care about in danger and be powerless to help. Quark attempts to empathize by talking about the dwindling of his financial investments during a. economic crisis, but it's written off as typical Ferengi greed. Yet for someone who does not live in a post-scarcity utopia, living through an economic crisis actually can be a severely stressful experience (just ask anyone who lived through the 2008 recession).

to:

*** In "[[Recap/StarTrekDeepSpaceNineS04E11Homefront Homefront]]", O'Brien discusses the recent bombing of a diplomatic conference on Earth, lamenting on how frustrating it can be to see something you care about in danger and be powerless to help. Quark attempts to empathize by talking about the dwindling of his financial investments during a. an economic crisis, but it's written off as typical Ferengi greed. Yet for someone who does not live in a post-scarcity utopia, living through an economic crisis actually can be a severely stressful experience (just ask anyone who lived through the 2008 recession).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Spot, Data's cat, is meant to be seen as a badly-behaved pet, yet the only bad things he does are [[HairballHumour cough up a hairball]] (which couldn't be helped), break a vase (which could have been an accident, and even if it ''was'' on purpose, it's relatively minor), and scratch Riker, who, as he admitted, hates cats (cats are known to dislike, or even be nervous of, those who dislike them).

to:

*** Spot, Data's cat, is meant to be seen as a badly-behaved pet, yet the only bad things he does are [[HairballHumour [[HairballHumor cough up a hairball]] (which couldn't be helped), break a vase (which could have been an accident, and even if it ''was'' on purpose, it's relatively minor), and scratch Riker, who, as he admitted, hates cats (cats are known to dislike, or even be nervous of, those who dislike them).them). Moreoever, Spot as a cat probably shouldn't be onboard a starship in the first place and it can be considered irresponsible and cruel to keep an animal on there.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/StrangersWithCandy'': The whole show is a DeconstructiveParody of 1970s {{Afterschool Special}}s and anti-drug [=PSAs=]. But if you actually take Jerri Blank's life into consideration -- her history of prostitution, drug abuse, issues with her appearance, relationships with her family and the world at large, her lack of general common sense -- it makes scenes like the end of "A Blank Stare" a bit poignant: [[spoiler:Jerri, saved by her friends and family, but still rejected when she attempts to hug them, simply wraps her arms around herself while standing alone in a basement]].

to:

* ''Series/StrangersWithCandy'': The whole show is a DeconstructiveParody of 1970s {{Afterschool Series/{{Afterschool Special}}s and anti-drug [=PSAs=]. But if you actually take Jerri Blank's life into consideration -- her history of prostitution, drug abuse, issues with her appearance, relationships with her family and the world at large, her lack of general common sense -- it makes scenes like the end of "A Blank Stare" a bit poignant: [[spoiler:Jerri, saved by her friends and family, but still rejected when she attempts to hug them, simply wraps her arms around herself while standing alone in a basement]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/StrangersWithCandy'': If you actually take Jerri Blank's life into consideration -- her history of prostitution, drug abuse, issues with her appearance, relationships with her family and the world at large, her lack of general common sense -- it makes scenes like the end of "A Blank Stare" a bit poignant: [[spoiler:Jerri, saved by her friends and family, but still rejected when she attempts to hug them, simply wraps her arms around herself while standing alone in a basement]].

to:

* ''Series/StrangersWithCandy'': If The whole show is a DeconstructiveParody of 1970s {{Afterschool Special}}s and anti-drug [=PSAs=]. But if you actually take Jerri Blank's life into consideration -- her history of prostitution, drug abuse, issues with her appearance, relationships with her family and the world at large, her lack of general common sense -- it makes scenes like the end of "A Blank Stare" a bit poignant: [[spoiler:Jerri, saved by her friends and family, but still rejected when she attempts to hug them, simply wraps her arms around herself while standing alone in a basement]].

Top