Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Trivia / SherlockHolmes2009

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Judging by the early trailers, a lot of stuff was cut or changed by the film's release. The girl Blackwood was going to "sacrifice" was apparently going to start floating in mid-air (whether this was going to be part of Holmes' drug trip later in the film is unknown), and Irene Adler was going to try and seduce Holmes by stripping into a showgirl dress, try to stab him with a hairpin, then knee him in the crotch.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheCastShowOff: Downey Jr is an avid Wing Chun practitioner in real life, crediting it with helping him maintain his sobriety, and uses a lot of blocks, traps and strikes from it in his fight scenes here.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DevelopmentHell: There has been talks for a third film for a while, to be directed by Creator/DexterFletcher, but the UsefulNotes/Covid19Pandemic seemingly put the project on hold, in addition to Robert Downey Jr. being busy elsewhere. [[https://www.digitalspy.com/movies/a858233/sherlock-holmes-3-movie-cast-trailer-release-date-plot-spoilers/ Read more here]].
Tabs MOD

Removed: 162

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
YMMV


* FanNickname: Watson, due to being taller, thinner, younger and [[ShapedLikeItself more Jude Law]] than some previous portrayals, quickly became known as Hotson.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FakeNationality: Robert Maillet (better known by his wrestling alias Wrestling/Kurrgan) is Canadian from Québec and plays a large French bad guy.

to:

* FakeNationality: Robert Maillet (better known by his wrestling alias Wrestling/Kurrgan) Wrestling/{{Kurrgan}}) is Canadian from Québec and plays a large French bad guy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FandomNod: In the extended preview (aired during the ''Series/{{Monk}}'' series finale), there's yet another clip of the Holmes-Watson VitriolicBestBuds routine, then a cut to Adler going "They've been flirting like this for ''hours''." To the general public, a funny joke. To those aware of the Holmes/Watson-shipping fanbase, ''bloody hilarious''. As it happened, [[spoiler:this seems to have been a deleted scene referring to Watson's bickering with a boat captain.]]

to:

* FandomNod: In the extended preview (aired during the ''Series/{{Monk}}'' series finale), there's yet another clip of the Holmes-Watson VitriolicBestBuds routine, then a cut to Adler going "They've been flirting like this for ''hours''." To the general public, a funny joke. To those aware of the Holmes/Watson-shipping fanbase, ''bloody hilarious''. As it happened, [[spoiler:this seems to have been a deleted scene referring to Watson's bickering with a boat captain.]]

Changed: 389

Removed: 1603

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


!!The 2009 film



* AuthorAppeal: Holmes and Watson manage to subdue Dredger with an arm bar and rear-naked choke, as director Creator/GuyRitchie is a fan and ardent practitioner of UsefulNotes/{{Judo}} and UsefulNotes/BrazilianJiuJitsu.
* CreatorInJoke: A brief shot of an inn called 'The Punch Bowl' is visible. Creator/GuyRitchie owns a pub called The Punch Bowl in Mayfair.
* CreditsGag: There are a couple, mostly in the juxtaposition of assorted credits with images from the film. The best of these is that the Costume Designer's credit appears with an image of the naked Holmes tied to a bed.



* FakeBrit: Robert Downey Jr spent hours perfecting his English accent as Sherlock Holmes.
* FakeNationality:
** Robert Maillet (better known by his wrestling alias Wrestling/Kurrgan) is Canadian from Québec and plays a large French bad guy.
** Creator/NoomiRapace, a Swedish actress, plays Simza, a French gypsy, though Rapace might have some Roma ancestry.
* FanNickname:
** Watson, due to being taller, thinner, younger and [[ShapedLikeItself more Jude Law]] than some previous portrayals, quickly became known as Hotson.
** Stephen Fry's version of Mycroft Holmes quickly took on the nickname "Frycroft".

to:

* FakeBrit: Robert Downey Jr Creator/RobertDowneyJr spent hours perfecting his English accent as Sherlock Holmes.
* FakeNationality:
**
FakeNationality: Robert Maillet (better known by his wrestling alias Wrestling/Kurrgan) is Canadian from Québec and plays a large French bad guy.
** Creator/NoomiRapace, a Swedish actress, plays Simza, a French gypsy, though Rapace might have some Roma ancestry.
* FanNickname:
**
FanNickname: Watson, due to being taller, thinner, younger and [[ShapedLikeItself more Jude Law]] than some previous portrayals, quickly became known as Hotson.
** Stephen Fry's version of Mycroft Holmes quickly took on the nickname "Frycroft".
Hotson.



* {{Jossed}}: Rumors circulated that Creator/BradPitt was in the running to play Moriarty in the second film. These were quickly denied, saying Pitt had never been considered.
* TheOtherDarrin: Jared Harris as Moriarty, in a way. Since, technically, he appeared always in shadow in the first movie and was played by Ed Tolputt in an uncredited role. Jared Harris redubbed Tolputt's lines to give it continuity with the second film in subsequent TV airings of the first film.
* RealLifeWritesThePlot: In the original stories, Holmes is trained in Baritsu. In the film it's Wing-Chun Kung Fu - because Robert Downey Jr practices that in real life.



** Sam Worthington and Creator/ColinFarrell were in talks to play Watson before Jude Law was cast.

to:

** Sam Worthington Creator/SamWorthington and Creator/ColinFarrell were in talks to play Watson before Jude Law was cast.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ReferencedBy: Canadian figure skater Stephen Gogolev performed to the ''Sherlock Holmes'' soundtrack for [[hthttps://www.dailymotion.com/video/x71s0d3 his long program]] during the 2018-2019 competitive season.

to:

* ReferencedBy: Canadian figure skater Stephen Gogolev performed to the ''Sherlock Holmes'' soundtrack for [[hthttps://www.[[https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x71s0d3 his long program]] during the 2018-2019 competitive season.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This performance is 30 seconds longer than the previous one.


* ReferencedBy: Canadian figure skater Stephen Gogolev performed to the ''Sherlock Holmes'' soundtrack for [[https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x6yld97 his long program]] during the 2018-2019 competitive season.

to:

* ReferencedBy: Canadian figure skater Stephen Gogolev performed to the ''Sherlock Holmes'' soundtrack for [[https://www.[[hthttps://www.dailymotion.com/video/x6yld97 com/video/x71s0d3 his long program]] during the 2018-2019 competitive season.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AuthorAppeal: Holmes and Watson manage to subdue Dredger with an arm bar and rear-naked choke, as director Creator/GuyRitchie is a fan of UsefulNotes/{{Judo}} and UsefulNotes/BrazilianJiuJitsu.

to:

* AuthorAppeal: Holmes and Watson manage to subdue Dredger with an arm bar and rear-naked choke, as director Creator/GuyRitchie is a fan and ardent practitioner of UsefulNotes/{{Judo}} and UsefulNotes/BrazilianJiuJitsu.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AuthorAppeal: Holmes and Watson manage to subdue Dredger with an arm bar and rear-naked choke, as director Creator/GuyRitchie is a fan of Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu.

to:

* AuthorAppeal: Holmes and Watson manage to subdue Dredger with an arm bar and rear-naked choke, as director Creator/GuyRitchie is a fan of Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu.UsefulNotes/{{Judo}} and UsefulNotes/BrazilianJiuJitsu.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Jossed}}: Rumours circulated that Creator/BradPitt was in the running to play Moriarty in the second film. These were quickly denied, saying Pitt had never been considered.
* TheOtherDarrin: Jared Harris as Moriarty, in a way. Since, technically, he appeared always in shadow in the first movie and was played by Ed Tolputt in an uncredited role. In subsequent TV airings of the first film, as Jared Harris was brought in to re-dub Tolputt's lines to give it continuity with the second film.

to:

* {{Jossed}}: Rumours Rumors circulated that Creator/BradPitt was in the running to play Moriarty in the second film. These were quickly denied, saying Pitt had never been considered.
* TheOtherDarrin: Jared Harris as Moriarty, in a way. Since, technically, he appeared always in shadow in the first movie and was played by Ed Tolputt in an uncredited role. In subsequent TV airings of the first film, as Jared Harris was brought in to re-dub redubbed Tolputt's lines to give it continuity with the second film in subsequent TV airings of the first film.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Dredger, the large French man from the first movie, is actually French-Canadian.

to:

** Dredger, the Robert Maillet (better known by his wrestling alias Wrestling/Kurrgan) is Canadian from Québec and plays a large French man from the first movie, is actually French-Canadian.bad guy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
moving to main work page


* CastingGag: Geraldine James, who plays Mrs Hudson, had previously starred in an adaptation of ''Literature/TheHoundOfTheBaskervilles''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ReferencedBy: Canadian figure skater Stephen Gogolev performed to the ''Sherlock Holmes'' soundtrack for [[https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x6yld97 his long program]] during the 2018-2019 competitive season.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Creator/SamWorthington and Creator/ColinFarrell were in talks to play Watson before Jude Law was cast.

to:

** Creator/SamWorthington Sam Worthington and Creator/ColinFarrell were in talks to play Watson before Jude Law was cast.

Added: 424

Changed: 865

Removed: 606

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DyeingForYourArt:
** Creator/RobertDowneyJr did this movie in between the first two ''Film/IronMan'' movies. Look at how beefy Tony Stark is compared to how wire-thin Holmes is. That takes ''dedication''.
** Rob also was meticulous in making sure his accent was perfect for the character and historical period. As per Creator/GuyRitchie's interview on ''Series/TopGear'', he succeeded.
*** It was perfect for modern perceptions, but it wasn't historically accurate. Historical British sounded much closer to modern Americans than modern Britons. It mainly revolves around [[http://www.lifeslittlemysteries.com/2047-americans-brits-accents.html rhotic speech]].
*** Received pronunciation with its non-rhotic "r" and enunciated consonants was already widely used by the mid 1800s, even more so in London and the rest of Southern England. Given that Holmes is an educated Londoner in the late 19th century, Downy's accent is both impeccable and historically accurate.
* FakeNationality: Quite a few examples.

** Holmes himself is played by Creator/RobertDowneyJr., making him a FakeBrit.
** Canadian actress Creator/RachelMcAdams plays the [[FakeAmerican American]] Irene Adler.

to:

* DyeingForYourArt:
**
DyeingForYourArt: Creator/RobertDowneyJr did this movie in between the first two ''Film/IronMan'' movies. Look at how beefy Tony Stark is compared to how wire-thin Holmes is. That takes ''dedication''.
** Rob also was meticulous in making sure * FakeAmerican: Canadians Creator/RachelMcAdams and William Hope play American characters.
* FakeBrit: Robert Downey Jr spent hours perfecting
his English accent was perfect for the character and historical period. As per Creator/GuyRitchie's interview on ''Series/TopGear'', he succeeded.
*** It was perfect for modern perceptions, but it wasn't historically accurate. Historical British sounded much closer to modern Americans than modern Britons. It mainly revolves around [[http://www.lifeslittlemysteries.com/2047-americans-brits-accents.html rhotic speech]].
*** Received pronunciation with its non-rhotic "r" and enunciated consonants was already widely used by the mid 1800s, even more so in London and the rest of Southern England. Given that Holmes is an educated Londoner in the late 19th century, Downy's accent is both impeccable and historically accurate.
as Sherlock Holmes.
* FakeNationality: Quite a few examples.

** Holmes himself is played by Creator/RobertDowneyJr., making him a FakeBrit.
** Canadian actress Creator/RachelMcAdams plays the [[FakeAmerican American]] Irene Adler.



** William Hope, a Canadian actor, played Standish, the American ambassador in the first film.


Added DiffLines:

* RealLifeWritesThePlot: In the original stories, Holmes is trained in Baritsu. In the film it's Wing-Chun Kung Fu - because Robert Downey Jr practices that in real life.
* TrollingCreator: Rachel [=McAdams=] tried to trick the wardrobe department by eating a large breakfast in the morning or pushing out her stomach during fitting - in the hopes of her corset not being tied so tight. They eventually caught on to her ruse.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***Received pronunciation with its non-rhotic "r" and enunciated consonants was already widely used by the mid 1800s, even more so in London and the rest of Southern England. Given that Holmes is an educated Londoner in the late 19th century, Downy's accent is both impeccable and historically accurate.


Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added: 330

Changed: 699

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AbilityOverAppearance: Robert Downey Jr. being cast as Holmes despite looking completely different from his descriptions in the stories.
* AuthorAppeal: Holmes and Watson manage to subdue Dredger with an arm bar and rear-naked choke, as director Guy Ritchie is a fan of Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu.

to:

* AbilityOverAppearance: Robert Downey Jr.Creator/RobertDowneyJr. being cast as Holmes despite looking completely different from his descriptions in the stories.
* AuthorAppeal: Holmes and Watson manage to subdue Dredger with an arm bar and rear-naked choke, as director Guy Ritchie Creator/GuyRitchie is a fan of Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu.



* CreatorInJoke: A brief shot of an inn called 'The Punch Bowl' is visible. Guy Ritchie owns a pub called The Punch Bowl in Mayfair.

to:

* CreatorInJoke: A brief shot of an inn called 'The Punch Bowl' is visible. Guy Ritchie Creator/GuyRitchie owns a pub called The Punch Bowl in Mayfair.



* DyeingForYourArt: Downey did this movie in between the first two ''Film/IronMan'' movies. Look at how beefy Tony Stark is compared to how wire-thin Holmes is. That takes ''dedication''.
** Rob also was meticulous in making sure his accent was perfect for the character and historical period. As per Guy Ritchie's interview on ''Series/TopGear'', he succeeded.

to:

* DyeingForYourArt: Downey DyeingForYourArt:
** Creator/RobertDowneyJr
did this movie in between the first two ''Film/IronMan'' movies. Look at how beefy Tony Stark is compared to how wire-thin Holmes is. That takes ''dedication''.
** Rob also was meticulous in making sure his accent was perfect for the character and historical period. As per Guy Ritchie's Creator/GuyRitchie's interview on ''Series/TopGear'', he succeeded.



** Holmes himself is played by Robert Downey Jr., making him a FakeBrit.
** Canadian actress Rachel [=McAdams=] plays the [[FakeAmerican American]] Irene Adler.

to:

** Holmes himself is played by Robert Downey Jr.Creator/RobertDowneyJr., making him a FakeBrit.
** Canadian actress Rachel [=McAdams=] Creator/RachelMcAdams plays the [[FakeAmerican American]] Irene Adler.



** Noomi Rapace, a Swedish actress, plays Simza, a French gypsy, though Rapace might have some Roma ancestry.
* FanNickname: Watson, due to being taller, thinner, younger and [[ShapedLikeItself more Jude Law]] than some previous portrayals, quickly became known as Hotson.

to:

** Noomi Rapace, Creator/NoomiRapace, a Swedish actress, plays Simza, a French gypsy, though Rapace might have some Roma ancestry.
* FanNickname: FanNickname:
**
Watson, due to being taller, thinner, younger and [[ShapedLikeItself more Jude Law]] than some previous portrayals, quickly became known as Hotson.



* {{Jossed}}: Rumours circulated that Brad Pitt was in the running to play Moriarty in the second film. These were quickly denied, saying Pitt had never been considered.

to:

* {{Jossed}}: Rumours circulated that Brad Pitt Creator/BradPitt was in the running to play Moriarty in the second film. These were quickly denied, saying Pitt had never been considered.



** Sienna Miller was in talks to star in the film, possibly as Mary. But when Jude Law was cast as Watson, this was quietly dropped - due to the couple's very public break-up when Law had an affair with their nanny.
** Sam Worthington and Colin Farrell were in talks to play Watson before Jude Law was cast.

to:

** Sienna Miller Creator/SiennaMiller was in talks to star in the film, possibly as Mary. But when Jude Law Creator/JudeLaw was cast as Watson, this was quietly dropped - due to the couple's very public break-up when Law had an affair with their nanny.
** Sam Worthington Creator/SamWorthington and Colin Farrell Creator/ColinFarrell were in talks to play Watson before Jude Law was cast.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Split individual works to their own pages.

Added DiffLines:

!!The 2009 film
* AbilityOverAppearance: Robert Downey Jr. being cast as Holmes despite looking completely different from his descriptions in the stories.
* AuthorAppeal: Holmes and Watson manage to subdue Dredger with an arm bar and rear-naked choke, as director Guy Ritchie is a fan of Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu.
* CastingGag: Geraldine James, who plays Mrs Hudson, had previously starred in an adaptation of ''Literature/TheHoundOfTheBaskervilles''.
* CreatorInJoke: A brief shot of an inn called 'The Punch Bowl' is visible. Guy Ritchie owns a pub called The Punch Bowl in Mayfair.
* CreditsGag: There are a couple, mostly in the juxtaposition of assorted credits with images from the film. The best of these is that the Costume Designer's credit appears with an image of the naked Holmes tied to a bed.
* DeletedScene: So, Irene never got around to trying to stab Holmes with a hair pin or kneeing him in the... meerschaum, eh?
* DyeingForYourArt: Downey did this movie in between the first two ''Film/IronMan'' movies. Look at how beefy Tony Stark is compared to how wire-thin Holmes is. That takes ''dedication''.
** Rob also was meticulous in making sure his accent was perfect for the character and historical period. As per Guy Ritchie's interview on ''Series/TopGear'', he succeeded.
*** It was perfect for modern perceptions, but it wasn't historically accurate. Historical British sounded much closer to modern Americans than modern Britons. It mainly revolves around [[http://www.lifeslittlemysteries.com/2047-americans-brits-accents.html rhotic speech]].
* FakeNationality: Quite a few examples.
** Holmes himself is played by Robert Downey Jr., making him a FakeBrit.
** Canadian actress Rachel [=McAdams=] plays the [[FakeAmerican American]] Irene Adler.
** Dredger, the large French man from the first movie, is actually French-Canadian.
** William Hope, a Canadian actor, played Standish, the American ambassador in the first film.
** Noomi Rapace, a Swedish actress, plays Simza, a French gypsy, though Rapace might have some Roma ancestry.
* FanNickname: Watson, due to being taller, thinner, younger and [[ShapedLikeItself more Jude Law]] than some previous portrayals, quickly became known as Hotson.
** Stephen Fry's version of Mycroft Holmes quickly took on the nickname "Frycroft".
* FandomNod: In the extended preview (aired during the ''Series/{{Monk}}'' series finale), there's yet another clip of the Holmes-Watson VitriolicBestBuds routine, then a cut to Adler going "They've been flirting like this for ''hours''." To the general public, a funny joke. To those aware of the Holmes/Watson-shipping fanbase, ''bloody hilarious''. As it happened, [[spoiler:this seems to have been a deleted scene referring to Watson's bickering with a boat captain.]]
* {{Jossed}}: Rumours circulated that Brad Pitt was in the running to play Moriarty in the second film. These were quickly denied, saying Pitt had never been considered.
* TheOtherDarrin: Jared Harris as Moriarty, in a way. Since, technically, he appeared always in shadow in the first movie and was played by Ed Tolputt in an uncredited role. In subsequent TV airings of the first film, as Jared Harris was brought in to re-dub Tolputt's lines to give it continuity with the second film.
* WhatCouldHaveBeen:
** Sienna Miller was in talks to star in the film, possibly as Mary. But when Jude Law was cast as Watson, this was quietly dropped - due to the couple's very public break-up when Law had an affair with their nanny.
** Sam Worthington and Colin Farrell were in talks to play Watson before Jude Law was cast.
----

Top