Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Series / SwitchedAtBirth

Go To

OR

Added: 41

Changed: 236

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** After Regina's secret comes out, the Kennishes' lawyer advises that it's too late for a custody battle, since by the time it's settled the girls would be eighteen (legal adults in US) anyway.

to:

** After Regina's secret comes out, the Kennishes' lawyer advises that it's too late for a custody battle, since by the time it's settled the girls would be eighteen (legal adults in the US) anyway.



* TheSpeechless: Melody and Emmett mostly, but [[spoiler: Emmett [[SuddenlyVoiced does speak]] in the summer finale.]] Melody occasionally does as well.

to:

* TheSpeechless: Melody and Emmett mostly, but [[spoiler: Emmett [[SuddenlyVoiced does speak]] in the summer finale.]] Melody occasionally does as well. Tyler also speaks once in a while. Natalie never does however, along with other deaf students.



%% commented out as Administrivia/ZeroContextExample * SwitchedAtBirth: Well, yeah.
* TactfulTranslation: Daphne sometimes does this for Emmett.

to:

%% commented out as Administrivia/ZeroContextExample * SwitchedAtBirth: Well, yeah.
The premise of the series, pretty obviously.
* TactfulTranslation: TactfulTranslation:
**
Daphne sometimes does this for Emmett.
Tabs MOD

Changed: 13

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* YokoOhNo: InUniverse - Simone tries to change Guitar Face's sound as soon as she starts dating Toby. However, she specifically denies being this, with varied evidence.

to:

* YokoOhNo: InUniverse - Simone tries to change Guitar Face's sound as soon as she starts dating Toby. However, she specifically denies being this, with varied evidence.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Commenting out a Zero Context Example.


* SwitchedAtBirth: [[CaptainObvious Well, yeah.]]

to:

%% commented out as Administrivia/ZeroContextExample * SwitchedAtBirth: [[CaptainObvious Well, yeah.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


** To ''{{Twilight}}'':

to:

** To ''{{Twilight}}'':''Literature/{{Twilight}}'':
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DisabledLoveInterest: The series has several deaf characters, all of whom are quite attractive- Daphne, Emmett, Emmett's mother-and have relationships with hearing people. However they're all played as ordinary people, with some of the relationships lasting a very long time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* QuestionableConsent: This issue is raised when [[spoiler: Bay]] wakes up next to Tank and can't remember what happened. After he reveals they had sex, she's skeptical that she'd consent to that, but he insists that she did. Others, however, note that being so drunk would cast doubt on her consent to begin, or even automatically make it a sexual assault.

to:

* QuestionableConsent: This issue is raised when [[spoiler: Bay]] wakes up next to Tank and can't remember what happened. After he reveals they had sex, she's skeptical that she'd consent to that, but he insists that she did. Others, however, note that being so drunk would cast doubt on her consent to begin, start, or even automatically make it a sexual assault.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In "Ecce Mono," John imagines that Regina came clean about discovering the switch in 1998 but lost custody of the girls due to her drinking. Daphne is raised with the Kennishes, getting an cochlear implant to help her hear and not identifying as Deaf - but is a manipulative brat. Bay is now a studious young woman who falls in her sister's shadow; Toby is still gambling, and Kathryn is having an affair with another man [[spoiler:(Chip Coto)]]) The girls grow up thinking that Regina stopped contacting them altogether. [[spoiler: She actually has tried to make contact with them their entire lives, but the Kennishes stash away the letters and presents instead of giving it to the girls. When they find this out and go to find Regina, they instead only find Adrianna; they find out from her that Regina died of drinking on their birthday.]]

to:

** In "Ecce Mono," John imagines that Regina came clean about discovering the switch in 1998 but lost custody of the girls due to her drinking. Daphne is raised with the Kennishes, getting an a cochlear implant to help her hear and not identifying as Deaf - but is a manipulative brat. Bay is now a studious young woman who falls in her sister's shadow; Toby is still gambling, and Kathryn is having an affair with another man [[spoiler:(Chip Coto)]]) ([[spoiler:Chip Coto)]]). The girls grow up thinking that Regina stopped contacting them altogether. [[spoiler: She actually has tried to make contact with them their entire lives, but the Kennishes stash away the letters and presents instead of giving it to the girls. When they find this out and go to find Regina, they instead only find Adrianna; they find out from her that Regina died of drinking on their birthday.]]



** Specifically, they're signing using ASL[[note]] American Sign Language[[/note]] and SEE[[note]] Signed Exact English [[/note]], in a mixture called Pidgin Signed English.
** Angelo speaks Italian, and French.

to:

** Specifically, they're signing using ASL[[note]] American ASL[[note]]American Sign Language[[/note]] and SEE[[note]] Signed SEE[[note]]Signed Exact English [[/note]], in a mixture called Pidgin Signed English.
** Angelo speaks Italian, Italian and French.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ChocolateBaby: Daphne. Unlike both her presumed birth parents, Regina and Angelo, she was pale-skinned, plus red-haired. Naturally, Angelo thought Regina cheated on him and Daphne wasn't his. He was right on the latter, though [[RightForTheWrongReasons wrong about the reasons]], as she was switched for their real daughter while in the hospital.

to:

* ChocolateBaby: Daphne. Unlike both her presumed birth parents, Regina and Angelo, she was pale-skinned, plus red-haired. Naturally, Angelo thought Regina cheated on him and Daphne wasn't his. He was right on the latter, though [[RightForTheWrongReasons wrong about the reasons]], as she was switched for their real daughter while in the hospital. Later it turns out that John had also suspected this of Bay for just the same reasons, getting both their DNA secretly tested. It explains why he's not surprised about the DNA results when Bay later gets them to as well. However, though he thought Kathryn must have cheated on him, he'd already decided that no matter what, Bay and she are still his family.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AllGaysArePedophiles: After Travis tells his mom her brother had molested him as a kid, she replies it's not true-because he isn't gay.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CessationOfExistence: {{Discussed}} by Regina and John. He believes there's some afterlife where you can meet your loved ones again, but Regina doesn't, unfortunate as she finds that.

Added: 80

Removed: 668

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BizarroEpisode: "Yuletide Fortune Tellers" counts as it's an AlternateRealityEpisode which aired as the last episode of season three, directly after... well, see BittersweetEnding above.



* TheCastShowoff: Lucas Grabeel and Sean Berdy get to show off their musical skills in the fourth episode.
** Creator/LeaThompson shows off her singing voice in "Tree of Forgiveness," and ends up singing a duet with Lucas Grabeel.
** "Dance Me to the End of Love" gives almost everyone (not least former professional dancer Lea Thompson), with their varying degrees of ability, a chance to dance.
** Kathryn singing Christmas carols is a RunningGag in the season 3 Christmas special.


Added DiffLines:

* ModestyBedsheet: This is used by many female characters after they've had sex.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnexplainedRecovery: After Travis and Natalie are hit by a drunk driver, they're both injured. We see him with his arm in a sling, and Natalie has a neck brace on. She also complains of pain in her back and an MRI is ordered to see if her pelvis was fractured. That is the last we see or hear about their injuries-their next appearances have them perfectly fine.

to:

* UnexplainedRecovery: After Travis and Natalie are hit by a drunk driver, they're both injured. We see him with his arm in a sling, and Natalie has a neck brace on. She also complains of pain in her back and an MRI is ordered to see if her pelvis was fractured. That is the last we see or hear about their these injuries-their next appearances have them perfectly fine.fine, and they're never brought up again.

Added: 364

Changed: 74

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NoPartyGiven: John's run for office. He's either an old-school New England style Republican (in Kansas!) or a Blue Dog Democrat - liberal on "live and let live" social issues, fiscally conservative. Good luck getting through the primary!

to:

* NoPartyGiven: John's run for office. He's either an old-school New England style Republican (in Kansas!) or a Blue Dog Democrat - liberal on "live and let live" social issues, fiscally conservative. Good luck getting through the primary!primary! Later he's explicitly called a Republican, but the problems above remain.


Added DiffLines:

* UnexplainedRecovery: After Travis and Natalie are hit by a drunk driver, they're both injured. We see him with his arm in a sling, and Natalie has a neck brace on. She also complains of pain in her back and an MRI is ordered to see if her pelvis was fractured. That is the last we see or hear about their injuries-their next appearances have them perfectly fine.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* [[spoiler: RapeAsBackstory]]: After what happens with [[spoiler: Bay, Kathryn]] reveals her best friend's brother once molested her when she was seventeen. Later [[spoiler: Travis]] reveals that a family friend had molested him too.

Added: 283

Changed: 80

Removed: 484

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NoBisexuals: When Kathryn is discussing with John whether her mother Bonnie and Bonnie's friend Lucille are lovers, she expresses skepticism at the idea of her "turning gay" now after all the years of being married to Kathryn's father. The idea she might be just bi never comes up.



* NeverTrustATrailer: A minor example but a lot of the previews use different takes than what’s actually used in the episode. One example being when a preview shows John, during a confrontation with Regina, saying in an angry yet restrained “You kept my daughter from me for thirteen years!” But in the episode proper he employs SuddenlyShouting by going “You kept...my daughter from me...for '''THIRTEEN YEARS!!!'''”



%% * NoPartyGiven: John's run for office. He's either an old-school New England style Republican (in Kansas!) or a Blue Dog Democrat - liberal on "live and let live" social issues, fiscally conservative. Good luck getting through the primary!

to:

%% * NoPartyGiven: John's run for office. He's either an old-school New England style Republican (in Kansas!) or a Blue Dog Democrat - liberal on "live and let live" social issues, fiscally conservative. Good luck getting through the primary!



* OffTheWagon: Not long after seeing Simone at an AA meeting, Regina catches a guy buying booze for Simone. After getting chewed out, Simone tells Regina that she fell off the wagon after her indiscretion was spread around the school, and that she felt like she had no friends anymore.
** [[spoiler:As of episode 2.05, Regina has fallen off the wagon.]]

to:

* OffTheWagon: Not long after seeing Simone at an AA meeting, Regina catches a guy buying booze for Simone. After getting chewed out, Simone tells Regina that she fell off the wagon after her indiscretion was spread around the school, and that she felt like she had no friends anymore.
** [[spoiler:As of episode 2.05, Regina has fallen
anymore. [[spoiler:Regina later falls off the wagon.wagon herself, though she gets sober.]]

Added: 469

Changed: 14

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* QuestionableConsent: This issue is raised when [[spoiler: Bay]] wakes up next to Tank and can't remember what happened. After he reveals they had sex, she's skeptical that she'd consent to that, but he insists that she did. Others, however, note that being so drunk would cast doubt on her consent to begin, or even automatically make it a sexual assault.



* [[spoiler:RapeAsDrama]]: A season 4 storyline.

to:

* [[spoiler:RapeAsDrama]]: A season 4 storyline.storyline explores this.
* RashomonStyle: Whether Bay kissed Tank, or Tank Bay, is told by their two opposing stories, with no agreement.

Added: 307

Changed: 420

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Before the families reveal to the public that Daphne and Bay were switched, Kathryn's friends think that John has a relationship with Regina.

to:

** Before the families reveal to the public that Daphne and Bay were switched, Kathryn's friends think that John has had a relationship with Regina.



** Bay tries to tell Emmett what happened with Tank, but he initially thinks she's confessing this, enraging him.



* SignificantGreenEyedRedhead: Daphne, who has green eyes and red hair (see the image above), much like her biological mother Kathryn. It's all the more jarring when Regina refers to Daphne as having been a blond, blue eyed baby.[[note]]Though babies often have lighter hair for the first two years or so.[[/note]]

to:

* SignificantGreenEyedRedhead: Daphne, who has green eyes and red hair (see the image above), much like her biological mother Kathryn. It's all the more jarring when Regina refers to Daphne as having been a blond, blue eyed baby.[[note]]Though babies often have lighter hair for the first two years or so.[[/note]][[/note]] This indicates to them she isn't Regina's or Angelo's child biologically, which is confirmed by a DNA test.



* SlutShaming: Someone finds out about Simone's indiscretion with Emmett, and posts it on a Slut Shaming website for the world to see. Toby had long since broken up with Simone over it, but he does call out some classmates for reading the website and being Slut Shamers themselves. Simone later confides in Regina that the slut shaming was the reason why she fell off the wagon.
* SocialServicesDoesNotExist: After Regina's secret comes out, the Kennishes' lawyer advises that it's too late for a custody battle, since by the time it's settled the girls would be eighteen (legal adults in US) anyway.

to:

* SlutShaming: Someone finds out about Simone's indiscretion with Emmett, and posts it on a Slut Shaming website for the world to see. Toby had long since broken up with Simone over it, but he does call out some classmates for reading the website and being Slut Shamers themselves. Simone later confides in Regina that the slut shaming was the reason why she fell off the wagon.
wagon. Later, with the sexual assault storyline, this happens to [[spoiler: Bay]].
* SocialServicesDoesNotExist: SocialServicesDoesNotExist:
**
After Regina's secret comes out, the Kennishes' lawyer advises that it's too late for a custody battle, since by the time it's settled the girls would be eighteen (legal adults in US) anyway.



* TheSpeechless: Melody, and Emmett, but, [[spoiler: Emmett [[SuddenlyVoiced does speak]] in the summer finale.]]

to:

* TheSpeechless: Melody, Melody and Emmett, but, Emmett mostly, but [[spoiler: Emmett [[SuddenlyVoiced does speak]] in the summer finale.]]]] Melody occasionally does as well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LatinoIsBrown: Averted with Daphne. Though her birth parents aren't actually Latinos, Regina who raised her was, and she still has the surname Vasquez, and none of the Latinos whom she meets doubt her status even though she's pale with red hair.

to:

* LatinoIsBrown: Averted with Daphne. Though her birth parents aren't actually Latinos, Regina who raised her was, Regina, Adriana, Natalie and she still has the surname Vasquez, and none of the other Latinos whom she meets doubt in East Riverside are all dark-skinned. Regina's daughter, Daphne (fair-skinned, red-haired, green-eyed) is revealed to have been SwitchedAtBirth. Regina's biological daughter Bay, played by a white actress of Italian descent is very pale skinned (which is really unlikely [[HollywoodGenetics given her status heritage]]). This becomes a plot point in one episode where Daphne applies for a Latina scholarship, every other candidate there is very stereotypical of a Latino. She laments to Regina that even though they think she's pale with Latina, no one else sees it that way. Later though when she's introduced to Jorge's family, none of them questions it though. A chemistry professor who she has is fascinated, remarking how rare red hair.hair is among Puerto Ricans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HollywoodAtheist: {{Averted}}. Regina says she's an atheist when Angelo is injured, explaining to Kathryn that she won't pray since it would make her a hypocrite, "one of those people who [[PrayerIsALastResort only believe in God when something goes wrong]]". This is not shown to be bad (nor does she begin to pray, though Kathryn says God won't mind).

Added: 596

Changed: 256

Removed: 86

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BreakHisHeartToSaveHim: gender-flipped version. [[spoiler:Ty lies to Bay that he cheated on her, because the alternative--admitting that he's going into a high-risk warzone with a serious chance of getting killed and leaving her heartbroken--is something he can't do.]]

to:

* BreakHisHeartToSaveHim: A gender-flipped version. [[spoiler:Ty lies to Bay that he cheated on her, because the alternative--admitting that he's going into a high-risk warzone with a serious chance of getting killed and leaving her heartbroken--is something he can't do.]]



* ChocolateBaby: Daphne. Unlike both her presumed birth parents, Regina and Angelo, she was pale-skinned, plus red-haired. Naturally, Angelo thought Regina cheated on him and Daphne wasn't his. He was right on the latter, though [[RightForTheWrongReasons wrong about the reasons]], as she was switched for their real daughter while in the hospital.



* DisappearedDad: Bay's biological father, Angelo. She's not happy about this. [[spoiler:He eventually shows up out of the blue in the midseason finale, after reading about the switch in a newspaper. Then disappears again. Then comes back. You can understand why Regina told him she wants off his roller coaster of comings and goings.]]

to:

* DisappearedDad: Bay's biological father, Angelo. She's not happy about this. [[spoiler:He eventually shows up out of the blue in the midseason finale, after reading about the switch in a newspaper. Then disappears again. Then comes back. You can understand why Regina told him she wants off his roller coaster of comings and goings. Before this, he'd also left after Daphne was born, rightly suspecting she wasn't really his daughter given that she looked distinctly different from both him and Regina.]]



* LamarckWasRight: Daphne gravitates toward athletic endeavors, as her biological father John is a retired major league ballplayer. She is also a really good cook like her mother Kathryn. Bay is an aspiring artist, a trait that she seems to have inherited from her biological mother Regina.
** Daphne even states that she believes she inherited her basketball skills from John.

to:

* LamarckWasRight: Daphne gravitates toward athletic endeavors, as her biological father John is a retired major league ballplayer. She is also a really good cook like her mother Kathryn. Bay is an aspiring artist, a trait that she seems to have inherited from her biological mother Regina.
**
Regina. Daphne even states that she believes she inherited her basketball skills from John.


Added DiffLines:

* LatinoIsBrown: Averted with Daphne. Though her birth parents aren't actually Latinos, Regina who raised her was, and she still has the surname Vasquez, and none of the Latinos whom she meets doubt her status even though she's pale with red hair.

Added: 819

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NeverTrustATrailer: Minor but a lot of the previews use different takes than the take used in the episode when aired. A notable example is during a confrontation with Regina, John says in an angry but somewhat restrained tone “You kept my daughter from me for thirteen years!” But in the episode proper John employs SuddenlyShouting with “You kept...my daughter from me...for '''THIRTEEN YEARS!!!'''”



* NeverTrustATrailer: A minor example but a lot of the previews use different takes than what’s actually used in the episode. One example being when a preview shows John, during a confrontation with Regina, saying in an angry yet restrained “You kept my daughter from me for thirteen years!” But in the episode proper he employs SuddenlyShouting by going “You kept...my daughter from me...for '''THIRTEEN YEARS!!!'''”



-->John: "You kept my daughter from me...for '''THIRTEEN YEARS!!!'''

to:

-->John: "You kept my daughter from me...for '''THIRTEEN YEARS!!!'''YEARS!!!'''”
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
not a trope


* VictimBlaming: All the other characters seem to like to do this with Bay in a minor way. Taken UpToEleven in season 4 after [[spoiler: Bay is raped by Tank]]. Mary Beth's attitude about the situation is especially awful.



* JustForFun/XMeetsY:
** Emmett's character was described by the producers as "Deaf James Dean." Similarly, Travis has been described in-series as "Deaf Creator/MattDamon."
** Invoked in universe by Bay.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Lea Thompson shows off her singing voice in "Tree of Forgiveness," and ends up singing a duet with Lucas Grabeel.

to:

** Lea Thompson Creator/LeaThompson shows off her singing voice in "Tree of Forgiveness," and ends up singing a duet with Lucas Grabeel.

Added: 494

Changed: 148

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhamEpisode:
** ''Memory is Your Image of Perfection'', in which [[spoiler:Sharee's mother stabs Dr. Jackson, Bay loses all movement in her right hand, and Kathryn tells John that she's unhappy and the life they had created together isn't the life she wants anymore]].
** ''At First Clear Word'', in which [[spoiler:Bay is sexually assaulted]].



* JustForFun/XMeetsY: Emmett's character was described by the producers as "Deaf James Dean." Similarly, Travis has been described in-series as "Deaf Creator/MattDamon."

to:

* JustForFun/XMeetsY: JustForFun/XMeetsY:
**
Emmett's character was described by the producers as "Deaf James Dean." Similarly, Travis has been described in-series as "Deaf Creator/MattDamon."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A particularly {{egregious}} example is during one episode where Bay walks around the campus in a tank top and plaid skirt that vaguely resemble the school colors.

to:

** A particularly {{egregious}} JustForFun/{{egregious}} example is during one episode where Bay walks around the campus in a tank top and plaid skirt that vaguely resemble the school colors.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SuddenlyShouting: John during a confrontation with Regina
-->John: "You kept my daughter from me...for '''THIRTEEN YEARS!!!'''

Removed: 119

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Expy}}: Chef Jeff is a blunt, no-nonsense chef with a short temper, leading to comparisons to Creator/GordonRamsay.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* XMeetsY: Emmett's character was described by the producers as "Deaf James Dean." Similarly, Travis has been described in-series as "Deaf Creator/MattDamon."

to:

* XMeetsY: JustForFun/XMeetsY: Emmett's character was described by the producers as "Deaf James Dean." Similarly, Travis has been described in-series as "Deaf Creator/MattDamon."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Homage}} / LawyerFriendlyCameo: One of Daphne's favorite movies is ''Deafenstein'', an incredibly cheesy ''{{Frankenstein}}'' adaptation performed entirely in ASL. It's a takeoff of the RealLife film ''Film/{{Deafula}}'', a 1975 version of ''{{Dracula}}'' done in ASL, with a similar reputation.

to:

* {{Homage}} / LawyerFriendlyCameo: One of Daphne's favorite movies is ''Deafenstein'', an incredibly cheesy ''{{Frankenstein}}'' ''Film/{{Frankenstein|1931}}'' adaptation performed entirely in ASL. It's a takeoff of the RealLife film ''Film/{{Deafula}}'', a 1975 version of ''{{Dracula}}'' done in ASL, with a similar reputation.

Top