Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Series / Girls

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SurprisinglySuddenDeath: One of Ray's coffee shop regulars dies this way in season six.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Played with, with Ray and Shoshanna. Though they were initially a decent couple, their differences quickly became too much to bear when Shoshanna considered Ray too aimless and hateful, and Ray couldn't fully respect the young Shoshanna. After they returned to each other as friends, their relationship became much stronger and built on mutual affection and respect, and it's Marnie that feels left out watching them talk.
** [[spoiler:Ray hates Marnie's guts at the start of the series, but ends up getting together with her and he declares her the love of his life. None of their attempts at a relationship last, however.]]

Added: 354

Changed: 414

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* YankTheDogsChain: Right as Shoshanna is really becoming comfortable, happy, and fulfilled in her job in Tokyo, she gets laid off. The creators outright stated in an interview that they couldn't let Shoshanna be ''too'' happy. Then after she finally finds her footing after landing back in New York, she has a chance to be part of part of a successful startup, Jamba Jeans... only to ruin her relationship with her coworkers and miss the opportunity due to trying to build up a relationship with Jessa, who takes her to Rockaway on the same day as an important Jamba Jeans trip for the chance to see Vincent Gallo, who doesn't even show up.

to:

* YankTheDogsChain: Right as Shoshanna is really becoming comfortable, happy, and fulfilled in her job in Tokyo, she gets laid off. The creators outright stated in an interview that they couldn't let Shoshanna be ''too'' happy. Then after
** In the past,
she finally finds her footing after landing back in New York, she has had a chance to be part of part of a successful startup, Jamba Jeans... only to ruin her relationship with her coworkers and miss the opportunity due to trying to build up a relationship with Jessa, who takes took her to Rockaway on the same day as an important Jamba Jeans trip for the chance to see Vincent Gallo, who doesn't didn't even show up.

Added: 711

Changed: 8

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeadbuttingHeroes[=/=]VitriolicBestBuds: Marnie and Jessa. It's not completely clear whether they are actually friends or not. In Episode 8 it's made clear that up until then they had a mutual friend in Hannah but really weren't friends with each other. However, their friendship develops - REALLY develops - in this episode (though their interactions wax and wane as the seasons go on).

to:

* HeadbuttingHeroes[=/=]VitriolicBestBuds: Marnie and Jessa. It's not completely clear whether they are actually friends or not. In Episode 8 it's made clear that up until then they had a mutual friend in Hannah but really weren't friends with each other. However, their friendship develops - REALLY develops - in this episode (though their interactions wax and wane as the seasons go on).


Added DiffLines:

** Ray's coffee shop rivals in season five are serious hipsters, and Shoshanna helps him market his own shop as "anti-hipster" to bring in revenue.
* HopeSpot: Charlie reappears in season five at the exact moment Marnie is at her wit's end with Desi. [[spoiler:After sharing a romantic evening together, Charlie suggests they run away together, an idea Marnie seriously considers as an out of her own unhappy life and marriage... Until she finds his heroin needle and realizes it's impossible.]]


Added DiffLines:

* RewatchBonus: Rewatching ''Panic in Central Park,'' it's easier to notice how Charlie frequently leaves, typically got the bathroom, and comes back more manic than before [[spoiler:because of his heroin addiction.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** FriendsRentControl: Several arcs and motivations are kicked off because people can't afford their lifestyles.

to:

** FriendsRentControl: Several arcs and motivations are kicked off because people can't afford their lifestyles.[[note]]This is played with as many characters have no problem finding jobs whenever the plot demands, many of which still couldn't support their rent.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AbsenceMakesTheHeartGoYonder: Despite having a real, passionate relationship and seemingly being an OfficialCouple, [[spoiler:Adam gets a new girlfriend and moves her into his apartment within a month of Hannah leaving for Iowa. It didn't help that the two of them agreed to have only sporadic contact, and Jessa manipulated him into a new relationship for her own benefit.]]


Added DiffLines:

* BrutalHonesty: After a devastated Hannah holes herself up in her bedroom [[spoiler:after learning Adam has a new girlfriend he's moved into their old apartment]], Marnie finally arrives.
---> '''Marnie:''' I know that, and it's fucking hard, but did you really think [[spoiler:you and Adam were gonna be [[OfficialCouple a forever couple]]?]]
---> '''Hannah:''' I would've liked the chance to find out.
---> '''Marnie:''' I think you have your answer.


Added DiffLines:

* HeroicBSOD: Hannah holes herself up in her bedroom under a blanket and refuses to eat or shower [[spoiler:after learning that within a month of her leaving, Adam has already gotten a new girlfriend, moved her in and removed all of Hannah's possessions.]]


Added DiffLines:

** Subverted when Hannah gives two failed ones to her GQ coworkers and her [[spoiler:grad school classmates]], as she quits both. The first ends up just coming off as her whining about having to work in a corporate environment instead of using her talents to spend all her time writing whatever she wants, and she lashes out against the one coworker who consistently treated her well and helped her; she recaps the incident later to acquaintances, to an unimpressed and awkward reception. In the latter [[spoiler:she's clearly bruised that she's not the star of the program that she thought she would be and not everyone loves her writing, and she goes around the room insulting everyone before awkwardly leaving.]]


Added DiffLines:

*** After she's accepted into the highly competitive grad school of her dreams, [[spoiler:she moves to Iowa and gets a nice place, but can't cope with any criticism and chafes with the other students when she realizes that she's not immediately made the coveted star of the program. After blowing up at the other students and giving an ItsAllAboutMe apology, she realizes she's not cut out for grad school and leaves after only one month... only to get salt rubbed in the wound when she returns to New York and find out that her stuff is gone, and Adam has moved his surprise new girlfriend into her old apartment. Ouch.]]

Added: 1051

Changed: 345

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BittersweetEnding: [[spoiler:The girls start drifting apart, which ends up permanent in the final episode. Shoshanna moves on with her life after cutting ties with the rest of the group, Hannah moves upstate with a steady job and preparing for her new baby, and though she and Marnie reconcile, things will never be back to the way they were, but Hannah has more or less grown up and finally put someone else above herself.]]

to:

* BittersweetEnding: [[spoiler:The girls start drifting apart, which ends up permanent in the final episode. Shoshanna moves on with her life after cutting ties with the rest of the group, group. Hannah and Jessa reconcile enough to respectfully decide to end their friendship, and Hannah moves upstate with a steady job and preparing for her new baby, and though she and Marnie reconcile, things will never be back to the way they were, but Hannah has more or less grown up and finally put someone else above herself.herself. The second-to-last episode, considered by many to be the real "ending" of the show and the leads, ends with the girls spending one final happy moment together as they dance the night away, before Hannah moves away and prepares for the next stage in her life.]]


Added DiffLines:

* GrowingUpSucks: Though many of the characters don't have to "grow up" as much as normal people do, as many are supported by their families (Marnie and Shoshanna) or get by through mooching off others (Jessa and Hannah), the show is clear that being a twentysomething -- something often celebrated by nostalgic older writers -- can ''really'' suck, especially if you're living in an extremely expensive area, didn't pursue a "useful" degree (or aren't sure about your plans at all), and are surrounded by a bunch of uncertain, aimless, self-involved acquaintances. Your dreams for the future can be crushed because of events that aren't even your fault, and relationships that you count on can blow up overnight. Have fun!


Added DiffLines:

** Hannah finally gets an e-book deal... and then her employer dies suddenly, leading the publishing house to shelve the project indefinitely. Fortunately, she's able to get another publisher interested, and for a physical book deal... only to learn that the first publisher owns the rights for three years, caving in her plans.

Added: 212

Changed: 156

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeadbuttingHeroes[=/=]VitriolicBestBuds: Marnie and Jessa. It's not completely clear whether they are actually friends or not. In Episode 8 it's made clear that up until then they had a mutual friend in Hannah but really weren't friends with each other. However, their friendship develops - REALLY develops - in this episode.

to:

* HeadbuttingHeroes[=/=]VitriolicBestBuds: Marnie and Jessa. It's not completely clear whether they are actually friends or not. In Episode 8 it's made clear that up until then they had a mutual friend in Hannah but really weren't friends with each other. However, their friendship develops - REALLY develops - in this episode. episode (though their interactions wax and wane as the seasons go on).



* LesbianJock: Discussed and averted in ''Females Only'' when "fat gay Laura" tells Jessa she hates it when people assume that because she's a lesbian, she likes sports and she really dislikes playing them.

to:

* LesbianJock: Discussed and averted in ''Females Only'' when "fat gay Laura" tells Jessa she hates it when people assume that because she's a lesbian, she likes sports and sports, when she really dislikes playing them.



* MeetCute: [[spoiler:Shosanna and her fiance]] meet in line for a Sprinkles cupcake ATM.

to:

* MeetCute: [[spoiler:Shosanna [[spoiler:Shoshanna and her fiance]] meet in line for a Sprinkles cupcake ATM.



** Laird also cries at Caroline's story about her dead cousin, even after she reveals it's fake.



* MonochromeCasting: One of the major complaints about the show. It's set in Brooklyn, albeit in a largely white part, which makes this fairly striking. This was addressed by Lena Dunham, who apologized for the show's whiteness in several interviews. Perhaps to offset this criticism, [[Music/ChildishGambino Donald Glover]] was cast in a recurring role in season 2.

to:

* MonochromeCasting: One of the major complaints about the show. It's set in Brooklyn, albeit in a largely white part, which makes this fairly striking. This was addressed by Lena Dunham, who apologized for the show's whiteness in several interviews. Perhaps to offset this criticism, [[Music/ChildishGambino Donald Glover]] was cast in a recurring role in season 2.2... only to disappear after a few episodes, with the show going on as usual.



** Marnie is a decent singer, but not even closely as good as she thinks. The folksy indie pop music she makes with Desi doesn't make one's ears bleed, but neither is it interesting whatsoever. [[invoked]]

to:

** Marnie is a decent singer, but not even closely as good as she thinks. The folksy indie pop music she makes with Desi doesn't make one's ears bleed, but neither is it interesting whatsoever. [[invoked]]
** Jessa is noted to be a decent painter, but never really puts in the time or motivation to become genuinely great.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AmbitionIsEvil: Shoshanna often gets criticism for trying to improve her life and getting a great career as something of an obsession with image and short-sightedness, such as Jessa deriding her "15-year plan" as Jessa herself only lives day to day. The series itself isn't as critical, however, [[spoiler:and Shoshanna ends up in the best position out of all of them, with a loving fiance, good job and lots of caring friends.]]


Added DiffLines:

* PairTheSpares: [[spoiler:Ray ends up with Shoshanna's old boss Abigail.]]


Added DiffLines:

* VirginShaming: Subverted. Shoshanna is the one most embarrassed and self-conscious about her own virginity, and those she reveals it to are momentarily taken aback (as this is a world where EverybodyHasLotsOfSex), but ultimately aren't concerned and even assure her that it's not a big deal, except for the first guy she tries to hook up with who refuses to sleep with virgins.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DowntimeDowngrade: Marnie and Charlie end season two finally getting back together after a season of WillTheyOrWontThey, but season three opens with him having abandoned her offscreen, without a word.


Added DiffLines:

** Then Thomas-John calls her out for using him for his money to get by without having to work, as she is "a whore with no work ethic," causing her to slap him.


Added DiffLines:

* TookALevelInJerkass: All the leads are a lot nicer and normal in the first two seasons, but become colder and more self-involved as the show runs on.


Added DiffLines:

* WillTheyOrWontThey: Hannah and Adam, as well as Marnie and Charlie, in season two after Hannah's relationship with Adam implodes. In the end both couples end up together, but the latter break up offscreen between seasons.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheFellowshipHasEnded: [[spoiler:The group begins to drift apart later in the show, and in the final season, a meetup without Hannah just feels awkward and forced. This culminates in Shoshanna's engagement party, where she gives an icy, devastating TheReasonYouSuckSpeech in the bathroom in the penultimate episode, stating firmly that the group's dynamic has become so toxic and tiresome that it would be better to just "call it [quits]". Shoshanna ends her friendship with the group, and Jessa and Hannah decide to mutually call it quits; in the finale, where only Hannah and Marnie appear, Marnie's mother encourages her to chase after her dreams and not spend her life supporting Hannah, as she did the same thing for her own best friend for decades and ended up resenting and hating her, making it likely that Marnie will ultimately end up doing the same.]]

to:

* TheFellowshipHasEnded: [[spoiler:The group begins to drift apart later in the show, and in the final season, a meetup without Hannah just feels awkward and forced. This culminates in Shoshanna's engagement party, where she gives an icy, devastating TheReasonYouSuckSpeech in the bathroom in the penultimate episode, stating firmly that the group's dynamic has become so toxic and tiresome that it would be better to just "call it [quits]". Shoshanna ends her friendship with the group, and Jessa and Hannah decide to mutually call it quits; in the finale, where only Hannah and Marnie appear, Marnie's mother Loreen encourages her to chase after her dreams and not spend her life supporting Hannah, as she did the same thing for her own best friend for decades and ended up resenting and hating her, making it likely that Marnie will ultimately end up doing the same.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PaperDestructionOfAnger: In "Female Author", Jessa relieves herself between two parked cars on a New York street. A police officer in a passing car spots her and gives her a ticket for public urination which she rips up in pieces.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Jerkass Has a Point

Added DiffLines:

* JerkassHasAPoint: Shoshanna's TheReasonYouSuckSpeech to her now-former friends in "Goodbye Tour" is pretty blunt and not the best note to end things on, but she's right about their past failings and the negative effect they've had on her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
fix last


* DoubleStandardRapeFemaleOnMale: In Season 5's "Homeward Bound", Ray drives his coffee van all the way upstate after Hannah breaks up with Fran at the beginning[[note]]and, as it turns out, end[[/note]] of their summer road trip, to take her back to Brooklyn, noting that this is costing him a lot of money. Shortly after they get underway, Hannah takes it upon herself to give him a blowjob while he's driving as a way of thanking him, even though he suggests she doesn't have to, and when he tries to put his hand on her head tells him not to as that's a "trigger" for her.[[note]]Incredibly, with [[https://althouse.blogspot.com/2016/04/the-lena-dunham-character-on-girls.html one exception]], most recaps of the show (written by women) downplayed the clear lack of consent.[[/note. This distraction [[RealityEnsuses naturally makes him crash the van and roll it over at the side of the road]][[note]]; [[https://fanfare.metafilter.com/6507/Girls-Homeward-Bound Some viewers]] even blamed Ray for the accident on the grounds that he had ''later consented to the blowjob by closing his eyes''[[/note]] where, to add insult to injury, Hannah taunts Ray about him not getting aroused and then hitches a ride home while ... it's ''[[PlayedForLaughs played for laughs]]''.

to:

* DoubleStandardRapeFemaleOnMale: In Season 5's "Homeward Bound", Ray drives his coffee van all the way upstate after Hannah breaks up with Fran at the beginning[[note]]and, as it turns out, end[[/note]] of their summer road trip, to take her back to Brooklyn, noting that this is costing him a lot of money. Shortly after they get underway, Hannah takes it upon herself to give him a blowjob while he's driving as a way of thanking him, even though he suggests she doesn't have to, and when he tries to put his hand on her head tells him not to as that's a "trigger" for her.[[note]]Incredibly, with [[https://althouse.blogspot.com/2016/04/the-lena-dunham-character-on-girls.html one exception]], most recaps of the show (written by women) downplayed the clear lack of consent.[[/note. [[/note]]. This distraction [[RealityEnsuses [[RealityEnsues naturally makes him crash the van and roll it over at the side of the road]][[note]]; [[https://fanfare.metafilter.com/6507/Girls-Homeward-Bound Some viewers]] even blamed Ray for the accident on the grounds that he had ''later consented to the blowjob by closing his eyes''[[/note]] where, to add insult to injury, Hannah taunts Ray about him not getting aroused and then hitches a ride home while ... it's ''[[PlayedForLaughs played for laughs]]''.

Added DiffLines:

* DoubleStandardRapeFemaleOnMale: In Season 5's "Homeward Bound", Ray drives his coffee van all the way upstate after Hannah breaks up with Fran at the beginning[[note]]and, as it turns out, end[[/note]] of their summer road trip, to take her back to Brooklyn, noting that this is costing him a lot of money. Shortly after they get underway, Hannah takes it upon herself to give him a blowjob while he's driving as a way of thanking him, even though he suggests she doesn't have to, and when he tries to put his hand on her head tells him not to as that's a "trigger" for her.[[note]]Incredibly, with [[https://althouse.blogspot.com/2016/04/the-lena-dunham-character-on-girls.html one exception]], most recaps of the show (written by women) downplayed the clear lack of consent.[[/note. This distraction [[RealityEnsuses naturally makes him crash the van and roll it over at the side of the road]][[note]]; [[https://fanfare.metafilter.com/6507/Girls-Homeward-Bound Some viewers]] even blamed Ray for the accident on the grounds that he had ''later consented to the blowjob by closing his eyes''[[/note]] where, to add insult to injury, Hannah taunts Ray about him not getting aroused and then hitches a ride home while ... it's ''[[PlayedForLaughs played for laughs]]''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Nature Tinkling

Added DiffLines:

* NatureTinkling:
** In "Video Games", Hannah relieves herself on a telephone pole while waiting for a train.
** Two seasons later, in "Female Author", Jessa crouches between two parked cars on a New York street when she can't find a bathroom. Police in a passing car spot her, and give her a ticket which she rips up, resulting in more serious charges against her and Adam.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Both Sides Have a Point

Added DiffLines:

* BothSidesHaveAPoint: In "Close-Up", Mimi-Rose blithely reveals to Adam that she aborted a pregnancy by him the day before. She asks him if he had wanted a child, and he says "Maybe". She points out that they have only been living together for seven weeks, which doesn't seem like a long enough time to have made that decision together. He responds that his parents got married after only having known each other for a week, however.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the pilot episode while Hannah is having dinner at a restaurant her parents (Loreen and Tad) try to tell her they're cutting her off while she's still unemployed because they gave up hope and patience on her becoming self-sufficient. A waiter arrives and Hannah tries to order dessert. Loreen barks at her obese daughter to stop eating.

to:

** In the pilot episode while Hannah is having dinner at a restaurant her parents (Loreen and Tad) try to tell her they're cutting her off while she's still unemployed because they've grown impatient with her enjoying an all-expenses paid lifestyle they gave up hope and patience on her becoming self-sufficient.were funding. A waiter arrives and Hannah tries to order dessert. Loreen barks at her obese daughter to stop eating.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the pilot episode while Hannah is having dinner at a restaurant her parents try to tell her they're cutting her off while she's still unemployed because they gave up hope and patience on her becoming self-sufficient. A waiter arrives and Hannah tries to order dessert. Her mom barks at Hannah to stop eating.

to:

** In the pilot episode while Hannah is having dinner at a restaurant her parents (Loreen and Tad) try to tell her they're cutting her off while she's still unemployed because they gave up hope and patience on her becoming self-sufficient. A waiter arrives and Hannah tries to order dessert. Her mom Loreen barks at Hannah her obese daughter to stop eating.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MeetCute: [[spoiler:Shosanna and her fiance]] meet in line for a Sprinkles cupcake ATM.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheFellowshipHasEnded: [[spoiler:The group begins to drift apart later in the show, and in the final season, a meetup without Hannah just feels awkward and forced. This culminates in Shoshanna's engagement party, where she gives an icy, devastating TheReasonYouSuckSpeech in the bathroom in the penultimate episode, stating firmly that the group's dynamic has become so toxic and tiresome that it would be better to just "call it [quits]". The fact that half the group doesn't even appear in the final episode underscores this.]]

to:

* TheFellowshipHasEnded: [[spoiler:The group begins to drift apart later in the show, and in the final season, a meetup without Hannah just feels awkward and forced. This culminates in Shoshanna's engagement party, where she gives an icy, devastating TheReasonYouSuckSpeech in the bathroom in the penultimate episode, stating firmly that the group's dynamic has become so toxic and tiresome that it would be better to just "call it [quits]". The fact that half Shoshanna ends her friendship with the group doesn't even appear group, and Jessa and Hannah decide to mutually call it quits; in the final episode underscores this.finale, where only Hannah and Marnie appear, Marnie's mother encourages her to chase after her dreams and not spend her life supporting Hannah, as she did the same thing for her own best friend for decades and ended up resenting and hating her, making it likely that Marnie will ultimately end up doing the same.]]



* YankTheDogsChain: Right as Shoshanna is really becoming comfortable, happy, and fulfilled in her job in Tokyo, she gets laid off. The creators outright stated in an interview that they couldn't let Shoshanna be ''too'' happy.

to:

* YankTheDogsChain: Right as Shoshanna is really becoming comfortable, happy, and fulfilled in her job in Tokyo, she gets laid off. The creators outright stated in an interview that they couldn't let Shoshanna be ''too'' happy. Then after she finally finds her footing after landing back in New York, she has a chance to be part of part of a successful startup, Jamba Jeans... only to ruin her relationship with her coworkers and miss the opportunity due to trying to build up a relationship with Jessa, who takes her to Rockaway on the same day as an important Jamba Jeans trip for the chance to see Vincent Gallo, who doesn't even show up.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the pilot episode while Hannah is having dinner at a restaurant her parents try to tell her they're cutting her off while she's still unemployed because they gave up hope and patience on her becoming self-sufficient. A waiter arrives and Hannah tries to order dessert. Her mom shoos away the waiter to make sure Hannah gets nothing more to eat.

to:

** In the pilot episode while Hannah is having dinner at a restaurant her parents try to tell her they're cutting her off while she's still unemployed because they gave up hope and patience on her becoming self-sufficient. A waiter arrives and Hannah tries to order dessert. Her mom shoos away the waiter to make sure barks at Hannah gets nothing more to eat.stop eating.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DownerBeginning: Up for interpretation. The series begins with Hannah's parents cutting her off citing she's 24 and she has a college education (albeit as an English major, and lacking technical or computer skills). Though we later see that Hannah is lazy, arrogant and irresponsible so her unemployment and loss of parental support is mostly karma.

to:

* DownerBeginning: Up for interpretation. The series begins with Hannah's parents cutting her off citing she's 24 and she has a college education (albeit as an English major, and lacking so she has no technical or computer skills). Though we later see that Hannah is lazy, arrogant and irresponsible so her unemployment and loss of parental support is mostly karma.entirely karma.



** In the pilot episode while Hannah is dinner at a restaurant her parents try to tell her they're cutting her off at a time when she's still unemployed. A waiter arrives and Hannah tries to order dessert. Her mom shoos away the waiter to make sure Hannah gets nothing more to eat.

to:

** In the pilot episode while Hannah is having dinner at a restaurant her parents try to tell her they're cutting her off at a time when while she's still unemployed.unemployed because they gave up hope and patience on her becoming self-sufficient. A waiter arrives and Hannah tries to order dessert. Her mom shoos away the waiter to make sure Hannah gets nothing more to eat.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the pilot episode while having dinner at a restaurant her parents announce they're cutting her off at a time when she's still unemployed, Hannah tries to order dessert. Her mom shoos away the waiter to make sure Hannah gets nothing more to eat.

to:

** In the pilot episode while having Hannah is dinner at a restaurant her parents announce try to tell her they're cutting her off at a time when she's still unemployed, unemployed. A waiter arrives and Hannah tries to order dessert. Her mom shoos away the waiter to make sure Hannah gets nothing more to eat.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In episode 5, after Hannah sabotaged Charlie and Marnie's relationship by saying the two don't belong in her journal or diary or whatever she calls it, Marnie tries to make Hannah apologize and admit what she did was wrong. Hannah just continues to eat cereal and with her mouth full, tries rationalizing her mistakes. This makes Marnie consider kicking Hannah out of the room and leave her homeless out on the streets because as Hannah has no job, she's not paying her half of the rent.

to:

** In episode 5, after Hannah sabotaged Charlie and Marnie's relationship by saying the two don't belong in her journal or diary or whatever she calls it, Marnie tries to make Hannah apologize and admit what she did was wrong. Hannah just continues to eat cereal and belittles Marnie with her mouth full, tries rationalizing her mistakes. This makes Marnie consider kicking Hannah out of the room and leave her homeless out on the streets because as Hannah has no job, she's not paying her half of the rent.full.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheSnackIsMoreInteresting: Hannah tries eating at even the most inappropriate times.
** In the pilot episode while having dinner at a restaurant her parents announce they're cutting her off at a time when she's still unemployed, Hannah tries to order dessert. Her mom shoos away the waiter to make sure Hannah gets nothing more to eat.
** In episode 5, after Hannah sabotaged Charlie and Marnie's relationship by saying the two don't belong in her journal or diary or whatever she calls it, Marnie tries to make Hannah apologize and admit what she did was wrong. Hannah just continues to eat cereal and with her mouth full, tries rationalizing her mistakes. This makes Marnie consider kicking Hannah out of the room and leave her homeless out on the streets because as Hannah has no job, she's not paying her half of the rent.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DeusExMachina: Hannah's fate in the final season. [[spoiler:She ends up getting interviewed for and accepting a cushy job as a professor upstate despite only having a bachelor's degree, [[InformedAbility apparently good writing]] and some spotty freelancing experience, with the department completely unconcerned with her lack of relevant experience, education or her advanced pregnancy (which has disqualified many real women looking for work).]] Real-life writers immediately lambasted the arc, pointing to the high unemployment rate for academics and the unfortunate trend of unpaid work, even for someone with years of experience and a graduate degree, arguing that it would be unlikely for Hannah to qualify for the job at all, much less receive benefits or make enough money to afford a house and support a family considering her relatively light course load.

Added: 675

Changed: 560

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** After [[spoiler:Shoshanna's icy TheReasonYouSuckSpeech effectively ending the group in her apartment's bathroom, Hannah announces that she's also fed up with the other girls and her decision to move to upstate New York is now cemented.]] Then Elijah pops in, crudely announcing that he got the lead role in ''White Men Can't Jump.''



* OddFriendship: Elijah is much more snarky and cynical compared to the quirky and optimistic Shoshanna, but despite his earlier apparent disdain for her, he ends up getting invited to her [[spoiler:engagement party]] over Hannah and Jessa. When a disbelieving Hannah asks why he's there, he simply comments that he and Shosh became "bros."



* OutOfFocus: Shoshanna largely fades from the narrative in the last couple of seasons.

to:

* OutOfFocus: Shoshanna largely fades from the narrative in the last couple of seasons.seasons, and in the final season got less screentime than ''Desi''. While this largely had to do with the narrative focusing more on Hannah as the main character, the creators argued that this was intentional, which was confirmed in the penultimate episode -- Shoshanna now has a life and love of her own, which Hannah only learns through conversation with others, proving Shoshanna's earlier concern that her friendship with the other girls (and thus her presence in the show) was holding her back from meeting people who would truly be good for her.



* YourCheatingHeart: There's quite a bit of infidelity going around, though the creators have outright stated that the affairs aren't usually romanticized infidelity, but a consequence of the characters wanting out of their relationships but being too [[AdultChild immature]] to just communicate this.

to:

* YourCheatingHeart: There's quite a bit of infidelity going around, though the creators have outright stated that the affairs aren't usually romanticized infidelity, but a consequence of the characters wanting out of their relationships but being too [[AdultChild immature]] to just communicate this.this to their partner.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* InstantlyProvenWrong: In the pilot episode, Hannah complains that being her parents' only child, she can't be draining all their resources. Her mother Loreen points out Hannah's making them cover her apartment rent (almost $2000 a month) plus insurance and utilities.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In "Latching," Marnie comes upstate, ostensibly to help Hannah [[spoiler:with her new baby.]] Conveniently, she's looking for a place to live at that time, and Hannah calls her out for expecting an idealized version of them living together when Marnie "sucks at" dealing with the reality.

Top