Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / TriptychContinuumGoosed

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Dewicked trope


* KillEmAll: What happened to the geese who were caught outside the Empire when the barrier originally went up. The story suggests that the griffons, who would normally respect a fierce fighting animal enough to start breeding it for meat on their ranches, deliberately ate them out of existence. Given that griffons ''breed monsters for their primary meat source'', the fact that they didn't seem to feel the geese were worth the ''trouble'' may really say something.

to:

* KillEmAll: KilledOffscreen: What happened to the geese who were caught outside the Empire when the barrier originally went up. The story suggests that the griffons, who would normally respect a fierce fighting animal enough to start breeding it for meat on their ranches, deliberately ate them out of existence. Given that griffons ''breed monsters for their primary meat source'', the fact that they didn't seem to feel the geese were worth the ''trouble'' may really say something.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* NumberTwo: In order to get her leading the mini-herd, Mayor Mare tells Applejack that she's this to the Bearers as a whole. Rarity later points out that Applejack [[WhatAnIdiot believed a politician who was saying something in order to achieve her own ends]]. However, it's also noted that there are times when Applejack ''does'' take charge, particularly when a practical solution is called for, and the others wind up asking her to lead on this one.

to:

* NumberTwo: In order to get her leading the mini-herd, Mayor Mare tells Applejack that she's this to the Bearers as a whole. Rarity later points out that Applejack [[WhatAnIdiot believed a politician who was saying something in order to achieve her own ends]].ends. However, it's also noted that there are times when Applejack ''does'' take charge, particularly when a practical solution is called for, and the others wind up asking her to lead on this one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Up To Eleven is a defunct trope


* DidntThinkThisThrough: After Applejack notices the geese having extreme stomach distress following the theft of a meal from [[LethalChef Mr. Flankington's restaurant]] and that other birds are retreating from their sick fellows, she hatches a plan to get the rest of the Saddle Arabian Grass out of the pegasus' greenhouse and serve it to every possible bird in the settled zone, to see if she can get all the healthy ones to flee from an incomprehensible contagion. And in the meantime, Mr. Flankington will fly over Ponyville and feed the birds what remains of his pantry stock. What she doesn't consider is that she's taking a "food" item known to wreak havoc on ''pony'' biology and giving it to the creature with the world's "single least efficient digestive system." Upon returning to Ponyville with the freshly-prepared grass, she gets to see the results, which are... somewhat acidic. And while she's still trying to reconcile the failure, [[FromBadToWorse the geese steal]] [[UpToEleven and begin consuming the fresh supply]]. Cue SanitySlippage.

to:

* DidntThinkThisThrough: After Applejack notices the geese having extreme stomach distress following the theft of a meal from [[LethalChef Mr. Flankington's restaurant]] and that other birds are retreating from their sick fellows, she hatches a plan to get the rest of the Saddle Arabian Grass out of the pegasus' greenhouse and serve it to every possible bird in the settled zone, to see if she can get all the healthy ones to flee from an incomprehensible contagion. And in the meantime, Mr. Flankington will fly over Ponyville and feed the birds what remains of his pantry stock. What she doesn't consider is that she's taking a "food" item known to wreak havoc on ''pony'' biology and giving it to the creature with the world's "single least efficient digestive system." Upon returning to Ponyville with the freshly-prepared grass, she gets to see the results, which are... somewhat acidic. And while she's still trying to reconcile the failure, [[FromBadToWorse the geese steal]] [[UpToEleven steal and begin consuming the fresh supply]]. Cue SanitySlippage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FeatheredFiend: The Crystal Geese are vicious, gluttonous, and highly territorial birds. They also spread Styrofoam everywhere thanks to their incredibly inefficient digestive systems. It's telling that the names other races have given them are distinctly unflattering. Even [[FriendToAllLivingThings Fluttershy]] can't get them to calm down (and she's befriended a ''bear''). Makes sense, since they're based on Canada Geese, which some people would agree are a RealLife example.

to:

* FeatheredFiend: FoulWaterfowl: The Crystal Geese are vicious, gluttonous, and highly territorial birds. They also spread Styrofoam everywhere thanks to their incredibly inefficient digestive systems. It's telling that the names other races have given them are distinctly unflattering. Even [[FriendToAllLivingThings Fluttershy]] can't get them to calm down (and she's befriended a ''bear''). Makes sense, since they're based on Canada Geese, which some people would agree are a RealLife example.

Added: 176

Removed: 183

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* NotSoExtinct: Everything within the borders of the Empire qualifies. A significant number of Crystal Geese were originally caught outside the barrier, but... well, see above.



* SpeciesLostAndFound: Everything within the borders of the Empire qualifies. A significant number of Crystal Geese were originally caught outside the barrier, but... well, see above.

Added: 420

Changed: 33

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Just noticed this. ... And we shouldn't pothole trope names. - How To Write An Example: "Do Not Pothole the Trope Name"


->"But... nopony's seen them since about two years ''after'' the Empire was cut off. Some of them were outside when it happened, and they went..."
->She peered closely at the thick book.
->"...'suspiciously extinct.'"
->Rainbow moved closer.

to:

->"But... nopony's seen them since about two years ''after'' the Empire was cut off. Some of them were outside when it happened, and they went..."
->She
"\\
She
peered closely at the thick book.
->"...
book.\\
"...
'suspiciously extinct.'"
->Rainbow
'"\\
Rainbow
moved closer.



* ContinuityNod: Saddle Arabian Grass being a delicacy is first mentioned in [[https://www.fimfiction.net/story/101769/9/triptych/setting Chapter 9 of Triptych]], where it says of Trotter's Falls:
--> There are several restaurants, all of which specialize in one kind of foreign cuisine each. The grass at one ''is'' a Saddle Arabian delicacy and at the bits you're paying for it, may have been carried in blade by blade.



* {{Misblamed}}: All over the place. Applejack originally ''and [[SeenItAll instinctively]]'' questions [[DoomMagnet Apple Bloom]] to see if the Crusaders did something to bring in the first goose. Both Fluttershy and Applejack wind up blaming themselves for the geese returning because if the Empire hadn't been freed, there might not have been a migration. (Which kind of assumes the ''other'' option was to have it declared an enemy power, followed by blasting it off the map -- but without Twilight present, the others don't necessarily understand every detail of how the banishment spell originally worked, and the last barriers didn't come down until after Sombra's defeat.) Rainbow counters this as soon as it comes out, but it doesn't stop Mayor Mare, who [[ExactEavesDropping overheard]] Fluttershy tell the others about the geese being from the Empire, from [[{{Blackmail}} blackmailing]] the Bearers into helping with the post-migration cleanup, or else she'll tell the townsponies just where the issue came from...
** [[WordOfGod Word Of Fanfic Author]] is that Mayor Mare was trying to get any degree of control back, even a petty one, and recognized that it wasn't so much about what she personally believed as what she could get the townsponies to fall in line behind: part of a political special talent can be the ability to anticipate and partially direct herd mentality.

to:

* {{Misblamed}}: All over the place. Applejack originally ''and [[SeenItAll instinctively]]'' questions [[DoomMagnet Apple Bloom]] to see if the Crusaders did something to bring in the first goose. Both Fluttershy and Applejack wind up blaming themselves for the geese returning because if the Empire hadn't been freed, there might not have been a migration. (Which kind of assumes the ''other'' option was to have it declared an enemy power, followed by blasting it off the map -- but without Twilight present, the others don't necessarily understand every detail of how the banishment spell originally worked, and the last barriers didn't come down until after Sombra's defeat.) Rainbow counters this as soon as it comes out, but it doesn't stop Mayor Mare, who [[ExactEavesDropping overheard]] Fluttershy tell the others about the geese being from the Empire, from [[{{Blackmail}} blackmailing]] {{blackmail}}ing the Bearers into helping with the post-migration cleanup, or else she'll tell the townsponies just where the issue came from...
** [[WordOfGod WordOfGod: Word Of Fanfic Author]] Author is that Mayor Mare was trying to get any degree of control back, even a petty one, and recognized that it wasn't so much about what she personally believed as what she could get the townsponies to fall in line behind: part of a political special talent can be the ability to anticipate and partially direct herd mentality.

Added: 2197

Removed: 2193

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
As an AU Fanfic, references to canon events fall under Mythology Gag, not Call Back (which refers to events of past fics in the same verse).


* CallBack: A few.
** Fluttershy wonders if the initial goose who's camped out at the Acres is being so mean because of [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS1E2ElementsOfHarmony another thorn]]. Applejack darkly reasons that being able to charge that fast means his feet are fine.
** After Applejack reaches the library and discovers the usual librarian has left town for a few days, Rainbow declares Spike to be [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS2E2TheReturnOfHarmonyPart2 the new Twilight Sparkle]]. Which Applejack actually goes along with, reasoning that even if Spike can't ''use'' [[MagicAIsMagicA unicorn magic]], he's been around Twilight long enough that he has to ''understand'' a lot of it. This comes in handy later, as he's the one among them who knows ''exactly'' what to do about [[PowerStrainBlackout magical overexertion]].
** Rainbow decides there's no point to [[Recap/TriptychContinuumStupidDirectionFace freezing]] the geese out if they can get through the weather around the empire.
** Fluttershy, while listing some of the hardships which the Bearers have to go through, says that she shouldn't have to do a ''lot'' of things. The context points towards this being a reference to [[Recap/TriptychContinuumFiveHundredLittleMurders Five Hundred Little Murders]].
** Towards the end, Applejack wishes Twilight was in Ponyville, in the hopes that she might be able to use a working which would just clean up the entire town in one casting. Pinkie notes that the ''other'' option is to have the spell merge all the [[InsistentTerminology styrofoam]] into a single giant monster which then attempts to ''eat' the town -- then remembers that they [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS1E10SwarmOfTheCentury sort of did that one already]], only without the giant monster part.
** Upon hearing that one of the many names for Crystal Geese is 'airasprites', Pinkie gets out her instruments again. It doesn't go so well.
-->"MUSIC!" Pinkie proudly announced, and marched towards her chosen audience.
-->Twenty seconds passed.
-->And then a pink blur shot past them, instruments falling away in every direction as a trio of hissing geese snapped at her curly tail.
-->"CRIIIIITIIIIICS!"


Added DiffLines:

* MythologyGag: A few.
** Fluttershy wonders if the initial goose who's camped out at the Acres is being so mean because of [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS1E2ElementsOfHarmony another thorn]]. Applejack darkly reasons that being able to charge that fast means his feet are fine.
** After Applejack reaches the library and discovers the usual librarian has left town for a few days, Rainbow declares Spike to be [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS2E2TheReturnOfHarmonyPart2 the new Twilight Sparkle]]. Which Applejack actually goes along with, reasoning that even if Spike can't ''use'' [[MagicAIsMagicA unicorn magic]], he's been around Twilight long enough that he has to ''understand'' a lot of it. This comes in handy later, as he's the one among them who knows ''exactly'' what to do about [[PowerStrainBlackout magical overexertion]].
** Rainbow decides there's no point to [[Recap/TriptychContinuumStupidDirectionFace freezing]] the geese out if they can get through the weather around the empire.
** Fluttershy, while listing some of the hardships which the Bearers have to go through, says that she shouldn't have to do a ''lot'' of things. The context points towards this being a reference to [[Recap/TriptychContinuumFiveHundredLittleMurders Five Hundred Little Murders]].
** Towards the end, Applejack wishes Twilight was in Ponyville, in the hopes that she might be able to use a working which would just clean up the entire town in one casting. Pinkie notes that the ''other'' option is to have the spell merge all the [[InsistentTerminology styrofoam]] into a single giant monster which then attempts to ''eat' the town -- then remembers that they [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS1E10SwarmOfTheCentury sort of did that one already]], only without the giant monster part.
** Upon hearing that one of the many names for Crystal Geese is 'airasprites', Pinkie gets out her instruments again. It doesn't go so well.
-->"MUSIC!" Pinkie proudly announced, and marched towards her chosen audience.
-->Twenty seconds passed.
-->And then a pink blur shot past them, instruments falling away in every direction as a trio of hissing geese snapped at her curly tail.
-->"CRIIIIITIIIIICS!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SolidGoldPoop: Initially, Rarity has hopes of collecting the Crystal Geese feathers that they shed so copiously, as their combination of exotic value and inherent beauty makes them material she could use to potentially produce extremely valuable clothing. Events conspire against her plan and in the end, she declares the feathers to be substandard and worthy only of [[Recap/TriptychContinuumSonicRainbigot Barneigh's]].

to:

* SolidGoldPoop: Initially, Rarity has hopes of collecting the Crystal Geese feathers that they shed so copiously, as their combination of exotic value and inherent beauty makes them material she could use to potentially produce extremely valuable clothing. Events conspire against her plan and in the end, she declares the feathers to be substandard and worthy only of [[Recap/TriptychContinuumSonicRainbigot [[Recap/TriptychContinuumOneTenthBit Barneigh's]].

Changed: 145

Removed: 155

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
No spoilers in recap pages.


** [[spoiler: Then they realize the next stop is the GRIFFON EMPIRE!]]

to:

** [[spoiler: Then they realize * DeusExitMachina: Twilight could have solved this, probably. Or at least made it much easier. She's absent for most of the next stop is the GRIFFON EMPIRE!]]story.



* HoldingBackThePhlebotinum: Twilight could have solved this, probably. Or at least made it much easier. Conveniently? She's absent for most of the story.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HoldingBackThePhlebotinum: Twilight could have solved this, probably. Or at least made it much easier. Conveniently? She's absent for most of the story.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**[[spoiler: Then they realize the next stop is the GRIFFON EMPIRE!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TakeThat: After a while, you might start to get the impression that the author doesn't ''like'' Canada Geese. Of course, judging by some of the reactions in the story comments section, the author has plenty of company... in fact, all of the names for them either directly referenced in the story or used as chapter titles were originally suggested by people in a blog that Estee put up before the story was written.

to:

* TakeThat: After a while, you might start to get the impression that the author doesn't ''like'' Canada Geese. Of course, judging by some of the reactions in the story comments section, the author has plenty of company... in fact, all of the names for them either directly referenced in the story or used as chapter titles were originally suggested by people in a blog that Estee the author put up before the story was written.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TakeThat: After a while, you might start to get the impression that the author doesn't ''like'' Canada Geese. Of course, judging by some of the reactions in the story comments section, the author has plenty of company... in fact, all of the titles for them either directly referenced in the story or used as chapter titles were originally suggested by people in a blog that Estee put up before the story was written.

to:

* TakeThat: After a while, you might start to get the impression that the author doesn't ''like'' Canada Geese. Of course, judging by some of the reactions in the story comments section, the author has plenty of company... in fact, all of the titles names for them either directly referenced in the story or used as chapter titles were originally suggested by people in a blog that Estee put up before the story was written.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SolidGoldPoop: Initially, Rarity has hopes of collecting the Crystal Geese feathers that they shed so copiously, as their combination of exotic value and inherent beauty makes them material she could produce extremely valuable clothing. Events conspire against her plan.

to:

* SolidGoldPoop: Initially, Rarity has hopes of collecting the Crystal Geese feathers that they shed so copiously, as their combination of exotic value and inherent beauty makes them material she could use to potentially produce extremely valuable clothing. Events conspire against her plan.plan and in the end, she declares the feathers to be substandard and worthy only of [[Recap/TriptychContinuumSonicRainbigot Barneigh's]].

Added: 619

Changed: 743

Removed: 100

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* AdmiringTheAbomination:
** Most ponies who see a Crystal Goose seem to have first impressions along the lines of "what a beautiful-looking bird". That impression fades very quickly when they find out what sorts of nasty things they are up close and personal.
** [[MeaningfulName Cartier Anserini]], the avian paleobiologist, is enthralled with the Crystal Geese to the point he absolutely refuses to listen to Applejack's warnings about how unpleasant they are.



* PrecisionFStrike: In Chapter Four, Pinkie spends some time reading off alternate names for the Crystal Geese in the background of the scene, eventually reaching "Grey-Winged Shitbuckets." It took nearly forty stories, but somepony in the Continuum finally got an actual curse word in.

to:

* PrecisionFStrike: In Chapter Four, Pinkie spends some time reading off alternate names for the Crystal Geese in the background of the scene, eventually reaching "Grey-Winged Shitbuckets." Shitbuckets", which makes everypony stop and stare at her in shock. It took nearly forty stories, but somepony in the Continuum finally got an actual curse word in.



* SpeciesLostAndFound: Everything within the borders of the Empire qualifies. (A significant number of Crystal Geese were originally caught outside the barrier, but... well, see above.)

to:

* SolidGoldPoop: Initially, Rarity has hopes of collecting the Crystal Geese feathers that they shed so copiously, as their combination of exotic value and inherent beauty makes them material she could produce extremely valuable clothing. Events conspire against her plan.
* SpeciesLostAndFound: Everything within the borders of the Empire qualifies. (A A significant number of Crystal Geese were originally caught outside the barrier, but... well, see above.)



* TakeThat: After a while, you might start to get the impression that the author doesn't ''like'' Canada Geese.
** Judging by some of the reactions in the story comments section, the author has plenty of company.

to:

* TakeThat: After a while, you might start to get the impression that the author doesn't ''like'' Canada Geese.
** Judging
Geese. Of course, judging by some of the reactions in the story comments section, the author has plenty of company.company... in fact, all of the titles for them either directly referenced in the story or used as chapter titles were originally suggested by people in a blog that Estee put up before the story was written.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NatureIsNotNice: Especially when it's in the form of an invasive species of territorial birds.

to:

* NatureIsNotNice: Especially when it's in the form of an invasive species of territorial birds.birds whose "territory" is "everywhere I land".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NatureIsNotNice: Especially when it's in the form of an invasive species of territorial birds.

Changed: 108

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FeatheredFiend: The Crystal Geese are vicious, gluttonous, and highly territorial birds. They also spread Styrofoam everywhere thanks to their incredibly inefficient digestive systems. It's telling that the names other races have given them are distinctly unflattering. Makes sense, since they're based on Canada Geese, which some people would agree are a RealLife example.

to:

* FeatheredFiend: The Crystal Geese are vicious, gluttonous, and highly territorial birds. They also spread Styrofoam everywhere thanks to their incredibly inefficient digestive systems. It's telling that the names other races have given them are distinctly unflattering. Even [[FriendToAllLivingThings Fluttershy]] can't get them to calm down (and she's befriended a ''bear''). Makes sense, since they're based on Canada Geese, which some people would agree are a RealLife example.

Top