Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / TheSimpsonsS8E6AMilhouseDivided

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Broken Aesop is YMMV now.


* BrokenAesop: Kirk and Luann Van Houten's divorce leads into an Aesop about Homer needing to respect his wife, which is what Kirk tells Homer after losing his home, his job, and his car. But the way losing Luann caused those was [[DeusAngstMachina utterly contrived]]: he lost his home because he apparently got absolutely nothing in the divorce settlement, he was fired ''[[GeorgeJetsonJobSecurity for being single]]'' ([[ArtisticLicenseLaw which is actually discrimination and grounds for Kirk to sue]]), an earlier comment from Luann also heavily implies his employer was [[ObnoxiousInLaws her father]][[note]]which, from Luann's tirade, may have been the reason he wasn't fired sooner, as she suggests that he was bad at his job. If so, his incompetence would be a perfectly valid reason the company could've cited for firing him, but they don't.[[/note]], and his car was stolen by a woman he met on the rebound who claims to be in the music business (which ''was'' his fault, but was more general incompetence as he was dumb enough to hand over his keys to someone he just met while waiting in a bar).

Added: 69

Changed: 33

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Character reactions don't qualify for this trope anymore.


* DivorceIsTemporary: {{Subverted}} when it looks like Kirk is about to [[StatusQuoIsGod win Luann back at the end]], but [[SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome she's not interested]] (though they would play this straight many seasons later). {{Exaggerated}} with Homer, who divorces Marge specifically for the purpose of marrying her again in a romantic gesture.

to:

* DivorceIsTemporary: {{Subverted}} when it looks like Kirk is about to [[StatusQuoIsGod win Luann back at the end]], but [[SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome she's not interested]] interested (though they would play this straight many seasons later). {{Exaggerated}} with Homer, who divorces Marge specifically for the purpose of marrying her again in a romantic gesture.


Added DiffLines:

* RiddleForTheAges: What did Luanne's drawing of "dignity" look like?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ContinuityNod: The previous season's "[[Recap/TheSimpsonsS7E16LisaTheIconoclast Lisa the Iconoclast]]" revealed that Jimbo's thug Kearney was [[OlderThanYouLook older than he looked]], apparently being old enough to remember the 1976 bicentennial celebration. This episode reveals he also has a child as well.

to:

* ContinuityNod: The previous season's "[[Recap/TheSimpsonsS7E16LisaTheIconoclast Lisa the Iconoclast]]" revealed that Jimbo's thug Kearney was [[OlderThanYouLook [[OlderThanTheyLook older than he looked]], apparently being old enough to remember the 1976 bicentennial celebration. celebration. This episode reveals he also has a child as well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ContinuityNod: The previous season's "[[Recap/TheSimpsonsS7E16LisaTheIconoclast Lisa the Iconoclast]]" revealed that Jimbo's thug Kearney was [[OlderThanYouLook older than he looked]], apparently being old enough to remember the 1976 bicentennial celebration. This episode reveals he also has a child as well.

Added: 792

Changed: 563

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PetTheDog: Despite the fact that Nelson and Kearney constantly pick on Milhouse, they give their sympathy for him after learning about his parents' divorce; they even refused to make fun of it in order to spare his feelings. Nelson explained that his own parents got divorced because of his mom's addiction of cough drops and that he felt that she wasn't acting like a real mother because of it. Kearney also admits that he was married and got a divorce that was tough on his son, but the latter was able to grow out of it, and Kearney assured that Milhouse can do the same.

to:

* PetTheDog: PetTheDog:
**
Despite the fact that Nelson and Kearney constantly pick on Milhouse, they give their sympathy for him after learning about his parents' divorce; they even refused to make fun of it in order to spare his feelings. Nelson explained that his own parents got divorced because of his mom's addiction of cough drops and that he felt that she wasn't acting like a real mother because of it. Kearney also admits that he was married and got a divorce that was tough on his son, but the latter was able to grow out of it, and Kearney assured that Milhouse can do the same.same.
** Despite the constant enmity between Homer and his in-laws, Jacqueline, Selma and Patty all happily show up to Homer and Marge's second wedding, which Homer would have had to invite them to since it was a surprise for Marge.

Changed: 204

Removed: 593

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I removed the first Artistic License Law example, which was about Kirk being fired for being single. This had been added, then a second edit had been added arguing it probably wasn’t really an example. Rather than having the article contradict itself, I removed the example.


* ArtisticLicenseLaw:
** You cannot fire someone for being single. In real life, Kirk would have had every right to sue the company into the ground for discrimination against his marital status, although this would depend on [[WhereTheHellIsSpringfield where Springfield actually is]] - about half of US states, as well as federal law, don't prohibit employment discrimination on the basis of marital status.
** Homer manages to get a divorce extremely quickly and without Marge knowing. In real life, the only way one would be able to get a divorce without the spouse knowing is if they were unable to be contacted.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseLaw:
** You cannot fire someone for being single. In real life, Kirk would have had every right to sue the company into the ground for discrimination against his marital status, although this would depend on [[WhereTheHellIsSpringfield where Springfield actually is]] - about half of US states, as well as federal law, don't prohibit employment discrimination on the basis of marital status.
**
ArtisticLicenseLaw: Homer manages to get a divorce extremely quickly and without Marge knowing. In real life, the only way one would be able to get a divorce without the spouse knowing is if they were unable to be contacted.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* OffModel: Kirk's eyebrows [[https://frinkiac.com/img/S08E06/778543.jpg briefly go from blue to yellow]] when giving Starla his keys.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RearrangeTheSong: The closing theme is played in the style of the later Steely Dan albums.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Their bickering reaches a breaking point while playing ''TabletopGame/{{Pictionary}}'', with Luann being unable to guess Kirk's drawing about "dignity." Kirk claims that he doesn't know to draw it because he lost it after marrying her. Luann then tells about the penurious conditions they have been through, and Kirk shoots back that she actually ''loves'' it when he fails. Finally, (after Lisa is brought in to sing to calm things down) Luann demands a divorce, something that takes Kirk back at first, but tries to brush it off by showing (or in this case, drawing) her the door. When the party finishes, Luann drives off before Kirk can get in the car.

to:

Their bickering reaches a breaking point while playing ''TabletopGame/{{Pictionary}}'', with Luann being unable to guess Kirk's drawing about "dignity." Kirk claims that he doesn't know to draw it because he lost it after marrying her. Luann then tells about the penurious conditions they have been through, and Kirk shoots back that she actually ''loves'' it when he fails. Finally, (after Lisa is brought in to sing to calm things down) Luann demands a divorce, something that takes Kirk back aback at first, but tries to brush it off by showing (or in this case, drawing) her the door. When the party finishes, Luann drives off before Kirk can get in the car.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PrisonersLastMeal: After finishing his meal at the Simpsons' dinner party, Dr. Hibbert makes reference to this when he "compliments" Marge's cooking in a way that does not entirely sound like a compliment.
--> '''Dr. Hibbert''': Marge, if that were my last meal, I'd tell the warden, "Bring on the lethal injection!" [SignatureLaugh]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
On both their parts - they were both arguing with each other.


* ToiletSeatDivorce: Kirk and Luanne divorce over a game of ''Pictionary'' ... well, sort of. In actuality, they were fighting all night before the game started, and the game just [[RageBreakingPoint unleashed years of frustration on Luanne's part]].

to:

* ToiletSeatDivorce: Kirk and Luanne divorce over a game of ''Pictionary'' ... well, sort of. In actuality, they were fighting all night before the game started, and the game just [[RageBreakingPoint unleashed years of frustration on Luanne's part]].frustration]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Their bickering reaches a breaking point while playing ''TabletopGame/{{Pictionary}}'', with Luann being unable to guess Kirk's drawing about "dignity." Kirk claims that he doesn't know to draw it because he lost it after marrying her. Luann then tells about the penurious conditions they have been through, and Kirk shoots back that she actually ''loves'' it when he fails. Finally, (after Lisa is brought in to sing to calm things down) Luann demands a divorce, something that takes Kirk back at first, but tries to brush it off by showing (or in this case, drawing) her the door. When the party finishes, Kirk is thrown off the family car.

to:

Their bickering reaches a breaking point while playing ''TabletopGame/{{Pictionary}}'', with Luann being unable to guess Kirk's drawing about "dignity." Kirk claims that he doesn't know to draw it because he lost it after marrying her. Luann then tells about the penurious conditions they have been through, and Kirk shoots back that she actually ''loves'' it when he fails. Finally, (after Lisa is brought in to sing to calm things down) Luann demands a divorce, something that takes Kirk back at first, but tries to brush it off by showing (or in this case, drawing) her the door. When the party finishes, Luann drives off before Kirk is thrown off can get in the family car.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Their bickering reaches breaking point while playing ''TabletopGame/{{Pictionary}}'', with Luann being unable to guess Kirk's drawing about "dignity", claiming that he doesn't know to draw it because he lost it after marrying her. Luann then tells about the penurious conditions they have been through and (after Lisa is brought in to sing to calm things down) she demands a divorce, something Kirk is too happy to oblige, showing (or in this case, drawing) her the door. When the party finishes, Kirk is thrown off the family car.

to:

Their bickering reaches a breaking point while playing ''TabletopGame/{{Pictionary}}'', with Luann being unable to guess Kirk's drawing about "dignity", claiming "dignity." Kirk claims that he doesn't know to draw it because he lost it after marrying her. Luann then tells about the penurious conditions they have been through through, and Kirk shoots back that she actually ''loves'' it when he fails. Finally, (after Lisa is brought in to sing to calm things down) she Luann demands a divorce, something that takes Kirk is too happy back at first, but tries to oblige, brush it off by showing (or in this case, drawing) her the door. When the party finishes, Kirk is thrown off the family car.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HalfwayPlotSwitch: Zigzagged. The start of the episode seems to be setting up Homer acting boorish and ruining another party, much akin to the same plot in "War of the Simpsons". Instead Homer cleans himself up quickly enough, and the party starts off amicably until the tension between Kirk and Luann rises. The final act of the episode does return to the formula of Marge and Homer's relationship in tension however.
* HollywoodBoardGames: Luann and Kirk van Houten, whose marriage is in its last legs, have been exchanging underhanded insults throughout the Simpsons' dinner party. Luanne has her RageBreakingPoint in the middle of a ''TabletopGame/{{Pictionary}}'' game. It's triggered by her inability to guess just what the hell that oblong shape her husband has made means. When Kirk points out it's supposed to be a drawing of "dignity", she loses it and accuses him of having lost his dignity since marrying her. Kirk challenges to depict "dignity", which she does so marvelously that some comments it's "worthy of Webster's".

to:

* HalfwayPlotSwitch: Zigzagged. The start of the episode seems to be setting up Homer acting boorish and ruining another party, much akin to the same plot in "War of the Simpsons". Simpsons." Instead Homer cleans himself up quickly enough, and the party starts off amicably until the tension between Kirk and Luann rises. The final act of the episode does return to the formula of Marge and Homer's relationship in tension however.
* HollywoodBoardGames: Luann and Kirk van Houten, whose marriage is in its last legs, have been exchanging underhanded insults throughout the Simpsons' dinner party. Luanne Kirk has her his RageBreakingPoint in the middle of a ''TabletopGame/{{Pictionary}}'' game. It's game, triggered by her his wife's inability to guess just what the hell that oblong shape her husband has made means. When time runs out, Kirk loses it, points out it's supposed to be a drawing of "dignity", she loses it "dignity," and accuses him of having lost his dignity since marrying her. Kirk challenges her to depict "dignity", it, which she does so marvelously that some Dr Hibbert comments it's "worthy of Webster's".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Hypocrite}}: Luann criticizes Kirk for driving the Southern Cracker Company into the ground after her father made him the manager...but her father is a thoroughly incompetent boob himself. He deliberately avoids trying to enter the singles market, even though the company's in trouble and it could use all the sales it could get.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HollywoodBoardGames: Luann and Kirk van Houten, whose marriage is in its last legs, have been exchanging underhanded insults throughout the Simpsons' dinner party. Luanne has her RageBreakingPoint in the middle of a ''TabletopGame/{{Pictionary}}'' game. It's triggered by her inability to guess just what the hell that oblong shape her husband has made means. When Kirk points out it's supposed to be a drawing of "dignity", she loses it and accuses him of having lost his dignity since marrying her. Kirk challenges to depict "dignity", which she does so marvelously that some comments it's "worthy of Webster's".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Their bickering reaches breaking point while playing Pictionary, with Luann being unable to guess Kirk's drawing about "dignity", claiming that he doesn't know to draw it because he lost it after marrying her. Luann then tells about the penurious conditions they have been through and (after Lisa is brought in to sing to calm things down) she demands a divorce, something Kirk is too happy to oblige, showing (or in this case, drawing) her the door. When the party finishes, Kirk is thrown off the family car.

to:

Their bickering reaches breaking point while playing Pictionary, ''TabletopGame/{{Pictionary}}'', with Luann being unable to guess Kirk's drawing about "dignity", claiming that he doesn't know to draw it because he lost it after marrying her. Luann then tells about the penurious conditions they have been through and (after Lisa is brought in to sing to calm things down) she demands a divorce, something Kirk is too happy to oblige, showing (or in this case, drawing) her the door. When the party finishes, Kirk is thrown off the family car.



* GameNightFight: Kirk and Luann bicker throughout the dinner party, but it all comes to a boil when Luann is unable to guess Kirk's drawing of "dignity" in Pictionary. This leads to a heated argument, leading to both of them getting divorced.

to:

* GameNightFight: Kirk and Luann bicker throughout the dinner party, but it all comes to a boil when Luann is unable to guess Kirk's drawing of "dignity" in Pictionary.''Pictionary''. This leads to a heated argument, leading to both of them getting divorced.



* PlayingPictionary: The Simpson family hosts a dinner party with a game of Pictionary. Maude guesses "cornstarch" from three dots drawn by Ned, while Kirk is unable to draw "dignity," though Luanne is. Homer thinks that Kirk is also unable to draw "a door".

to:

* PlayingPictionary: The Simpson family hosts a dinner party with a game of Pictionary.''Pictionary''. Maude guesses "cornstarch" from three dots drawn by Ned, while Kirk is unable to draw "dignity," though Luanne is. Homer thinks that Kirk is also unable to draw "a door".

Added: 593

Changed: 384

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseLaw: You cannot fire someone for being single. In real life, Kirk would have had every right to sue the company into the ground for discrimination against his marital status, although this would depend on [[WhereTheHellIsSpringfield where Springfield actually is]] - about half of US states, as well as federal law, don't prohibit employment discrimination on the basis of marital status.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseLaw: ArtisticLicenseLaw:
**
You cannot fire someone for being single. In real life, Kirk would have had every right to sue the company into the ground for discrimination against his marital status, although this would depend on [[WhereTheHellIsSpringfield where Springfield actually is]] - about half of US states, as well as federal law, don't prohibit employment discrimination on the basis of marital status.
** Homer manages to get a divorce extremely quickly and without Marge knowing. In real life, the only way one would be able to get a divorce without the spouse knowing is if they were unable to be contacted.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* AluminiumChristmasTrees: A number of people thought that ''ComicStrip/LoveIs'' was something Homer made up, or at least totally misunderstood the concept of.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** After his car gets stolen, Kirk tells Homer that he took Luan for granted for so long that that the divorce caught him by surprise, and tells Homer about how one day his wife will be preparing his favorite meal, the next thawing hot dogs over a sink, and Homer says that he has nothing to worry about since he and Marge have a comfortable routine going. The next scene has Homer reading a note from Marge telling him that since he didn't go with her to have dinner with Luan and her new boyfriend, she left him some hot dogs thawing in the sink.

to:

** After his car gets stolen, Kirk tells Homer that he took Luan Luann for granted for so long that that the divorce caught him by surprise, and tells Homer about how one day his wife will be preparing his favorite meal, the next thawing hot dogs over a sink, and Homer says that he has nothing to worry about since he and Marge have a comfortable routine going. The next scene has Homer reading a note from Marge telling him that since he didn't go with her to have dinner with Luan Luann and her new boyfriend, she left him some hot dogs thawing in the sink.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseLaw: You cannot fire someone for being single. In real life, Kirk would have had every right to sue the company into the ground for discrimination against his marital status, althought this would depend on [[WhereTheHellIsSpringfield where Springfield actually is]] - about half of US states, as well as federal law, don't prohibit employment discrimination on the basis of marital status.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseLaw: You cannot fire someone for being single. In real life, Kirk would have had every right to sue the company into the ground for discrimination against his marital status, althought although this would depend on [[WhereTheHellIsSpringfield where Springfield actually is]] - about half of US states, as well as federal law, don't prohibit employment discrimination on the basis of marital status.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NonIndictativeName: Otto walks out of "Stoner's Pot Palace", not particularly happy.

to:

* NonIndictativeName: NonIndicativeName: Otto walks out of "Stoner's Pot Palace", not particularly happy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NonIndicativeName: The title refers to Milhouse's parents breaking up, but Milhouse isn't really focused upon throughout the episode.
** In universe example: Otto walks out of "Stoner's Pot Palace", not particularly happy.

to:

* NonIndicativeName: NeverTrustATitle: The title refers to Milhouse's parents breaking up, but Milhouse isn't really focused upon throughout the episode.
** In universe example: * NonIndictativeName: Otto walks out of "Stoner's Pot Palace", not particularly happy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PetTheDog: Despite the fact that Nelson and Kearney constantly pick on Milhouse, they give their sympathy for him after learning about his parents' divorce; they even refused to make fun of it in order to spare Milhouse's feelings. Nelson explained that his parents got divorced because of his mom's addiction of cough drops, and Kearney admits that he was married and got a divorce, but he and his son were able to grow out of it and kindly assured that Milhouse can do the same.

to:

* PetTheDog: Despite the fact that Nelson and Kearney constantly pick on Milhouse, they give their sympathy for him after learning about his parents' divorce; they even refused to make fun of it in order to spare Milhouse's his feelings. Nelson explained that his own parents got divorced because of his mom's addiction of cough drops, drops and that he felt that she wasn't acting like a real mother because of it. Kearney also admits that he was married and got a divorce, divorce that was tough on his son, but he and his son were the latter was able to grow out of it it, and kindly Kearney assured that Milhouse can do the same.

Changed: 249

Removed: 248

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PetTheDog: Despite the fact that Nelson and Kearney constantly pick on Milhouse, they give their sympathy for him after learning about his parents' divorce; they even refused to make fun of it in order to spare Milhouse's feelings.
Nelson explained that his parents got divorced because of his mom's addiction of cough drops, and Kearney admits that he was married and got a divorce, but he and his son were able to grow out of it and kindly assured that Milhouse can do the same.

to:

* PetTheDog: Despite the fact that Nelson and Kearney constantly pick on Milhouse, they give their sympathy for him after learning about his parents' divorce; they even refused to make fun of it in order to spare Milhouse's feelings.
feelings. Nelson explained that his parents got divorced because of his mom's addiction of cough drops, and Kearney admits that he was married and got a divorce, but he and his son were able to grow out of it and kindly assured that Milhouse can do the same.

Added: 248

Changed: 169

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PetTheDog: Nelson and Kearney express sympathy for Milhouse during his parents' divorce.

to:

* PetTheDog: Despite the fact that Nelson and Kearney express constantly pick on Milhouse, they give their sympathy for Milhouse during him after learning about his parents' divorce.divorce; they even refused to make fun of it in order to spare Milhouse's feelings.
Nelson explained that his parents got divorced because of his mom's addiction of cough drops, and Kearney admits that he was married and got a divorce, but he and his son were able to grow out of it and kindly assured that Milhouse can do the same.

Added: 134

Changed: 347

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OffModel: Kirk's eyebrows [[https://frinkiac.com/img/S08E06/778543.jpg briefly go from blue to yellow]] when giving Starla his keys.



* OffModel: Kirk's eyebrows [[https://frinkiac.com/img/S08E06/778543.jpg briefly go from blue to yellow]] when giving Starla his keys.

to:

* OffModel: OnlyTheLeadsGetAHappyEnding: Increasingly concerned about his own marriage thanks to the Van Houten's bitter divorce, Homer demonstrates his love by committing to Marge again with all their friends in attendance. However, Luann rejects Kirk's eyebrows [[https://frinkiac.com/img/S08E06/778543.jpg briefly go from blue attempt to yellow]] when giving Starla his keys.do the same.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ClumsyCopyrightCensorship: The store where Homer buys Marge a cake after their wedding is clearly Carvel (with the cake itself resembling the store's signature "Fudgie the Whale" cake), but only the bottom half of the logo is visible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ChekhovsGun: Homer dates his failures as a husband back to the "wedding reception" he had for Marge, which was just the two of them seated at a picnic table outside Carvel with a cake he bought in the store—to which she said sadly, "It's getting less and less likely [[SurpriseParty you're going to yell 'surprise' and have all my friends jump out]]." When he decides to marry her again, that's just what he does.

Added: 356

Removed: 356

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DivorceIsTemporary: {{Subverted}} when it looks like Kirk is about to [[StatusQuoIsGod win Luann back at the end]], but [[SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome she's not interested]] (though they would play this straight many seasons later). {{Exaggerated}} with Homer, who divorces Marge specifically for the purpose of marrying her again in a romantic gesture.



* DivorceIsTemporary: {{Subverted}} when it looks like Kirk is about to [[StatusQuoIsGod win Luann back at the end]], but [[SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome she's not interested]] (though they would play this straight many seasons later). {{Exaggerated}} with Homer, who divorces Marge specifically for the purpose of marrying her again in a romantic gesture.

Top